Initially a synonym for "Satanic metal", black metal has often sparked controversy, due to the actions andideologies associated with the genre. Some artists expressmisanthropic views, and others advocate various forms of extremeanti-Christian sentiment,Satanism, orethnicpaganism. In the 1990s, members of the scene were responsible for a spate ofchurch burnings and murders. There is also aneo-Nazimovement within black metal, although it has been shunned by many prominent artists. Generally, black metal strives to remain anunderground phenomenon.
Althoughcontemporary black metal typically refers to the Norwegian style with shrieking vocals and raw production, the term has traditionally been applied to bands with widely differing sounds, such asDeath SS,Mercyful Fate,Mayhem,Blasphemy,[5][11] and the Greek and Finnish bands that emerged around the same time as the Norwegian scene.[5]
Manish Agarwal ofTime Out describes black metal as "acult strain of ultra-thrash" characterized by "icynoise." Norwegian-inspired black metal guitarists usually favor high-pitched ortrebly guitar tones and heavydistortion.[12] The guitar is usually played with fast, un-mutedtremolo picking andpower chords.[12][13][14] Guitarists often usedissonance—along with specificscales,intervals and chord progressions—to create a sense of dread. Thetritone, or flat-fifth, is often used.Guitar solos and lowguitar tunings are rare in black metal.[14] Thebass guitar is seldom used to play stand-alone melodies. It is common for the bass to be muted against the guitar,[14] or for it tohomophonically follow the low-pitched riffs of the guitar. While electronic keyboards are not a standard instrument, some bands, likeDimmu Borgir, use keyboards "in the background" or as "proper instruments" for creating atmosphere.[15] Some newer black metal bands began raising their production quality and introducing additional instruments such assynthesizers and evenorchestras.
Thedrumming is usually fast and relies ondouble-bass andblast beats to maintain tempos that can sometimes approach 300 beats per minute. These fast tempos require great skill and physical stamina, typified by black metal drummers Frost (Kjetil-Vidar Haraldstad) and Hellhammer (Jan Axel Blomberg).[16] Even still,authenticity is still prioritized over technique. "This professionalism has to go," insists well-respected drummer and metal historianFenriz (Gylve Fenris Nagell) ofDarkthrone. "I want tode-learn playing drums, I want to play primitive and simple, I don't want to play like a drum solo all the time and make these complicated riffs".[17]
Black metal songs often stray fromconventional song structure and often lack clear verse-chorus sections. Instead, many black metal songs contain lengthy and repetitive instrumental sections. The Greek style—established byRotting Christ,Necromantia and Varathron[18]—has moredeath metal traits than Norwegian black metal.[8]
Members of Gorgoroth wearing typical black metal gear such ascorpse paint, spikes and bullet belts. The band was formed by guitaristInfernus to express hisSatanist beliefs.[19]
Traditional black metal bands tend to favor raspy, high-pitched vocals which include techniques such as shrieking,screaming, and snarling,[12][14] a vocal style influenced byQuorthon ofBathory.[20]Death growls, common in thedeath metal genre, are sometimes used, but less frequently than the characteristic black metal shriek.[21][22]
A common black metal convention is the use of corpse paint, black-and-white make-up intended to make the wearer look inhuman, corpse-like, or demonic. Shown here: Taalroth of French pagan band Hindvir.
Many bands choose not to play live.[32][33] Many of those who do play live maintain that their performances "are not for entertainment or spectacle. Sincerity,authenticity and extremity are valued above all else".[34] Some bands consider their concerts to berituals[34] and often make use of stageprops andtheatrics. Bands such asMayhem,Gorgoroth, andWatain are noted for their controversial shows, which have featured impaled animal heads, mock crucifixions,medieval weaponry and band members doused in animal blood.[35] A few vocalists, such asDead,Maniac andKvarforth, are known forcutting themselves while singing onstage.
Black metal artists often appear dressed in black withcombat boots,bullet belts, spiked wristbands[25] andinverted crosses and invertedpentagrams to reinforce their anti-Christian or anti-religious stance.[36] However, the most widely-known trait is their use ofcorpse paint—black and white face paint sometimes mixed with real or fake blood, which is used to create a corpse-like or demonic appearance.[citation needed]
The imagery of black metal reflects its lyrics and ideology. In the early 1990s, most pioneering black metal artists hadminimalist album covers featuringxeroxed black-and-white pictures and/or writing.[5] This was partly a reaction against death metal bands, who at that time had begun to use brightly colored album artwork.[5] Many purist black metal artists have continued this style. Black metal album covers are typically dark and tend to be atmospheric or provocative; some feature natural orfantasy landscapes (for exampleBurzum'sFilosofem and Emperor'sIn the Nightside Eclipse) while others are violent, sexually transgressive, sacrilegious, or iconoclastic (for exampleMarduk'sFuck Me Jesus andDimmu Borgir'sIn Sorte Diaboli).
The earliest black metal artists had very limited resources, which meant that recordings were often made in homes or basements,[12] giving their recordings a distinctive "lo-fi" quality. However, even when success allowed access to professional studios, many artists instead chose to continue making lo-fi recordings.[14][25] Artists believed that by doing so, they would both stay true to the genre's underground roots as well as make the music sound more "raw" or "cold".[25] A well-known example of this approach is on the albumTransilvanian Hunger byDarkthrone, a band who Johnathan Selzer ofTerrorizer magazine says "represent theDIY aspect of black metal."[25] In addition, lo-fi production was used to keep black metal inaccessible or unappealing to mainstream music fans and those who arenot committed. Many have claimed that black metal was originally intended only for those who were part of the scene and not for a wider audience.[25] FormerGorgoroth vocalistGaahl stated his belief that during the genre's infancy, black metal "was never meant to reach [a wide] audience," and that creating it was "purely for [the members of the scene's] own satisfaction."[13]
Occult and Satanic lyrical themes were present in the music of heavy metal and rock bands of the late 1960s and early 1970s such asBlack Sabbath andCoven.[37]
In the late 1970s, the form of rough and aggressive heavy metal played by the British bandMotörhead gained popularity.[37] Manyfirst-wave black metal bands cited Motörhead as an influence.[37] Also popular in the late 1970s,punk rock came to influence the birth of black metal.[37]Tom G. Warrior of Hellhammer and Celtic Frost credited English punk groupDischarge as "a revolution, much like Venom", saying, "When I heard the first two Discharge records, I was blown away. I was just starting to play an instrument and I had no idea you could go so far."[38]
The use of corpse paint in the black metal imagery was mainly influenced by the American 1970srock bandKiss.[37]
Venom's second album,Black Metal, inspired the name of the genre.
