Editorial Reviews
FromBooklist
Review
“Meticulous . . . illuminat[es] an entire social milieu . . . Beautifully rendered . . . this new biography is a gem, and includes a touching look at Wyatt's single lifelong friendship with Doc Holliday . . . offer[s] the reader an exciting glimpse into vanished forms of American life. The field of Western history has now entered a phase of precision scholarship, [of] deep research and glorious writing.” ―The Wichita Eagle
“This brief, well-written, and superbly researched volume reconfigures the life of the western notable Wyatt Earp.... Anyone who reads this important book is not likely to view Wyatt Earp the same way.” ―Richard Etulain, Journal of American History
“Absorbing . . . Isenberg's brilliance as a historian comes in part from finding the gaps within the myth . . .Wyatt Earp is part biography, part historical nonfiction that reads like a gripping novel. Like David McCollough, Richard Slotkin, Nathaniel Philbruck, and S.C. Gwynne, Isenberg gives us a narrative of the Old West and 19th century America that's at once edifying and exhilarating in its scope.” ―PopMatters
“his is the best dead-on Earp deconstruction I've ever read. At a time when vigilante action is being widely discussed―when we must ask ourselves if standing one's ground after stalking a black teenager translates into justifiable murder―it’s good to know that, in the old days, the issue was even more shockingly unsettled. Not only did Earp slay with impunity, but he also relied on the media to help him wipe the fingerprints and clean up the blood. Isenberg’s book deftly shows how a man of violence remade himself into a man of valor.” ―Tucson Weekly
“Masterful . . . [the book] will be applauded by those who like their history to adhere more closely to facts.” ―The New Mexican (Santa Fe)
“Isenberg carefully separates the historic from the hysterical, examines documents, evaluates sources critically and eventually scrapes away from Earp's image the gilding that cultural history has applied . . . Isenberg shows us Earp as an early Jay Gatsby, reinventing himself continually.” ―Kirkus Reviews
“Meticulously researched and persuasively argued, this weave of a single life and its constantly changing culture shows how an ambitious, violent man from the Midwest who made his name as a gambler, pimp, and all-around enforcer ultimately took up the cause of remaking his own reputation, with enduring consequences for Hollywood myth and popular lore. No biographer has ever illuminated the origins of Wyatt Earp's legend or captured his complexities and contradictions as compellingly and with such beautiful prose as Andrew C. Isenberg does inWyatt Earp: A Vigilante Life.” ―Louis S. Warren, author of Buffalo Bill’s America: William Cody and the Wild West Show
“Even Wyatt Earp must sometimes stand naked. Andrew C. Isenberg’s new biography of Earp shows us the man bereft of his own mythologizing―a cardsharp, a flimflam man, and most of all a ruthless self-promoter. This is a remarkable and revealing portrait.” ―Thomas Cobb, author of With Blood in Their Eyes and Crazy Heart
“This book is quite simply absorbing. That a life as tangled, contradictory, mythologized, and disguised as Wyatt Earp's could offer such a clear window into the nineteenth- and twentieth-century West is a tribute to Andrew C. Isenberg's talent as a historian and writer.” ―Richard White, author of Railroaded: The Transcontinentals and the Making of Modern America
“With no ax to grind, and showing respect for even the most outrageous attempts at history and biography (which he systematically disassembles), Andrew C. Isenberg has written a reliable guide to Wyatt Earp's conflicted existence.” ―Loren D. Estleman, author of The Perils of Sherlock Holmes
About the Author
Andrew C. Isenberg is the author ofMining California: An Ecological HistoryandThe Destruction of the Bison: An Environmental History, 1750–1920, and the editor of The Nature of Cities: Culture, Landscape, and Urban Space. He is a historian at Temple University.
Product details
- ASIN : B009LRWHV8
- Publisher : Hill and Wang; 1st edition (August 6, 2024)
- Publication date : August 6, 2024
- Language : English
- File size : 5.6 MB
- Text-to-Speech : Enabled
- Screen Reader : Supported
- Enhanced typesetting : Enabled
- X-Ray : Not Enabled
- Word Wise : Enabled
- Print length : 321 pages
- Best Sellers Rank: #343,052 in Kindle Store (See Top 100 in Kindle Store)
- #90 inHistory of Southwestern U.S.
- #153 inHistory of Western U.S.
