Dismissal Formalized in SAG-AFTRA Merger Lawsuit (Exclusive)
The litigation comes to an end as the union moves forward with the task of implementing the merger.
Federal JudgeJames Otero accepted on Tuesday the proposed order filed by the parties dismissing the federal lawsuit that sought to enjoin the SAG/AFTRA merger referendum,The Hollywood Reporter has learned. The move marks the formal end to the litigation.
The referendum passed almost two months ago and last week, the partiesfiled a settlement agreement to dismiss the case. That came aftera letter from plaintiffs’ counselDavid Casselman released Wednesday, addressed toSAG-AFTRA’s outside lawyer,Bob Bush, in which Casselman agreed to dismiss the case.
Under the settlement, neither side will pay damages or attorneys fees to the other. As is usual, none of the parties admitted liability. The dismissal is “with prejudice,” a legal term that means the lawsuit cannot be refilled. The settlement encompasses “all claims brought . . . or that could have been brought in the (lawsuit).”
The rerendum’s passage was overwhelming: 82 percent of SAG members voted Yes, and 86 percent of AFTRA members did so as well. The tally was announced March 30.The Hollywood Reporter subsequently reported another unexpected result, that the Yes vote was78 percent in SAG’s Hollywood Division, previously a stronghold of merger opponents.
Those numbers, and the court’s refusal two days earlier to enjoin the vote count, set the stage for today’s dismissal.
AsTHRpreviously reported, the current lawsuit is the fourth filed in the last six years against SAG by members of the MembershipFirst group, whose leaders are key plaintiffs in the current suit.
The defendants in the current suit, in addition to the union, were SAG-AFTRA co-presidentKen Howard, co-secretary-treasurerAmy Aquino and executive vice-presidentNed Vaughn, vice-presidentsMike Hodge andDavid Hartley-Margolin and national executive directorDavid White.
The plaintiffs wereMartin Sheen, Edward Asner, Ed Harris, Valerie Harper, Clancy Brown, James Remar, George Coe, Diane Ladd, Lainie Kazan, Nichelle Nichols, Renee Aubry, Jane Austin, Erick Avari, Steve Barr, Sara Barrett, Terrance Beasor, Michael Bell, Warren Berlinger, Joe Bologna, Ralph Brennen, Alexandra Castro, Jude Ciccolella, Cynthia Lea Clark, David Clennon, Joe D’Angerio, Patricia D’Arbanville, Dick Gautier, Dorothy Goulah, Marty Grey, Sumi Haru, Angel Harper, Basil Hoffman, David Huddleston, Anne-Marie Johnson, David Jolliffe, Kerrie Keane, Peter Kwong, Kurt Lott, Barbara Luna, Eric Lutes, Stephen Macht, Michael McConnohie, Peter Antico, Susan McNabb, Phyllis Timbes, Marguerite Moreau, Traci Murray, Nicole Mandich, Larry Newman, Barbara Niven, Kathleen Nolan, Jack Ong, Peggy Lane O’Rourke, Leslie Parrish, Scott Pierce, Robin Riker, Stephanie Rose, Alan Rosenberg, Alan Ruck, Wendy Schaal, Tascha Schaal, Nancy Sinatra, Cynthia Steele, Renee Taylor, Malachi Throne, Beverly Todd, Jessica Wright and Momo Yashima. In addition, there were a number of other clients in the litigation who were not listed as plaintiffs, includingPaul Edney.
Bookmark The Hollywood Reporter’sLabor Page for the most in-depth coverage of entertainment unions and guilds.
Email:jhandel@att.net
Twitter:@jhandel
THR Newsletters
Sign up for THR news straight to your inbox every day
More from The Hollywood Reporter
![]()
![]()
- Warner Bros. Discovery
Paramount, Comcast and Netflix Make Official Bids for Warner Bros. Discovery as High-Stakes Fight for the Company Begins
![]()
- Gotham Awards
The Gotham’s Filmmaker Magazine to Be Rebooted Under Vanity Fair Veteran Mike Hogan (Exclusive)
![]()
- Warner Bros. Discovery
A Paramount Takeover of Warner Bros. Discovery? HBO Max’s Casey Bloys Isn’t Sweating It
![]()
![]()
Essential Reads
THR Newsletters
Sign up for THR news straight to your inbox every day
The Definitive Voice of Entertainment News
Subscribe for full access to The Hollywood Reporter