The term "black metal" was coined by the English band Venom with their second albumBlack Metal (1982).[25] Playing a style borderingspeed metal orthrash metal, the album initiated thefirst wave of black metal, forming an early prototype for the genre.[36][39] The band introduced many tropes that became ubiquitous in the genre, such asblasphemous lyrics and imagery, as well as stage names, costumes and face paint meant to strike fear.[40] During this first wave of bands, distinct borders of the genre had not been set, instead, black metal bands existed in a broaderextreme metal umbrella alongside the earliest groups indeath metal,grindcore andthrash metal.[41]
Hellhammer, from Switzerland, "made truly raw and brutal music"[42] with Satanic lyrics, and became an important influence on later black metal;[43] "Their simple yet effective riffs and fast guitar sound were groundbreaking, anticipating the later trademark sound of early Swedish death metal".[42] In 1984, members of Hellhammer formedCeltic Frost,[44] whose music "explored more orchestral and experimental territories. The lyrics also became more personal, with topics about inner feelings and majestic stories. But for a couple of years, Celtic Frost was one of the world's most extreme and original metal bands, with a huge impact on the mid-1990s black metal scene".[42]
Another influential early band wasBathory from Sweden. The band, led by Thomas Forsberg (a.k.a.Quorthon), created "the blueprint for Scandinavian black metal".[45] Not only was Bathory's music dark, fast, heavily distorted, lo-fi and with anti-Christian themes, Quorthon was also the first to use the shrieked vocals that later became a common trait.[20] Their third albumUnder the Sign of the Black Mark (1987) was the first record in the genre to subvert most traditional rock tropes, in a way that led journalistDayal Patterson that "undoubtedly... create[d] the black metal sound as we know it".[46]
In 1987, in the fifth issue of hisSlayer fanzine,Jon 'Metalion' Kristiansen wrote that "the latest fad of black/Satanic bands seems to be over", citing United States bands Incubus andMorbid Angel, as well asSabbat from Great Britain as some of the few continuing the genre.[54] However, black metal continued in the underground, with scenes developing in Brazil withSepultura,Vulcano,[55]Holocausto[56] andSarcófago,[57] Czechoslovakia withRoot,Törr andMaster's Hammer,[58] and Sweden withGrotesque,[59][60]Merciless,Mefisto,[61]Tiamat[59][62] andMorbid.[63] Sarcófago's debut albumI.N.R.I. (1987), was widely influential on subsequent acts in the genre, especially the second wave Norwegian scene[57] and groups in thewar metal style.[64][65][66]BrooklynVegan writer Kim Kelly calling it "a gigantic influence on black metal's sound, aesthetics, and attitude."[67] Furthermore, during this time other influential records in the genre were released byVon (from the United States),[68]Rotting Christ (from Greece),[69]Tormentor (from Hungary),[55]Mortuary Drape (from Italy),[70]Kat (from Poland),[55]Samael (from Switzerland)[71] andBlasphemy (from Canada).[64] Blasphemy's debut albumFallen Angel of Doom (1990) is considered one of the most influential records for the war metal style.[64][65][66]Fenriz of the Norwegian band Darkthrone called Master's Hammer's debut albumRitual "the first Norwegian black metal album, even though they are from Czechoslovakia".[72] It was only during this post–1987 era of bands that the various extreme metal styles began to develop definitions distinct from one another, and the borders of what now consistues black metal were drawn.[41]
Thesecond wave of black metal began in 1991, withRock Hard magazine creditingSamael'sWorship Him (1 April 1991) as its beginnings,[71] while,Metal Hammer writer Enrico Ahlig cited it as beginning with the 8 April 1991 suicide ofMayhem vocalistDead.[73]
Norwegian band Immortal influenced countless bands in the genre
During1990–1993, a number of Norwegian artists began performing and releasing a new kind of black metal music; this includedMayhem,Darkthrone,Burzum,Immortal,Emperor,Satyricon,Enslaved,Thorns, andGorgoroth. They developed the style of their 1980s forebears into a distinct genre. This was partly thanks to a new kind of guitar playing developed bySnorre 'Blackthorn' Ruch andØystein 'Euronymous' Aarseth.[5][13]Fenriz of Darkthrone described it as being "derived from Bathory"[74] and noted that "those kinds of riffs became the new order for a lot of bands in the '90s".[75]
The wearing ofcorpse paint became standard, and was a way for many black metal artists to distinguish themselves from other metal bands of the era.[25] The scene also had an ideology and ethos. Artists were bitterly opposed to Christianity and presented themselves as misanthropic Devil worshippers who wanted to spread terror, hatred and evil.[76] They professed to be serious in their views and vowed to act on them.Ihsahn of Emperor said that they sought to "create fear among people"[77] and "be in opposition to society".[78] The scene was exclusive and created boundaries around itself, incorporating only those who were "true" and attempting to expel all "poseurs".[79] Some members of the scene were responsible for a spate of church burnings and murder, which eventually drew attention to it and led to a number of artists being imprisoned.
