Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Outline

Ethnomusicology and the Exiles (2016)

Profile image of Jeff Todd TitonJeff Todd Titon

2016, On the Third Hand: A Festschrift for David Josephson

visibility

description

4 pages

Sign up for access to the world's latest research

checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Play
Audio Waves
Listen to Podcast Summary
Generated with AI
Transcript: Hello and welcome to another episode of "In Depth with Academia," where we dive into intriguing academic findings and explore their relevance to our everyday lives! I'm Richard Price, your host today, and I'm eager to wade through the academic waters with all of you listening out there!

Today, we’ve got a pretty fascinating topic on our hands! We're looking at a paper by Jeff Todd Titon titled "Ethnomusicology and the Exiles"! Now, I know what some of you might be thinking—ethnomusicology? What's that about, Richard? Good question! Ethnomusicology is, um, basically the study of music from the cultural aspect—how music relates to the social lives of individuals and groups!

This paper dives into, well, the impact of exiled scholars on the development of ethnomusicology as a discipline, particularly in North America! It's captivating how the involuntary movement of people due to social and political upheaval has enriched entire academic fields! One of the main thrusts of Titon’s argument here addresses how these scholars—exiles fleeing Nazism and European anti-Semitism during the 1930s and 1940s—added layers of depth to this field! Why is that significant, you ask?

Well, consider this—ethnomusicology wouldn’t be what it is today without their contributions! These scholars brought with them a treasure trove of musical traditions and perspectives, effectively intertwining their diverse experiences with the academic discourse in the countries they moved to—North America being a major hub! It’s like opening a door to a fascinating dimension that we wouldn’t have accessed otherwise! The interplay of their forced exile with the evolution of ethnomusicology reflects a vivid narrative of resilience and innovation, don’t you think?

Now, let's dive into some key points in the paper! Titon explains how these exiled musicologists significantly influenced the discipline by merging methodologies—those from comparative musicology with cultural anthropology! That’s a pretty big deal! For instance, George Herzog, one of the exiles, is highlighted as a pivotal figure—integrating Boasian anthropology with music analysis, essentially laying the groundwork for the ethnomusicology we recognize today!

Ah, speaking of which—Boasian anthropology was spearheaded by Franz Boas, who kinda revolutionized anthropology through cultural relativism! Imagine, each culture viewed based on its own merits rather than against another! Anyways, back to Herzog—he was a mentor to many who, um, would go on to be pillars in ethnomusicology themselves, despite…you know, his harsh—even grueling—methods!

I mean, can we pause to consider what it would have been like in those grueling office sessions Herzog held where he critiqued students' musical transcriptions? Talk about academic pressure! But, hey, that kind of rigour carved out the meticulous details that ethnomusicology needed to be recognized as a serious field of study! Now, some students barely survived Herzog's tough love while others thrived— it’s a classic “do or die” scenario!

Oh, wait! That reminds me of something a bit unrelated—has anyone else had those mentors or bosses who were unrelentingly critical and yet, thinking back, you realize they pushed you further than you thought possible? Yeah, like you didn’t appreciate it in the moment, but later, you're somewhat grateful? Anyway…back to the paper!

Titon also delves into the legacy left behind by Herzog’s students, having learned their lessons to, um, adapt their approaches—you know, like balancing tradition and innovation! People like David McAllester and Bruno Nettl carried the torch forward by championing new societal dynamics and pedagogical insights! They helped lay the bricks for organizations such as the Society for Ethnomusicology, broadening the reach and impact of the field!

But listen—as inspiring as all these details are, remember! I’m just presenting findings from Titon’s paper, not endorsing them, alright? Ethnomusicology, like any academic field, is built on shifting knowledge and interpretations. It’s not absolute truth, but rather offers valuable insights, to ponder on and reflect upon!

By the way, Titon gives us another intriguing angle—how generations of exiles and their immediate students were tentative about ethnomusicology aligning with social and political activism! And there's a reason for this stance: they'd witnessed how music was manipulated for propaganda by oppressive regimes, understandably creating this skepticism! Though sad, it’s revelatory, isn’t it—music, an elemental force of unity, distorted into something sinister—not to get too grim here!

Yet, as time moved forward into the late 1990s, the field opened up, you know? Ethnomusicology broadened its horizons to embrace applied and public dimensions, intertwining music with community and social responsibility! It began intertwining with the public interest! It's interesting how sometimes, fields—like people—find a way to evolve their identities over time!

