| | |
| 2020 |
| Paul Di Filippo | The Prevalence of Witches, by Aubrey Menen (1947) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Grand Canyon, by Vita Sackville-West (1942) |
| Thomas Kaufsek | The Contaminant, by Leonard Reiffel (1978) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Hackenfeller's Ape, by Brigid Brophy (1953) |
| Graham Andrews | Public Faces, by Harold Nicolson (1932) |
| Rich Horton | Man's Mortality, by Michael Arlen (1933) |
| 2019 |
| Paul Di Filippo | The Arrogant History of White Ben, by Clemence Dane (1939) |
| Thomas Kaufsek | Science Fiction: Complete with Everything: Aliens, Giant Ants, Space Cadets, Robots, and One Plucky Girl by No-Frills Entertainment (1981) |
| David Langford | The Mind of Mr Soames, by Charles Eric Maine (1961) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Atomsk, by Cordwainer Smith (1949) |
| Graham Andrews | The Brontës Went to Woolworths, by Rachel Ferguson (1931) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Pink Furniture, by A. E. Coppard (1930) |
| 2018 |
| David Langford | The Supernatural in Modern English Fiction, by Dorothy Scarborough (1917) |
| Mike Ashley | A Prisoner in Fairyland, by Algernon Blackwood (1913) |
| Paul Di Filippo | The Wreck of the Titan, or Futility, by Morgan Robertson (1912) |
| Phoenix Alexander | The Beast of Bradhurst Avenue, by George S. Schuyler (1934) |
| Robert Eldridge | The Cloud Dream of the Nine, by Kim Man-Choong (1922) |
| Graham Andrews | Up the Ladder of Gold, by E. Phillips Oppenheim (1931) |
| 2017 |
| David Langford | A Christmas Garland, by Max Beerbohm (1912) |
| Robert Eldridge | The Great Demonstration, by Katharine Metcalf Roof (1920) |
| Paul Di Filippo | A Report from Group 17, by Robert C. O'Brien (1972) |
| Mark Esping | The Moon Is Inhabited, by "Columba" Annabell Krebs Culverwell (1961) |
| David Langford | A Beleaguered City, by Mrs. Oliphant (1879) |
| David Langford | A Voyage To Purilia, by Elmer Rice (1930) |
| 2016 |
| Graham Andrews | The Morlocks, by James C. Welsh, M.P. (1924) |
| Robert Eldridge | The Adventures of Hatim Tai, by Anonymous (1830) |
| Robert Eldridge | Star of the Unborn, by Franz Werfel (1946) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Twilight Stories, by Rhoda Broughton (1872) |
| Douglas A. Anderson | Monk's Magic, by Alexander De Comeau (1931) |
| Graham Andrews | The Truth About Wilson, by W.S.K. Webb (1962) |
| 2015 |
| Douglas A. Anderson | The Capture of Nina Carroll, by Arthur Thrush (1924) |
| Phoenix Alexander | Light Ahead for the Negro, by Edward A. Johnson (1904) |
| Bud Webster | American Denim—A New Folk Art, Presented by Richard M. Owens and Tony Lane, Text by Peter Beagle (1975) |
| David Langford | The Judges Of Hades, By Edward D. Hoch (1971) |
| Paul Di Filippo | The Refugee Centaur, by Antoniorrobles (1952) |
| Stephen Haffner | The Devil and the Doctor, David H. Keller (1940) |
| 2014 |
| David Langford | The Condemned Playground, by Cyril Connolly (1945) |
| Graham Andrews | Froomb!, by John Lymington (1964) |
| Paul Di Filippo | The Robot Lovers, by Dean Hudson (1966) |
| Bud Webster | The Murder of the U.S.A., By Will F. Jenkins (1946) |
| David Langford | The Devil In Velvet, by John Dickson Carr (1951) |
| Lawrence Forbes | The Magic Island, by W.B. Seabrook (1929) |
| 2013 |
| Douglas A. Anderson | The Word of Teregor, by Guy Ridley (1914) |
| Douglas A. Anderson | The Gates of Horn, by Bernard Sleigh (1926) |
| Mark Esping | Nequa, or, The Problem of the Ages by Jack Adams (1900) |
| Anatoly Belilovsky | Bull's Hour, by Ivan Yefremov (1968) |
| Richard A. Lupoff | Afternoons In Utopia, by Stephen Leacock (1932) |