On 8 April 1991, Mayhem vocalistPer "Dead" Ohlin committed suicide while left alone in a house shared by the band.[80][81] Fellow musicians described Dead as odd, introverted and depressed. Mayhem's drummer,Hellhammer, said that Dead was the first to wear the distinctive corpse paint that became widespread in the scene.[82] He was found with slit wrists and ashotgun wound to the head. Dead's suicide note began with "Excuse all the blood", and apologized for firing the weapon indoors.[81][83] Before calling the police, Euronymous got a disposable camera and photographed the body,[84] after re-arranging some items. One of these photographs was later used as the cover of a bootleg live album,Dawn of the Black Hearts.[82]
Euronymous made necklaces with bits of Dead's skull and gave some to musicians he deemed worthy.[36] Rumors also spread that he had made a stew with bits of his brain.[25][80] Euronymous used Dead's suicide to foster Mayhem's evil image and claimed Dead had killed himself because extreme metal had become trendy and commercialized.[85] Mayhem bassistJørn 'Necrobutcher' Stubberud noted that "people became more aware of the black metal scene after Dead had shot himself ... I think it was Dead's suicide that really changed the scene".[86]
Two other members of the early Norwegian scene later committed suicide: Erik 'Grim' Brødreskift (ofImmortal,Borknagar,Gorgoroth) in 1999[87][88] and Espen 'Storm' Andersen (ofStrid) in 2001.[89]
The basement of Helvete, showing graffiti from the early 1990s
During May–June 1991,[90] Euronymous of Mayhem opened an independent record shop named "Helvete" (Norwegian for "Hell") at Schweigaards gate 56 inOslo. It quickly became the focal point of Norway's emerging black metal scene and a meeting place for many of its musicians; especially the members of Mayhem, Burzum, Emperor and Thorns.[91] Jon 'Metalion' Kristiansen, writer of the fanzineSlayer, said that the opening of Helvete was "the creation of the whole Norwegian black metal scene".[92] In its basement, Euronymous founded anindependent record label namedDeathlike Silence Productions. With the rising popularity of his band and others like it, the underground success of Euronymous's label is often credited for encouraging other record labels, who had previously shunned black metal acts, to then reconsider and release their material.
In 1992, members of the Norwegian black metal scene began a wave of arson attacks on Christian churches. By 1996, there had been at least 50 such attacks in Norway.[91] Some of the buildings were hundreds of years old and seen as important historical landmarks. The first to be burnt down was Norway'sFantoft Stave Church. Police believeVarg Vikernes of Burzum was responsible.[91] The cover of Burzum's EPAske ("ashes") is a photograph of the destroyed church.[93] In May 1994, Vikernes was found guilty for burning down theHolmenkollen Chapel,Skjold Church, andÅsane Church.[74][94] In addition, he was found guilty for an attempted arson of a fourth church, and for the theft and storage of 150 kg of explosives.[95] To coincide with the release of Mayhem'sDe Mysteriis Dom Sathanas, Vikernes and Euronymous had also allegedly plotted to bomb theNidaros Cathedral, which appears on the album cover. The musiciansFaust,[96]Samoth,[95] (both of Emperor), andJørn Inge Tunsberg (ofHades Almighty)[95][91] were also convicted for church arsons. Members of the Swedish black metal scene started to burn churches as well in 1993.[97]
Those convicted for church burnings showed no remorse and described their actions as a symbolic "retaliation" againstChristianity in Norway.[98] Mayhem drummer Hellhammer said he had called for attacks onmosques andHindu temples, on the basis that they were more foreign.[99] Today, opinions on the church burnings differ within the black metal community. Many musicians, singers, and songwriters in the early Norwegian black metal scene, such asInfernus andGaahl ofGorgoroth, continue to praise the church burnings, with the latter saying "there should have been more of them, and there will be more of them".[36] Others, such asNecrobutcher andKjetil Manheim of Mayhem andAbbath of Immortal,[36] see the church burnings as having been futile. Manheim claimed that many arsons were "just people trying to gain acceptance" within the black metal scene.[80]Watain vocalist Erik Danielsson respected the attacks, but said of those responsible: "the only Christianity they defeated was the last piece of Christianity within themselves. Which is a very good beginning, of course".[100]
In early 1993, animosity arose between Euronymous and Vikernes.[101] On the night of 10 August 1993, Varg Vikernes (of Burzum) and Snorre 'Blackthorn' Ruch (of Thorns) drove from Bergen to Euronymous's apartment in Oslo. When they arrived a confrontation began and Vikernes stabbed Euronymous to death. His body was found outside the apartment with 23 cut wounds—two to the head, five to the neck, and sixteen to the back.[102]
It has been speculated that the murder was the result of either a power struggle, a financial dispute over Burzum records or an attempt at outdoing a stabbing in Lillehammer the year before by Faust.[103] Vikernes denies all of these, claiming that he attacked Euronymous in self-defense. He says that Euronymous had plotted to stun him with anelectroshock weapon, tie him up and torture him to death while videotaping the event.[74] He said Euronymous planned to use a meeting about an unsigned contract to ambush him.[74][104] Vikernes claims he intended to hand Euronymous the signed contract that night and "tell him to fuck off", but that Euronymous panicked and attacked him first.[104] He also claims that most of the cuts were from broken glass Euronymous had fallen on during the struggle.[104] The self-defense story is doubted by Faust,[105] whileNecrobutcher confirmed that Vikernes killed Euronymous in self-defense due to the death threats he received from him.[106]
