Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


[RFC Home] [TEXT|PDF|HTML] [Tracker] [IPR] [Info page]

PROPOSED STANDARD
Network Working Group                                      H. HazewinkelRequest for Comments: 2594             Joint Research Centre of the E.C.Category: Standards Track                                 C. Kalbfleisch                                                             Verio, Inc.                                                        J. Schoenwaelder                                                         TU Braunschweig                                                                May 1999Definitions of Managed Objects for WWW ServicesStatus of this Memo   This document specifies an Internet standards track protocol for the   Internet community, and requests discussion and suggestions for   improvements.  Please refer to the current edition of the "Internet   Official Protocol Standards" (STD 1) for the standardization state   and status of this protocol.  Distribution of this memo is unlimited.Copyright Notice   Copyright (C) The Internet Society (1999).  All Rights Reserved.Abstract   This memo defines a portion of the Management Information Base (MIB)   for use with network management protocols in the Internet Community.   In particular it describes a set of objects for managing World Wide   Web (WWW) services.Table of Contents1 Introduction .................................................12 The SNMP Management Framework ................................23 Terminology ..................................................34 Overview .....................................................44.1 Purpose and Requirements ...................................44.2 Relationship to other Standards Efforts ....................54.3 WWW Services ...............................................54.4 Document Transfer Protocol .................................65 Structure of the MIB .........................................75.1 Service Information Group ..................................75.2 Protocol Statistics Group ..................................75.3 Document Statistics Group ..................................86 Definitions ..................................................107 Document Transfer Protocol Mappings ..........................367.1 The HyperText Transfer Protocol ............................367.2 The File Transfer Protocol .................................378 Security Considerations ......................................389 Intellectual Property ........................................3910 Acknowledgments .............................................39Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                     [Page 1]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 199911 Editors' Addresses ..........................................3912 References ..................................................4013 Full Copyright Statement ....................................431.  Introduction   This memo defines a set of objects for managing World Wide Web (WWW)   services. This MIB extends the application management framework   defined by the System Application Management MIB (SYSAPPL-MIB) [23]   and the Application Management MIB (APPLICATION-MIB) [24]. The MIB is   also self-contained so that it can be implemented and used without   having to implement or install the APPLICATION-MIB or the SYSAPPL-   MIB.   The protocol statistics defined in the WWW Service MIB are based on   an abstract document transfer protocol (DTP). This memo also defines   a mapping of the abstract DTP to HTTP and FTP.  Additional mappings   may be defined in the future in order to use this MIB with other   document transfer protocols. It is anticipated that such future   mappings will be defined in separate RFCs.   The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT",   "SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "MAY", and "OPTIONAL" in this   document are to be interpreted as described inRFC 2119 [17].2.  The SNMP Management Framework   The SNMP Management Framework presently consists of five major   components:    o   An overall architecture, described inRFC 2571 [1].    o   Mechanisms for describing and naming objects and events for the        purpose of management. The first version of this Structure of        Management Information (SMI) is called SMIv1 and described in        STD 16,RFC 1155 [2], STD 16,RFC 1212 [3] andRFC 1215 [4]. The        second version, called SMIv2, is described in STD 58,RFC 2578        [5],RFC 2579 [6] andRFC 2580 [7].    o   Message protocols for transferring management information. The        first version of the SNMP message protocol is called SNMPv1 and        described in STD 15,RFC 1157 [8]. A second version of the SNMP        message protocol, which is not an Internet standards track        protocol, is called SNMPv2c and described inRFC 1901 [9] andRFC 1906 [10]. The third version of the message protocol is        called SNMPv3 and described inRFC 1906 [10],RFC 2572 [11] andRFC 2574 [12].Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                     [Page 2]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999    o   Protocol operations for accessing management information. The        first set of protocol operations and associated PDU formats is        described inRFC 1157 [8]. A second set of protocol operations        and associated PDU formats is described inRFC 1905 [13].    o   A set of fundamental applications described inRFC 2573 [14] and        the view-based access control mechanism described inRFC 2575        [15].   Managed objects are accessed via a virtual information store, termed   the Management Information Base or MIB.  Objects in the MIB are   defined using the mechanisms defined in the SMI.   This memo specifies a MIB module that is compliant to the SMIv2. A   MIB conforming to the SMIv1 can be produced through the appropriate   translations. The resulting translated MIB must be semantically   equivalent, except where objects or events are omitted because no   translation is possible (use of Counter64). Some machine readable   information in SMIv2 will be converted into textual descriptions in   SMIv1 during the translation process. However, this loss of machine   readable information is not considered to change the semantics of the   MIB.3.  Terminology   This section defines the terminology used throughout this document.   o    The 'World Wide Web' (WWW) is a world wide information system        which is based on the concept of documents that are linked        together by embedding references (links) to other local or        remote documents.   o    A 'document' is a coherent piece of data which is accessible in        the World Wide Web. No assumptions are made about the content or        the type of a document.   o    A 'Uniform Resource Locator' (URL) is a formatted string        representation for a document available via the Internet. URLs        are used to express references between documents. For the syntax        and semantics of the URL string representation refer toRFC 2396        [18]   o    A 'Document Transfer Protocol' (DTP) is a protocol used within        the World Wide Web to invoke actions on documents. The DTP is an        abstraction from real protocols, such as HTTP [19,20] or FTP        [21].Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                     [Page 3]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   o    A 'request' is a DTP protocol operation which is targeted to a        'document' and invokes an action on the target document.  The        request type specifies the action that should be performed. A        request can have a document associated with it.   o    A 'response' is a DTP protocol operation which is returned as a        result of a previous (and associated) request. The response        status indicates if the requested action was successful or if        errors occurred. A response can have a document associated with        it.   o    A 'WWW service' is a set of actions that can be invoked on a        document. Typical actions are the transfer of documents or the        retrieval of administrative information about documents. WWW        services are provided by means of a DTP. A WWW service can be        identified by the DTP protocol used to invoke services and the        transport endpoint used by that protocol.   o    A 'client' is a program which establishes connections for the        purpose of sending requests and receiving responses.   o    A 'server' is a program that accepts connections in order to        service requests by sending back responses.   o    A 'proxy' is an intermediary program which acts as both a server        and a client for the purpose of making requests on behalf of        other clients.  Requests are serviced internally or by passing        them on, with possible translation, to other servers.   o    A 'caching proxy' is a proxy with the capability of locally        storing responses to associated requests. A caching proxy can        respond to similar requests with a previously stored response.4.  Overview   The World Wide Web (WWW) is a global network of information.   Information is stored in documents, which can have various formats,   including hyper-text and multi-media documents. Access to these   documents is provided by servers which are located all around the   world and are linked to each other via hyper-links embedded in   documents.   The usability of the World Wide Web depends largely on the   performance of the services realized by these servers. The services   are typically monitored through log files. This becomes a difficult   task when a single organization is responsible for a large number of   services. It is therefore desirable to treat WWW services as objects   that can be managed by using the Internet network management   framework [22].Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                     [Page 4]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 19994.1.  Purpose and Requirements   The goal of this MIB is to define a standardized set of objects which   lead to integrated and improved performance and fault management in a   heterogeneous environment of WWW services. This MIB focuses on the   service-oriented view. It does not deal with the process oriented   view, which is covered by the System Application MIB [23] and the   Application MIB [24].   