Wow! This paper encompasses so much–from oppression to innovation, stringent methodologies to empathetic expansions—it is quite a journey through history! Titon’s account offers us a mirror into the past—a chance to see how adversity has been a crucible for progress in unexpected domains!

As we wind down, my takeaway here is the appreciation for how interconnected things are. How global events shape even niche fields, how perseverance in academia can lead to groundbreaking shifts! Wherever you sit in your interest in music or academia, these insights remind us of this enduring human tapestry woven through struggle and triumph!

Thanks for staying with me today on "In Depth with Academia"—I always find joy in sifting through academia with all of you folks! Remember to explore, question, and engage with the knowledge, because every piece is worth reflecting on—you never know what it will spark in you!

Until next time, keep questioning, keep searching, and be excited by those curiosities! Take care and enjoy the tunes of your lives!

Abstract

A short essay, for David Josephson's festschrift, on the European exiles from Nazi Germany, and their impact on the field of ethnomusicology in North America. My Brown University colleague David accomplished monumental research on the exiles and their impact on musicology. Conversations with him about it led me to ask how they impacted ethnomusicology.

Key takeaways
sparkles

AI

  1. George Herzog's influence shaped comparative musicology and ethnomusicology in North America from the 1930s to 1950s.
  2. The founding of the Society for Ethnomusicology (SEM) in 1955 marked a pivotal moment for the discipline.
  3. Exile scholars played a critical role in establishing ethnomusicology as an academic field in the U.S.
  4. The founding generation prioritized academic legitimacy over social activism in ethnomusicology.
  5. Bruno Nettl's contributions significantly advanced ethnomusicology, influencing generations of scholars since 1983.

Related papers

Individuals and contexts in musicology and ethnomusicology. An introduction

Music, individuals and contexts: dialectical interaction, 2019, ISBN 978-88-32932-64-5, págs. 1-8, 2019

Volume realizzato con il patrocinio dell'Associazione "Ricerca Continua. Alumni Lettere e Filosofi a Tor Vergata"

Ethnomusicological Encounters with Music and Musicians: Essays in Honor of Robert Garfias. (review)

Notes, 2012

In 1962, only a dozen years after the term "ethnomusicology" first appeared in print in the writings of Jaap Kunst, Robert Garfias arrived at the University of Washington to found a program in ethnomusicology studies. Over the ensuing decades, the program at Washington influenced hundreds of students, musicians, and scholars, at the university and beyond. In this book, former students and colleagues of Garfias contribute essays on a variety of ethnomusicological topics in tribute to his influence on each of them and on the field as a whole.

Performing Ethnomusicology: Teaching and Representation in World Music Ensembles (review)

Ethnologies, 2006

Ethnomusicology as the Study of People Making Music ([1989] 2020)

Toward a Sound Ecology, 2020

Ethnomusicology is the study of people making music. People make sounds that are recognized as music, and people also make “music” into a cultural domain. This 1989 conference paper defined ethnomusicology and contrasted music as a contingent cultural category with earlier scientific definitions that essentialized music as an object. It was published for the first time in Musicology Annual (2015). Here it is as reprinted, with a new introduction, in my book Toward a Sound Ecology: New and Selected Essays (Indiana University Press, 2020). The book is available from IU Press, the usual online sources, and your favorite independent bookstore.

Ethnomusicology, Archives, & Decolonization (Music 445a)

Syllabus/Schedule and Flyer, 2021

In this seminar students examine the field of ethnomusicology through the lens of its archives, those storehouses of field recordings that helped establish the field. Discussions and assignments will focus on: - Extraction and "salvage" practices in ethnomusicology and its archives; -Decolonizing archives through repatriation and collaborative practices; -Traditional and evolving functions of archives, from collection and preservation, to access and community partnerships.

The New (Ethno)musicologies - Introduction

The New (Ethno)musicologies, 2008

Over the last twenty years a range of radical developments have revolutionised Musicology – leading certain practitioners to describe their discipline as ‘New’. What has happened to Ethnomusicology during this time? Do its theories, methodologies and values remain rooted in the 1970s and 1980s or has it also transformed? What directions might or should it take in the new millenium? With contributions from a number of key figures in Ethnomusicology and related disciplines, this volume explores Ethnomusicology’s shifting relationship to other disciplines and to its own ‘mythic’ history, and plots a range of potential developments for its future. It also considers perspectives on Ethnomusicology from ‘inside’ and ‘outside’ the ‘discipline’, and its broader contribution and relevance beyond the academy. In a period of particular dynamism and intense technological change, when Music departments, in the UK at least, are increasingly opening their doors to Ethnomusicologists, and valuing the types of skills and approaches they offer, such reflection is particularly timely. In many respects, this volume also offers a European perspective; one that provides some interesting and refreshing contrasts from the North American discourses and institutional dynamics that have tended to dominate Ethnomusicology since the 1950s.

