Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.

To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser.

Log In



or



orreset password

Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link.

Need an account? Click here to sign up
Academia.eduAcademia.edu

“Being Poloné in Haiti: Origins, Survivals, Development, and Narrative Production of the Polish Presence in Haiti”

Profile image of Sebastian  RypsonSebastian Rypson
visibility

description

188 pages

link

1 file

Sign up for access to the world's latest research

checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact

Abstract

In this thesis I provide a descriptive and analytical overview of the historical circumstances concerning the participation of Polish Legionnaires in the Haitian Revolution during the period 1802-1803. I analyse the reasons for their defection to the Haitian Army and their subsequent naturalisation as Haitian, and thus ‘Black’, citizens. Furthermore, I provide an in-depth overview and analysis of the Poloné-Ayisyen community and its history in Haiti, focussing also on the survival of material and immaterial artefacts of the Poloné-Ayisyen existence remaining in Haiti today. The confluence of the discourse about development and marginalisation on the one had, and communal identity is dealt with as a central contemporary issue. Finally, I specifically focus on the intertwinement of historical narratives produced by the Poloné-Ayisyens themselves and narratives concerning development of their community, as well as an analysis of historical narratives about the Poloné-Ayisyens produced by non-Haitian authors, and the way historical narrative production works in general.

Figures (36)

