NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.
Madame Curie Bioscience Database [Internet]. Austin (TX): Landes Bioscience; 2000-2013.
Peggy Marconi,Rafaela Argnani,Alberto L. Epstein, andRoberto Manservigi.
Author Information and AffiliationsThe very deep knowledge acquired on the genetics and molecular biology of herpes simplex virus (HSV), major human pathogen whose lifestyle is based on a long-term dual interaction with the infected host characterized by the existence of lytic and latent infections, has allowed the development of potential vectors for several applications in human healthcare. These include delivery and expression of human genes to cells of the nervous system, selective destruction of cancer cells, prophylaxis against infection with HSV or other infectious diseases and targeted infection of specific tissues or organs. Three different classes of vectors can be derived from HSV-1: replication-competent attenuated vectors, replication-incompetent recombinant vectors and defective helper-dependent vectors known as amplicons. This chapter highlights the current knowledge concerning design, construction and recent applications, as well as the potential and current limitations of the three different classes of HSV-1-based vectors.
The human herpesviruses are an important family of viruses, which become established in various tissues for the life of the host.1,2 Herpes simplex virus (HSV), is a complex human neurotrophic virus that after initial infection and lytic multiplication at the body periphery, generally at oral or genital epithelial cells, enters in sensory nerve endings innervating the site of multiplication and it is retrograde transported to the nucleus of sensory neurons.3,4
The genome is a linear double stranded DNA of 152 kb encoding at least 80 gene products. The genome is replicating by a rolling circle mechanism forming head-to-tail concatamers. During the replication, the presence of inverted repeats sequences flanking the two unique segments of the genome (unique long UL and unique short US) are causing the formation of four isomers equally infectious (Fig. 1).3,5
Herpes simplex virus type 1 genome. The rolling circle replication mechanisms, essential and non-essential accessory genes are depicted.
The infectious virus particle comprehends an icosahedral capsid, which contains the viral DNA genome in association with core proteins. Around the capsid there is an amorphous layer known as the tegument, containing some 20 different proteins with structural and regulatory roles, surrounded by an external envelope containing different glycoproteins involved in different functions, among which the first steps of binding and entry into the host cell. Once the de-enveloped particle has entered the cytoplasm, it is transported through association with microtubules to the nuclear membrane where the viral DNA is released into the nucleus through the nuclear pores;6 all the viral replication, from the transcription to the assembly of a new capsid, takes place into the nucleus. Following the release of the viral DNA into the nucleus, the viral genome circularizes and a cascade is initiated with the transcription of five immediate early (IE) genes (infected cell protein ICP4, ICP27, ICP0, ICP22, ICP47) through the binding of a viral protein present in the tegument (VP16), in combination with cellular factors, to the enhancer element present in all IE promoters (TAATGARAT).7 The products of the above genes are responsible of the transactivation of the early genes (E) which are encoding enzymes and DNA binding proteins required for the viral synthesis; the IE and E are followed by expression of late genes (L) which products are principally structural proteins of the capsid, tegument and envelope (primarily viral structural components).3,5
Following natural infection the virus is know to be axonal transported from the periphery to the cell body of the sensory ganglion where establishes a lytic or a latent infection.8 HSV-1 persists in the latent state in the nervous systems of the host for a lifetime where the viral genome persists in an epichromosomal state associated with histones without integrating into the host genome.9 During a latent infection the virus is in a relative quiescent state where the transcription is limited to a single region of the viral genome and only a group of latency-specific RNAs are detectable in the nuclei of neuronal infected cells. Due to several stimuli, the virus can be reactivated from the latency and usually by anterograde transport gets back to the site of primary infection where it starts a new lytic cycle. Only in few cases the viral particle is retrograde transported to the central nervous system (CNS) and starts a latent or a lytic infection, which evolves in encephalitis.10,11 The newly replicated virus transported anterograde, usually to a site at or near the portal of entry, may cause a localized cold sore disease lasting 2-10 days with subsequent remission when the cold sores disappear. Over time, periods of remission generally increase in length and the duration of cold sores decrease, until the person rarely has active disease. This process is regulated by specific immunity developed by the patient against the virus.12 The virus infection is, however, life-long and can be retriggered in some individuals by specific events, such as sunburn, stress or other infections.13,14
The complete knowledge of the HSV sequences and progress of molecular techniques has leaded to the development of HSV as a vector for several potential applications in human health.15-19 These include (i) delivery and expression of human genes to the nervous system cells,20,21 (ii) selective destruction of cancer cells,22,23 (iii) prophylaxis and immunotherapy against tumors24,25 and (iv) prophylaxis against infections with HSV and other infectious diseases.26,27
In the viral genome there are approximately 80 gene products that can be classified as immediate early (IE or α), early (E or β) and late (L or γ) depending on their kinetics of expression during replication. The viral genes can also be categorized according to whether they are essential or non essential for virus replication (Fig. 1). Essential genes are required to produce new infectious viral particles in permissive cell culture infections. Non essential, or accessory, genes encode products that are not absolutely required in cell culture but are important for optimum lytic replication or affect the natural life cycle of the virusin vivo, contributing to host range, pathogenesis, or latency. The viral DNA contains at least 37 essential genes. The US region of the genome contains only one essential gene encoding the glycoprotein D, which offers the opportunity to replace large segments of viral sequences with foreign DNA.4,28,29 The modified HSV genome should be able to accommodate up to 40-50 kb of exogenous sequences. However, the modification of these viruses to reduce pathogenicity and increase safety often results in the loss of viral activities, which are required for efficient gene delivery and life long association with the host.
In recent years, new technologies have allowed researchers to get deeper into these problems.30 The challenge for many research groups is to develop the tools to render these organisms harmless yet effective for targeted gene transfer and appropriate gene expression. Vectors based on HSV type 1 are currently a) amplicon vectors, b) replication-defective viruses and c) genetically engineered replication-competent viruses with restricted host range.19,31
Amplicon vectors are HSV-1 particles identical to wild type HSV-1 from the structural, immunological and host-range points of view, but which carry a concatemeric form of a plasmid DNA, named the amplicon plasmid, instead of the viral genome.32-34 Amplicon vectors possess several advantages as gene delivery vehicles: a) a large transgene capacity (150 kb); b) the repetitive character of the genome carried by the amplicon particle ensures the introduction of multiple copies of the transgene per infected cell; c) the ability to infect a wide variety of cell types, including dendritic cells; d) the ease of vector construction; e) the limited toxicity due to the lack of viral coding sequences.
