| Rafah paramedic massacre | |
|---|---|
| Part of theMarch 2025 Israeli attacks on the Gaza Strip during theGaza war and theGaza genocide | |
  Rafah | |
| Location | Rafah,Gaza Strip,Palestine |
| Date | 23 March 2025 |
| Target | Palestine Red Crescent Society,Gaza Civil Defense,UNRWA |
Attack type | Extrajudicial killings,summary execution,execution by shooting,massacre,war crime,mass burial |
| Deaths | 15 Palestinian medics |
| Perpetrators |  Israel Defense Forces |
On 23 March 2025, theIsrael Defense Forces (IDF) attacked several humanitarian vehicles, including five ambulances, a fire truck, and aUnited Nations vehicle, in Al-Hashashin area in southernRafah,Gaza Strip. The massacre[1] resulted in the deaths of at least 15 aid workers, including eight members of thePalestine Red Crescent Society, fivecivil defense, and oneUN agency employee. It was not until 30 March that most of the missing bodies were retrieved from amass grave in Rafah, although one ambulance officer who was initially declared missing remains under Israeli custody.[2] TheInternational Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC) condemned the attacks, stating that they were the "single most deadly" for its workers in almost a decade.[3][4]
On 18 March 2025, Israel launched asurprise attack on the Gaza Strip, effectively ending the2025 Gaza war ceasefire and resuming theGaza war. Israel's missile and artillery attack killed more than 400Palestinians, including 263 women and children, making it one of the deadliest in the Gaza war.[5][6]
On 23 March 2025, the IDF fired on five ambulances and a fire truck "one by one."[4][7] The humanitarian vehicles were "crushed and dumped, covered in sand" in an apparent attempt to cover up the killings,[8] while the aid workers, wearing uniforms, were left missing in a mass grave for eight days.[3] The ambulances were initially dispatched to the Al-Hashashin area in response to casualties caused by Israeli attacks on the area, before being surrounded by Israeli troops and losing contact with dispatchers. The paramedics that went to search for them were killed and wounded.[9][10] Israel said the vehicles were "advancing suspiciously" without headlights or emergency signals. It claimed that the vehicles were being used as cover by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad. It alleged that among those killed were a Hamas operative and "eight other terrorists," without providing evidence.[4][7]
According to forensic analyst Ahmad Dhaher who examined five of the bodies, the aid workers were killed at close-range in execution-style killings, with "specific and intentional" bullet wounds in heads and hearts.[11] Relatives of the victims described various signs of abuse. One relative noted marks on a victim's wrists from restraint and broken fingers, while another mentioned multiple gunshot wounds to the chest and wrist. Two witnesses also reported that some victims had their hands or feet bound.[12]
A video recording discovered on a cellphone of one of the medics contradicts Israel's narrative of the incident, showing the ambulances and fire truck clearly marked with theiremergency lights on as Israeli troops hit them with a barrage of gunfire, killing all the medics. In the video, a paramedic recited theShahada, and added, "Forgive me, Mom, forgive me. I swear I only chose this path to help others." The paramedic was later found in the mass grave with a bullet in his head.The New York Times analyzed satellite imagery that showed Israeli forces bulldozing the site after the attack.[13][14] Following the release of the video recording, Israel changed its account of the incident, admitting that its soldiers have "made mistakes."[15]
The massacre was carried out by soldiers from theGolani Brigade. At the moment of the killings, they were acting under the command of Brig Gen Yehuda Vach, who has a history of establishing "kill zones" in Gaza where civilians are killed and of telling his subordinates that "there are no innocents in Gaza."[16] Also present at the site were field operatives from Unit 504, a military intelligence unit with a reputation for cruelty and acts of torture.[16]
Munther Abed, a 27-year-old volunteer with the Red Crescent since he was 18, was in the first ambulance to arrive at the scene of an airstrike in Rafah's Hashashin district when it came under Israeli gunfire. Abed survived by throwing himself to the floor, while his two colleagues in the front were killed.[1]
After being captured by Israeli soldiers, Abed described his treatment: "I was completely stripped, left only in my underwear, and my hands were bound behind my back," he recalled. "They threw me to the ground, and the interrogation began. I endured severe torture, including beatings, insults, threats of death, and suffocation when one soldier pressed a rifle against my neck. Another soldier held a dagger to my left shoulder." During his detention, he witnessed other rescue vehicles, including ambulances and fire trucks, being ambushed by Israeli forces. He also saw a bulldozer and excavator arrive to dig a pit where the vehicles and bodies were buried. Abed stated that a Red Crescent ambulance officer, Assad al-Nassara, who remains missing, was alive in Israeli detention near the scene of the killings[1][12]
Abed stated that the ambulance was marked with lights on and the Red Crescent logo visible as they headed to the site.[17] While the IDF described the area as a war zone, Abed asserted that Hashashin was a civilian area where daily life was ongoing, not a designated combat zone.[1] He also rejected Israel's claim that Hamas had used ambulances, calling it "utterly untrue" and reaffirming that all the crews involved were civilians.[17]
Abed was forced to help Israeli soldiers in the vetting and photographing of local residents, who were ordered to leave the area and move to al-Mawasi. He was released in the evening and given back his watch and underwear but not his identity card, paramedic uniform, or shoes. Abed was instructed to walk toward al-Mawasi and was eventually able to flag down a passing Red Crescent vehicle for assistance.[1]