- #564 inBiographies & Memoirs of Criminals
- Customer Reviews:
About the author

Andrew C. Isenberg is the Hall Distinguished Professor of American History at the University of Kansas. He was born in Chicago and studied at St. Olaf College and Northwestern University. He specializes in American environmental history and the history of the North American West.
Looking for specific info?
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find the book to be an excellent read with meticulous research, and one review describes it as a great source of information about the old west. The writing is well-executed, and customers find it inexorably interesting, with one noting how it cuts through the mythology surrounding Wyatt Earp.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Select to learn more
Customers find the book to be an excellent read.
"...This is anexcellent book."Read more
"...By all means, give thisimportant book a read if you are interested in American character...."Read more
"...Portrays Earp as a man of his timesReally good read"Read more
"Great book but I have my doubts about the author thinking about Wyatt & Doc Hollidays relationship...."Read more
Customers praise the book's meticulous research, with one customer noting it provides a comprehensive and informative account of the Old West, while another mentions it clears up many questions about Wyatt Earp's life.
"Avery eye opening comprehensive informative account of who and what Wyatt Earp really was. This book really goes deep into what made him tick...."Read more
"Well written, balanced writing about the real Wyatt EarpMeticulously researched, sharing facts vs the legend created by Lake..."Read more
"It'snot a very engaging book considering the subject's multiple "reinventions"...."Read more
"Excellent reading !Great source of information about the old west."Read more
Customers find the book interesting, with one review noting how it goes deep into what made Wyatt Earp tick and cuts through the mythology surrounding him.
"...This book reallygoes deep into what made him tick...."Read more
"Also interesting."Read more
"...Casey Tefertiller mined these hills back in 1997 in hisinexorably interesting and entertainingly exhaustive WYATT EARP: THE LIFE BEHIND THE LEGEND...."Read more
"This book gave aclear understanding of Wyatt Earp...."Read more
Customers praise the writing quality of the book.
"This ia anexceptionally well written book. It covers the background of the Earp family and it sets them in the context of the time and place...."Read more
"Well written,balanced writing about the real Wyatt Earp Meticulously researched, sharing facts vs the legend created by Lake..."Read more
"...Thewriting was clear and precise. I thoroughly enjoyed the book."Read more
"Awell-written biography that cuts through the mythology of Earp, Tombstone and the west. Highly recommended. Best, JS"Read more
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United States on February 4, 2025A very eye opening comprehensive informative account of who and what Wyatt Earp really was. This book really goes deep into what made him tick. It was fascinating to learn about the “ not so law and order” man that he was and about the amount of run ins he had with the justice system ….as an accused criminal.
- Reviewed in the United States on October 2, 2013It's not a very engaging book considering the subject's multiple "reinventions". Wyatt almost becomes a secondary character to his father and brothers. Demythologizing western heroes in my view has become passe. Earp has to have been more engaging than he is presented by Isenberg,if only by virtue of his travels and multiple careers. I can't recommend this book,
- Reviewed in the United States on June 7, 2018This ia an exceptionally well written book. It covers the background of the Earp family and it sets them in the context of the time and place. The character of Wyatt Earp and his brothers is set out with all the complexity and contradictions that allow the reader to see them as real human being. The historical forces that were affecting the West are also explained the move from a largely ranching community to mining and cities and the political cross currents at play are placed in context. This is an excellent book.
- Reviewed in the United States on July 16, 2013Eric Isenberg has done a decent job of taking a position and explaining himself. He believes that Wyatt Earp was a con man and gambler who reinvented himself every time he moved from place to place; a man, who, in fact, moved in order to reinvent himself according the code of masculinity of the time. It is Isenberg’s discussion of this code of masculinity that I find most interesting, not anything supposedly new that he has to say about Earp.
Isenberg does not really turn up anything that no one had turned up before. I’ve not done a whole lot of original research on the Earp brothers, but I did find what I considered a few glitches that indicated Isenberg had not entirely immersed himself in the literature. He called the place where Earp claimed to have killed Curly Bill Brocius “Burleigh Springs,” for instance, and most folks who are familiar with the story know that it was given that name only once by the Tombstone EPITAPH, and thereafter most folks relating the story called it Iron Springs. The general consensus is that the EPITAPH used the name Burleigh Springs to mislead the reading public at the time.