Amplicons are bacterial plasmids that contain one or more transgene cassettes and two non coding viral sequences, an origin of DNA replication (ori) and a DNA cleavage/packaging signal (pac) and they require a helper system to be produced. In the presence of HSV-1 helper functions, a circular amplicon can be replicated and amplified as head-to-tail concatemers and packaged into HSV-1 particles as approx 152 kb linear DNA (Fig. 2).35 Classically, amplicon vectors were prepared in cells transfected with the amplicon plasmid and superinfected with helper HSV-1. As the helper virus was generally a replication-defective mutant of HSV-1, the amplicon stocks were produced in transcomplementing cell lines. However, the use of standard HSV-1 as helper resulted in the production of helper-contaminated vector stocks.36,37 The contaminant helper particles, even if defective, induced significant cytotoxicity and inflammatory responses, preventing their use in gene therapy or vaccination protocols.30 To overcome these obstacles, different helper systems that produce essentially helper-free vector stocks have been recently developed.38 The last generation of helper system consists of the entire HSV-1 genome, without pac signals, cloned as a bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) inE. coli supplying the full set of transacting HSV-1 functions.39,40 Another different helper system recently developed is based on the deletion, by Cre/loxP-based site-specific recombination, of the packaging signals of the helper virus in the cells that are producing the amplicons.41
Structure and mechanism of packaging of the amplicon vector.
The replication-defective viruses are viral vectors where “essential” genes forin vitro viral replication are either mutated or deleted. Therefore, these mutants cannot grow except in transformed cell lines, where they are complemented in trans. To date, several replication-defective vectors have been constructed in which the IE genes, expressing infected cell proteins (ICP) 0, 4, 22, 27 and 47, have been deleted in various combinations. IE genes are expressed shortly after viral entry into the host cell and are required for initiation of a cascade of E and L viral gene transcription. ICP4 and ICP27 are essential for replication and the deletion of one or both of these genes requires adequate complementing cell lines capable of providing in trans the proteins encoded by deleted viral genes.42-44 ICP0, 4 and 27 are responsible for E and L gene expression.45,46 Beside its transcriptional functions, ICP27 also affects the splicing, polyadenylation and stability of mRNAs. ICP0 is a promiscuous transactivator acting on ICP6 gene, which encodes the viral ribonucleotide reductase large subunit and possesses a hybrid promoter, which is activated as an IE and an E function.47,48 ICP22, the viral product that might be involved in sequestering of cellular DNA polymerase49 is phosphorylated by two accessory genes UL13 and US3-encoded proteins50-52 and is required for the optimal expression of the ICP0 protein. Deletion of the ICP22 IE gene can be responsible for an over expression of ICP0.53 ICP47 inhibits MHC class I antigen presentation contributing to the virus escape from the immune surveillance.54-56 The “first generation” of replication-defective HSV-1 based vectors consisted of mutants deleted in the single essential IE gene encoding ICP4, namely d120.45 Although these vectors show reduced pathogenicity and can be used to efficiently transfer and transiently express reporter genes in brain, they are nonetheless cytotoxic for neurons in culture. Cell lines that complement ICP4 and ICP27 have permitted the construction of a “second generation” of highly defective mutants.43,57-59 To date, several replication-defective vectors have been constructed in which ICP0, ICP4, ICP27, ICP22 and ICP47 genes have been deleted in various combinations.43,58 Deletion of all five IE genes (ICP 0, 4, 22, 27 and 47) prevents virus toxicity for cells at high multiplicity of infection, allowing the vector gene to persist in cells for long periods60-62 demonstrating that the residual cytotoxicity of the “first generation” of replication-defective HSV-1 based vectors results from the expression of the other four IE genes.28 The multiply deleted mutants show an unusually prolonged transgene expression from the ICP0 IE promoter or the HCMV IE promoter in neurons.63 The advantages of these second generations of replication-defective vectors are characterized by absence of early and late viral gene expression and provide enough space to introduce distinct and independently regulated expression cassettes for different transgenes.43
Deletion of some non essential viral genes results in viruses that retain the ability to replicatein vitro, but are compromised in vivo, in a context dependent manner.64,65 Among the limitations to the use of HSV is the fact that wt virus is highly pathogenic and cerebral injection causes fatal encephalitis. Toxic and/or pathogenic properties of the virus must, therefore, be disabled prior its use as a gene delivery vector.
Several genes involved in HSV replication, virulence and immune evasion, which are non essential for viral life cyclein vitro, have been identified. These genes are usually involved in multiple interactions with cellular proteins, which optimize the ability of the virus to grow within cells. Understanding such interactions has permitted the deletion/modification of these genes, alone or in combination, to create HSV mutants with a reduced ability to replicate in normal quiescent cells, but that can replicate in tumor or dividing cells. These attenuated viruses harbor further modification so they also serve as therapeutic gene delivery vehicles.65,66
Many HSV-1 and HSV-2 genes that are non essential in culture alter virulence in animal models. Among these genes, the ones encoding thymidine kinase (TK), ribonucleotide reductase (RR), the virion-host shut off (Vhs)67 and the ICP34.5 proteins have been extensively studied.68TK is involved in optimizing nucleic acid metabolism for virus growth and is necessary for efficient replication in neurons. RR is necessary for the conversion of rNTPs to dNTPs in neurons, which are otherwise lacking but necessary for the synthesis of new viral DNA during virus replication.69 The Vhs function of HSV causes rapid destabilization of host RNAs and translational arrest.70 Vhs also destabilizes viral messages, resulting in over accumulation of IE and E genes during lytic infection.70-72 The ICP34.5 neurovirulence factor has been found to be essential for HSV pathogenicity.73 It appears to provide multiple functions to the virus life cycle, one of which is to block the arrest in translation, which usually occurs in virus-infected cells as an antiviral response preventing virus replication. This effect is mediated through the cellular PKR kinase, which phosphorylates the translation initiation factor eIF2α, thereby stopping translation. ICP34.5 recruits protein phosphatase 1a, to rephosphorylate eIF2α, allowing protein translation and continued virus replication. Tumor cells often display an impaired PKR pathway and/or elevated levels of eIF2α, that allow replication of ICP34.5-deleted viruses, as the inactivation of the PKR response is less critical in this contest.74,75 Secondly, ICP34.5 seems to be involved in allowing new virions to become packaged and leave infected cells in a cell type-specific fashion. Consequently, in non permissive cells in the absence of ICP34.5 the nucleocapsids are retained in the nucleus and a productive infection cannot ensue.
Use of non replicating viruses or non viral systems as vectors can limit the maximum achievable efficiency of gene transfer. In contrast, use of replicating vectors to allow replication of genes delivered initially to a small number of cells and their subsequent transfer to neighboring cells, as infection spreads, can significantly increase the efficacy of gene delivery.76-78 Attenuated HSV vectors have been tested as live viral vaccines, as oncolytic viruses and as gene therapy vectors to deliver transgenes to the nervous system.
