| Hay - 1895 (Roll: 1,814)| Retained by Free Trade | | Nominations: Friday, 19 July 1895 | | | Candidate | Party | Votes | Votes % |
|---|
| Ashton, James (Re-elected) | Free Trade | 556 | 61.30 | | Newton, James | Protectionist | 351 | 38.70 | | Formal Votes | | 907 | | | Informal Votes | | 14 | 1.52 | | Total Votes / Turnout | | 921 | 50.77 | |
|