Call for students to film 'biased' teachers brings Brazil's culture wars to classroom
President Bolsonaro has accused schoolteachers of indoctrination but educators say his aim is to stifle critical thinking
Jair Bolsonaro has encouraged school students to film teachers during class if they suspect them of pushing leftist ideas, reigniting a battle in one of the most contested arenas of Brazil’s raging culture wars.
“Teachers need to teach and not indoctrinate,” Bolsonaro tweeted this week as he shared a video shot in class by a student who accused her teacher of criticizing the far-right president.
Bolsonaro’s son Carlos also retweeted a student-made video with the comment: “Filming/recording in schools is an act of legitimate defense against ideological predators who are disguised as teachers.”
The call to film teachers originated with a movement called Schools without Party (known by its Portuguese acronym ESP) – a fringe rightwing movement founded in 2004 which gained influence as Bolsonaro rose to power.
The movement’s founder Miguel, Nagib, says that Brazil’s education system is dominated by leftwingers who shape their lessons to win votes for progressive parties.
Bolsonaro’s endorsement of that message comes amid a growing battle over education in Brazil. This week the government abruptly cut the budget for three major public universities by 30% – in a move partly motivated by alleged complaints about partisan activities on campus.
Meanwhile, a federal deputy from Bolsonaro’s party introduced a bill to strip a revered leftwing educational theorist of his ceremonial title as the “patron of Brazilian education”.
ESP supporters have collected anecdotal evidence ofteachers wearing T-shirts supporting leftist candidates, a public university event to protest “against fascism and in favor of democracy” (whicha rightwing activist said was “clearly” supporting Brazil’s largest leftist party), anda teacher who shouted at students about Bolsonaro. But there has been no scientific study documenting systemic leftist bias in Brazilian education.
Critics allege that ESP’s real agenda is to censor teachers and rid lessons of critical thinking. “These recordings destroy classrooms as a place for debate,” said Fernando Penna, an education professor at the Federal Fluminense University who is a leader of a group called Teachers Against ESP.
Penna said that ESP has created an environment of fear for teachers who self-censor discussions of potentially controversial subjects. Several educators have lost their jobs for assigning materials that discusssex, gender orpolitics.
History is an especially contested subject – all the more so because Bolsonaro has himself been accused ofattempting to rewrite the country’s past,denying that Brazil’s 21 years of military rule constituted a dictatorship and arguing that Africans – not Brazil’s Portuguese colonizers – were responsible for slavery.
Bolsonaro has also frequently attacked Paulo Freire, the late Brazilian educationalist who gained worldwide recognition for his literacy programmes.This week the president supported a move to strip Freire of his posthumous title of “patron” of the country’s education system.
Earlier this month a popular YouTube comedy channel, Porta dos Fundos, satirized the current mood in Brazilian classrooms witha skit showing a teacher trying to teach a history class.
“Today we are going to talk about thesupposed slavery that there was in Brazil,” the teacher says.
“Wasn’t slavery very cruel?” asks a student, as one by one his classmates raise their phones to record.
“Many would say yes,” replies the teacher. “But I’m not here to indoctrinate anyone … And actually I’m required by law to say that thanks to slavery, Brazil experienced growth like never before.”
The campaign to film teachers has been supported by Bolsonaro’s education ministerAbraham Weintraub, an economist and conspiracy theorist, who has argued that crack was deliberately introduced inBrazil as part of a communist plot.
Weintraub was Bolsonaro’s second education minister, replacing Ricardo Vélez, a Colombian theologian who was fired after a string of gaffes.
“The problem with ESP is that they are distracting from the real issues that plague Brazilian education – such as the lack of infrastructure, violence and low teacher salaries,” said Penna.