Alterations of the HSV genome can be achieved in a number of ways. These usually require a two-step process (named: marker transfer/marker rescue) in which portions of the herpes genome, which have been cloned into a plasmid vector, are first modifiedin vitro. The plasmid DNA is then cotransfected into cultured cells with infectious viral DNA and recombinant viruses are selected. Several methods have been described to insert DNA sequences into the viral genome. Efficient recombination into specific sites within the viral genome has been achievedin vitro using a recombination system derived from phage P1.79 It is also possible to enhance the frequency of recombination.59 The initial requirement is the insertion of a reporter gene such as β-galactosidase (lacZ) cassette flanked byPacI orPmeI restriction enzyme sites not otherwise found in the viral genome. The second phase is the substitution of the reporter gene with other foreign cDNAs by digestion of the vector DNA withPacI orPmeI to remove thelacZ gene and subsequent repair of the vector genome by homologous recombination with a transgene expression plasmid. Potential recombinant identified by a “clear plaque” phenotype after X-gal staining arose at high frequency (80-100%) (Fig. 3).59 A different procedure involves transfection of cells with overlapping cosmids containing appropriate insertion or deletions. Expression of genes contained in cosmids leads through recombination to the construction of full-length viral genome.80,81 To select recombinant vectors it is critical to have a system by which to identify successful recombinants. The viralTK gene is particularly useful site for insertion since its inactivation does not affectin vitro the replication of the virus.TK mutants can be easily selected in the presence of bromovinyl deoxyuridine or acyclovir.82,83 Another marker system involves disruption of non-essential viral envelope glycoprotein genes, such as the ones encoding gC or gE. Recombinant viruses are identified by loss of an antigenic determinant of the glycoprotein using specific monoclonal antibodies (black or white plaques staining).
Mechanism of construction of recombinant viruses by classical homologous recombination (marker transfer/marker rescue) and using the “PacI system”.
Traditionally, recombinant HSV vectors have been generated through homologous recombination between the HSV genome and a recombination plasmid, which usually requires laborious screening or selection and can take several months. Recent advances in bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) technology have enabled cloning of the whole HSV genome as a BAC plasmid and subsequent manipulation inE. coli. Thus, we sought a method to generate recombinant HSV vectors more easily and quickly using the bacterial recombination machinery.84,85
BAC cloning requires insertion of mini F plasmid sequences and antibiotic resistance genes into the viral genome and the length of these BAC backbone sequences is usually greater than 6 kb in total. Insertion of BAC sequences into the wild-type HSV genome (152 kb) will increase the genome length to ∼158 kb and there will be no space left for the insertion of additional sequences. To avoid deleterious effects of the BAC sequences, including growth defects and potential transmission between bacteria and man, some herpesvirus BAC clones have been constructed with loxP site-flanked BAC sequences, which can be removed by Cre recombinase.86-88
Many of the HSV based vectors have been used in gene therapy studies and some of them as experimental vaccines against HSV-1 infection.26,89,90 However, studies related to the evaluation of the potential of these vectors, as foreign gene or protein delivery systems for immunological studies are very limited. The use of HSV vectors requires the development of mutated viruses that are genetically stable, incapable of replicating in the CNS and of spreading in immunocompromised individuals, not transmissible from immunized individual by contacts and, at the same time, capable of inducing protective immunity against the disease. Recent major breakthroughs in the field of HSV-1 technology authorize and support the use of HSV-1 as vaccine vectors for the delivery of foreign antigens.89,91-95 In particular, HSV vectors show several advantages for prophylaxis against viral infections. They have been shown: (i) to elicit strong and durable immune responses by various routes of inoculation;96,97 (ii) the viral DNA persists inside the host's cell nucleus as an episomal element, thus eliminating the safety concerns deriving from the random integration of the viral genome into the host's DNA; (iii) they carry thetk gene, that, in case of undesired effects, can be used, in combination with specific antiviral drugs, to kill the virus-harboring cells.
The efficacy of all of these vectors might potentially be affected by the preexisting immunity to viral antigens in host. The effect of pre-existing immunity on HSV-1 vectors remains controversial, with some studies showing strong immune response in the face of anti-HSV-1 immunity,96,98 whereas another study showed a reduction in the immune response to a transgene, with the intensity of the reduction depending on the route of inoculation.99
Amplicons were studied as vaccines against HIV96 or intracellular bacteria.93 They show unique advantages over other viral vectors.93 Firstly, amplicon particles are absolutely apathogenic for infected cells since their genome is devoid from HSV-1 genes. Secondly, the repetitive character of the genome carried by the amplicon particle ensures the introduction of multiple copies of the transgene transcription unit per infected cell, likely resulting in strong expression. Lastly, the pantropic properties of HSV-1 particles in experimental systems, which are conserved in amplicons, should allow these vectors to infect a large range of cells, including dendritic cells.
Moreover, amplicons could also allow antigens to be presented by both MHC pathways during the same immunization protocol. This could be achieved (i) by introducing the transgene both in the amplicon genome and in the helper genome or, (ii) by inducing thein vivoproduction of empty virus-like capsids of selected viruses (e.g., HIV-1, HCV, or HPV-16). Concerning this last property, it has been shown that HSV-1 amplicons encoding Moloney murine leukemia virus gag, pol and env genes can induce the synthesis of retrovirus-like particles in cultured cells. Amplicons have been used to efficiently transduce the full set of proteins of MoMLV retrovirus vectors, thus rescuing integrated retrovirus vectors,100,101 as well as the nonstructural102 or structural103 proteins of HCV.104 An interesting remark is that amplicon expressing cytokine genes have been found to be a promising strategy for the development of tumor vaccines.105,106
Until recently, it was believed that, to be effective, viral vaccines must consist of a live, replication-competent virus or a large dose of inactivated virus. Replication of live virus was believed to be essential to provide sufficient immunogen to induce a strong immune response. However, several non replicating vaccines, including replication incompetent HSVs, have been shown to induce an immune response.92,107 These HSV mutants show a reduced cytotoxicity, due to their inability to replicate and to spread in the host, but maintain the capability to infect a wide range of tissues and host species.