And I admit to dismissing his interpretation of the O’Rourke affair as soon as I read it. Again, I didn’t think that was the point of the book. Minor interpretations of historic events don’t necessarily matter, although they are interesting fodder for discussion in forums that like that sort of thing.
What I DID find interesting was the fact that Earp’s brother-in-law, William Edwards, presented him with a copy of Owen Wister’s THE VIRGINIAN, and Isenberg believes he was inspired to reinvent himself in the form of the gunfighter hero of that novel (pp. 202-204). The notion fits with what I talk about in THAT FIEND IN HELL, when I write “Legends are the stories we tell ourselves to reinforce our myths, which articulate our value systems. One builds upon the other, feeding back and forth. History becomes shaped by legend. Myth shapes how we express our perception of history. Legend becomes historic fact” (p. 211).
I think where Isenberg missed the boat was in not taking the next step. It is not important what Wyatt Earp thought of himself. What is important is what the rest of the world thought of him. Why, if Isenberg is correct about Earp’s criminal background, has he become the legend he is today? It is not because Earp continually reinvented himself, but because Earp as he viewed himself and what others – such as Bat Masterson and journalists in San Francisco and Stuart Lake and Walter Noble Burns – saw in his story the makings of a legendary hero and his contribution to American myth.
By all means, give this important book a read if you are interested in American character. It tells us all a great deal about ourselves as Americans, far more than about a con man and gambler of the nineteenth century. – Catherine Holder Spude, Author of “THAT FIEND IN HELL”: SOAPY SMITH IN LEGEND. - Reviewed in the United States on March 6, 2022Well written, balanced writing about the real Wyatt Earp
Meticulously researched, sharing facts vs the legend created by Lake
Portrays Earp as a man of his times
Really good read - Reviewed in the United States on June 28, 2013What the reviewer has to say seems to reflect that either s/he hasn't read the book, or if s/he has they didn't pay much attention. To anyone with an open mind the book is a thoroughly researched and documented portrait of this conflicted and highly mythologized figure. The author is trying to do exactly what the reviewer embodies in his/her "review" (which is actually an ad hominem character assassination designed to discredit the book sight unseen): overcome the myth of Earp as an upright lawman, when he actually lived on and played both sides of the law for almost his entire life - a myth many people have a personal and professional stake in protecting. To ignore the evidence and the conclusions it leads to is the shoddy part. Just read the book and you'll see that the historical record describes not only Earp the tough and fearless enforcer (which he was) but also Earp the brothel bouncer, horse thief, absconder of public funds, fugitive, and vigilante who shaped his past in order to create the kind of legend the reviewer completely buys into.
- Reviewed in the United States on December 23, 2014Also interesting.
Top reviews from other countries
- BeamerdogReviewed in Canada on May 13, 2017
3.0 out of 5 starsThree Stars
Much better books on this subject. - ShirleyReviewed in Australia on September 9, 2015
4.0 out of 5 starsFour Stars
Very informative - ian bennettReviewed in the United Kingdom on October 18, 2017
5.0 out of 5 starsWyatt Earp, Hero Are Con Man
Excellent Book, Well Researched, Shows The Famous Law Man, Warts And All,Although I Have Read Many Books On Wyatt Earp, This Book Surprised Me, With All This Extra Information, Most Of Which Is Uncomplimentary, A Great Read Though. - CorrêaReviewed in Brazil on January 13, 2019
5.0 out of 5 starsHistoria interessante
Produto muito bom, estou satisfeito com a compra - Amazon CustomerReviewed in France on December 21, 2024
1.0 out of 5 starsNul
Ce livre est un pamphlet contre le personnage et non une biographie objective et bien sourcée. Le livre dépeint Wyatt Earp comme un criminel, homosexuel, qui utilisait la force de la loi pour servir ses intérêts personnels. Les sources sont biaisées, et on reconnaît la patte de certains critiques anti Earp.
On sent également très fort l'orientation anticapitaliste et gauchiste de l'auteur, pour qui les hommes de loi sont souvent des bandits vénaux, et les bandits sont des hommes bien qui ont eu de mauvaises fréquentations...
Le seul aspect intéressant est le tableau sociologique de l'Ouest américain au 19è siècle.
Si vous voulez une biographie de Wyatt Earp, essayez plutôt Wyatt Earp: frontier Marshal ou la biographie écrite par Teterfiler, qui sont bien plus fidèles.