Jähnichen, Gisa (2018). Review Essay—Francesco Giannattasio & Giovanni Giuriati, eds. 2017. “Perspectives on a 21st Century Comparative Musicology: Ethnomusicology or Transcultural Musicology?’ AEMR-EJ, 1: 65-69.

This compilation of articles resulting from papers given on the occasion of three different seminars in three consecutive years from 2013 to 2015 (Perspectives on an 21st Century Comparative Musicology: Ethnomusicology or Transcultural Musicology?; Living Music: Case Studies and New Research Prospects, and Musical Traditions in Archives, Patrimonies, and New Creativities) is an interesting mixture of very updated and at the same time well-grounded insights into the core problems of a discipline that starts to question itself: Ethnomusicology or transcultural musicology? It is not by accident that the title of the first conference is also the general topic of the publication, whether there are sections on local music practices, historical research activities or general anthropology. The central question seems to be the denial of purity in cultures and the consequences for anything ethnomusicology has achieved so far.

It Was Never Just About the Music: Is Ethnoarts Ethnomusicology’s Next Incarnation?

2018

In this rhetorical essay, I argue for the benefits and possibility of grounding ethnomusicological research in enactments of artistic communication genres. I describe conceptual imprecision and incomplete analyses that often result from our fieldwork being guided by abstract categories like music and dance. I go on to outline the kinds of research needed to better understand any and all artistic acts formally and socially, and points to the promise of richer, more coherent, more productive, more multi-disciplinary output, with more relevance to the world. This unpublished 2018 version includes important content about pro- social impact removed for publication in the International Journal of Traditional Arts, https://tradartsjournal.ncl.ac.uk/index.php/ijta/article/view/19.

Ethnomusicology in Action -An Appeal of Musicology (My applied research on Ethnomusicology 365 at the University of Alberta, department of Ethnomusicology)

European Journal of Research , 2020

Ethnomusicology, formerly known as Comparative Musicology (Ethnomusicology Newsletter in 1953) is a theoretical subject which is the combination of archiving, research, teaching & learning, presentation, outreaching, interviewing, gathering data, observation, documenting musical tradition, for the development of human being, global development, community sustainability, peace and harmony, social integrity, justice, health and education. It is music like other music through singing, dancing, playing instruments, drama, poetry (Ramayana, a great Indian epic written by a great monk and poet Tulsi Das, it reflexes nationalism, music folklore, ethnology (Giving Voice to Hope for Liberia, a refugee camp in Ghana's village is the combination of nationalism, folklore and ethnology, international folk music council, a UNESCO affiliated organization created for international cooperation manifested in the creation of the United Nations). The paper aims to explore Ethnomusicology as an independent subject from the subject of Musicology and to know traditional music from around the world through its participatory research activities within the community and in the classroom. The outcome is to establish and understanding its glimpses to the society, its complexity through social, economic, cultural bonds in every ethnic and traditional community such as discover of Pigmy Community through the reading of Rain Forest. The question is how does Ethnomusicology work as a medication for the deprived community from the ancient world to the present world? The future activities are to expand its various roots by writing and researching especially to know about the music of lost communities from humanity such as Maya civilization.

Performing Ethnomusicology: Teaching and Representation in World Music Ensembles. By Ted Solís, ed. (Berkeley, Los Angeles and London: University of California Press, 2004. Pp. Vii + 322, index, ISBN 0520238311)

Ethnologies, 2006

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (2)

  1. McAllester, David. 1989. Unpublished videotape of seminar at Brown University, transcribed by Lisa Lawson. Accessible from the author, and from the American Folklife Center, Archive of Folk Cul- ture, Library of Congress, Washington, DC.
  2. Merriam, Alan. 1963. Review of Henry Weman, "African Music and the Church in Africa." Ethnomusicology 7 (2):135.