Fig. 3 - Cazale lying in the basin of the River Brethelle, as seen from Beilac
Fig. 3 - Cazale lying in the basin of the River Brethelle, as seen from Beilac
Fig. 4 - A favourite past-time of rural Haitian men; the cockfight, or gaguerre (or gagé) in Cazale
Fig. 4 - A favourite past-time of rural Haitian men; the cockfight, or gaguerre (or gagé) in Cazale
Fig. 5 - Cérémonie du Bois Caiman by Louverture Poisson
Fig. 5 - Cérémonie du Bois Caiman by Louverture Poisson
Fig. 9 - Massacre at St. Marc as depicted in “Popiofy” by Andrzej Wajda
Fig. 9 - Massacre at St. Marc as depicted in “Popiofy” by Andrzej Wajda
Fig. 12 - Battle on San Domingo by January Suchodolski
Fig. 12 - Battle on San Domingo by January Suchodolski
Fig. 13 - The variations in racial phenotype of Cazaliens is striking; Cazaliens in KaDet and KaBelno, both are habitations of greater Cazale
Fig. 13 - The variations in racial phenotype of Cazaliens is striking; Cazaliens in KaDet and KaBelno, both are habitations of greater Cazale
Fig. 14 - Variations in phenotype occur frequent- ly within families  nalise the traumatic events that befell them during the spring of 1969, as well as the current feeling of economic marginalisation as a direct prod- uct of the 1969 Massacre. *!
Fig. 14 - Variations in phenotype occur frequent- ly within families nalise the traumatic events that befell them during the spring of 1969, as well as the current feeling of economic marginalisation as a direct prod- uct of the 1969 Massacre. *!
Fig. 21 - Descendant sitting on his ancestors’ grave; the ‘Belnots’ first Polish settler of Cazale; Cazale cemetery  Fig. 20 - Purported head- stone of “Zal”: mvthical
Fig. 21 - Descendant sitting on his ancestors’ grave; the ‘Belnots’ first Polish settler of Cazale; Cazale cemetery Fig. 20 - Purported head- stone of “Zal”: mvthical
Fig. 22 - Haitian fanal or Christmas lantern
Fig. 22 - Haitian fanal or Christmas lantern
Fig. 24 - Fond Blanc; purported site of first Polish settlement  ence to the white settlers that settled there. Importantly, Fond Blanc is the first location where the Polish Legionnaires decided (or were grant- ed permission by Dessalines) to settle. This is testified to by both the inhabitants of Cazale as of Fond Blanc.*! It is therefore impossible at this point to totally reject the idea that the ‘Blanc’ in the ‘Fond’ has nothing to do with the ‘blans’ who settled this remote village.
Fig. 24 - Fond Blanc; purported site of first Polish settlement ence to the white settlers that settled there. Importantly, Fond Blanc is the first location where the Polish Legionnaires decided (or were grant- ed permission by Dessalines) to settle. This is testified to by both the inhabitants of Cazale as of Fond Blanc.*! It is therefore impossible at this point to totally reject the idea that the ‘Blanc’ in the ‘Fond’ has nothing to do with the ‘blans’ who settled this remote village.
Fig. 27 - Véve, drawn symbol to invoke Ezili Danto  Vodou seems limited to merely providing a visual contribution to an already existing system of beliefs, stories, symbols, and myths.
Fig. 27 - Véve, drawn symbol to invoke Ezili Danto Vodou seems limited to merely providing a visual contribution to an already existing system of beliefs, stories, symbols, and myths.
Fig. 29 - Polish rewriting of The White King of La Gonave; Bialy Krol Gonawy by Jan Kilarski  .. . tradition that they were the descendants of a Polish regiment sent over by Napoleon . . . to recover Haiti as a French dominion. The black patriot Dessalines, driving the French invaders into the sea (as those who have followed still have fervid dreams of driving all white invaders into the sea) spared the Polish legion and their descendants of mixed blood. Dessalines said the Poles were victims of Napoleon, pressed into service against their will to make war on a strange people for whom they had no ill feeling. They were in Haiti, said Dessalines, because of Napoleon’s interference with Poland’s liberty and had been through troubles of their own which he had no desire to make worse.  (Wirkus 1931:115)
Fig. 29 - Polish rewriting of The White King of La Gonave; Bialy Krol Gonawy by Jan Kilarski .. . tradition that they were the descendants of a Polish regiment sent over by Napoleon . . . to recover Haiti as a French dominion. The black patriot Dessalines, driving the French invaders into the sea (as those who have followed still have fervid dreams of driving all white invaders into the sea) spared the Polish legion and their descendants of mixed blood. Dessalines said the Poles were victims of Napoleon, pressed into service against their will to make war on a strange people for whom they had no ill feeling. They were in Haiti, said Dessalines, because of Napoleon’s interference with Poland’s liberty and had been through troubles of their own which he had no desire to make worse. (Wirkus 1931:115)
Fig. 30 - Présence Polonaise en Haiti; published during the Pope’s visit, showing the Pope and Dessalines side by side
Fig. 30 - Présence Polonaise en Haiti; published during the Pope’s visit, showing the Pope and Dessalines side by side
Fig. 31 - Géri Benoit interviewing an old Cazalien for documentary Sang Mélée
Fig. 31 - Géri Benoit interviewing an old Cazalien for documentary Sang Mélée
Fig. 33 - Poloné children at the home of Andléne Garcon; teacher and leading GCDC member  Ultimately, one can see that with dévlopman, Polishness is only an asset in the sense that it sets the Cazaliens in a unique position with a unique history. Their special history can even be seen as a counterweight to the request for developmental aid; ‘we might be poor, but we’re spe- cial, we have a heroic history, our ancestors fought for freedom.’
Fig. 33 - Poloné children at the home of Andléne Garcon; teacher and leading GCDC member Ultimately, one can see that with dévlopman, Polishness is only an asset in the sense that it sets the Cazaliens in a unique position with a unique history. Their special history can even be seen as a counterweight to the request for developmental aid; ‘we might be poor, but we’re spe- cial, we have a heroic history, our ancestors fought for freedom.’
Fig. 34 - The local school; Lycee Jérémie Eliazer, partially funded by the GCDC
Fig. 34 - The local school; Lycee Jérémie Eliazer, partially funded by the GCDC

Key takeaways

  • Important events which have had bearing on the Poloné-Ayisyen community after the death of Dessalines, such as the entrenchment of colour as a social fixture of Haitian social reality; the American Occupation (1915)(1916)(1917)(1918)(1919)(1920)(1921)(1922)(1923)(1924)(1925)(1926)(1927)(1928)(1929)(1930)(1931)(1932)(1933)(1934) and the crowning of King Faustin Wirkus on the island of La Gonâve; the Massacre of 1969 in Cazale, the best known community of Poloné-Ayisyens in Haiti; the visit of legendary Polish dramatist Jerzy Grotowski (1980Grotowski ( -1981; and the visit of Pope John Paul II (1983) will all be dealt with in the chapter: 'Events, Memory, Narrative, and Historical Production'.
  • Indeed, trudging through Cazale and its environs, I often met people who, when asking if they were Polish (after clarifying that I too, was Polish), would answer, 'mon cher, gade figi'm, gade zye'm, gade Colour then, is the most distinguishing Polish retention in Haiti today.
  • This is not to exclude the possibility of cultural synthesis, Haitian and Polish, but typically Polish?
  • However, although the tone is respectful, an emphasis is put on the Polish connection with Cazale twice, implying that because of a certain blood bond (familial in this case I think), the Polish government has an obligation of sorts to aid their (Polish) descendants who don't have the means to do it themselves.
  • Why has something remained from the Polish Presence in Haiti?