This document defines a set of managed objects to monitor WWW   services for short-term operational purposes, such as problem   detection and troubleshooting. No attempts are made here to cover   accounting or hit metering issues.   The scope of the MIB is further limited by the requirement that an   implementation conforming to this MIB must be possible without   putting a huge CPU or memory burden on the WWW server implementation.   In addition, this MIB does not cover WWW service configuration.   Server software has become an open market where competing vendors   constantly invent new features in order to shape their products. It   is therefore not possible to reach consensus on a common way to   configure WWW services at this point in time.4.2.  Relationship to other Standards Efforts   The WWW Service MIB fits into the application management architecture   defined in the System Application MIB [23]. The System Application   MIB and the Application MIB [24] use a process-oriented view, where   an application is viewed as a collection of processes. The WWW   Service MIB described in this memo uses a service-oriented view,   which looks at the services provided by a set of processes.   The relationship between the process-oriented view and the service-   oriented view is a many-to-many relationship, because one process can   implement multiple services and multiple services can be implemented   by a single set of processes. The Application Management MIB [24]   contains generic mapping tables, which map back and forth between   both views.   The WWW Service MIB interfaces to the Application MIB [24] by using   the service instance identifier (applSrvIndex) for wwwServiceIndex if   an applicable instance of applSrvIndex is available. The WWW Service   MIB is self-contained and can be implemented as a stand-alone module   if the service-level tables in the Application MIB are not available.Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                     [Page 5]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 19994.3.  WWW Services   The MIB is organized around the concept of WWW services. WWW services   are a set of actions that can be invoked on a document. A WWW service   is provided or used by either a client, a server or a proxy. Clients   send out requests for information to server or proxy server. Servers   receive, process and respond to requests received from clients.   Servers usually have access to local documents, which can be   transferred to clients.   A proxy is a special server, who acts as both a server and a client   for the purpose of making requests on behalf of other clients. A   proxy is able to translate between the client and the origin server.   A proxy might also interact with other information retrieval system,   like for example databases.   The MIB defined in this memo distinguishes between outgoing and   incoming requests and responses. This makes it possible to obtain   statistics for clients, servers and proxies with a single set of   objects.   A special proxy server is the caching proxy, which maintains a cache   of previously received documents in order to reduce the bandwidth   used by World Wide Web clients. One interesting piece of management   information is the percentage of requests that were served from the   cache of the caching proxy (hits/miss-ratio). This ratio is not   contained explicitly in this MIB. Instead, the ratio can be derived   from the objects that count incoming and outgoing requests and   responses.4.4.  Document Transfer Protocol   The MIB is based on the concept of an abstract document transfer   protocol (DTP). The purpose of the abstract document transfer   protocol is to make the MIB definitions independent from concrete   protocols, like the Hypertext Transfer Protocol (HTTP) [19,20] or the   File Transfer Protocol (FTP) [21].   The abstract document transfer protocol makes the following   assumptions about a concrete transfer protocol:   o    The transfer protocol uses a request/response style of        interactions.   o    Every request contains a request type, which defines the        operations performed by the receiving server. The request type        is represented by an OCTET STRING. It might be necessary to        define a translation into an OCTET STRING value for protocols        that use numbers to identify request types.Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                     [Page 6]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   o    A response contains a status code, which indicates if the        request was processed successfully or which error occurred. The        status code is represented as an INTEGER value. It might be        necessary to define a mapping for protocols that do not use an        INTEGER status code.   o    A transfer protocol can send multiple responses for a single        request.  Multiple responses are counted separately in the        protocol statistics group.        A primary response has to be identified for the document        statistics. The primary response is the response that indicates        whether the request was successful.Section 7 of this memo defines a mapping of the document transfer   protocol to the HTTP protocol and the FTP protocol. Mappings to other   protocols, like NNTP [25] or WebNFS [26,27] might be defined in the   future.5.  Structure of the MIB   This section presents the structure of the MIB. The objects are   arranged into the following groups:   o    service information   o    protocol statistics   o    document statistics5.1.  Service Information Group   The service information group consists of a single table describing   all the WWW services managed by the SNMP agent. The service table   contains administrative network management information for   (potentially) multiple WWW services running on a single host. It also   contains information for all services within virtual domains of a   host. The columnar objects in the table can be divided into two main   groups:   o    global administrative information of the service, such as        service contact person, and   o    network information, such as the transfer protocol.Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                     [Page 7]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 19995.2.  Protocol Statistics Group   The protocol statistics group provides network management information   about the traffic received or transmitted by a WWW service. This   group contains counters related to DTP protocol operations and   consists of five tables:   o    The wwwSummaryTable contains a set of network traffic related        counters. The table provides a summarization of the network        traffic and protocol operations related to a WWW service. It is        well recognized that certain variables are redundant with        respect to the request and response tables, but they are added        to provide an operator a quick overview and to reduce SNMP        network traffic.   o    The wwwRequestInTable contains detailed information about        incoming requests. Every particular request type is counted        separately.   o    The wwwRequestOutTable contains detailed information about        outgoing requests. Every particular request type is counted        separately.   o    The wwwResponseInTable contains detailed information about        incoming responses. Every particular response type is counted        separately.   o    The wwwResponseOutTable contains detailed information about        outgoing responses. Every particular response type is counted        separately.5.3.  Document Statistics Group   The document group contains information about the documents which   were accessed in the past. The group provides four types of   statistics.   1.   Details about the last N attempts to invoke actions on        documents.   2.   The Top N documents sorted by the number of actions invoked on        them computed over a time interval.   3.   The Top N documents sorted by the number of content bytes        transferred computed over a time interval.   4.   Summary statistics computed over a time interval.Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                     [Page 8]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   The Top N document statistics are collected in buckets in order to   reduce agent resources and to allow a manager to detect changes in   the service usage pattern. Buckets are filled over a configurable   time interval. The agent computes the Top N statistics and starts a   new bucket once the time interval for the bucket has passed. The time   interval is configurable for each WWW service.   The document statistics group associates a response type to the   request which invoked an action. In case a DTP sends multiple   responses, the primary response must be used to derive the response   type of the request/response interaction.   The group consist of the following tables:   o    The wwwDocCtrlTable provides the manager a means to limit the        document statistic tables in size and to control the expiration        and creation of buckets.   o    The wwwDocLastNTable provides the manager information about the        last N documents which where accessed. The table lists the        documents for which access was attempted along with the request        and response type of the DTP and a status message. The request        and response types provide a manager information of how attempts        to invoke actions were handled by the DTP. The status message        object provides human readable text to further describe the        response type.        The number of documents in the wwwDocLastNTable is controlled by        the wwwDocCtrlLastNSize object in the wwwDocCtrlTable. The        wwwDocCtrlLastNLock object of the wwwDocCtrlTable allows a        management application to lock the wwwDocLastNTable in order to        retrieve a consistent snapshot of the fast changing        wwwDocLastNTable.   o    The wwwDocBucketTable lists the buckets of statistical        information that have been collected. An entry in the        wwwDocBucketTable contains the creation timestamp of the bucket        as well as summary information (number of accesses, number of        documents accessed and number of bytes transferred).        