FAQs

sparkles

AI

What methodology did George Herzog combine in his research process?add

Herzog integrated comparative musicology techniques with Boasian cultural anthropology methods, emphasizing transcription and ethnographic fieldwork.

How did Herzog influence musicology curricula in the United States?add

Herzog's high standards shaped the training of students and the establishment of doctoral programs, leading to a professionalized discipline.

What characterized the teaching approach of George Herzog towards his students?add

Herzog employed a rigorous method of critique, pushing students like McAllester to improve under tough feedback, which some found overwhelming.

What was the perception of public ethnomusicology among Herzog's contemporaries?add

The founding generation viewed public ethnomusicology skeptically, prioritizing academic rigor over social activism or educational outreach within music education.

When did the significant influence of applied ethnomusicology emerge in the field?add

Applied ethnomusicology gained traction in the late 1990s, following earlier skepticism from the exiled founders who experienced music’s role in propaganda.

Related papers

Introduction to the Special Issue: The Ethnomusicology of Western Art Music

Ethnomusicology Forum, 2011

Pacific Review of Ethnomusicology Department of Music
Toward an ethnomusicology of the early music movement: Thoughts on bridging disciplines and musical …

Ethnomusicology, 2001

I. Ethnomusicology, Ethnographic Method, and "Non-Western" Music In an introduction to a special issue of the Journal of the American Musicological Society (JAMS) published in 1995, Regula Qureshi discussed the relationship between anthropology, history, and a broader musicology that includes ethnomusicology. Qureshi characterizes the "anthropologizing of music history," the primary and most productive relationship to date of anthropology and historical musicology, as beginning with "a recasting of the musical product into the realm of experience" (Qureshi 1995:335). The four essays that follow Qureshi's introduction interrogate music in culture through highlighting the notions of "dialogue, de-essentializing, and difference" (Qureshi 1995:339). Indeed, the specialJAMS issue builds on historical musicology's growing engagement with a range of anthropological theories that have served to enliven and enrich the musicological palette, forecast earlier in writings by Tomlinson (1984) and Treitler (1989). Ethnomusicologists, of course, have drawn freely on anthropology; indeed, they have spent much of the second half of the twentieth century trying to remake their own discipline in its image. To note just a few milestones, one might cite Merriam's Anthropology of Music (1964), Alan Lomax's Cantometrics (1976), Timothy Rice's remodeling of ethnomusicological theory (1987) based on readings of Clifford Geertz, and Mark Slobin's schema for transnational musics (1993) which draws upon Arjun Appardurai's notion of "ethnoscapes" (Appadurai 1990). Ethnomusicological research and writing have further interacted closely with a number of different streams of anthropological thought, ranging from structuralism, to symbolic, linguistic, and reflexive anthropology. While none of these efforts has resulted in a new theory that moves beyond its anthropological model, there have been, particularly recently, a number of increasingly nuanced case studies. Yet there is one area allied to anthropology in which ethnomusicologists alone have innovated. I have earlier suggested (Shelemay 1996b) that the domain of ethnographic method is where ethnomusicologists have most successfully and creatively occupied a disciplinary space midway between anthropology and musical scholarship. One is tempted to dub this a true "anthromusicology." But since terminology is already so problematic, I will draw instead on a distinction made over a decade ago by Anthony Seeger (1987). While historical musicologists are now beginning to participate actively in an "anthropology of music," bringing the "concepts, methods, and concerns of anthropology" to studies of music history, ethnomusicologists have in the meantime moved much more aggressively toward what Seeger has termed a "musical anthropology," exploring the way[s] "musi

The Ethnomusicologist as Inventor of Musical Tradition*

To Judith Cohen, longtime colleague and friend Very little remains of the conceptual world in which ethnomusicologists received their education and worked in the first half of the twentieth century. Suffice it to recall some key words and concepts born in the second half of that century, which convey the scope and depth of the intellectual revolution: imagined communities, imagined ethnicities, ethnography as "writing culture", the ethnographer or ethnomusicologist as an objective outsider, and subsequent alternative titles -"participant observer" and even "insider" (Clifford and Marcus 1986; Barz & Cooley 2008). The very concept of tradition, a central tenet of anthropology and ethnography, underwent a thorough interpretive reevaluation, which now claimed it to be invented and malleable (Hobsbawm & Ranger 1983). In this article, I focus on a single case of invented musical tradition. It concerns Professor Edith Gerson-Kiwi, a well-trained historical musicologist, who switched to ethnomusicology mainly due to the circumstances of her life, that is, due to the historical and cultural-ideological trends and pressures of the time and place to which she belonged. Far from wishing to criticize her findings or methodology, my purpose here is to learn something about situations that might arise when ethnomusicologists intervene with the musical life of their own culture.