Vikernes was arrested on 19 August 1993, in Bergen.[107] Many other members of the scene were taken in for questioning around the same time. Some of them confessed to their crimes and implicated others. In May 1994, Vikernes was sentenced to 21 years in prison (Norway's maximum penalty) for the murder of Euronymous, the arson of four churches, and for possession of 150 kg of explosives. However, he only confessed to the latter. Two churches were burnt the day he was sentenced, "presumably as a statement of symbolic support".[95] Vikernes smiled when his verdict was read and the picture was widely reprinted in the news media. Blackthorn was sentenced to eight years in prison for being an accomplice to the murder.[95] That month saw the release of Mayhem's albumDe Mysteriis Dom Sathanas, which featured Euronymous on guitar and Vikernes on bass guitar.[13] Euronymous's family had asked Mayhem's drummer, Hellhammer, to remove the bass tracks recorded by Vikernes, but Hellhammer said: "I thought it was appropriate that the murderer and victim were on the same record. I put word out that I was re-recording the bass parts. But I never did".[13] In 2003, Vikernes failed to return to Tønsberg prison after being given a short leave. He was re-arrested shortly after while driving a stolen car with various weapons.[108] Vikernes was released onparole in 2009.[109][110]
Japanese bandSigh formed in 1990 and was in regular contact with key members of the Norwegian scene. Their debut album,Scorn Defeat, became "a cult classic in the black metal world".[111]
In 1990 and 1991, Northern European metal acts began to release music influenced by these bands or the older ones from the first wave. In Sweden, this includedDissection,[112]Abruptum,[112][113]Marduk,[112][114][115] andNifelheim.[112] In Finland, there emerged a scene that mixed the first-wave black metal style with elements of death metal andgrindcore; this includedBeherit,Archgoat andImpaled Nazarene, whose debut albumTol Cormpt Norz Norz NorzRock Hard journalist Wolf-Rüdiger Mühlmann considers a part of war metal's roots.[116] Bands such asDemoncy andProfanatica emerged during this time in the United States, when death metal was more popular among extreme metal fans. The Norwegian band Mayhem's concert in Leipzig with Eminenz and Manos in 1990, later released asLive in Leipzig, was said to have had a strong influence on the East German scene[117] and is even called the unofficial beginning of German black metal.[118]
Black metal scenes also emerged on the European mainland during the early 1990s, inspired by the Norwegian scene or the older bands, or both. In Poland, a scene was spearheaded byGraveland andBehemoth. In France, a close-knit group of musicians known asLes Légions Noires emerged; this included artists such asMütiilation,Vlad Tepes, Belketre and Torgeist. In Belgium, there were acts such asAncient Rites andEnthroned. Bands such as Black Funeral,Grand Belial's Key andJudas Iscariot emerged during this time in the United States. Black Funeral, fromHouston, formed in 1993, was associated withblack magic andSatanism.[119]
English band Cradle of Filth performing atMetalmania in 2005
A notable black metal group in England wasCradle of Filth, who released three demos in a black/death metal style with symphonic flourishes, followed by the albumThe Principle of Evil Made Flesh, which featured a then-unusual hybrid style of black andgothic metal. The band then abandoned black metal for gothic metal,[120] becoming one of the most successfulextreme metal bands to date. John Serba ofAllMusic commented that their first album "made waves in the early black metal scene, putting Cradle of Filth on the tips of metalheads' tongues, whether in praise of the band's brazen attempts to break the black metal mold or in derision for its 'commercialization' of an underground phenomenon that was proud of its grimy heritage".[121] Some black metal fans did not consider Cradle of Filth to be black metal. When asked if he considers Cradle of Filth a black metal band, vocalistDani Filth said he considers them black metal in terms of philosophy and atmosphere, but not in other ways.[122] Another English band called Necropolis never released any music, but "began a desecratory assault against churches and cemeteries in their area" and "almost caused Black Metal to be banned in Britain as a result".[123]Dayal Patterson says successful acts like Cradle of Filth "provoked an even greater extremity [of negative opinion] from the underground" scene due to concerns about "selling out".[124]
The controversy surrounding the Thuringian bandAbsurd drew attention to the German black metal scene. In 1993, the members murdered a boy from their school, Sandro Beyer.[125] A photo of Beyer's gravestone is on the cover of one of their demos,[126]Thuringian Pagan Madness, along with pro-Nazi statements. It was recorded in prison and released in Poland by Graveland drummer Capricornus.[127] The band's early music was more influenced byOi! andRock Against Communism (RAC) than by black metal,[128] and described as being "more akin to '60sgarage punk than some of the […] Black Metal of their contemporaries".[129]Alexander von Meilenwald from German bandNagelfar considers Ungod's 1993 debutCircle of the Seven Infernal Pacts,Desaster's 1994 demoLost in the Ages,Tha-Norr's 1995 albumWolfenzeitalter, Lunar Aurora's 1996 debutWeltengänger andKatharsis's 2000 debut666[130] to be the most important recordings for the German scene.[117] He said they were "not necessarily the best German releases, but they all kicked off something".[117]
Dimmu Borgir's music features synthesizers and orchestras[131]
In the beginning of the second wave, the different scenes developed their own styles; asAlan 'Nemtheanga' Averill says, "you had the Greek sound and the Finnish sound, and the Norwegian sound, and there was German bands and Swiss bands and that kind of thing."[5] By the mid-1990s, the style of the Norwegian scene was being adopted by bands worldwide, and in 1998,Kerrang! journalistMalcolm Dome said that "black metal as we know it in 1998 owes more to Norway and to Scandinavia than any other particular country".[91] Newer black metal bands also began raising their production quality and introducing additional instruments such assynthesizers and even full-symphonyorchestras. By the late 1990s, the underground concluded that several of the Norwegian pioneers—like Emperor,[65][132] Immortal,[65][132]Dimmu Borgir,[132]Ancient,[65][132]Covenant/The Kovenant,[132] and Satyricon[65]—had commercialized[65][132] orsold out to the mainstream and "big bastard labels."[132] Dayal Patterson states that successful acts like Dimmu Borgir "provoked and even greater extremity [of negative opinion] from the underground" regarding the view that these bands had "sold out."[124]