The time interval is controlled by the        wwwDocCtrlBucketTimeInterval object of the wwwDocCtrlTable. The        maximum number of buckets maintained by the SNMP agent for a        particular WWW service is controlled by the wwwDocCtrlBuckets        object of the wwwDocCtrlTable.   o    The wwwDocAccessTopNTable provides the manager an overview of        the top N documents which were accessed while statistics were        collected for a particular bucket. The wwwDocAccessTopNTable isHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                     [Page 9]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999        sorted by the number of read attempts per document. The maximum        number of entries in the wwwDocAccessTopNTable is controlled by        the wwwDocCtrlTopNSize object.   o    The wwwDocBytesTopNTable provides the manager an overview of the        top N documents which caused most of the network traffic while        statistics were collected for a particular bucket. The        wwwDocBytesTopNTable is sorted by the number of bytes        transferred. The maximum number of entries in the        wwwDocBytesTopNTable is controlled by the wwwDocCtrlTopNSize        object.   The Top N statistics and the parameters of the underlying bucket are   not visible in the MIB as long as the bucket is filling up. Instead,   the following steps must be taken when the time interval for a   buckets has passed:   1.   A new entry in the wwwDocBucketTable is created to summarize the        document statistics for that time interval.   2.   The corresponding entries in the wwwDocAccessTopNTable and the        wwwDocBytesTopNTable are computed and made available.   3.   If the resulting number of entries in the wwwDocBucketTable for        the WWW service now exceeds wwwDocCtrlBuckets, then the oldest        bucket for this WWW service and all corresponding entries in the        wwwDocBucketTable, wwwDocAccessTopNTable, and        wwwDocBytesTopNTable are deleted.   Note that a bucket usually contains much more data than displayed in   the Top N tables. The number of entries in the Top N table for a   bucket is controlled by wwwDocCtrlTopNSize, while the number of   entries in a bucket depends on the number of actions invoked on   documents within the time interval over which a bucket is filled up.   It is therefore suggested to discard the data associated with a   bucket once the entries for the wwwDocBucketTable,   wwwDocAccessTopNTable and wwwDocBytesTopNTable have been calculated.6.  Definitions   WWW-MIB DEFINITIONS ::= BEGIN   IMPORTS       MODULE-IDENTITY, OBJECT-TYPE, mib-2,       Counter32, Counter64, Integer32, Unsigned32, TimeTicks           FROM SNMPv2-SMIHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 10]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999       TEXTUAL-CONVENTION, DisplayString, DateAndTime, TimeInterval           FROM SNMPv2-TC       MODULE-COMPLIANCE, OBJECT-GROUP           FROM SNMPv2-CONF       Utf8String           FROM SYSAPPL-MIB;   wwwMIB MODULE-IDENTITY       LAST-UPDATED "9902251400Z"       ORGANIZATION "IETF Application MIB Working Group"       CONTACT-INFO           "        Harrie Hazewinkel            Postal: Joint Research Centre of the E.C.                    via Fermi - Ispra 21020 (VA)                    Italy               Tel: +39+(0)332 786322               Fax: +39+(0)332 785641            E-mail: harrie.hazewinkel@jrc.it                    Carl W. Kalbfleisch            Postal: Verio, Inc.                    1950 Stemmons Freeway                    Suite 2006                    Dallas, TX 75207                    US               Tel: +1 214 290-8653               Fax: +1 214 744-0742            E-mail: cwk@verio.net                    Juergen Schoenwaelder            Postal: TU Braunschweig                    Bueltenweg 74/75                    38106 Braunschweig                    Germany               Tel: +49 531 391-3683               Fax: +49 531 489-5936            E-mail: schoenw@ibr.cs.tu-bs.de"       DESCRIPTION           "This WWW service MIB module is applicable to services            realized by a family of 'Document Transfer Protocols'            (DTP). Examples of DTPs are HTTP and FTP."Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 11]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999          -- revision history          REVISION    "9902251400Z"          DESCRIPTION "Initial version, published asRFC2594."          ::= { mib-2 65 }   --   --  Object Identifier Assignments   --   wwwMIBObjects     OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { wwwMIB 1 }   wwwMIBConformance OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { wwwMIB 2 }   --   -- Textual Conventions   --   WwwRequestType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The WwwRequestType defines the textual identification of            request types used by a document transfer protocol. For            the proper values for a given DTP, refer to the protocol            mappings for that DTP."       SYNTAX      OCTET STRING (SIZE (1..40))   WwwResponseType ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The WwwResponseType defines the different response values            used by document transfer protocols. For the proper values            for a given DTP, refer to the protocol mappings for that            DTP."       SYNTAX      Integer32 (0..2147483647)   WwwOperStatus ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The operational status of a WWW service. 'down' indicates            that the service is not available. 'running' indicates            that the service is operational and available. 'halted'            indicates that the service is operational but not            available. 'congested' indicates that the service is            operational but no additional inbound associations can be            accommodated. 'restarting' indicates that the service is            currently unavailable but is in the process of restarting            and will be available soon."       SYNTAX      INTEGER {                       down(1),Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 12]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999                       running(2),                       halted(3),                       congested(4),                       restarting(5)                   }   WwwDocName ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION       DISPLAY-HINT "255a"       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The server relative name of a document. If the URL werehttp://www.x.org/standards/search/search.cgi?string=test            then the value of this textual convention would resolve            to '/standards/search/search.cgi'. This textual convention            uses the character set for URIs as defined inRFC 2396            section 2."       SYNTAX      OCTET STRING (SIZE (0..255))   -- The WWW Service Information Group   --   -- The WWW service information group contains information about   -- the WWW services known by the SNMP agent.   wwwService OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { wwwMIBObjects 1 }   wwwServiceTable OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF WwwServiceEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The table of the WWW services known by the SNMP agent."       ::= { wwwService 1 }   wwwServiceEntry OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwServiceEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "Details about a particular WWW service."       INDEX       { wwwServiceIndex }       ::= { wwwServiceTable 1 }   WwwServiceEntry ::= SEQUENCE {       wwwServiceIndex             Unsigned32,       wwwServiceDescription       Utf8String,       wwwServiceContact           Utf8String,       wwwServiceProtocol          OBJECT IDENTIFIER,       wwwServiceName              DisplayString,       wwwServiceType              INTEGER,Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 13]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999       wwwServiceStartTime         DateAndTime,       wwwServiceOperStatus        WwwOperStatus,       wwwServiceLastChange        DateAndTime   }   wwwServiceIndex OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "An integer used to uniquely identify a WWW service. The            value must be the same as the corresponding value of the            applSrvIndex defined in the Application Management MIB            (APPLICATION-MIB) if the applSrvIndex object is available.            It might be necessary to manually configure sub-agents in            order to meet this requirement."       ::= { wwwServiceEntry 1 }   wwwServiceDescription OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Utf8String       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "Textual description of the WWW service. This shall include            at least the vendor and version number of the application            realizing the WWW service. In a minimal case, this might            be the Product Token (seeRFC 2068) for the application."       ::= { wwwServiceEntry 2 }   wwwServiceContact OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Utf8String       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The textual identification of the contact person for this            service, together with information on how to contact this            person. For instance, this might be a string containing an            email address, e.g. '<webmaster@domain.name>'."       ::= { wwwServiceEntry 3 }   wwwServiceProtocol OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      OBJECT IDENTIFIER       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "An identification of the primary protocol in use by this            service. For Internet applications, the IANA maintains            a registry of the OIDs which correspond to well-known            application protocols.  If the application protocol is not            listed in the registry, an OID value of the formHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 14]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999            {applTCPProtoID port} or {applUDPProtoID port} are used for            TCP-based and UDP-based protocols, respectively. In either            case 'port' corresponds to the primary port number being            used by the protocol."       