| Stefan Dziemianowicz | The Poet's Curse, by M. Y. Halidom (1911) |
| 2012 |
| David Langford | Heavens, by Louis Untermeyer (1922) |
| Chris De Vito | The Clock That Went Backward, by Edward Page Mitchell (1881) |
| Bud Webster | Rip Foster Rides the Gray Planet, by Blake Savage (1952) |
| Jack Womack | The Outcast Manufacturers, by Charles Fort (1909) |
| Frances Grimble | The Fixed Period, by Anthony Trollope (1882) |
| Don Webb | Hollywood vs. the Aliens: The Motion Picture Industry's Participation In UFO Disinformation, by Bruce Rux(1997) |
| 2011 |
| Paul Dellinger | Peter and Prue, by Mary Dickerson Donahey (1924) |
| David Langford | The Gap in the Curtain, by John Buchan (1932) |
| Paul Di Filippo | The Island of Not-Me, by Ezra Gerson Gotthelf (1935) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | The Beetle: A Mystery, by Richard Marsh (1897) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | The Haunted Pajamas, by Lawrence Perry Elliott (1911) |
| David Langford | To End All Telescopes, by Eric C. Williams (1969) |
| 2010 |
| Paul Di Filippo | The Last American, by John Ames Mitchell (1889) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | True History, by Lucian of Samosata (CA. 160 A.D.) |
| David Langford | But For Bunter, by David Hughes (1985) |
| Bud Webster | Alvin Steadfast on Vernacular Island, by Frank Jacobs (1965) |
| Rick Norwood | Beware The Cat, by William Baldwin (1533) |
| John Eggeling | The Triuneverse: A Scientific Romance, by R.A. Kennedy (dated 1962, but actually 1912) |
| 2009 |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | Micromégas, by Voltaire (1752) |
| David Langford | The Troglodytes, by Nal Rafcam (1961) |
| Patricia A. Martinelli | The Coming Race, by Edward Bulwer-Lytton (1870) |
| Graham Andrews | The Mclandress Dimension, by John Kenneth Galbraith (1963) |
| Roberto de Sousa Causo | Sambaqui: A Novel of Pre-History, by Stella Carr Ribeiro (1987) |
| David Langford | Transfinite Man, by Colin Kapp (1964) |
| Lawrence Person | Smallcreep's Day, by Peter Currell Brown (1965) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | The Man Who Was Thursday; A Nightmare, by G.K. Chesterton (1908) |
| 2008 |
| Lucy Sussex | Anno Domini 2000; or, Woman's Destiny by Julius Vogel (1889) |
| Fred Chappell | Rainbow on the Road, by Esther Forbes (1954) |
| Dave Truesdale | Letters on Demonology and Witchcraft, by Sir Walter Scott (1830) |
| David Langford | Adrift in the Stratosphere, by Professor A.M. Low (1937) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | The Big Ball of Wax: A Story of Tomorrow's Happy World, by Shepherd Mead (1954) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Return to the Future, by Diamandis Florakis (1973) |
| David Langford | The Stolen March, by Dornford Yates (1926) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | Ernestine Takes Over, By Walter Brooks (1935) |
| Bud Webster | Father of the Amazons, by Pete Lewis (?) (1961) |
| Peter Tremayne | Uneasy Freehold (retitledThe Uninvited), by Dorothy Macardle (1941) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | How Like A God, by Rex Stout (1929) |
| 2007 |
| David Langford | Parallel Botany, by Leo Lionni (1977) |
| Don D'Ammassa | Tentacles of Dawn, by Robert Wilson (1978) |
| Douglas A. Anderson | Flower Phantoms, by Ronald Fraser (1926) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | Star Begotten: A Biological Fantasia, by H.G. Wells (1937) |
| Graham Andrews | The Thirty-first of June, by J. B. Priestley (1961) |
| Bud Webster | The 27th Day, by John Mantley (1956) |