After Euronymous's death, "some bands went more towards the Viking metal and epic style, while some bands went deeper into the abyss."[100] Since 1993, the Swedish scene had carried out church burnings, grave desecration, and other violent acts. In 1995,Jon Nödtveidt ofDissection joined theMisanthropic Luciferian Order (MLO).[133] In 1997, he and another MLO member were arrested and charged withshooting dead a 37-year-old man. It was said he was killed "out of anger" because he had "harassed" the two men. Nödtveidt received a 10-year sentence.[134] As the victim was a homosexual immigrant, Dissection was accused of being a Nazi band,[135] but Nödtveidt denied this and dismissed racism and nationalism.[135][136]
The Swedish bandShining, founded in 1996, began writing music almost exclusively about depression and suicide, musically inspired by Strid and by Burzum's albumsHvis lyset tar oss andFilosofem.[137] Vocalist Niklas Kvarforth wanted to "force-feed" his listeners "with self-destructive and suicidal imagery and lyrics."[100] In the beginning, he used the term "suicidal black metal" for his music.[100][138] However, he stopped using the term in 2001 because it had begun to be used by a slew of other bands, whom he felt had misinterpreted his vision[100][138] and were using the music as a kind of therapy[100][138] rather than a weapon against the listener as Kvarforth intended.[138] He said that he "wouldn't call Shining a black metal band" and called the "suicidal black metal" term a "foolish idea."[100]
Watain singer Erik Danielsson in torn clothes and covered with blood
According to Erik Danielsson, when his band Watain formed in 1998, there were very few bands who took black metal as seriously as the early Norwegian scene had.[100] A newer generation of Swedish Satanic bands like Watain andOndskapt, inspired byOfermod,[139][140] the new band of Nefandus member Belfagor, put this scene "into a new light." Kvarforth said, "It seems like people actually [got] afraid again."[100] "The current Swedish black metal scene has a particularly ambitious and articulate understanding ofmysticism and its validity to black metal. Many Swedish black metal bands, most notably Watain and Dissection, are [or were] affiliated with the Temple of the Black Light, or Misanthropic Luciferian Order […] aTheistic,Gnostic, Satanic organization based in Sweden".[141] Upon his release in 2004, Jon Nödtveidt restarted Dissection with new members whom he felt were able to "stand behind and live up to the demands of Dissection's Satanic concept."[142] He started calling Dissection "the sonic propaganda unit of the MLO"[143][144] and released a third full-length album,Reinkaos. The lyrics containmagical formulae from theLiber Azerate and are based on the organization's teachings.[145] After the album's release and a few concerts, Nödtveidt said that he had "reached the limitations of music as a tool for expressing what I want to express, for myself and the handful of others that I care about" and disbanded Dissection[144] before dying by suicide.[146]
A part of the underground scene adopted aJungian interpretation of the church burnings and other acts of the early scene as the re-emergence of ancient archetypes, which Kadmon ofAllerseelen and the authors ofLords of Chaos had implied in their writings.[147][148] They mixed this interpretation with Paganism and Nationalism.[148] Varg Vikernes was seen as "an ideological messiah" by some,[149] although Vikernes had disassociated himself from black metal[149][150] and his neo-Nazism had nothing to do with that subculture.[150] This led to the rise ofNational Socialist black metal (NSBM), which Hendrik Möbus ofAbsurd calls "the logical conclusion" of the Norwegian black metal "movement".[148] Other parts of the scene oppose NSBM as it is "indelibly linked with Asá Trŭ and opposed to Satanism", or look upon Nazism "with vague skepticism and indifference".[151] Members of the NSBM scene, among others, see the Norwegian bands asposeurs whose "ideology is cheap", although they still respect Vikernes and Burzum, whom Grand Belial's Key vocalist Richard Mills called "the only Norwegian band that remains unapologetic and literally convicted of his beliefs."[149]
In France, besides Les Légions Noires (The Black Legions), an NSBM scene arose. Members of French band Funeral desecrated a grave inToulon in June 1996, and a 19-year-old black metal fan stabbed a priest to death inMulhouse on Christmas Eve 1996.[152] According to MkM ofAntaeus and Aosoth, the early French scene "was quite easy to divide: either you were NSBM, and you had the support from zine and the audience, or you were part of the black legions, and you had that 'cult' aura", whereas his band Antaeus, not belonging to either of these sub-scenes, "did not fit anywhere."[153] Many French bands, likeDeathspell Omega and Aosoth, have an avantgarde approach[154] and a disharmonic sound that is representative of that scene.[155]
The early American black metal bands remained underground. Some of them—likeGrand Belial's Key andJudas Iscariot—joined an international NSBM organization called the Pagan Front, although Judas Iscariot's sole member Akhenaten left the organization.[156] Other bands likeAverse Sefira never had any link with Nazism.[156] The US bands have no common style. Many were musically inspired by Burzum but did not necessarily adopt Vikernes's ideas.[156] Profanatica's music is close to death metal,[157] while Demoncy were accused of ripping off Gorgoroth riffs.[158] There also emerged bands likeXasthur andLeviathan[33] (whose music is inspired by Burzum[156] and whose lyrics focus on topics such as depression and suicide),[159][160]Nachtmystium,[33]Krallice,[33][161]Wolves in the Throne Room[33][161] (a band linked to thecrust punk scene and theenvironmental movement),[162][163] andLiturgy (the style of whom frontwoman Hunter Hunt-Hendrix describes as 'transcendental black metal').[33][164] These bands eschew black metal's traditional lyrical content for "something moreWhitman-esque"[33] and have been rejected by some traditional black-metallers for their ideologies[165] and thepost-rock andshoegazing influences some of them have adopted.[161] Also, some bands likeAgalloch started to incorporate "doom and folk elements into the traditional blast-beat and tremolo-picking of the Scandinavian incarnation", a style that later became known asCascadian black metal, in reference to the region where it emerged.[166]