REFERENCE           "The OID values applTCPProtoID and applUDPProtoID are            defined in the NETWORK-SERVICES-MIB (RFC 2248)."       ::= { wwwServiceEntry 4 }   wwwServiceName OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      DisplayString       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The fully qualified domain name by which this service is            known. This object must contain the virtual host name if            the service is realized for a virtual host."       ::= { wwwServiceEntry 5 }   wwwServiceType OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      INTEGER {                       wwwOther(1),                       wwwServer(2),                       wwwClient(3),                       wwwProxy(4),                       wwwCachingProxy(5)                   }       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The application type using or realizing this WWW service."       ::= { wwwServiceEntry 6 }   wwwServiceStartTime OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      DateAndTime       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The date and time when this WWW service was last started.            The value SHALL be '0000000000000000'H if the last start            time of this WWW service is not known."       ::= { wwwServiceEntry 7 }   wwwServiceOperStatus OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwOperStatus       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "Indicates the operational status of the WWW service."       ::= { wwwServiceEntry 8 }Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 15]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   wwwServiceLastChange OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      DateAndTime       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The date and time when this WWW service entered its current            operational state. The value SHALL be '0000000000000000'H if            the time of the last state change is not known."       ::= { wwwServiceEntry 9 }   -- The WWW Protocol Statistics Group   --   -- The WWW protocol statistics group contains statistics about   -- the DTP requests and responses sent or received.   wwwProtocolStatistics OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { wwwMIBObjects 2 }   wwwSummaryTable OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF WwwSummaryEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The table providing overview statistics for the            WWW services on this system."       ::= { wwwProtocolStatistics 1 }   wwwSummaryEntry OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwSummaryEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "Overview statistics for an individual service."       INDEX       { wwwServiceIndex }       ::= { wwwSummaryTable 1 }   WwwSummaryEntry ::= SEQUENCE {       wwwSummaryInRequests        Counter32,       wwwSummaryOutRequests       Counter32,       wwwSummaryInResponses       Counter32,       wwwSummaryOutResponses      Counter32,       wwwSummaryInBytes           Counter64,       wwwSummaryInLowBytes        Counter32,       wwwSummaryOutBytes          Counter64,       wwwSummaryOutLowBytes       Counter32   }   wwwSummaryInRequests OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-onlyHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 16]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of requests successfully received."       ::= { wwwSummaryEntry 1 }   wwwSummaryOutRequests OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of requests generated."       ::= { wwwSummaryEntry 2 }   wwwSummaryInResponses OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of responses successfully received."       ::= { wwwSummaryEntry 3 }   wwwSummaryOutResponses OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of responses generated."       ::= { wwwSummaryEntry 4 }   wwwSummaryInBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter64       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of content bytes received."       ::= { wwwSummaryEntry 5 }   wwwSummaryInLowBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The lowest thirty-two bits of wwwSummaryInBytes."       ::= { wwwSummaryEntry 6 }   wwwSummaryOutBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter64       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTIONHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 17]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999           "The number of content bytes transmitted."       ::= { wwwSummaryEntry 7 }   wwwSummaryOutLowBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The lowest thirty-two bits of wwwSummaryOutBytes."       ::= { wwwSummaryEntry 8 }   -- The WWW request tables contain detailed information about   -- requests send or received by WWW services.   wwwRequestInTable OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF WwwRequestInEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The table providing detailed statistics for requests            received by WWW services on this system."       ::= { wwwProtocolStatistics 2 }   wwwRequestInEntry OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwRequestInEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "Request statistics for an individual service."       INDEX       { wwwServiceIndex, wwwRequestInIndex }       ::= { wwwRequestInTable 1 }   WwwRequestInEntry ::= SEQUENCE {       wwwRequestInIndex           WwwRequestType,       wwwRequestInRequests        Counter32,       wwwRequestInBytes           Counter32,       wwwRequestInLastTime        DateAndTime   }   wwwRequestInIndex OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwRequestType       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The particular request type the statistics apply to."       ::= { wwwRequestInEntry 1 }   wwwRequestInRequests OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-onlyHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 18]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of requests of this type received by this            WWW service."       ::= { wwwRequestInEntry 2 }   wwwRequestInBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of content bytes per request type received            by this WWW service."       ::= { wwwRequestInEntry 3 }   wwwRequestInLastTime OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      DateAndTime       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The date and time when the last byte of the last complete            request of this type was received by this WWW service. The            value SHALL be '0000000000000000'H if no request of this            type has been received yet."       ::= { wwwRequestInEntry 4 }   wwwRequestOutTable OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF WwwRequestOutEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The table providing detailed statistics for requests            generated by the services on this system."       ::= { wwwProtocolStatistics 3 }   wwwRequestOutEntry OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwRequestOutEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "Request statistics for an individual service."       INDEX       { wwwServiceIndex, wwwRequestOutIndex }       ::= { wwwRequestOutTable 1 }   WwwRequestOutEntry ::= SEQUENCE {       wwwRequestOutIndex          WwwRequestType,       wwwRequestOutRequests       Counter32,       wwwRequestOutBytes          Counter32,       wwwRequestOutLastTime       DateAndTime   }Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 19]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   wwwRequestOutIndex OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwRequestType       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The particular request type the statistics apply to."       ::= { wwwRequestOutEntry 1 }   wwwRequestOutRequests OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of requests of this type generated by this            WWW service."       ::= { wwwRequestOutEntry 2 }   wwwRequestOutBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of content bytes per requests type generated            by this WWW service."       ::= { wwwRequestOutEntry 3 }   wwwRequestOutLastTime OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      DateAndTime       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The date and time when the first byte of the last request            of this type was send by this WWW service. The value SHALL            be '0000000000000000'H if no request of this type has been            send yet."       ::= { wwwRequestOutEntry 4 }   -- The WWW response tables contain detailed information about   -- responses sent or received by WWW services.   wwwResponseInTable OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF WwwResponseInEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The table providing detailed statistics for responses            received by WWW services on this system."       ::= { wwwProtocolStatistics 4 }   wwwResponseInEntry OBJECT-TYPEHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 20]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999       SYNTAX      WwwResponseInEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "Response statistics for an individual service."       INDEX       { wwwServiceIndex, wwwResponseInIndex }       ::= { wwwResponseInTable 1 }   WwwResponseInEntry ::= SEQUENCE {       wwwResponseInIndex          WwwResponseType,       wwwResponseInResponses      Counter32,       wwwResponseInBytes          Counter32,       wwwResponseInLastTime       DateAndTime   }   wwwResponseInIndex OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwResponseType       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The particular response type the statistics apply to."       ::= { wwwResponseInEntry 1 }   wwwResponseInResponses OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of responses of this type received by this            WWW service."       ::= { wwwResponseInEntry 2 }   wwwResponseInBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of content bytes per response type received            by this WWW service."       ::= { wwwResponseInEntry 3 }   wwwResponseInLastTime OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      DateAndTime       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The date and time when the last byte of the last complete            response of this type was received by this WWW service. The            value SHALL be '0000000000000000'H if no response of this            type has been received yet."Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 21]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999       ::= { wwwResponseInEntry 4 }   wwwResponseOutTable OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF WwwResponseOutEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The table providing detailed statistics for responses            generated by services on this system."       ::= { wwwProtocolStatistics 5 }   wwwResponseOutEntry OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwResponseOutEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "Response statistics for an individual service."       INDEX       { wwwServiceIndex, wwwResponseOutIndex }       ::= { wwwResponseOutTable 1 }   WwwResponseOutEntry ::= SEQUENCE {       wwwResponseOutIndex         WwwResponseType,       wwwResponseOutResponses     Counter32,       wwwResponseOutBytes         Counter32,       wwwResponseOutLastTime      DateAndTime   }   wwwResponseOutIndex OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwResponseType       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The particular response type the statistics apply to."       ::= { wwwResponseOutEntry 1 }   wwwResponseOutResponses OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of responses of this type generated by this            WWW service."       ::= { wwwResponseOutEntry 2 }   wwwResponseOutBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Counter32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of content bytes per response type generatedHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 22]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999            by this WWW service."       ::= { wwwResponseOutEntry 3 }   wwwResponseOutLastTime OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      DateAndTime       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The date and time when the first byte of the last response of            this type was sent by this WWW service. The value SHALL be            '0000000000000000'H if response of this type has been send            yet."       ::= { wwwResponseOutEntry 4 }   -- The WWW Document Statistics Group   --   -- The WWW document statistics group contains statistics about   -- document read attempts.   wwwDocumentStatistics OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { wwwMIBObjects 3 }   wwwDocCtrlTable OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF WwwDocCtrlEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "A table which controls how the MIB implementation            collects and maintains document statistics."       ::= { wwwDocumentStatistics 1 }   wwwDocCtrlEntry OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwDocCtrlEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "An entry used to configure the wwwDocLastNTable,            the wwwDocBucketTable, the wwwDocAccessTopNTable,            and the wwwDocBytesTopNTable."       INDEX       { wwwServiceIndex }       ::= { wwwDocCtrlTable 1 }   WwwDocCtrlEntry ::= SEQUENCE {       wwwDocCtrlLastNSize           Unsigned32,       wwwDocCtrlLastNLock           TimeTicks,       wwwDocCtrlBuckets             Unsigned32,       wwwDocCtrlBucketTimeInterval  TimeInterval,       wwwDocCtrlTopNSize            Unsigned32   }Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 23]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   wwwDocCtrlLastNSize OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32       MAX-ACCESS  read-write       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The maximum number of entries in the wwwDocLastNTable."       DEFVAL { 25 }       ::= { wwwDocCtrlEntry 1 }   wwwDocCtrlLastNLock OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      TimeTicks       MAX-ACCESS  read-write       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "This object allows a manager to lock the wwwDocLastNTable            in order to retrieve the wwwDocLastNTable in a consistent            state. The agent is expected to take a snapshot of the            wwwDocLastNTable when it is locked and to continue updating            the real wwwDocLastNTable table so that recent information is            available as soon as the wwwDocLastNTable is unlocked again.            Setting this object to a value greater than 0 will lock            the table. The timer ticks backwards until it reaches 0.            The table unlocks automatically once the timer reaches 0            and the timer stops ticking.            A manager can increase the timer to request more time to            read the table. However, any attempt to decrease the timer            will fail with an inconsistentValue error. This rule ensures            that multiple managers can simultaneously lock and retrieve            the wwwDocLastNTable. Note that managers must cooperate in            using wwwDocCtrlLastNLock. In particular, a manager MUST not            keep the wwwDocLastNTable locked when it is not necessary to            finish a retrieval operation."       ::= { wwwDocCtrlEntry 2 }   wwwDocCtrlBuckets OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32       MAX-ACCESS  read-write       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The maximum number of buckets maintained by the agent            before the oldest bucket is deleted. The buckets are            used to populate the wwwDocAccessTopNTable and the            wwwDocBytesTopNTable. The time interval captured in            each bucket can be configured by setting the            wwwDocCtrlBucketTimeInterval object."       DEFVAL { 4 }        -- 4 buckets times 15 minutes = 1 hour       ::= { wwwDocCtrlEntry 3 }Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 24]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   wwwDocCtrlBucketTimeInterval OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      TimeInterval       MAX-ACCESS  read-write       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The time interval after which a new bucket is created.            Changing this object has no effect on existing buckets."       DEFVAL { 90000 }    -- 15 minutes (resolution .01 s)       ::= { wwwDocCtrlEntry 4 }   wwwDocCtrlTopNSize OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32       MAX-ACCESS  read-write       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The maximum number of entries shown in the            wwwDocAccessTopNTable and the wwwDocBytesTopNTable.            Changing this object has no effect on existing buckets."       DEFVAL { 25 }       ::= { wwwDocCtrlEntry 5 }   wwwDocLastNTable OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF WwwDocLastNEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The table which logs the last N access attempts."       ::= { wwwDocumentStatistics 2 }   wwwDocLastNEntry OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwDocLastNEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "An entry which describes a recent access attempt."       INDEX       { wwwServiceIndex, wwwDocLastNIndex }       ::= { wwwDocLastNTable 1 }   WwwDocLastNEntry ::= SEQUENCE {       wwwDocLastNIndex            Unsigned32,       wwwDocLastNName             WwwDocName,       wwwDocLastNTimeStamp        DateAndTime,       wwwDocLastNRequestType      WwwRequestType,       wwwDocLastNResponseType     WwwResponseType,       wwwDocLastNStatusMsg        Utf8String,       wwwDocLastNBytes            Unsigned32   }   wwwDocLastNIndex OBJECT-TYPEHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 25]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999       SYNTAX      Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "An arbitrary monotonically increasing integer number used            for indexing the wwwDocLastNTable. The first document            accessed appears in the table with this index value equal            to one. Each subsequent document is indexed with the next            sequential index value. The Nth document accessed will be            indexed by N. This table presents a sliding window of the            last wwwDocCtrlLastNSize documents accessed. Thus, entries            in this table will be indexed by N-wwwDocCtrlLastNSize            thru N if N > wwwDocCtrlLastNSize and 1 thru N if            N <= wwwDocCtrlLastNSize.            The wwwDocCtrlLastNLock attribute can be used to lock            this table to allow the manager to read its contents."       ::= { wwwDocLastNEntry 1 }   wwwDocLastNName OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwDocName       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The name of the document for which access was attempted."       ::= { wwwDocLastNEntry 2 }   wwwDocLastNTimeStamp OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      DateAndTime       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The date and time of the last attempt to access this            document."       ::= { wwwDocLastNEntry 3 }   wwwDocLastNRequestType OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwRequestType       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The protocol request type which was received by the            server when this document access was attempted."       ::= { wwwDocLastNEntry 4 }   wwwDocLastNResponseType OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwResponseType       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTIONHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 26]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999           "The protocol response type which was sent to the client            as a result of this attempt to access a document. This            object contains the type of the primary response if            there were multiple responses to a single request."       ::= { wwwDocLastNEntry 5 }   wwwDocLastNStatusMsg OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Utf8String       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "This object contains a human readable description of the            reason why the wwwDocLastNResponseType was returned to the            client. This object defines the implementation-specific            reason if the value of wwwDocLastNResponseType indicates            an error. For example, this object can indicate that the            requested document could not be transferred due to a            timeout condition or the document could not be transferred            because a 'soft link' pointing to the document could not be            resolved."       ::= { wwwDocLastNEntry 6 }   wwwDocLastNBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The number of content bytes that were returned as a            result of this attempt to access a document."       ::= { wwwDocLastNEntry 7 }   wwwDocBucketTable OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF WwwDocBucketEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "This table provides administrative summary information for            the buckets maintained per WWW service."       ::= { wwwDocumentStatistics 3 }   wwwDocBucketEntry OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwDocBucketEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "An entry which describes the parameters associated with a            particular bucket."       INDEX       { wwwServiceIndex, wwwDocBucketIndex }       ::= { wwwDocBucketTable 1 }Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 27]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   WwwDocBucketEntry ::= SEQUENCE {       wwwDocBucketIndex           Unsigned32,       wwwDocBucketTimeStamp       DateAndTime,       wwwDocBucketAccesses        Unsigned32,       wwwDocBucketDocuments       Unsigned32,       wwwDocBucketBytes           Unsigned32   }   wwwDocBucketIndex OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "An arbitrary monotonically increasing integer number            used for indexing the wwwDocBucketTable. The index number            wraps to 1 whenever the maximum value is reached."       ::= { wwwDocBucketEntry 1 }   wwwDocBucketTimeStamp OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      DateAndTime       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The date and time when the bucket was made available."       ::= { wwwDocBucketEntry 2 }   wwwDocBucketAccesses OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The total number of access attempts for any document            provided by this WWW service during the time interval            over which this bucket was created."       ::= { wwwDocBucketEntry 3 }   wwwDocBucketDocuments OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The total number of different documents for which access            was attempted this this WWW service during the time interval            over which this bucket was created."       ::= { wwwDocBucketEntry 4 }   wwwDocBucketBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      currentHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 28]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999       DESCRIPTION           "The total number of content bytes which were transferred            from this WWW service during the time interval over which            this bucket was created."       ::= { wwwDocBucketEntry 5 }   wwwDocAccessTopNTable OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF WwwDocAccessTopNEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The table of the most frequently accessed documents in a            given bucket. This table is sorted by the column            wwwDocAccessTopNAccesses. Entries having the same number            of accesses are secondarily sorted by wwwDocAccessTopNBytes.            Entries with the same number of accesses and the same            number of bytes will have an arbitrary order."       ::= { wwwDocumentStatistics 4 }   wwwDocAccessTopNEntry OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwDocAccessTopNEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "An entry in the top N table sorted by document accesses."       INDEX       { wwwServiceIndex, wwwDocBucketIndex,                     wwwDocAccessTopNIndex }       ::= { wwwDocAccessTopNTable 1 }   WwwDocAccessTopNEntry ::= SEQUENCE {       wwwDocAccessTopNIndex             Unsigned32,       wwwDocAccessTopNName              WwwDocName,       wwwDocAccessTopNAccesses          Unsigned32,       wwwDocAccessTopNBytes             Unsigned32,       wwwDocAccessTopNLastResponseType  WwwResponseType   }   wwwDocAccessTopNIndex OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "An arbitrary monotonically increasing integer number            used for indexing the wwwDocAccessTopNTable. The index is            inversely correlated to the sorting order of the table. The            document with the highest access count will get the index            value 1."       ::= { wwwDocAccessTopNEntry 1 }Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 29]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   wwwDocAccessTopNName OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwDocName       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The name of the document for which access was attempted."       ::= { wwwDocAccessTopNEntry 2 }   wwwDocAccessTopNAccesses OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The total number of access attempts for this document."       ::= { wwwDocAccessTopNEntry 3 }   wwwDocAccessTopNBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The total number of content bytes that were transmitted            as a result of attempts to access this document."       ::= { wwwDocAccessTopNEntry 4 }   wwwDocAccessTopNLastResponseType OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwResponseType       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The protocol response type which was sent to the client            as a result of the last attempt to access this document.            This object contains the type of the primary response if            there were multiple responses to a single request."       ::= { wwwDocAccessTopNEntry 5 }   wwwDocBytesTopNTable OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF WwwDocBytesTopNEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The table of the documents which caused most network            traffic in a given bucket. This table is sorted by the            column wwwDocBytesTopNBytes. Entries having the same number            bytes are secondarily sorted by wwwDocBytesTopNAccesses.            Entries with the same number of accesses and the same            number of bytes will have an arbitrary order."       ::= { wwwDocumentStatistics 5 }Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 30]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   wwwDocBytesTopNEntry OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwDocBytesTopNEntry       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "An entry in the top N table sorted by network traffic."       INDEX       { wwwServiceIndex, wwwDocBucketIndex,                     wwwDocBytesTopNIndex }       ::= { wwwDocBytesTopNTable 1 }   WwwDocBytesTopNEntry ::= SEQUENCE {       wwwDocBytesTopNIndex             Unsigned32,       wwwDocBytesTopNName              WwwDocName,       wwwDocBytesTopNAccesses          Unsigned32,       wwwDocBytesTopNBytes             Unsigned32,       wwwDocBytesTopNLastResponseType  WwwResponseType   }   wwwDocBytesTopNIndex OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32 (1..4294967295)       MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "An arbitrary monotonically increasing integer number            used for indexing the wwwDocBytesTopNTable. The index is            inversely correlated to the sorting order of the table. The            document with the highest byte count will get the index            value 1."       ::= { wwwDocBytesTopNEntry 1 }   wwwDocBytesTopNName OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwDocName       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The name of the document for which access was attempted."       ::= { wwwDocBytesTopNEntry 2 }   wwwDocBytesTopNAccesses OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The total number of access attempts for this document."       ::= { wwwDocBytesTopNEntry 3 }   wwwDocBytesTopNBytes OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      Unsigned32       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      currentHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 31]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999       DESCRIPTION           "The total number of content bytes that were transmitted            as a result of attempts to access this document."       ::= { wwwDocBytesTopNEntry 4 }   wwwDocBytesTopNLastResponseType OBJECT-TYPE       SYNTAX      WwwResponseType       MAX-ACCESS  read-only       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The protocol response type which was sent to the client            as a result of the last attempt to access this document.            This object contains the type of the primary response if            there were multiple responses to a single request."       ::= { wwwDocBytesTopNEntry 5 }   --   -- Conformance Definitions   --   wwwMIBCompliances OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { wwwMIBConformance 1 }   wwwMIBGroups      OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { wwwMIBConformance 2 }   wwwMinimalCompliance MODULE-COMPLIANCE       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The compliance statement for SNMP agents which implement            the minimal subset of the WWW-MIB. Implementors might            choose this subset for high-performance server where            full compliance might be to expensive."       MODULE  -- this module       MANDATORY-GROUPS {           wwwServiceGroup,           wwwSummaryGroup       }       OBJECT wwwSummaryOutRequests       DESCRIPTION           "Instances of wwwSummaryOutRequests do not exist on pure            WWW server implementations."       OBJECT wwwSummaryInResponses       DESCRIPTION           "Instances of wwwSummaryOutRequests do not exist on pure            WWW server implementations."       OBJECT wwwSummaryInRequests       DESCRIPTION           "Instances of wwwSummaryInRequests do not exist on pure            WWW client implementations."       