HSV replication-defective viruses with mutations in essential genes that fail to form progeny virions and DISC viruses with mutations in structural protein genes that form uninfectious progeny virions have been used as vaccines against HSV infections and as vaccine vectors.108-110 It has been shown that an HSV-2 double mutant (dl5-29) does not cause any disease in immunodeficient mice indicating that the virus would be safe even in immunocompromised individuals.111 DISC-HSV-2 has been shown to be an efficient vector for cytokine gene delivery into tumor cells and that the expression of mGM-CSF or hIL-2 enhances the immunogenicity of whole-cell vaccines.112
The appealing properties of replication incompetent HSV-1-based vectors inducing strong CTL response, both in murine and in simian models, against foreign genes delivered by viral particles have made them very promising candidates for potential anti-HIV-1 and also other viral or intracellular bacterial pathogens vaccine development.91,113,114 It has been shown that a mutant HSV-1 virus deleted for the ICP4, ICP22 and ICP27 genes and expressing ovalbumin (OVA) as a model antigen elicited protection in mice against a lethal challenge with a recombinantListeria monocytogenes expressing OVA.91 A similar vector, expressing HIV-1 Tat protein, has been demonstrated to induce long-term Tat-specific immune responses in the Balb/c murine model.113 Moreover, vaccination ofRhesus macaques with a HSV-1 mutant virus that contains a deletion in ICP27 and expresses SIV Env and Nef antigens showed partial protection against mucosal challenge with the highly pathogenic SIVmac239.115 In the same animal model, using a prime-boost strategy of vaccination, recombinant HSV-1 vectors deleted for ICP4, ICP22, ICP27 and ICP47 and expressing Gag, Env and a Tat-Rev-Nef fusion protein of SIV, elicited robust anti-Gag and anti-Env cellular responses and induced partial protection against intravenous challenge with SIVmac239.27,92
Due to their ability to accept multiple heterologous genes, the IE replication defective vectors could be used for innovative and synergistic strategies of immunization. For example, it is possible to engineer vectors to express specific chemokines and cytokines, together with antigens targeted to MHC-I or II molecules, in order to attract monocytes to the sites of infection, to induce their differentiation into dendritic cells and to favor antigen presentation.
Attenuated live viruses are the most effective to serve as vectors for vaccination. However, a major concern exists about attenuated HSV as a vector. In fact, in addition to the problem of genotypic stability there are other safety issues including questions regarding the potential of vaccine vector to establish latency, reactivate or recombine with virulent wild type strain. To overcome some of these problems, an approach based on defining and eliminating genes involved in neurovirulence, latency or reactivation was developed.116
The first and to date the only one, attenuated HSV-1 virus to be constructed and analyzed as a viral vaccine in humans, was the NV1020 (formerly R7020) strain.117 This virus, based on HSV-1 strain F, has a portion of the unique short region of the viral genome, encoding glycoproteins G, D, I and E, replaced by the homologous region from HSV-2 and possesses only one copy of ICP4. This virus is very strongly attenuated in rodents and primates. In a dose escalation study, local reactions were noted in HSV-1-infected persons. A dose-dependent induction of antibodies occurred in HSV-1 seronegative subjects, but the development of this mutant has been stopped since it resulted too over-attenuated and it was consequently poorly immunogenic.
The goal to construct a safe, less attenuated vaccine candidate, lead to the construction of RAV 9395 mutant.118 RAV 9395 is based on HSV-2, strain G, which carries deletions in the UL55 and UL56 genes, encoding proteins with unknown functions, the deletion of which causes attenuation and deletion in both copies of the γ34.5 gene (encoding ICP34.5 protein). Concomitant with this deletion, both copies of the open reading frame (ORF) P have also been deleted. Thetk gene was left intact and functional, conferring acyclovir sensitivity to the recombinant virus. When used as a live viral vaccine in a guinea pig model of HSV-1 infection, it was shown to be protective and it was also demonstrated that the immunologic answer depended on the route of administration of the virus.
AD472 is an evolution of RAV 9395, in which deletions in UL43.5 and in the US10-12 region were added to obtain an additional safety level by increasing the genetic and phenotypic stability of the virus.119 In a guinea pig model, AD472 administered intramuscularly did not prevent infection and viral replication in the vaginal tract, but reduced lesion development and severity in a dose-dependent manner after HSV-2 wt challenge. Moreover, it generally precluded establishment of latency by the challenge virus.
Mutations in TK, especially for HSV-2, do not attenuate the virus sufficiently for human vaccines.120,121 Other attenuated HSV-1 and HSV-2 viruses with single deletion in vhs or in RR respectively,122,123 were shown to determine a protective immunity when tested in animal models, but still they are too neurovirulent to be used for human trials.
A further improvement to antigen presentation to the immune system could involve the deletion, from the viral DNA backbone, of the genes that codify for the vhs and the ICP47 proteins. In fact, two mechanisms have been described by which HSV inhibits antigen presentation by MHC class I and class II molecules. The first is related with the ability of the Vhs protein to accelerate the degradation of cellular mRNA molecules70 and has also been shown to block dendritic cell maturation and thus to inhibit the immune response against the vector-delivered transgene.67 The elimination of the UL41 locus from the viral genome was reported in the same paper to allow dendritic cell activation and also to stimulate the antigen specific T-cell responsein vitro. The second is based on the ability of ICP47, one of the immediate early proteins, to bind to Tap, the transporter associated with antigen processing and to prevent peptide translocation into the endoplasmic reticulum.54,56
HSV-1 presents several outstanding adaptations to the nerve system and each of them can be rationally exploited in the design of gene therapy vectors with regard to neurological applications. HSV-1 contains genes that control neuroinvasiveness and neurovirulence; this virus can move both in the retrograde and anterograde directions and disseminates transynaptically from neuron to neuron. The virus envelope contains several glycoproteins that mediate entry to neurons due to the recognition of specific receptors (nectins). In most neurons, HSV-1 will establish a latent infection, a situation in which the viral genome will persist as a stable chromatinised episomal element and in which all lytic genes are silenced. Recent studies indicate that, during latency, the viral genome generates a chromatin structure that allows it to behave much like a mammalian minichromosome, with very sophisticated regulation of gene expression. The LATs do not encode proteins and there is increasing evidence suggesting that they can play a major role in the inhibition of the apoptotic response of neurons to virus infection, thereby preventing cell death and favoring eventual reactivation of the virus. The latent virus genome can be reactivated by stress, fever, or immune suppression and, through anterograde traveling along axons, the virus is transported back to the sites of initial epithelial infection, causing recurrent mucocutaneous infections which, in most cases, remain asymptomatic. Recent data indicates that HSV-1 anterograde movement along the axons is dependent upon the interaction of virus proteins with plus-end microtubule motors that move the capsids toward the axon terminals. Many studies indicate that most of these neurotropic features are retained in defective and attenuated HSV-1 vectors, including the abilities to been efficiently transported along axons in both directions and to establish latent infections with prolonged gene expression, both in sensitive and in motor neurons.