New Musicologies, Old Musicologies: Ethnomusicology and the Study of Western Music*

Current Musicology, 1997

Music, the Public Interest, and the Practice of Ethnomusicology (1992)

Ethnomusicology, Vol. 36, no. 3, 1992

Definition, theory and review of practice in the fields that became known as public and/or applied ethnomusicology, from the first (and only) issue of the journal of the Society for Ethnomusicology devoted entirely to that topic.

The Problem of Ethnocentricity in Music Archaeology

R. Eichmann, E. Hickmann og L.-C. Koch (eds.), Studies in Music Archaeology VII. On Ethnographic Analogy in Music Archaeology, s. 103–108., 2010

‘Music’ is a surprisingly new invention. Most of the languages of the world lack a concept of music, yet in all known cultures people play, sing and dance. Historical musicologists too often employ an ethnocentric understanding of music, arisen from the western art music tradition. Does music archaeology represent an alternative voice that challenges ethnocentric approaches to music? Since the field consists of individual researchers with different interests and views, there is no easy answer to this question. But the fact that music archaeologists use material culture as their primary point of departure means that they arrive at other perspectives and approaches to musical activities than historical musicologists using written sources. Most music archaeologists will probably understand music in the widest sense. On the other hand, does our discipline need ‘music’ at all? Some music archaeologists tend to abandon the concept of music, in favour of ‘intentional sound’ or similar, and some prefer to label their field of study ‘archaeomusicology’ or ‘archaeo-organology’. Such strategies could be seen as a response to an unwanted ethnocentric perspective.

Ethnomusicological collections in the Sound Archives in the face of globalisation

2004

Various enquiries and a census reveal that more than half of patrimonial sound collections with ethnographical interest being made in France are about ethnomusicology and dancing. Overwhelmingly association-made collections have been recorded in the wake of identity movements and concern chiefly “indigenous” music. For several years now, researchers have begun to deposit musical recordings from migrant or nomadic communities and more generally from living music deeply immersed in local cultures in the sound archives. Frequently “the world music” is a generic expression covering this music whereas local traditional music is being left aside. Beyond the controversy of words, it is becoming more and more obvious that today's traditional music practices go beyond the geographical and cultural areas that regionalist movements of the 70's claimed as their turf and include all migrant communities or nomadic groups roaming about the country. The deposits made in the sound archives j...

Longing to belong: Musical practices in the expulsion of the Germans from the Bohemian lands

2014

In 1945/46, after the surrender of Germany in the Second World War, approximately twelve million German civilians living in Central and Eastern Europe were expelled (or fled before they received the inevitable expulsion order) mostly to Germany in what R.M. Douglas termed the “largest forced population transfer [...] in human history.” Even though these events occurred over sixty years ago, the recollections of these expellees suggest the ongoing immediacy of their experiences. For this phenomenological-historical ethnography, I collected more than eighty life stories and oral histories specifically from ethnic Germans expelled from Bohemia, Moravia, and Czech Silesia (Sudeten Germans). Through the lenses of musical practice and musical repertoire, I investigate how these Sudeten Germans used and still continue to use music as a tool for both remembrance and adaptation in their new environments. I seek to understand music’s significances for social and political integration in the S...

Exploring Disciplinary Boundaries between Ethnomusicology and Cultural Musicology Through My Own PhD Research Project

The 16th Annual Symposium for Music Scholars in Finland, 2012

The present paper seeks to establish the distinction (if there is any) between contemporary ethnomusicology and cultural musicology by using my own Ph.D. research project as a case study. One way to approach this task is to assess the extent to which the very topic and objectives of my Ph.D. project, as well as at the theories and methodologies used, correspond to the current tendencies in the two fields of studies. The aim of such a survey is twofold: one is to open a debate on the (im)possibility of drawing clear disciplinary boundaries, and the other is to try and position my Ph.D. research along disciplinary lines.

Related topics

  • Musicology
  • Ethnomusicology
  • Academia
    Academia
    580 California St., Suite 400
    San Francisco, CA, 94104
    © 2026 Academia. All rights reserved

    [8]ページ先頭

    ©2009-2026 Movatter.jp