OBJECT wwwSummaryOutResponses       DESCRIPTION           "Instances of wwwSummaryOutResponses do not exist on pureHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 32]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999            WWW client implementations."       ::= { wwwMIBCompliances 1 }   wwwFullCompliance MODULE-COMPLIANCE       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "The compliance statement for SNMP agents which implement            the full WWW-MIB."       MODULE  -- this module       MANDATORY-GROUPS {           wwwServiceGroup,           wwwSummaryGroup       }       GROUP  wwwRequestInGroup       DESCRIPTION           "The wwwRequestInGroup is mandatory only for WWW server            or proxy server implementations."       GROUP wwwResponseOutGroup       DESCRIPTION           "The wwwResponseOutGroup is mandatory only for WWW server            or proxy server implementations."       GROUP wwwRequestOutGroup       DESCRIPTION           "The wwwRequestOutGroup is mandatory only for WWW client            or proxy server implementations."       GROUP wwwResponseInGroup       DESCRIPTION           "The wwwRequestOutGroup is mandatory only for WWW client            or proxy server implementations."       GROUP wwwDocumentGroup       DESCRIPTION           "The wwwDocumentGroup is mandatory only for WWW server            or proxy server implementations."       OBJECT wwwSummaryOutRequests       DESCRIPTION           "Instances of wwwSummaryOutRequests do not exist on pure            WWW server implementations."       OBJECT wwwSummaryInResponses       DESCRIPTION           "Instances of wwwSummaryOutRequests do not exist on pure            WWW server implementations."       OBJECT wwwSummaryInRequests       DESCRIPTION           "Instances of wwwSummaryInRequests do not exist on pure            WWW client implementations."       OBJECT wwwSummaryOutResponses       DESCRIPTION           "Instances of wwwSummaryOutResponses do not exist on pure            WWW client implementations."       ::= { wwwMIBCompliances 2 }Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 33]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   wwwServiceGroup OBJECT-GROUP       OBJECTS {           wwwServiceDescription,           wwwServiceContact,           wwwServiceProtocol,           wwwServiceName,           wwwServiceType,           wwwServiceStartTime,           wwwServiceOperStatus,           wwwServiceLastChange       }       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "A collection of objects providing information about            the WWW services known by the SNMP agent."       ::= { wwwMIBGroups 1 }   wwwSummaryGroup OBJECT-GROUP       OBJECTS {           wwwSummaryInRequests,           wwwSummaryOutRequests,           wwwSummaryInResponses,           wwwSummaryOutResponses,           wwwSummaryInBytes,           wwwSummaryInLowBytes,           wwwSummaryOutBytes,           wwwSummaryOutLowBytes       }       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "A collection of objects providing summary statistics            about requests and responses generated and received            by a WWW service."       ::= { wwwMIBGroups 2 }   wwwRequestInGroup OBJECT-GROUP       OBJECTS {           wwwRequestInRequests,           wwwRequestInBytes,           wwwRequestInLastTime       }       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "A collection of objects providing detailed statistics            about requests received by a WWW service."       ::= { wwwMIBGroups 3 }   wwwRequestOutGroup OBJECT-GROUP       OBJECTS {           wwwRequestOutRequests,Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 34]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999           wwwRequestOutBytes,           wwwRequestOutLastTime       }       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "A collection of objects providing detailed statistics            about requests generated by a WWW service."       ::= { wwwMIBGroups 4 }   wwwResponseInGroup OBJECT-GROUP       OBJECTS {           wwwResponseInResponses,           wwwResponseInBytes,           wwwResponseInLastTime       }       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "A collection of objects providing detailed statistics            about responses received by a WWW service."       ::= { wwwMIBGroups 5 }   wwwResponseOutGroup OBJECT-GROUP       OBJECTS {           wwwResponseOutResponses,           wwwResponseOutBytes,           wwwResponseOutLastTime       }       STATUS      current       DESCRIPTION           "A collection of objects providing detailed statistics            about responses generated by a WWW service."       ::= { wwwMIBGroups 6 }   wwwDocumentGroup OBJECT-GROUP       OBJECTS {           wwwDocCtrlLastNSize,           wwwDocCtrlLastNLock,           wwwDocCtrlBuckets,           wwwDocCtrlBucketTimeInterval,           wwwDocCtrlTopNSize,           wwwDocLastNName,           wwwDocLastNTimeStamp,           wwwDocLastNRequestType,           wwwDocLastNResponseType,           wwwDocLastNStatusMsg,           wwwDocLastNBytes,           wwwDocBucketTimeStamp,           wwwDocBucketAccesses,           wwwDocBucketDocuments,           wwwDocBucketBytes,Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 35]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999           wwwDocAccessTopNName,           wwwDocAccessTopNAccesses,           wwwDocAccessTopNBytes,           wwwDocAccessTopNLastResponseType,           wwwDocBytesTopNName,           wwwDocBytesTopNAccesses,           wwwDocBytesTopNBytes,           wwwDocBytesTopNLastResponseType       }       STATUS  current       DESCRIPTION           "A collection of objects providing information about            accesses to documents."       ::= { wwwMIBGroups 7 }   END7.  Document Transfer Protocol Mappings   This section describes how existing protocols such as HTTP [19,20]   and FTP [21] can be mapped on the abstract Document Transfer Protocol   (DTP) used within the definitions of the WWW MIB. Every mapping must   define the identifier which is used to uniquely identify the transfer   protocol. In addition, the mappings must define how requests and   responses are identified.7.1.  The HyperText Transfer Protocol   The HyperText Transfer Protocol (HTTP) [19,20] is an application-   level protocol used to transfer hypermedia documents in a distributed   networked environment. HTTP is based on the request/response paradigm   and can be mapped on the abstract DTP easily.   The HTTP protocol usually runs over TCP and uses the well-known TCP   port 80. Therefore, the default value for the wwwServiceProtocol   object is { applTCPProtoID 80 }.   HTTP allows for both requests and responses and an open-ended set of   message types. The general message syntax of HTTP is therefore used   for the protocol mapping. The BNF specification of the general HTTP   message syntax as defined in [20] is as follows:       generic-message = start-line                         *message-header                         CRLF                         [ message-body ]       start-line   = Request-Line | Status-LineHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 36]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999       Request-Line = Method SP Request-URI SP HTTP-Version CRLF       Status-Line  = HTTP-Version SP Status-Code SP Reason-Phrase CRLF   Every HTTP-message where the start-line is a Request-Line is   considered a request in the abstract DTP. Every HTTP-message where   the start-line is a Status-Line is considered a response in the   abstract DTP. The mappings of WwwRequestType and WwwResponseType are   defined as follows:   o    The WwwRequestType corresponds to the method token in the        Request-Line.   o    The WwwResponseType corresponds to the Status-Code in the        Status-Line.7.2.  The File Transfer Protocol   The File Transfer Protocol (FTP) [21] is an application-level   protocol used to transfer files between hosts connected by the TCP/IP   suite of protocols. FTP is based on a request/response paradigm and   is mapped on the abstract DTP as defined in this section. The FTP   model as defined in [21] is depicted below.                                              -------------                                              |+---------+|                                              ||   User  ||    --------                                              ||Interface|<--->| User |                                              |+----|----+|    --------                ----------                    |     |     |                |+------+| control connection |+----|----+|                ||Server|<------------------->||  Client ||                ||  PI  ||  Commands/Replies  ||    PI   ||                |+--|---+|                    |+----|----+|                |   |    |                    |     |     |    --------    |+--|---+|        Data        |+----|----+|    --------    | File |<--->|Server|<------------------->||  Client |<--->| File |    |System|    || DTP  ||     Connection     ||   DTP   ||    |System|    --------    |+------+|                    |+---------+|    --------                ----------                    -------------   FTP uses two different connection types between a client and a server   to transfer files. The control connection is persistent during a FTP   session and used to exchange FTP commands and associated replies. The   data connection is only available when bulk data has to be   transferred.   The FTP protocol usually runs over TCP and uses the well-known TCP   port 21 to setup the control connection. Therefore, the default valueHazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 37]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   for the wwwServiceProtocol object is { applTCPProtoID 21 }.   Every FTP command is considered a request in the abstract DTP. Every   FTP reply is considered a response in the abstract DTP. It should be   noted that a single FTP command can result in multiple FTP replies   (e.g. preliminary positive replies). The primary response for a FTP   request contains a status code of the form 2xy, 3xy, 4xy or 5xy.  See   section 4.2 in [21] for the exact meaning of these status codes.  The   mappings for WwwRequestType and WwwResponseType are defined as   follows:   o    The WwwRequestType corresponds to the FTP command token.   