Amplicons have been used to deliver and express transgenes in neuronsin vitroand in brainin vivo. They have been used to deliver neurotrophins, like nerve growth factor (NGF)124,125 or brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF),124,126 antiapoptotic genes,127,128 heat-shock proteins129 or antioxidant enzymes,130 in attempts to protect neurons against a variety of neurological insults, in many different experimental settings. Amplicons expressing genes affecting neurotransmitter expression or neuroreceptor synthesis have been used to study behavioral features, like learning and memory.131-134 Amplicons have also been used to deliver tyrosine hydroxylase and other genes to the nigro-striatal system or to cultured striatal cells, in studies aimed to treat Parkinson's disease.135-139 More recently, amplicons were shown to be able to deliver genes to the retinal pigment epithelial cells of the rat retina, but not to the adjacent photoreceptors.140 In this study, amplicons allowed rapid and efficient, but transient, gene transfer, following subretinal injection.
The limitation in the amplicons safety profile was the presence of helper virus particles that resulted in some cytotoxicity. This problem has been circumvented recently by using a plasmid-based BAC transfection system to provide the helper functions, although the particle yield is relatively low.39,40 Gene expressionin vivo using amplicons has been reported to persist as long as one month. However, it cannot be excluded that long-term expression from amplicons may be related to persistent low-level replication by contaminating recombinant wild-type virus in the brain. In fact, in contrast with other amplicon preparations, “helper-free” stocks produce only transient expression of reporter transgenein vivo using the same promoter reported previously to remain active long-term. Another limitation of the amplicons was that they cannot accommodate inserts longer than 10 kb. Wade-Martins and coworkers have developed an efficient viral delivery and expression system based on the HSV-1 amplicon vector, termed the iBAC, or infectious BAC that can carry large genomic locus with surrounding sequences.141-143
Major advances have recently been made to improve the characteristics of these vectors, in particular to reduce their toxicity, to modulate the greatness and the time-course of transgene expression, to precisely target specific cell populations and to transfer multiple genes.17,21,144-147 Non-replicative HSV vectors have been tested in many different gene therapy animal models of various neuropathies, Parkinson's disease,148-150 Alzheimer's disease,151 chronic pain152,153 or lysosomal storage disorders with neurological involvement.154
Therapy of lysosomal storage disorders with neurological involvement such as Tay-Sachs (TS) disease requires production and distribution of the missing enzyme into the CNS. Several therapeutic approaches allow restoring the enzymatic activity in many key tissues (kidney, liver, spleen, etc.) but the reduction of the GM2 ganglioside deposits in the CNS is difficult to achieve since CNS, is kept in a privileged environment separated from the blood system by the blood-brain barrier (BBB), which represents an obstacle to therapy.154 Martino et al have demonstrated that a non-replicating HSV vector encoding for the hexosaminidase (Hex) A α-subunit (HSV-T0αHex) and delivered into the internal capsule of the TS brain animal model was able to re-established the Hex A activity and removed the GM2 ganglioside storage in both injected and controlateral hemisphere and in the cerebellum one month of treatment. The studies concerning lysosomal storage disorders are particularly important because they represent the first evidence of the distribution of a therapeutic viral vector throughout the entire CNS and suggest that the anatomic structure of the brain may be a useful tool in therapy for genetic neurodegenerative disorders.154
Among them, vectors expressing multiple trophic factors seem to be very promising as a side treatment for neurodegenerative diseases. Motor neuron disease (MND) is a group of neurological diseases characterized by degenerative process of the upper and lower motor neuron155 in different parts of the motor system including the spinal cord, brain stem and motor cortex. One of the major breakthroughs in the field of CNS regeneration is the concept that neurotrophic factors (NTFs), which are endogenous soluble proteins regulating survival, growth, morphological plasticity, or synthesis of proteins for differential functions of neurons, govern the processes involved in brain and spinal cord repair.156 Experimental evidence indicates that treatment with multiple neurotrophic factors can significantly increase motor neuron survival in comparison with the delivery of a single factor alone.157,158 HSV-1 vectors that have been engineered to express multiple neurotrophic factors have been used to deliver these molecules to specific neuron populations.159 Non-replicative vectors containing basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) and EGFP (as a reporter gene) have already been shown to induce proliferation and differentiation in O-2A oligospheres obtained from newborn rat brainsin vitro and also in the rat hippocampusin vivo.158
One of the potential target organs of replication competent HSV vector applications, the peripheral nervous system (PNS), seems likely to promise the most successful results. In fact, inoculation of HSV vector by peripheral routes can take advantage of the natural life cycle of the virus, which usually infects axonal nerve terminal at peripheral sites before retrograde transport to neuronal cell bodies where latency is established. It is well known that viral replication is necessary to cross the synapses among neurons and for efficient establishment of latency.160 In the PNS there are a number of potential applications for HSV replication competent vectors capable of peripheral replication and axonal transport, including the stimulation of regrowth of damaged nerves, the study and treatment of various pain states, the protection of neurons from further degeneration in motor neuron disease, the study and treatment of various neuropathies, the study of neuronal development and the screening of the relevance of genes implicated as being important in any of these processes by a gene delivery approach. Thus, viruses mutated in either gC or TK or RR have been extensively used, which, while being somewhat attenuated compared to wt virus, are also replication-competent. The data obtained to date show the potential of such vectors for gene transfer. Attenuated vectors in fact demonstrated to be highly efficient in driving proenkephalin A (PA) gene expression in dorsal root ganglia (DRG),161 to deliver genes into monkey eyes162 and to rodent visual system163 and to express active nerve growth factor beta subunit (β-NGF) in latently infected DRG.