| David Langford | The Uncelestial City, by Humbert Wolfe (1930) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | Professor Baffin's Adventures, by Max Adeler (1881) |
| Douglas A. Anderson | Devil's Tor, by David Lindsay (1932) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | The Octave of Claudius, by Barry Pain (1897) |
| Graham Andrews | Love Is Forever We Are For Tonight by Robert Moore Williams (1970) |
| 2006 |
| David Langford | The Cruise of the Talking Fish, by W. E. Bowman (1957) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Black Oxen, by Gertrude Atherton (1923) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | Dr. Transit, By "I.S." (1925) |
| Thomas Marcinko | The Master, By T. H. White (1957) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | Davy and the Goblin; Or, What Followed Reading "Alice's Adventures In Wonderland," By Charles Edward Carryl (1884) |
| Bud Webster | The Quest of the Gole by John Hollander (1966) |
| Dennis Lien | Lazy Bear Lane, by Thorne Smith (1931) |
| Michael Swanwick | How To Write "Scientific" Fiction, by Hugo Gernsback (1930) |
| Gregory J. Koster | Wild Card, by Raymond Hawkey and Roger Bingham (1974) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | The Land of Mist, By Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (1926) |
| Bud Webster | Planet Big Zero, by Franklin Hadley (1964) |
| 2005 |
| Dennis Lien | My Bones and My Flute, by Edgar Mittelholzer (1955) |
| Douglas A. Anderson | The Flying Cows of Biloxi, by Benson Bidwell (1907) |
| Darrell Schweitzer | The Unfortunate Fursey andThe Return Of Fursey, by Mervyn Wall (1946/1948) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | Peter Graves: An Extraordinary Adventure, By William Péne Du Bois (1950) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Jog Rummage, By Grahame Wright (1974) |
| David Langford | The Mind Readers, by Margery Allingham (1965) |
| Steven Utley | Space Western Comics, (1952-1953) |
| Bud Webster | Codex Seraphinianus, by Luigi Serafini (1981) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | Adventures in the Unknown, by Carl H. Claudy (1933/34) |
| Connie Braton Meek | The Three Perils Of Man: War, Women And Witchcraft, by James Hogg (1822) |
| Roberto de Sousa Causo | The War of the Worlds, illustrated by Alvim Corrêa (1906) |
| 2004 |
| Bill Sheehan | The Late Great Creature, by Brock Brower (1971) |
| David Langford | March of the Robots, by "Leo Brett" (1961) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Cloud Chamber, by Howard Myers (1977) |
| Jason Van Hollander | Great Mischief, by Josephine Pinckney (1948) |
| Bud Webster | The Gods Hate Kansas, by Joseph Millard (1941) |
| Bud Webster | Legal Daisy Spacing, by Chris Winn (1985) |
| Paul Di Filippo | The Divine Comedy of Ariadne and Jupiter, by Shere Hite (1994), andTetrarch, By Alex Comfort (1980) |
| John Kessel | Tom's A-Cold by John Collier (1933) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | The Rolling Pin, By Charles Williams (1955) |
| David Langford | Book of the Three Dragons by Kenneth Morris (1930) |
| Bud Webster | Adventures to Come edited by J. Berg Esenwein (1937) |
| 2003 |
| J.M. Graetz | Watch the North Wind Rise (Seven Days in New Crete) by Robert Graves (1949) |
| Henry Wessells | In a Land of Clear Colors by Robert Sheckley (1979) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Thunder on the Left by Christopher Morley (1925) |
| Bill Sheehan | The Girl in a Swing by Richard Adams (1980) |
| F. Gwynplaine MacIntyre | The Wind on the Moon by Eric Linklater (1944) |
| Bud Webster | The Snouters: Form and Life of the Rhinogrades by Dr. Harald Stümpke (1967) |