According to the UN, the killed Palestinian medics were buried by Israeli troops inunmarked graves.[10] The autopsy results of the 15 bodies analyzed indicate that they were shot in the upper part of the body, indicating intent to kill.[18]
The IFRC identified its missing workers as ambulance officers Mostafa Khufaga, Saleh Muamer, and Ezzedine Shaath, and first responder volunteers Mohammad Bahloul, Mohammed al-Heila, Ashraf Abu Labda, Raed al-Sharif, and Rifatt Radwan, adding that ambulance officer Assad al-Nassasra was still missing.[3] None of the names reported to have been recovered from the mass grave match the names of "terrorists" the IDF claimed to have eliminated, and one recovered body had his hands bound.[7]
On 13 April, the Palestine Red Crescent received confirmation that its missing medic, Assad al-Nassara, was being held by Israeli authorities.[2][19]
From 23 March to 30 March, a "complex, week-long rescue operation" took place involving bulldozers and heavy machinery to search for the buried bodies left under the sand and debris, while emergency responders used shovels to dig through the dirt. The rescue operation was complicated by the IDF's refusal to cooperate with the Red Crescent, OCHA, and the UN, denying them entry. On 27 March, the body of a civil defense worker was recovered, and fourteen more were recovered on 30 March. One medic belonging to the PRCS remained missing[3][4] until it was confirmed on 13 April that he was being held by Israeli authorities.[19]
Following the release of the video recording, Israel changed its account of the incident, admitting that its soldiers have "made mistakes."[15] Analysts have noted that Israel has a history of giving inaccurate explanations to account for its killings of civilians and of changing its version of events when evidence emerges that refutes its initial explanation.[20] IDF Chief of StaffEyal Zamir ordered an internal investigation into the incident by the unit responsible for handling suspected war crimes. To date, dozens of incidents have been referred to this unit, but no reprimands or punishments have been issued against IDF soldiers.[21]
According to the Israeli human rights organizationYesh Din, the system established by the IDF’s general staff to investigate potential war crimes is primarily designed to shield the military from accountability while maintaining the appearance of due process. An analysis of Israeli military campaigns over the past decade revealed that at least 664 complaints were submitted for review, yet more than 80% were closed without even launching a criminal investigation. The organization concluded that the military's law enforcement system seldom pursues charges against low-ranking soldiers and almost entirely avoids investigating senior commanders.[20]
Autopsies were conducted by a Gazan doctor on all paramedics killed in the attack except an UN aid worker.[22] The post-mortem report, reviewed by a Norwegian pathologist, found these paramedics were killed by gunfires either to their chests, abdomens or backs or to the head.[22][23] Most of them were shot several times.[22]
Israeli military released the investigation report on 20 April 2025, which found the killings were caused by "several professional failures, breaches of orders, and a failure to fully report the incident."[24] United Nations humanitarian agency in Gaza, Palestine Red Crescent and Gazan civil defense denounced the investigation report.[25]
Israel: The IDF claimed that its troops had fired on the vehicles as they were "advancing suspiciously," and added that "it was determined that the forces had eliminated a Hamas military operative, Mohammad Amin Ibrahim Shubaki, along with eight other terrorists from Hamas and the PIJ."[3] Shubaki's name does not appear on the list of the 15 deceased emergency workers, and Israel has not accounted for the whereabouts of his body.[17] After video evidence emerged exposing their initial description as inaccurate, the IDF admitted that account was "mistaken."[26]
United States: The U.S. said that it expects "all parties on the ground" in Gaza to comply with international humanitarian law, although it refused to confirm whether it is conducting its own assessment into the incident.State Department SpokeswomanTammy Bruce claimed that "every single thing that happens in Gaza is happening because of Hamas."[27]
Hamas: Hamas condemned a statement by the U.S. accusing it of weaponizing ambulances, calling it "pure lies, devoid of any evidence, propagated by the US administration, alongside the government ofwar criminalNetanyahu, to justify its heinous and documented crime against paramedics and rescue workers."[28]
United Kingdom: Foreign SecretaryDavid Lammy stated that "Gaza has become the world's most dangerous place for humanitarian workers" and called "for those responsible for the killings to be held accountable."[29]
Germany: After the video footage emerged,foreign ministry spokesperson Christian Wagner stated, "There are very significant questions about the actions of the Israeli army now," and said, "An investigation and accountability of the perpetrators are urgently needed", adding that the matter ultimately affects the credibility of the Israeli constitutional state.[18][20]
Netherlands: Foreign MinisterCaspar Veldkamp stated the attack "appears to be a breach of the laws of war." He demanded a "thorough and independent investigation", adding that "The suffering of Palestinians in Gaza is unbearable".General Intelligence and Security Service (AIVD) Director-General Erik Akerboom said regarding the footage: "They add fuel to the fire forjihadists. They are being pushed further into action. These images have a strong mobilizing impact."[30]
Norway: Foreign MinisterEspen Barth Eide strongly condemned the killing of the paramedics, calling the incident "very serious" and urged for an investigation to hold those responsible accountable.[31][better source needed]