HSV vectors have wide-range natural hosts and have been proven to efficiently infect numerous human tumor cell linesin vitro. A number of new therapies have been developed for treatment of cancer and the knowledge of the basic defects that occur in malignant tumors has lead to the conclusion that the association of different therapeutic approaches is the method to eradicate these malignancies. Potential genes should induce a selective antitumor response that attacks the primary tumor, inhibits metastasis, prevent recurrence and does not promote drug resistance. Another important feature of HSV-1-based vectors for cancer gene therapy is their capacity to express the autologoustk gene, encoding the TK enzyme, a well characterized suicide gene, widely used in gene therapy of different experimental tumors164-166 and which has already been tested in clinical trials.167-169 Another advantage of the use of TK/GCV system is that it is capable of killing both vector-transduced and neighboring cells, owing to the effect.164,170,171
Recent efforts at modifying the envelope of the HSV-1 virion to target specific receptors, e.g., replacement of the heparan sulfate binding domain in gC in the envelope with a receptor ligand or single chain antibody, indicate that it is possible to selectively increase infectivity of tumor cells bearing corresponding receptors.172,173 Infection of normally non infectable cells has been achieved using a soluble adapter fusion protein consisting of the HSV-1 envelope gD and a single chain antibody for the epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), which is enriched on many tumor cells.174
Most anticancer amplicon vectors used to date have employed standard amplicon vectors, which efficiently deliver genes to the cell nucleus but are lost with successive cell division. Therapeutic transgenes used in the context of amplicon vectors have included antiangiogenic factors, immune enhancing agents, proapoptotic proteins and RNAi.175
Stunting of tumor growth can be achieved by inducing hypoxia through inhibition of neovascularization. HSV amplicon vectors have been used to attenuate angiogenesis and thereby inhibit pancreatic tumor growth by expression of a dominant-negative soluble vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) receptor, sFlk-1 under control of a promoter induced in hypoxic conditions.176,177 HSV amplicon vectors have also been evaluated as cancer vaccines by expressing combinations of cytokines and immunomodulatory proteins for treatment of a variety of experimental tumors.24,175,178-181
A promising, new approach to cancer is the selective degradation of mRNA by RNA interference (RNAi)182 or interference with microRNAs that support tumor growth.183 HSV amplicon vectors expressing siRNAs have been used recently to mediate posttranscriptional silencing of EGFR, which is frequently activated in human glioblastoma cells184 and to inhibit the expression of BKV T-Ag and tumorigenicity of BKV-transformed cells.185
Of the wide range of prodrug activating enzymes tested for cancer therapy,186,187 only a few have been delivered via HSV amplicon vectors. One of these is HSV TK, which converts nucleoside analogues, such as ganciclovir, into toxic analogues which incorporate into replicating DNA and lead to cell death.188 A chimeric fusion protein between cytochrome P450 4B1 and GFP in combination with the prodrug 4-ipomeanol was found to confer toxicity to glioma cells with a bystander effect.189 Amplicon vectors have also been girded with two synergistic pro-drug activating enzymes, TK and cytosine deaminase (CD) for tumor therapy and imaging.190,191
The use of a replication-conditional virus to package amplicon vector can improve the efficacy of cancer therapy by combining delivery of therapeutic gene(s) via the amplicon vector with selective viral oncolysis of tumor cells by the replication-conditional virus. It has been demonstrated local and distant immune-mediated control of colon cancer growth with fusogenic membrane glycoproteins in combination with viral oncolysis.192,193 Moreover, an amplicon vector that expresses an essential viral gene, such as ICP4, can complement ICP4- recombinant viruses to efficiently replicate and cause lysis in prostate cancer cells.194 Furthermore, it has been shown that the immunostimulatory effects of amplicon vector-mediated cytokine expression enhance direct viral-induced oncolysis in a syngenic squamous cell carcinoma flank model.105,195,196
Targeting proliferating tumor cells via the transcriptional control of therapeutic genes can potentially improve the safety and efficacy of cancer gene therapy. It has been shown that transgene expression could be targeted to proliferating cells when cell cycle transcriptional regulatory elements are incorporated into amplicon backbone vectors.197-199 For example, transcriptional regulation can be rendered specific to human hepatocellular carcinoma cells by inserting the chimeric gene Gal4/NF-YA under the regulation of a HCC-specific hybrid promoter.200
Tumor necrosis factor-related apoptosis-inducing ligand (TRAIL) has been shown to induce apoptosis in neoplastic cells. It has been reported the efficacy of amplicon delivered TRAIL and its secreted form (S-TRAIL) in treating tumors in vivo and in monitoring both gene delivery and efficacy of TRAIL-mediated apoptosis by dual-substrate bioluminescence imaging.201-203
Multiple immediate early gene-deleted nonreplicative HSV-1 vectors are characterized by high efficiency of transduction of several different host species and cell types, both dividing and non dividing, including various tumor as well as endothelial cells.23,204-207 Different replication-defective HSV vectors have been produced that deliver anticancer transgenes to tumor cells such as melanoma,43 gliosarcoma,205,208,209 or glioblastoma.210 Two or more therapeutic molecules, acting additively or synergistically, can thus be expressed at comparable levels by cells transduced with a combination vector, which is clearly an advantage in comparison with co-administration of two or more vectors encoding a single transgene and also in comparison with co-expression of two molecules, separated by IRES sequences, by a unique vector.
These mutant vectors express, in association with the autologous HSV-1tk gene acting as a suicide gene when accompanied by its pro-drug ganciclovir, further transgenes chosen for their potential to synergize in tumor cell killing and induction of antitumor immunity with genes encoding for soluble human cytokines (IL-2, GM-CSF and IFN-γ), the human B7.1 gene encoding a costimulatory surface antigen (CD80);43 rat connexin 43 gene improving the HSV-1 TK/GCV killing of glioma cells by increasing the bystander effect211 or rat connexin and human TNFα.210,212 Recently, an HSV-1-derived replication-defective vector (T0-IFI16) was developed,204 which has been shown to efficiently transduce an interferon-inducible gene (IFI16), into primary human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVEC), which are usually poorly transfectable. It has also been possible to infect HUVEC cells with similar HSV-1-based vectors expressing antiangiogenic fusion proteins endostatin::angiostatin and endostatin::kringle 5. The expression of antiangiogenic proteins by directly infected HUVEC cells has been shown to induce cytostatic effects in proliferation assaysin vitro. Also, by addition of gancyclovir to the cell culture media, a major cell killing effect was observed.206In vivo, the expression of autologoustk gene in association with GCV was shown to be highly efficient in both reducing small tumor masses growth rates and also in inhibiting tumor cell engraftment. The expression by tumor cells of vector-encoded angiostatic proteins was also extremely efficient in inhibiting the tumor establishment, both in presence or in absence of GCV.206
The wide spectrum of dividing or non-dividing cell types that can be easily infected by nonreplicative HSV-1 vectors and among them endothelial and dendritic cells, along with their large exogenous DNA accommodating capacity, makes these vectors very attractive delivery systems. These unique features might be of extreme importance for combined therapeutic strategies requiring the simultaneous expression of high levels of multiple foreign genes, like suicide genes, cytokines or other immunomodulatory molecules, antiangiogenic proteins, soluble growth factor receptors and so forth. As various types of tumors present different characteristics, the high manageability of large, well characterized HSV-1 genome might permit the combination, in a unique backbone, of the most appropriate exogenous genes for treatment of each particular tumor.
Oncolytic viruses, which selectively infect or replicate in cancer cells while sparing normal cells, have been explored as alternative cancer therapies in both preclinical and clinical trials.77,78 The optimal strategy might be to derive a replicating vector from a highly prevalent but weakly pathogenic human virus,213 so the reversion to wt would then be of no serious risk to the patient or to the population.