| Jack Williamson | Rocket to the Morgue by Anthony Boucher (1942) |
| Stephen Jones | The Not At Night Series edited by Christine Campbell Thompson (1925-1937) |
| Graham Andrews | The Birds by Frank Baker (1936) |
| Claude Lalumière | An East Wind Coming by Arthur Byron Cover (1979) |
| Peter Atkins | Fully Dressed and in his Right Mind by Michael Fessier (1935) |
| 2002 |
| David Westwood | The House on the Strand by Daphne du Maurier (1969) |
| John Eggeling | The End of an Epoch by A. Lincoln Green (1901) |
| Mike Ashley | The Bright Messenger by Algernon Blackwood (1921) |
| Bill Sheehan | The Cadaver of Gideon Wyck by Alexander Laing (1934) |
| Paul Di Filippo | I Am Thinking of My Darling by Vincent McHugh (1943) |
| David Langford | Musrum by Eric Thacker and Anthony Earnshaw (1968) |
| Jeff VanderMeer | Smile on the Void by Stuart Gordon (1983) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Under the Triple Suns by Stanton Coblentz (1955) |
| Gregory Benford | Habitable Planets for Man by Stephen H. Dole (1970) |
| Dave Langford | The Last Revolution by Lord Dunsany (1951) |
| Stefan Dziemianowicz | Fingers of Fear by J.U. Nicolson (1937) |
| 2001 |
| Paul Di Filippo | The Cat's Cradle-Book by Sylvia Townsend Warner (1940) |
| Douglas A. Anderson | The Marvellous Land of Snergs by E.A. Wyke-Smith (1927) |
| Jeff VanderMeer | Jerusalem Quartet by Edward Whittemore |
| Paul Di Filippo | Seaports in the Moon by Vincent Starrett (1928) |
| Bradley Denton | Cosmic Banditos by A. C. Weisbecker (1986) |
| Gavin J. Grant | Travel Light Naomi Mitchison (1952) |
| Mike Ashley | The Tower of Oblivion by Oliver Onions (1921) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Teenocracy by Robert Shirley (1969) |
| Barry N. Malzberg | Passing for Human by Jody Scott (1977) |
| Don Webb | The Box from Japan by Harry Stephen Keeler (1932) |
| David Langford | The Fourth Dimension by C. Howard Hinton (1904) |
| 2000 |
| Peter Atkins | The London Adventure by Arthur Machen (1924) |
| Howard Waldrop | Looking for the General by Warren Miller (1964) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Through the Alimentary Canal with Gun and Camera by George Chappell (1930) |
| Stefan Dziemianowicz | The Thing in the Woods by Harper Williams (1924) |
| Dave Langford | The Exploits of Engelbrecht by Maurice Richardson (1950) |
| Jeffrey Ford | The Other Side of the Mountain by Michel Bernanos |
| Mike Ashley | Julius LeVallon by Algernon Blackwood |
| Barry N. Malzberg | The Voyage: an Opera by Phillip Glass (1992) |
| Paul Di Filippo | Carnacki The Ghost-Finder by William Hope Hodgson (1913) |
| Paul J. McAuley | Sannikov Land by Vladimir Obruchev |
| 1999 |
| Henry Wessells | The Well of the Unicorn by Fletcher Pratt |
| Dave Langford | "The Strange Case of Cyril Bycourt" (InMax Carrados Mysteries, by Ernest Bramah, 1927 |
| Ruth Berman | The Unicorn with Silver Shoes by Ella Young, 1932 |
| Neil Gaiman | Lud-in-the-Mist by Hope Mirlees |
| Paul Di Filippo | Where the Blue Begins by Christopher Morley |
| Richard Bowes | Floor Games by H.G. Wells |
| Jeffrey Ford | Kater Murr by E.T.A. Hoffmann |
| Keith Ferrell | The Shape of Further Things: Speculations on Change by Brian W. Aldiss, 1971 |
| David J. Schow | The Lights in the Sky Are Stars by Fredric Brown, 1953 |
| Paul Di Filippo | Murder in Millennium VI by Curme Gray |
| 1998 |
| Marc Laidlaw | The Diamond in the Window by Jane Langton, 1962 |
| Jonathan Lethem | The Unholy City, by Charles Finney, 1937 |
| William Tenn | Dr. Arnoldi by Tiffany Thayer, 1934 |
| Richard A. Lupoff | Clare Winger Harris |
| Jack Womack | I Remember Lemuria by Richard S. Shaver, 1948 |
