NEW YORK — Testimony concluded Monday in the seven-week trial of Bernhard H. Goetz with an expert for the prosecution casting doubt on the subway gunman’s claim the four youths he shot were standing around him when he opened fire.
Suffolk County Medical Examiner Charles Hirsch, the prosecution’s last rebuttal witness, said it was medically impossible to determine how the victims were positioned when they were shot.
Hirsch’s testimony contradicted expert testimony by defense witnesses that the youths were standing in a threatening semi-circle around the gunman and could not have been seated.
Goetz has asserted he acted in self-defense because he thought the four youths, each 19 at the time, were going to rob him on a Manhattan subway train Dec. 22, 1984.
Hirsch said he “strongly” disagreed with earlier testimony from Dominick DiMaio, the city’s former chief medical examiner who on Friday testified that Goetz’s victims were standing in a semi-circle around the gunman when he opened fire.
Hirsch said the bullets that hit victims Barry Allen and Darrell Cabey, who was left permanently paralyzed and brain-damaged, traveled from back to front, bolstering the prosecution’s contention that the youths were shot in the back.
Testimony concluded on Monday afternoon and Manhattan state Supreme Court Justice Stephen Crane said summations would begin Wednesday to accommodate a juror with an important appointment today.
Sign up for Essential California
The most important California stories and recommendations in your inbox every morning.
By continuing, you agree to ourTerms of Service and ourPrivacy Policy.
More From the Los Angeles Times
Podcasts
Taped Jan 8, 2026, a year after the Eaton Fire, this episode features Ondi Timoner. After losing her home, she began documenting the displacement and financial struggles of her neighbors, joining My Tribe Rise to help Altadena rebuild and recover.
Attorney Frank Carson defended the accused for decades. Framed for murder and later acquitted, a star witness admitted he lied. Stanislaus County paid $22.5M to settle his estate’s lawsuit.
Hear from the winner of the 1968 Caltech vs MIT electric car race. But it’s not all fresh air: smog devastates communities of color, and the Trump administration may pull the plug on California’s ability to clear its own air.