o    The WwwResponseType corresponds to the three-digit code which        starts a reply. Multi-line replies with the same three-digit        code are counted as a single DTP response.8.  Security Considerations   There are a number of management objects defined in this MIB module   that have a MAX-ACCESS clause of read-write.  Such objects may be   considered sensitive or vulnerable in some network environments.  The   support for write operations in a non-secure environment without   proper protection can have a negative effect on network operations.   There are a number of managed objects in this MIB that may contain   sensitive information:   o    The document statistics group contains traffic information        including the names of documents that were a target of protocol        operations. This information is sensitive as it allows to obtain        access statistics for documents.   o    The protocol statistics are less sensitive, because they do not        contain details about the target of individual requests and        responses.  However, traffic statistics and error counters still        provide usage information about WWW services and about the        overall quality of WWW services. It is suggested that sites        configure MIB views so that a user of this MIB can only access        the portion of the statistics that belong to the WWW services        managed by that user.   o    The service and the summary statistics groups provide        information about the existence of WWW services and condensed        usage statistics.  Some sites may want to protect this        information as well, especially if they offer private WWW        services that should not be known by the outside world.Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 38]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999   SNMPv1 by itself is not a secure environment.  Even if the network   itself is secure (for example by using IPSec), there is no control as   to who on the secure network is allowed to access   (read/change/create/delete) the objects in this MIB.   It is recommended that implementers consider the security features as   provided by the SNMPv3 framework.  Specifically, the use of the   User-based Security ModelRFC 2574 [12] and the View-based Access   Control ModelRFC 2575 [15] is recommended.   It is then a customer/user responsibility to ensure that the SNMP   entity giving access to an instance of this MIB is properly   configured to give access to the objects only to those principals   (users) that have legitimate rights to indeed read or write   (change/create/delete) them.9.  Intellectual Property   The IETF takes no position regarding the validity or scope of any   intellectual property or other rights that might be claimed to   pertain to the implementation or use of the technology described in   this document or the extent to which any license under such rights   might or might not be available; neither does it represent that it   has made any effort to identify any such rights.  Information on the   IETF's procedures with respect to rights in standards-track and   standards-related documentation can be found inBCP-11.  Copies of   claims of rights made available for publication and any assurances of   licenses to be made available, or the result of an attempt made to   obtain a general license or permission for the use of such   proprietary rights by implementors or users of this specification can   be obtained from the IETF Secretariat.   The IETF invites any interested party to bring to its attention any   copyrights, patents or patent applications, or other proprietary   rights which may cover technology that may be required to practice   this standard.  Please address the information to the IETF Executive   Director.10.  Acknowledgments   This document was produced by the Application MIB working group.  The   editors gratefully acknowledge the comments of the following   individuals:       Mark Gamble, Cheryl Krupczak, Randy Presuhn, Jon Saperia,       Bob Stewart, Martin Toet, Chris Wellens, Kenneth White.Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 39]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 199911.  Editors' Addresses     Harrie Hazewinkel     Joint Research Centre of the E.C.     via Fermi - Ispra 21020 (VA)     Italy     Phone: +39 0332786322     Fax: +39 0332785641     EMail: harrie.hazewinkel@jrc.it     Carl W. Kalbfleisch     Verio, Inc.     1950 Stemmons Frwy     Suite 2006     Dallas, TX 75207     USA     Phone: +1 214 290-8653     Fax: +1 214 744-0742     EMail: cwk@verio.net     Juergen Schoenwaelder     TU Braunschweig     Bueltenweg 74/75     38106 Braunschweig     Germany     Phone: +49 531 391-3683     Fax: +49 531 489-5936     EMail: schoenw@ibr.cs.tu-bs.de12.  References[1]  Wijnen,, B., Harrington, D. and R.  Presuhn, "An Architecture for     Describing SNMP Management Frameworks",RFC 2571, April 1999.[2]  Rose, M. and K. McCloghrie, "Structure and Identification of     Management Information for TCP/IP-based Internets", STD, 16,RFC1155, May 1990.[3]  Rose, M. and K. McCloghrie, "Concise MIB Definitions", STD 16,RFC1212, Performance Systems International, March 1991.[4]  Rose, M., "A Convention for Defining Traps for use with the SNMP",RFC 1215, March 1991.Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 40]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999[5]  McCloghrie, K., Perkins, D., Schoenwaelder, J., Case, J., Rose, M.     and S. Waldbusser, "Structure of Management Information Version 2     (SMIv2)", STD 58,RFC 2578, April 1999.[6]  McCloghrie, K., Perkins, D., Schoenwaelder, J., Case, J., Rose, M.     and S. Waldbusser, "Textual Conventions for SMIv2", STD 58,RFC2579, April 1999.[7]  McCloghrie, K., Perkins, D., Schoenwaelder, J., Case, J., Rose, M.     and S. Waldbusser, "Conformance Statements for SMIv2", STD 58,RFC2580, April 1999.[8]  Case, J., Fedor, M., Schoffstall, M. and J. Davin, "Simple Network     Management Protocol", STD 15,RFC 1157, May 1990.[9]  Case, J., McCloghrie, K., Rose, M. and S. Waldbusser, "Introduction     to Community-based SNMPv2",RFC 1901, January 1996.[10] Case, J., McCloghrie, K., Rose, M. and S. Waldbusser, "Transport     Mappings for Version 2 of the Simple Network Management Protocol     (SNMPv2)",RFC 1906, January 1996.[11] Case, J., Harrington D., Presuhn R. and B. Wijnen, "Message     Processing and Dispatching for the Simple Network Management     Protocol (SNMP)",RFC 2572, April 1999.[12] Blumenthal, U. and B. Wijnen, "User-based Security Model (USM) for     version 3 of the Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMPv3)",RFC2574, April 1999.[13] Case, J., McCloghrie, K., Rose, M. and S. Waldbusser, "Protocol     Operations for Version 2 of the Simple Network Management Protocol     (SNMPv2)",RFC 1905, January 1996.[14] Levi, D., Meyer, P. and B. Stewart, "SNMP Applications",RFC 2573,     April 1999.[15] Wijnen, B., Presuhn, R. and K. McCloghrie, "View-based Access     Control Model (VACM) for the Simple Network Management Protocol     (SNMP)",RFC 2575, April 1999.[16] Hovey, R. and S. Bradner, "The Organizations Involved in the IETF     Standards Process",BCP 11,RFC 2028, October 1996.Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 41]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 1999[17] Bradner, S., "Key words for use in RFCs to Indicate Requirement     Levels",BCP 14,RFC 2119, March 1997.[18] Berners-Lee, T., Fielding, R. and L. Masinter, "Uniform Resource     Identifiers (URI): Generic Syntax",RFC 2396, August 1998.[19] Berners-Lee, T., Fielding, R. and H. Frystyk, "Hypertext Transfer     Protocol -- HTTP/1.0",RFC 1945, May 1996.[20] Fielding, R., Gettys, J., Mogul, J., Frystyk, H. and T. Berners-     Lee, "Hypertext Transfer Protocol -- HTTP/1.1",RFC 2068, January     1997.[21] Postel, J. and J. Reynolds, "File Transfer Protocol (FTP)", STD 9,RFC 959, October 1985.[22] Kalbfleisch, C., "Applicability of Standards Track MIBs to     Management of World Wide Web Servers",RFC 2039, November 1996.[23] Krupczak, C. and J. Saperia, "Definitions of System-Level Managed     Objects for Applications",RFC 2287, February 1998.[24] Kalbfleisch, C., Krupczak, C., Presuhn, R. and J. Saperia,     "Application Management MIB",RFC 2564, May 1999.[25] Kantor, B. and P. Lapsley, "Network News Transfer Protocol: A     Proposed Standard for the Stream-Based Transmission of News",RFC977, February 1986.[26] Callaghan, B., "WebNFS Client Specification",RFC 2054, October     1996[27] Callaghan, B., "WebNFS Server Specification",RFC 2055, October     1996.Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 42]

RFC 2594                    WWW Service MIB                     May 199913.  Full Copyright Statement   Copyright (C) The Internet Society (1999). All Rights Reserved.   This document and translations of it may be copied and furnished to   others, and derivative works that comment on or otherwise explain it   or assist in its implementation may be prepared, copied, published   and distributed, in whole or in part, without restriction of any   kind, provided that the above copyright notice and this paragraph are   included on all such copies and derivative works.  However, this   document itself may not be modified in any way, such as by removing   the copyright notice or references to the Internet Society or other   Internet organizations, except as needed for the  purpose of   developing Internet standards in which case the procedures for   copyrights defined in the Internet Standards process must be   followed, or as required to translate it into languages other than   English.   The limited permissions granted above are perpetual and will not be   revoked by the Internet Society or its successors or assigns.   This document and the information contained herein is provided on an   "AS IS" basis and THE INTERNET SOCIETY AND THE INTERNET ENGINEERING   TASK FORCE DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING   BUT NOT LIMITED TO ANY WARRANTY THAT THE USE OF THE INFORMATION   HEREIN WILL NOT INFRINGE ANY RIGHTS OR ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF   MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.Acknowledgement   Funding for the RFC Editor function is currently provided by the   Internet Society.Hazewinkel, et al.          Standards Track                    [Page 43]

[8]ページ先頭

©2009-2026 Movatter.jp