Construction of oncolytic viruses that cannot only target cancer cells, but can also retain their ability to infect, usurp host replication machinery, then release newly made progeny to infect other transformed cells after lysing and killing the host cell, has become a major area of therapeutic cancer research. There are some characteristics that an ideal replication-competent, oncolytic virus should possess above and beyond those viruses that function simply as delivery vectors: (i) be easy to engineer and to produce in large quantities; (ii) selectivity to neoplastic cell alone; (iii) minimal toxicity to normal tissue; (iv) show proliferation within and systematic killing of tumor tissue which itself may be rapidly propagating; (v) ability to disseminate throughout the tumor mass and possibly to sites of invasion distant from the initial inoculation site; (vi) carry low or bearable toxicity; (vii) genomically stable, thus avoiding the generation of toxic, undesirable mutants that could pose a danger; (viii) incorporate a “fail-safe” mechanism for inactivation; (ix) absence of potential spread to the general population; and (x) enduring efficacy despite prospect of encountering a mounting immune response to replicating viruses. Replication-conditional HSV-based vectors have great potential in the treatment of various types of cancers including brain tumors.64-66,77,214-220
So far, several oncolytic HSV vectors have been developed. The first generation of these vectors contained mutation in a single gene that restricted their replication to dividing cells. Three such HSV-1 mutants were constructed: (i)dlspTk containing a deletion in thetk gene;221 (ii) hrR3 containing an insertion of theE. coli lac-Z gene in the early gene UL39, encoding the large subunit of the viral RR (ICP6);222,223 and (iii) R3616 containing 1 kb deletions in both copies of the γ34.5 gene, encoding the neurovirulence factor ICP34.5.224-226
TK mutants are highly neuroattenuated and when used in different mouse models of various nervous system-derived tumor types, showed a slowed tumor growth and prolonged survival. However, clinical trials were not pursued because of (i) undesirable level of toxicity at high titers and (ii) its TK-negative status made it resistant to traditional antiherpetic treatments, a major disadvantage should any viral toxicity to arise in treated patients.221,227
ICP6 mutants have been tested as replicative anticancer agents, alone or in combination with acyclovir/gancyclovir, as the mutants retain their sensitivity to such antivirals. Moreover, the RR- mutants have been shown to display an increased sensitivity to gancyclovir, compared to the wt virus. These recombinant viruses showed enhanced killing of tumor cells in vitro and showed improved survival of animals. However, like TK mutants, they can cause fatal encephalitis when used at sufficient dose and were not thought to provide a sufficient margin of safety for testing in humans.223,228
It has been shown that deletion of ICP34.5, the neurovirulence factor essential for HSV pathogenicity, provides the greatest degree of attenuation of any individual mutation where the virus can still replicate in actively dividing cells. R3616, the prototype HSV-1 deleted in both copies of γ34.5, had demonstrated attenuated neurovirulence but with maintained antiglioma activity and was found to produce no encephalitis in a nude mouse model.22,116,229,230 The use of γ34.5 mutated viruses demonstrated considerable antitumor efficacy, combined with a good safety profile and different versions of HSV ICP34.5-deleted are currently in human clinical trials.231
Following preclinical testing with the above mentioned oncolytic vectors, second generation vectors with multigenic mutations were created. G207 contains deletion in both γ34.5 loci and alacZgene insertion in the ICP6 gene.232 These multiple mutations made the reversion to wt highly unlikely and conferred several important safety advantages. Moreover, G207 retains its susceptibility to standard anti-HSV therapies such as acyclovir, since thetk gene is intact. After oncolytic activity and safety evaluation studies in the mouse model,232 G207 neurotoxicity was further evaluated in non-human primates.233 The data obtained in the previous experiment allowed to move into Phase I clinical trials234 and, presently, enrollment has begun for sequential Phases Ib/II trials employing G207 as an antitumor agent for malignant gliomas. Almost simultaneously, HSV1716, derived from the parent wt strain HSV-1 17+ in which both the copies of γ34.5 have been deleted, also underwent clinical trials to evaluate its toxicity in patients with recurrent human glioma,235,236 after it was demonstrated to be avirulent in mice.237,238
Oncolytic herpesvirus have been also studied as an oncolytic antitumor therapy against a variety of tumors different than GBM and anaplastic astrocytoma, such as human breast cancer in a brain metastatic model,25 colorectal cancer and liver metastases,239 prostate cancer,240 pancreatic cancer241,242 and head and neck squamous carcinoma.243 In many of these studies, the efficacy of G207 has been compared with that of the above mentioned NV1020, which has shown to be too attenuated to work as a live viral vaccine.117,244 Moreover, NV1020 is currently being investigated in Phase I clinical trials for patients with colon cancer that has metastasized to the liver and has proven recalcitrant to chemotherapy. This is also the first trial to investigate administration via intravascular delivery. In fact, oncolytic viruses can be administered locally, by direct intratumoral inoculation, or systemically, by intravascular administration. However, the route of administration of the virus did influence efficacy, as was observed in the animal model.
Despite the promising results obtained with the engineered HSV-1 based oncolytic vectors described above, it is likely that a multimodal approach to eradicate cancer will be more effective with the final goal to improve safety and efficacy of the system. At this regard, oncolytic HSV vectors have been further modified to augment their antitumor efficacy, by incorporation of expression cassettes for the delivery of various transgenes. Moreover, if the therapeutic gene is chosen carefully, this may be synergistic with the antitumor effect of virus replication.
Molecules including a number of interleukins and interferons have been tested with oncolytic HSVs. Among these, IL-4,245 IL-12,25,246,247 IL-10,245 GM-CSF,231,247 and B7.1,248 which increase tumor immune recognition. This approach also reduces the possibility of toxicity derived from the systemic administration of the cytokine.
Oncolytic HSVs have been tested, which encode different pro-drug-activating systems other than the endogenous TK activity of the virus. Both the 5-fluorocytosine (5-FC) pro-drug/yeast cytosine deaminase (CD) gene system,249 alone or in combination with the TK/gancyclovir system186 and the cytocrome P-450/cyclophosphamide (CPA) system,250,251 were shown to induce beneficial effects.
