Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


X

Sign in

Oireachtas committee calls for tougher penalties after major Blackwater fish kill in Cork

An Oireachtas committee recommends stronger enforcement powers, rapid response protocols and tougher penalties following Ireland’s largest recorded fish kill
Oireachtas committee calls for tougher penalties after major Blackwater fish kill in Cork

An inter-agency report into the Blackwater fish kill published in September concluded that there was no evidence of a systemic disease in the dead fish. File photo: IFI/Facebook

Fri, 28 Nov, 2025 - 13:40

Penalties for environmental offences should be increased to include custodial sentences, an Oireachtas committee has urged, in the wake of the major Blackwater fish kill in Cork earlier this year.

Having held an urgent meeting in September to try to "build a comprehensive picture" of the causes of the State’s largest ever fish kill incident, the Oireachtas Environment Committee has made 11 recommendations aimed at ensuring such an event does not take place again.

It calls for greater powers for bodies such as Inland Fisheries Ireland, encourages the Environmental Protection Agency to revoke discharge licences for persistent non-compliance, and that sampling be mandated to happen within 24 hours of any reported fish kill.

In August, tens of thousands of salmon and brown trout died in a stretch of the Blackwater near Mallow leaving local fishermen horrified and answers demanded as to how such an event could occur.

An inter-agency report published in September into the incident could pinpoint no definitive cause. The report outlined that there was no evidence of a chronic water quality issue either before or after the kill.

It also concluded that there was no evidence of a systemic disease in the dead fish, with the likelihood being that a waterborne agent had likely entered the water three days before the kill before dissipating quickly.

The special Oireachtas committee hearing into the incident heard that the response of State bodies to the fish kill has resulted in a lack of evidence, which has made an appropriate prosecution very difficult. 

Killavullen Angling Club chairman, Conor Arnold, told the committee that there “was no procedural advice for river users or indeed the public with regard to health and safety or disinfection protocols from the secondary fungal infection” in the Blackwater as a result of the kill.

“Ultimately, the time lost plus the State bodies’ complete inability to observe international best practices during their investigations has resulted in a lack of evidence which has made an appropriate prosecution very difficult,” he said.

The fallout from the incident has continued with calls to end “light touch” environmental enforcement and criticism of the Government for failing to compensate angling interests or install pollution monitors along the river.

Last week, councillors hit out at the Government's response with Labour'sRonan Sheehan calling for real-time monitors. Local angling clubs are currently fundraising to put their own pollution monitoring equipment into the river.

"I don’t believe the State is really serious about stopping this happening again," Mr Sheehan said.

In August, tens of thousands of salmon and brown trout died in a stretch of the Blackwater near Mallow leaving local fishermen horrified and answers demanded as to how such an event could occur. File photo: Facebook/Conor Arnold
In August, tens of thousands of salmon and brown trout died in a stretch of the Blackwater near Mallow leaving local fishermen horrified and answers demanded as to how such an event could occur. File photo: Facebook/Conor Arnold

In its brief report, the Oireachtas Committee said a national rapid response protocol should be urgently established for fish kills, to ensure an immediate and co-ordinated sampling of water, sediment and fish tissue.

“[We recommend] formal multi-agency co-operation be strengthened and formalised, and joint training to improve co-ordination during environmental incidents,” it said. "National standards for fish kill investigations be introduced.

“Penalties for environmental offences be increased, including higher fines and custodial sentences, with provision for cases to be heard in higher courts.

“[And] that a Blackwater River restoration scheme be created to support fish restocking, if appropriate, and give assistance to angling clubs and affected communities.”

x
Irish Examiner Logo

BLACK FRIDAY

Get full digital access for€3 a month. Cancel anytime.

Already a subscriber?Sign in

Black Friday Offer

CONNECT WITH US TODAY

Be the first to know the latest news and updates

More in this section

Lunchtime News

Newsletter

Keep up with stories of the day with our lunchtime news wrap and important breaking news alerts.

logo podcast

War of Independence Podcast

A special four-part series hosted by Mick Clifford

Available on
www.irishexaminer.com/podcasts

IE logo

Commemorating 100 years since the War of Independence

IE_logo_newsletters

Select your favourite newsletters and get the best of Irish Examiner delivered to your inbox

Cookie PolicyPrivacy PolicyBrand SafetyFAQHelpContact UsTerms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited


[8]ページ先頭

©2009-2025 Movatter.jp