In Australia, a scene led by bands likeDeströyer 666, Vomitor,Hobbs' Angel of Death, Nocturnal Graves andGospel of the Horns arose. This scene's typical style is a mixture of old school black metal and raw thrash metal influenced by old Celtic Frost, Bathory, Venom, and Sodom but also with its own elements.[167]
Melechesh was formed inJerusalem in 1993, "the first overtly anti-Christian band to exist in one of the holiest cities in the world".[168] Melechesh began as a straightforward black metal act with their first foray intofolk metal occurring on their 1996 EPThe Siege of Lachish.[169] Their subsequent albums straddled black, death, and thrash metal.[170] Another band,Arallu, was formed in the late 1990s and has relationships with Melechesh and Salem.[171][172] Melechesh and Arallu perform a style they call "Mesopotamian Black Metal", a blend of black metal andMesopotamian folk music.[168][172]
Since the 2000s, a number ofanti-Islamic andanti-religious black metal bands—whose members come from Muslim backgrounds—have emerged in the Middle East. Janaza, believed to be Iraq's first female black metal artist, released the demoBurning Quran Ceremony in 2010. Its frontwoman, Anahita, claimed her parents and brother were killed by asuicide bomb during theIraq War. Another Iraqi band, Seeds of Iblis, also fronted by Anahita,[173] released their debut EPJihad Against Islam in 2011 through French label Legion of Death. Metal news website Metalluminati suggests that their claims of being based in Iraq are a hoax.[174] These bands, along with Tadnees (from Saudi Arabia), Halla (from Iran), False Allah (from Bahrain), and Mosque of Satan (from Lebanon), style themselves as the "Arabic Anti-Islamic Legion". Another Lebanese band,Ayat, drew much attention with their debut albumSix Years of Dormant Hatred, released through North American label Moribund Records in 2008.[173] Some European bands have also begun expressing anti-Islamic views, most notably the Norwegian bandTaake.[175]
Regarding the sound of black metal, there are two conflicting groups within the genre: "those that stay true to the genre's roots, and those that introduce progressive elements".[25] The former believe that the music should always beminimalist—performed only with the standard guitar-bass-drums setup and recorded in alow fidelity style. One supporter of this train of thought isBlake Judd ofNachtmystium, who has rejected labeling his band black metal for its departure from the genre's typical sound.[176] Snorre Ruch ofThorns, on the other hand, has said that modern black metal is "too narrow" and believes that this was "not the idea at the beginning".[177]
Since the 1990s, different styles of black metal have emerged and some have melded Norwegian-style black metal with other genres:
Ambient black metal is a style of black metal that relies on heavy incorporation of atmospheric, sometimes dreamy textures, and is therefore less aggressive. It often features synthesizers or classical instrumentation, typically for melody or ethereal "shimmering" over the wall of sound provided by the guitars. The music is usually slow to mid paced with rare blast beat usage, without any abrupt changes and generally features slowly developing, sometimes repetitive melodies and riffs, which separate it from other black metal styles. Subject matter usually concerns nature, folklore, mythology, and personal introspection.[178] Artists includeSummoning,[179]Agalloch[180] andWolves in the Throne Room.[180]
Pioneered by black-doom bands likeOphthalamia,Katatonia,Bethlehem,Forgotten Tomb andShining, depressive suicidal black metal, also known as suicidal black metal, depressive black metal or DSBM, is a style that melds thesecond wave-style of black metal with doom metal,[190] with lyrics revolving around themes such asdepression,self-harm,misanthropy,suicide and death.[30][31] DSBM bands draw on the lo-fi recording and highly distorted guitars of black metal, while employing the usage of acoustic instruments and non-distorted electric guitar timbres present in doom metal, interchanging the slower, doom-like, sections with faster tremolo picking.[190] Vocals are usually high-pitched like in black metal, but lacking energy, simulating feelings like hopelessness, desperation, and entreaty.[190] The presence of one-man bands is more prominent in this genre compared to others.[190] Examples of bands includeXasthur,[191]Leviathan,[190]Strid,[190]Silencer,[30][31] Make a Change… Kill Yourself,[190]Lifelover[192] andI Shalt Become.[30][31]
Crust punk groups, such asAntisect,Sacrilege andAnti System took some influence fromearly black metal bands likeVenom,Hellhammer, andCeltic Frost,[203] whileAmebix's lead vocalist and guitarist sent his band's early demo tape toCronos of Venom, who replied by saying "We'll rip you off."[204] Similarly,Bathory was initially inspired by crust punk as well as heavy metal.[205] Crust punk was affected by a second wave of black metal in the 1990s, with some bands emphasizing these black metal elements. Iskra are probably the most obvious example ofsecond-wave black metal-influenced crust punk;[206] Iskra coined their own phrase "blackened crust" to describe their new style. The Japanese groupGallhammer also fused crust punk with black metal[207] while the English band Fukpig has been said to have elements of crust punk, black metal, and grindcore.[208][209] North Carolina'sYoung and in the Way have been playing blackened crust since their formation in 2009.[210] In addition, Norwegian bandDarkthrone have incorporated crust punk traits in their more recent material. As Daniel Ekeroth wrote in 2008,
In a very ironic paradox, black metal and crust punk have recently started to embrace one another. Members of Darkthrone and Satyricon have lately claimed that they love punk, while among crusties, black metal is the latest fashion. In fact, the latest album by crust punk bandSkitsystem sounds very black metal—while the latest black metal opus by Darkthrone sounds very punk! This would have been unimaginable in the early 90s.[211]
Many "red and anarchist black metal" (RABM) artists are influenced by crust punk or have a background in that scene.