Nevertheless, ICP34.5 mutants replicate with considerable reduced efficiency in most tumor cells, compared to wt HSV. To improve tumor-selective replication, an ICP34.5 deleted HSV with enhanced growth characteristics was isolated after serial passages on a tumor cell line. This mutant was also found to give improved antitumor activityin vivo, without compromising safety.252 These improved characteristics were found to derive from a second site suppressor mutation in the unique short region, which determines the expression of the US11 gene as an IE rather than a L gene and the deletion of US12, encoding the ICP47 protein, contributing the improvement of antitumor immune response.253 This viral isolate was shown to exhibit enhanced antitumor effect.254
Most of the oncolytic HSVs analyzed have been based on serially passaged laboratory strains of HSV. These strains have probably lost some of their aggressive properties. It has in fact been recently demonstrated that an oncolytic HSV, JS1/ICP34.5-/ICP47-/GM-CSF, derived from a clinical isolate of HSV-1, possesses a higher ability to kill tumor cellsin vitro andin vivo. Moreover, in a model of mouse lymphoma, mice cured with this virus were protected against further tumor challenge.231
In early clinical trials, however, treatment with the current generation of oncolytic viruses did not significantly affect tumor growth.234,235 This suboptimal result may reflect viral gene deletions, which can reduce the replicative potential of viruses in tumor cells. For example, deletion of the γ34.5 gene significantly reduced viral growth even in rapidly dividing cells.223 A variety of strategies are being pursued to enhance the potency of oncolytic viruses. Overall, the results so far obtained demonstrate that incorporating suicide and/or cytokine transgenes in the viral genome can increase antitumor efficacy, especially if used in combination with preexisting anticancer treatments such as chemotherapy or radiotherapy.66,255 Another strategy is to clone therapeutic genes into the viral genome to arm the virus with additional cytotoxic mechanisms that augment the direct lytic functions of the virus. Particularly attractive in this context are cytotoxic mechanisms with potent bystander effect capable of eliminating tumor cells that the virus cannot reach. To this purpose, it has been recently demonstrated that incorporation of cell membrane fusion capability into an oncolytic HSV can significantly increase the antitumor potency of the virus.256,257 These oncolytic HSVs were constructed by three different methods: (i) screening for the syncytial phenotype after random mutation of a well-established oncolytic HSV (to obtain Fu-10); (ii) insertion of the gene encoding the hyperfusogenic membrane glycoprotein of gibbon ape leukemia virus (GALV.fus) into the genome of an oncolytic HSV (to generate Synco-2); and (iii) incorporation of both of these two membrane fusion mechanisms into a single oncolytic HSV (to generate Synco-2D). These vectors have been tested for their antitumor activity against liver, breast, ovarian and metastatic prostate cancers showing a significant increase in viral oncolysis; this may lead to an enhanced clinical performance, especially in the late stage cancer patients.
The different kinds of vectors that derive from HSV-1 were conceived to take advantage of the biological properties of this virus. Therefore, recombinant HSV-1 vectors, either attenuated or defective, attempt to exploit different adaptations of HSV-1 to the nerve system, such as latency, the presence of powerful neurospecific promoters, or the occurrence of viral genes controlling neuroinvasiveness or neurovirulence. So far, promising results have been obtained in treatment of several models of PNS and CNS diseases,154,258,259 in treatment of pain17,161 and using such vectors as tools for investigation of behavioral traits, like learning and memory132 and for neuroscience research in general.146 Although these vectors have been used mainly for gene transfer to neurons or glial cells, they hold a big potential as vector vaccines,93 both against infectious disease and cancer. In fact, they can efficiently deliver genes to other cell types, including epithelial cells, fibroblasts, myoblasts, myotubes, embryonic and adult cardiomyocytes and cell lines derived from gliomas, hepatocellular carcinomas, osteosarcomas, epidermoid carcinomas and many other human and murine malignancies. In no case, the vector genomes integrate into host chromosomes, therefore precluding the risk of insertional mutagenesis. The other type of vector, namely the amplicon vectors, attempts to exploit the capacity of the virus capsid to accommodate more than 150 kb of foreign DNA. HSV amplicons possess the unique feature to possibly deliver entire genomic loci including all upstream regulatory elements and downstream introns and to convert them into human artificial chromosomes. One of the major areas of interest in amplicon development regards the possibility to produce still larger amounts of purified vectors than those generated by current procedures. To this purpose, different suggestions regard the improvement of the structure of the amplicon plasmids, of the helper virus systems and of the transcomplementing cell lines where the amplicon vector stocks are being produced. As a second point, there is the possibility of controlling transgenic expression for therapeutical applications and to avoid transgenic silencing. This can be achieved since helper-free amplicons do not express proteins enhancing expression, like ICP4, 27 and 22, or proteins protecting from silencing, like ICP0. As a consequence, transgene expression depends on cell type, multiplicity of infection and cell cycle. It is possible that placing transgenic expression under the control of genuine cellular regulatory sequences will resolve, at least in part, this difficulty.142,260,261
Much more work remains to be carried out, especially if we intend to prolong transgene expression and to improve cell targeting. However, although short-term transgene expression represents a great limitation for the use of vectors in the gene therapy of diseases, this is not necessarily the case when considering their use for gene expression that are associated with certain behaviors that are often transient.
Another goal to increase the efficacy of the HSV vectors and to decrease the undesired effects such as infection of healthy cells is to target infection to specific tissues or organs or to restrict transgene expression to predefined subsets of cells. Genetic modifications to the genome of HSV-1 vectors have been generated to preferentially target viral infection and/or replication to tumor cells versus normal cells.174 Targeting viral infection to particular cells can be obtained by modifying the first steps of the virus life cycle, i.e., adsorption and penetration. Efforts for engineering the HSV-1 envelope to obtain targeted infection are currently in progress.16,262-264 Altering HSV-1 host range has proved a formidable task because HSV-1 infection is a complex process involving the action of several glycoproteins in cell attachment, entry and cell-to-cell spread.
As a final consideration, although the vectorology area of research is still in continuous development, certainly, more work should be done in order to better understand the vector/host interactions. Anyway, it can be inferred, from what it is known on HSV-1 immune biology, that all the three types of HSV vectors, including amplicons, will induce an antiviral cellular response, at least in some cell types and will stimulate both the innate and adaptive branches of the immune response in the infected organism. These responses can eventually result in the elimination of the vector or in the silencing of the therapeutic transgenes. Finally, it can be predicted that the large size insert capacity of the amplicon genome, that allow these vectors to express several viral or cellular proteins well-known to down-regulate or to inhibit the antiviral and immune responses, will be a major advantage of amplicons over other vectors to fight against the silencing cellular forces.
This work was supported by MIUR-FIRB-2001 (RBNE0127YS-002), by grants from the Istituto Superiore di Sanità (ISS), the Italian Concerted Action on HIV-AIDS Vaccine Development (ICAV), the Italian Ministry for the University and Scientific Research (FISR), the Italian National Institute of Health (Program Stem Cells, CS 126.1), as well as by the French societies Association Franaise contre les Myopathies (AFM) and Association pour la Recherche sur le Cancer (ARC) and from grants form European Commission (THOVLEN project and HEVAR project, FP6).
Your browsing activity is empty.
Activity recording is turned off.
See more...