This PEP is retained for historical purposes, but the officialgovernance document is nowPEP 13.
This PEP proposes a model of Python governance based around a steeringcouncil. The council has broad authority, which they seek to exerciseas rarely as possible; instead, they use this power to establishstandard processes, like those proposed in the other 801x-series PEPs.This follows the general philosophy that it’s better to split up largechanges into a series of small changes that can be reviewedindependently: instead of trying to do everything in one PEP, we focuson providing a minimal-but-solid foundation for further governancedecisions.
PEP 8016 was acceptedby a core developer votedescribed inPEP 8001 on Monday, December 17, 2018.
The main goals of this proposal are:
A number of details were discussed inthis Discourse thread,and thenthis thread has further discussion. Thesemay be useful to anyone trying to understand the rationale for variousminor decisions.
The steering council is a 5-person committee.
The steering council shall work to:
The council has broad authority to make decisions about the project.For example, they can:
However, they cannot modify this PEP, or affect the membership of thecore team, except via the mechanisms specified in this PEP.
The council should look for ways to use these powers as little aspossible. Instead of voting, it’s better to seek consensus. Instead ofruling on individual PEPs, it’s better to define a standard processfor PEP decision making (for example, by accepting one of the other801x series of PEPs). It’s better to establish a Code of Conductcommittee than to rule on individual cases. And so on.
To use its powers, the council votes. Every council member must eithervote or explicitly abstain. Members with conflicts of interest on aparticular vote must abstain. Passing requires support from a majorityof non-abstaining council members.
Whenever possible, the council’s deliberations and votes shall be heldin public.
A council election consists of two phases:
Each phase lasts one to two weeks, at the outgoing council’s discretion.For the initial election, both phases will last two weeks.
The election process is managed by a returns officer nominated by theoutgoing steering council. For the initial election, the returnsofficer will be nominated by the PSF Executive Director.
The council should ideally reflect the diversity of Pythoncontributors and users, and core team members are encouraged to voteaccordingly.
A new council is elected after each feature release. Each council’sterm runs from when their election results are finalized until thenext council’s term starts. There are no term limits.
Council members may resign their position at any time.
Whenever there is a vacancy during the regular council term, thecouncil may vote to appoint a replacement to serve out the rest of theterm.
If a council member drops out of touch and cannot be contacted for amonth or longer, then the rest of the council may vote to replacethem.
While we trust council members to act in the best interests of Pythonrather than themselves or their employers, the mere appearance of anyone company dominating Python development could itself be harmful anderode trust. In order to avoid any appearance of conflict of interest,at most 2 members of the council can work for any single employer.
In a council election, if 3 of the top 5 vote-getters work for thesame employer, then whichever of them ranked lowest is disqualifiedand the 6th-ranking candidate moves up into 5th place; this isrepeated until a valid council is formed.
During a council term, if changing circumstances cause this rule to bebroken (for instance, due to a council member changing employment),then one or more council members must resign to remedy the issue, andthe resulting vacancies can then be filled as normal.
In exceptional circumstances, it may be necessary to remove someonefrom the core team against their will. (For example: egregious andongoing code of conduct violations.) This can be accomplished by asteering council vote, but unlike other steering council votes, thisrequires at least a two-thirds majority. With 5 members voting, thismeans that a 3:2 vote is insufficient; 4:1 in favor is the minimumrequired for such a vote to succeed. In addition, this is the onepower of the steering council which cannot be delegated, and thispower cannot be used while a vote of no confidence is in process.
If the ejected core team member is also on the steering council, thenthey are removed from the steering council as well.
In exceptional circumstances, the core team may remove a sittingcouncil member, or the entire council, via a vote of no confidence.
A no-confidence vote is triggered when a core team member calls forone publicly on an appropriate project communication channel, andanother core team member seconds the proposal.
The vote lasts for two weeks. Core team members vote for or against.If at least two thirds of voters express a lack of confidence, thenthe vote succeeds.
There are two forms of no-confidence votes: those targeting a singlemember, and those targeting the council as a whole. The initial callfor a no-confidence vote must specify which type is intended. If asingle-member vote succeeds, then that member is removed from thecouncil and the resulting vacancy can be handled in the usual way. Ifa whole-council vote succeeds, the council is dissolved and a newcouncil election is triggered immediately.
The core team is the group of trusted volunteers who manage Python.They assume many roles required to achieve the project’s goals,especially those that require a high level of trust. They make thedecisions that shape the future of the project.
Core team members are expected to act as role models for the communityand custodians of the project, on behalf of the community and allthose who rely on Python.
They will intervene, where necessary, in online discussions or atofficial Python events on the rare occasions that a situation arisesthat requires intervention.
They have authority over the Python Project infrastructure, includingthe Python Project website itself, the Python GitHub organization andrepositories, the bug tracker, the mailing lists, IRC channels, etc.
Core team members may participate in formal votes, typically to nominate newteam members and to elect the steering council.
Python core team members demonstrate:
As the project matures, contributions go beyond code. Here’s anincomplete list of areas where contributions may be considered forjoining the core team, in no particular order:
Core team membership acknowledges sustained and valuable efforts thatalign well with the philosophy and the goals of the Python project.
It is granted by receiving at least two-thirds positive votes in acore team vote and no veto by the steering council.
Core team members are always looking for promising contributors,teaching them how the project is managed, and submitting their namesto the core team’s vote when they’re ready.
There’s no time limit on core team membership. However, in order toprovide the general public with a reasonable idea of how many peoplemaintain Python, core team members who have stopped contributing areencouraged to declare themselves as “inactive”. Those who haven’t madeany non-trivial contribution in two years may be asked to movethemselves to this category, and moved there if they don’t respond. Torecord and honor their contributions, inactive team members willcontinue to be listed alongside active core team members; and, if theylater resume contributing, they can switch back to active status atwill. While someone is in inactive status, though, they lose theiractive privileges like voting or nominating for the steering council,and commit access.
The initial active core team members will consist of everyonecurrently listed in the“Python core” team on GitHub, and theinitial inactive members will consist of everyone else who has been acommitter in the past.
Changes to this document require at least a two-thirds majority ofvotes cast in a core team vote.
Substantial text was copied shamelessly fromThe Django project’sgovernance document.
Text copied from Django used undertheir license. The rest ofthis document has been placed in the public domain.
Source:https://github.com/python/peps/blob/main/peps/pep-8016.rst
Last modified:2025-02-01 08:55:40 GMT