Related papers

Halka/Haiti - white archive, black body? Reenactment and repetition in the Polish-colonial context

My speech focuses on the artwork prepared for the Polish Pavilion during 2015 Venice Biennale. Two Polish-American artists: C.T. Jaspers and Joanna Malinowska with curator Magdalena Moskalewicz realized a project that consisted of bringing a Polish 19th century opera entitled Halka to a “Polish” village in Haiti. In 1802 Napoleon send soldiers to crush the revolt of black slaves in Saint-Domingue (now Haiti). Among them – a Polish squad. The legend says that they refused to fight. In result they stayed in Haiti and their descendants (black people with blue eyes) are called Poles till today. They live in the small, mountain village called Cazale. Halka/Haiti. 18°48’05”N 72°23’01”W project, inspired by Werner Herzog’s Fitzcarraldo movie, have brought first Polish opera to Haitian Poles as a kind of gift. Analyzing the project and its contexts I address the issue of the relation between performance and repetition. The whole project can be interpreted as a kind of reenactment of Polish and Haitian history. But in fact in the archive we can find another version of events. Polish Napoleonic soldiers in majority were fighting against Haitians. Few of them – and none of the officers – changed sides. I ask what is performed in Cazale? What is enacted and reenacted when Polish opera signers in Polish traditional costumes sing Polish opera in the Haitian village, for the Haitian villagers and with their small input? The theoretical background is Rebecca Schneider’s conceptions of reenactment and repetition. At the end I address another issue: how the relation between the history, repetition and performance can be analyzed when it is seen in the colonial and post-colonial context? What is the relation between this artwork, the story held in the archives, the document it produces and the notions of blackness and whiteness it uses? How the document reenacted by the body changes itself depending on the skin color? I refer to the concepts of blackness provided by Fred Moten in his writings.

View PDFchevron_right
Colonial Subjects No More: Histories of the Haitian Revolution

In his 1995 book Silencing the Past: Power and the Production of History, Michel-Rolph Trouillot has used the construction of both public memory and the academic M a t t s o n | 2 historiography of the Haitian Revolution to explore issues such as dominant narratives, historical silences, and the postmodernist recognition of many truths. These themes can in fact be seen quite often in the recent historiography of the Haitian Revolution due to its remarkable but for too long silenced impact on world history. Trouillot emphasizes the usefulness of the Haitian Revolution in examining the discipline of history itself, down to the insistence upon the rigors of research even in a postmodernist context. "The unearthing of silences," writes Trouillot, "and the historian's subsequent emphasis on the retrospective significance of hitherto neglected events, requires not only extra labor at the archives […] but also a project linked to an interpretation." 1 The historiography of the Haitian Revolution intersects with many issues of French colonialism; modernism, colonialism, postcolonialism, slavery, revolts, revolutions, racism, citizenship, republicanism and historical discourse are all topics which are well-represented in the scholarship. This essay will explore the English-language histories of the Haitian Revolution with a primary focus on the most recent works.

View PDFchevron_right
The construction of identity in haitian indigenism and the post-colonial debate

This article focuses on three moments in the intellectual elucidation of Haitian identity during the time that Haiti was occupied by the United States, from 1915 to 1934. It analyses the intellectual output of writers of Haitian Indigenism, which emerged during this period of crisis and its political developments. The article makes five main points: first, it presents the emergence of Haitian Indigenism; second, it turns to the first manifestation of Haitian intellectuals against the US occupation, considering the so-called 'writers at the margins of Indigenism; third, it presents the position of authors of the Revue Indigène, particularly of Jean Price-Mars; fourth, it analyses the Revue Les Griots, concentrating on how François Duvalier makes political use of the racial issue. Finally, through these investigations, the article establishes a dialogue with contemporary authors who discuss the construction of identity within post-colonial debate.