Blackened death metal is commonlydeath metal that incorporates musical, lyrical or ideological elements of black metal, such as an increased use oftremolo picking, anti-Christian orSatanic lyrical themes and chord progressions similar to those used in black metal.[218][219] Blackened death metal bands are also more likely to wearcorpse paint and suits of armour, than bands from other styles of death metal.[220] Lower range guitar tunings,death growls and abrupttempo changes are common in the genre.[221] Examples of blackened death metal bands areBelphegor,[222]Behemoth,[223]Akercocke,[224] andSacramentum.[225]
Raw black metal is a subgenre that seeks to amplify the primitive qualities of the second wave of black metal, by giving priority to itslo-fi production values.[279][280] To achieve this, bands under this style usually emphasize the usage of higher-pitches in their guitar sound and vocals, while employing techniques such as tremolo picking and blast beats more often.[280] Its imagery is often associated withdystopic andminimalistic tendencies.[279][280] The style was pioneered byIldjarn,[281] with other notable bands includingGorgoroth[279] andDarkthrone.[282]
Symphonic black metal is a style of black metal that incorporatessymphonic andorchestral elements. This may include the usage of instruments found in symphony orchestras (piano, violin,cello, flute and keyboards), "clean" or operatic vocals and guitars with less distortion.[283]Notable bands includeEmperor,Troll,Dimmu Borgir andBal Sagoth.[284][285]
Theinverted Christian cross is a common symbol associated with black metal imagery, usually used to signify opposition to Christianity.
Unlike other metal genres, black metal is associated with an ideology and ethos. It is fiercelyopposed to Christianity[36] and the other maininstitutional religions,Islam andJudaism. Many black metal bands areSatanists and see Satanism as a key part of black metal. Others advocate ethnic Paganism, "often coupled with nationalism",[286] although the early Pagan bands did not call themselves 'black metal'.[250][287][288]
Black metal tends to bemisanthropic and hostile to modern society.[25] It is "a reaction against the mundanity, insincerity and emotional emptiness that participants feel is intrinsic to modern secular culture".[289] The black metal scene tends to opposepolitical correctness,humanitarianism,consumerism,globalization and homogeneity.[290][291][292] Aaron Weaver fromWolves in the Throne Room said: "I think that black metal is an artistic movement that is critiquing modernity on a fundamental level, saying that the modern world view is missing something".[293] As part of this, some parts of the scene glorify nature and have a fascination with the distant past.[294][295] Black metal has been likened toRomanticism and there is an undercurrent ofromantic nationalism in the genre.[296][297]Sam Dunn noted that "unlike any other heavy metal scene, the culture and the place is incorporated into the music and imagery".[36]Individualism is also an important part of black metal,[36] withFenriz of Darkthrone describing black metal as "individualism above all".[298] Unlike other kinds of metal, black metal has numerous one-man bands. However, it is argued that followers of Euronymous were anti-individualistic,[299] and that "Black Metal is characterized by a conflict between radical individualism and group identity and by an attempt to accept both polarities simultaneously".[294]
In his master's thesis, Benjamin Hedge Olson wrote that some artists can be seen astranscendentalists. Dissatisfied with a "world that they feel is devoid of spiritual and cultural significance",[300] they try to leave or "transcend" their "mundane physical forms" and become one with the divine.[301] This is done through their concerts, which he describes as "musical rituals" that involve self-mortification and taking on an alternative, "spiritual persona" (for example, by the wearing of costume and face paint).[302]
Generally, black metal strives to remain anunderground phenomenon.[79]
The invertedpentagram is commonly used by bands in the genre
Black metal was originally a term for extreme metal bands with Satanic lyrics and imagery.[303]However, most of the 'first wave' bands (including Venom, who coined the term 'black metal') were not Satanists; rather, they used Satanic themes to provoke controversy or gain attention. One of the few exceptions wasMercyful Fate singer andChurch of Satan memberKing Diamond, whomMichael Moynihan calls "one of the only performers of the '80s Satanic metal who was more than just aposeur using a devilish image forshock value".[304]
Video shoot for "Carving a Giant" by Gorgoroth, which features mock crucifixions
In the early 1990s, many Norwegian black-metallers presented themselves as genuine Devil worshippers.[305]Mayhem'sEuronymous was the key figure behind this.[299] They attacked the Church of Satan for its "freedom and life-loving" views;[306] thetheistic Satanism they espoused was an inversion of Christianity. Benjamin Hedge Olson wrote that they "transform[ed] Venom's quasi-Satanic stage theatrics into a form of cultural expression unique from other forms of metal or Satanism" and "abandoned the mundane identities and ambitions of other forms of metal in favor of religious and ideological fanaticism".[299] Some prominent scene members—such as Euronymous and Faust[11][51]—stated that only bands who are Satanists can be called 'black metal'. Bands with a Norwegian style, but without Satanic lyrics, tended to use other names for their music.[250][287][288] This view is still held by many artists—such asInfernus,[307]Arioch,[308]Nornagest and Erik Danielsson.[309] Some bands, like the reformed Dissection[142][144] and Watain,[310] insist that all members must be of the same Satanic belief, whereas Michael Ford ofBlack Funeral[119] and MkM ofAntaeus[311] believe black metal must be Satanic but not all band members need to be Satanists. Others—such asJan Axel Blomberg,[312]Sigurd Wongraven[25] and Eric Horner[313]—believe that black metal does not need to be Satanic. An article in Metalion'sSlayer fanzine attacked musicians that "care more about their guitars than the actual essence onto which the whole concept was and is based upon", and insisted that "the music itself doesn't come as the first priority".[314] Bands with a similar style but with Pagan lyrics tend to be referred to as 'Pagan Metal' by many 'purist' black-metallers.[315]
Others shun Satanism, seeing it as Christian or "Judeo-Christian" in origin,[316][317] and regard Satanists as perpetuating the "Judeo-Christian" worldview.[318]Quorthon of Bathory said he used 'Satan' to provoke and attack Christianity. However, with his third and fourth albums,Under the Sign of the Black Mark andBlood Fire Death, he began "attacking Christianity from a different angle", realizing that Satanism is a "Christian product".[317] Nevertheless, some artists use Satan as a symbol or metaphor for their beliefs, such asLaVeyan Satanists (who are atheist). VocalistGaahl, who considers himself aNorseShaman,[319] said: "We use the word 'Satanist' because it is Christian world and we have to speak their language ... When I use the word 'Satan', it means the natural order, the will of a man, the will to grow, the will to become the superman".[320] Varg Vikernes called himself a Satanist in early interviews but "now downplays his former interest in Satanism", saying he was using Satan as a symbol forOdin as the 'adversary' of theChristian God.[321] He saw Satanism as "an introduction to more indigenous heathen beliefs".[322] Some bands such asCarach Angren[323] andEnslaved[324][325] do not have Satanic lyrics.