View PDFchevron_right
The Haitian Revolution in Interstices and Shadows: A Re-Reading of The Kingdom of This World

2004

Alejo Carpentier's The Kingdom of this World (1949), the only sustained literary rendering of the Haitian Revolution in the Spanish Caribbean, is known both for its fi ctional treatment of Haitian history from a slave's perspective and for the preface that claimed for that history the distinction of epitomizing marvelous realism in the Americas. This reading of the text's approach to one of the salient foundational narratives of Caribbean history looks at how, despite the "minute correspondence of dates and chronology" of the events narrated in The Kingdom of This World, the version of Haitian history offered by Carpentier is a fractured tale whose fi ssures may be read as subverting the adherence to the facts of Haitian history and its primary sources that the author claims for his text. It looks specifi cally as how the erasure of the leaders of the Revolution from the text, particularly that of Jean-Jacques Dessalines, reveals Carpentier's hopelessness concerning the Haitian land and its people.

View PDFchevron_right
Becoming Indigenous in Haiti, from Dessalines to La Revue Indigène

small axe, 2017

This essay analyzes the long genealogy of Haitian indigenism as an alternative discourse to diaspora in discussing Caribbean identity. I focus on two moments when indigenous rhetoric becomes prominent: the 1920s cultural movement against the U.S. Occupation and the War of Independence itself. At both of these conjunctures, the rhetoric of indigeneity foregrounds issues of sovereignty, making specific territorial claims on the basis of filiation while demanding the expulsion of others as foreign. At the same time, the term indigène more frequently designates a position in relation to an imperial power than a set of concrete cultural attributes, advancing an argument that is more political than essentialist. While examining how this indigenous rhetoric envisions relations with the aboriginal Taino, I demonstrate the strengths, limitations, and contradictions of a discourse that sought to anchor Africans and their descendants in New World spaces.

View PDFchevron_right
The Aftermaths of the Haitian Revolution and the Modern Haitian Diaspora

Written for Dartmouth College MALS program and presented at the 2104 AGLSP Conference, this paper explores the modern Haitian diaspora and Haitian cultural difficulties with links tracing back to the Haitian Revolution and French colonialism.

View PDFchevron_right
The Haitian Revolution in Interstices and Shadows: A Re-reading of Alejo Carpentier's The Kingdom of This World

Research in African Literatures, 2004

Alejo Carpentier's The Kingdom of this World (1949), the only sustained literary rendering of the Haitian Revolution in the Spanish Caribbean, is known both for its fi ctional treatment of Haitian history from a slave's perspective and for the preface that claimed for that history the distinction of epitomizing marvelous realism in the Americas. This reading of the text's approach to one of the salient foundational narratives of Caribbean history looks at how, despite the "minute correspondence of dates and chronology" of the events narrated in The Kingdom of This World, the version of Haitian history offered by Carpentier is a fractured tale whose fi ssures may be read as subverting the adherence to the facts of Haitian history and its primary sources that the author claims for his text. It looks specifi cally as how the erasure of the leaders of the Revolution from the text, particularly that of Jean-Jacques Dessalines, reveals Carpentier's hopelessness concerning the Haitian land and its people.

View PDFchevron_right
Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

Related papers

5. “’The Haitian Turn’: An Appraisal of Recent Literary and Historiographical Works on the Haitian Revolution,” The Journal of Pan African Studies, 5:6 (September 2012):37-55
View PDFchevron_right
"Haitian Narration." Review of Laurent Dubois, Avengers of the New World: The Story of the Haitian Revolution (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2005).
View PDFchevron_right
The Haitian Revolution in Interstices and Shadows: A Re-reading of Alejo Carpentier's<i>The Kingdom of This World</i>

Research in African Literatures, 2004

View PDFchevron_right
AINSI PARLA L'ONCLE AND THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE HAITIAN IDEOLOGY
View PDFchevron_right
Review: V. Figueroa, Prophetic Visions of the Past: Pan-Caribbean Representations of the Haitian Revolution
View PDFchevron_right
Maroon Movements Against Empire: The Long Haitian Revolution, Sixteenth-Nineteenth Centuries

JOURNAL OF WORLD-SYSTEMS RESEARCH , 2022

View PDFchevron_right
Twin Pillars of Resistance: Vodou and Haitian Kreyòl in Michel-Rolph Trouillot’s Ti difé boulé sou istoua Ayiti [Stirring the Pot of Haitian History]

Latin American Literary Review, 2021

View PDFchevron_right
African Identities The anti-dialectical signification of Erzulie Danthor and Bois Caiman of the Haitian Revolution The anti-dialectical signification of Erzulie Danthor and Bois Caiman of the Haitian Revolution
View PDFchevron_right
States of Ghetto, Ghettos of States: Haiti and the “Era de Francia” in the Dominican Republic, 1804–1808

The Global South, 2012

View PDFchevron_right
Introduction Haiti's Paper War: Post-Independence Writing, Civil War, and the Making of the Republic, 1804–1954 (NYU Press 2020)

Haiti's Paper War: Post-Independence Writing, Civil War, and the Making of the Republic, 1804–1954, 2020

View PDFchevron_right
Julia Gaffield. ‘Haitian Connections in the Atlantic World: Recognition after Revolution’ (Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2015)

Journal of Latin American Studies, 2017

View PDFchevron_right
Stealing the Citadel: Icons of Nationhood and Memories of Theft in Haitian Narratives of Kout Kouto

New West Indian Guide, 2024

View PDFchevron_right
“Unexploited sources for the history of the Haitian Revolution”

Latin American Research Review 18 : 95-103, 1983

View PDFchevron_right
Haitian History: New Perspectives, edited by Alyssa Goldstein Sepinwall

New West Indian Guide, 2015

View PDFchevron_right
Racial Property, Radical Memory: Epilogues to the Haitian Revolution

Global Raciality: Empire, Postcoloniality, Decoloniality , 2019

View PDFchevron_right
4: Haitian Identities at the Juncture Between Diaspora and Homeland

Center for Migration Studies special issues, 1996

View PDFchevron_right
Encountering Creole genesis in the Haitian press: Massillon Coicou's fin-de-siècle feuilleton "La Noire" in La Española-Isla de Encuentros, ed. Jessica Barzen, Hanna Lene Geiger, Silke Jansen (Tübingen: Narr, 2015)
View PDFchevron_right
FROM "KNOWLEDGE" OF THE OTHER TO THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE SELF: HOW "KNOWLEDGE" FACTORS INTO THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE HAITIAN STATE
View PDFchevron_right
Archives of Revolution: Toward New Narratives of Haiti and the Revolution
View PDFchevron_right
“Atrocity, Race, and Region in the Early Haitian Revolution: The Fond d’Icaque Rising.” In The Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Latin American History. April 2018.

http://latinamericanhistory.oxfordre.com/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780199366439.001.0001/acrefore-9780199366439-e-361, 2013

View PDFchevron_right
Interesting Beings and Racial Difference in Fictions of the Haitian Revolution

Karib: Nordic Journal for Caribbean Studies, 2018

View PDFchevron_right
Re-thinking the Haitian Other in Relation as prochain: A Reading of Édouard Glissant and Lyonel Trouillot

Journal of Haitian Studies, 2013

View PDFchevron_right
In the shadow of the Citadel: Haitian national patrimony and vernacular concerns

Journal of Social Archaeology, 2019

View PDFchevron_right
Revolution and Universality: Interpreting the Time and Age of the Haitian Revolution 1791-1804

The Future(s) of the Revolution and the Reformation, Elena Namli (ed.), 2019

View PDFchevron_right
Tropics of Haiti: Race and the Literary History of the Haitian Revolution in the Atlantic World, 1789–1865, written by Marlene L. Daut

New West Indian Guide / Nieuwe West-Indische Gids

View PDFchevron_right

Related topics

Historical AnthropologySocial and Cultural AnthropologyPolish HistoryHaitian RevolutionHaitian History

[8]ページ先頭

©2009-2025 Movatter.jp