'Unblack metal' (or 'Christian black metal') promotes Christianity through its lyrics and imagery.[326] The first unblack metal record,Hellig Usvart (1994) by Australian artistHorde, was a provocative parody of Norwegian black metal. It sparked controversy, and death threats were issued against Horde. Norwegian Christian metal band Crush Evil adopted a black metal style in the late 1990s and were renamedAntestor.
Many black-metallers see "Christian black metal" as an oxymoron[327] and believe black metal cannot be Christian.[25] In fact, the early unblack metal groups Horde and Antestor refused to call their music "black metal" because they did not share its ethos. Horde called its music "holy unblack metal"[328] and Antestor called theirs "sorrow metal".[329] Horde'sJayson Sherlock later said "I will never understand why Christians think they can play Black Metal. I really don't think they understand what true Black Metal is".[330] However, current unblack metal bands such asCrimson Moonlight feel that black metal has changed from an ideological movement to a purely musical genre, and thus call their music 'black metal'.[327]
A wide range of political views are found in the black metal scene. Black metal is generally not political music and the vast majority of bands do not express their political views.[335][336][337] The genre is seen more as "fantastical escapism". Artists usually see themselves as merely depicting the "macabre nature of the world" as opposed to what they see as the "preachiness" of genres like hardcore punk.[338]Ihsahn of Emperor explained: "I see it much more as an atmospheric and emotional thing rather than a political one. Hardcore bands can deal with political things; black metal is something else".[339]
However, some black metal artists promote political ideologies. National Socialist black metal (NSBM) promotesneo-Nazi orfar-right politics through its lyrics and imagery. It is "distinguished only by ideology, not musical character".[340] Artists typically meld neo-Nazism with ethnic European paganism; however, a few meld these beliefs with Satanism or occultism. Some commentators see it as a natural development of the "black metal worldview". Members of the early Norwegian scene flirted with Nazi themes, but this was largely for shock value and to provoke.[341] Varg Vikernes—who now refers to his ideology as 'Odalism'[342]—is credited with popularizing such views within the scene.[343][344] Some bands blend Nazism and Satanism by voicing support for fascist satanist groups like theOrder of Nine Angles. Bands that have featured ONA ideology and symbolism in their albums include Hvile I Kaos, Altar of Perversion, Aosoth and Spear of Longinus.[345][346][347][348]
NSBM artists are a small minority within the genre.[337][349] While some black metal fans boycott Neo-Nazi artists, others are indifferent or appreciate the music without supporting the musicians.[151] NSBM has been criticized by some prominent and influential black metal artists—includingJon Nödtveidt,[136]Gorgoroth,[350][351][352]Dark Funeral,[5][353]Richard Lederer,[354] Michael Ford,[355] andArkhon Infaustus.[5] Some liken Nazism to Christianity by arguing that both areauthoritarian,collectivist, and a "herd mentality".[136][350] Olson writes that the shunning of Nazism by some black-metallers "has nothing to do with notions of a 'universal humanity' or a rejection of hate" but that Nazism is shunned "because its hatred is too specific and exclusive".[356]
Partly in reaction to NSBM, a small number of artists began promotingleft-wing politics such asanarchism orMarxism,[357][358][359][360] creating a movement known as "Red and anarchist black metal" (RABM).[361][362][363] Many artists have a background in anarchistcrust punk.[360] Artists labelled RABM include Iskra,Panopticon, Skagos,[360][363] Storm of Sedition,[362] Not A Cost,[362] and Black Kronstadt.[362] Some others with similar outlook, such as Wolves in the Throne Room, are not overtly political and do not endorse the label.[360]
666 – At Calling Death (1993) was a documentary released byNuclear Blast, which provides an abundance of interviews and perspectives on the meaning of both death and black metal genres from musicians who perform these styles, in light of the Norwegian scene church burnings and murders, which had been occurring around that time. The latter half of the documentary focuses on black metal.
Metal: A Headbanger's Journey (2005) touches on black metal in the early 1990s, and includes an extensive 25-minute feature on the DVD release.
True Norwegian Black Metal (2007) is a five-part feature fromVICE. It explores some of the aspects of the lifestyle, beliefs and controversies surrounding former Gorgoroth vocalistGaahl.[365]
Black Metal: A Documentary (2007), produced byBill Zebub, explores the world of black metal from the point of view of the artists. There is no narrator and no one outside of black metal takes part in any interview or storytelling.
Pure Fucking Mayhem (2009) tells the story of the black metal band Mayhem and the tragedies surrounding them.[366]
Until the Light Takes Us (2009) explores black metal's origins and subculture, featuring exclusive interviews and including rare footage from the Black Circle's early days.
Loputon Gehennan Liekki (Eternal Flame of Gehenna)(2011) Finnish black metal documentary
Out of the Black – A Black Metal Documentary (2012), an examination of the musical and social origins of black metal while exploring the full spectrum of the religious ideology within the scene. Also examines black metal in America and the multiple differences between the American and the Scandinavian scene.[368]
One Man Metal (2012) explores the lifestyle and thoughts of the members of the three one-man bandsXasthur,Leviathan andStriborg.[369]
Attention! Black Metal (2012)
Helvete: Historien om norsk black metal (2020). The history of Norwegian black metal from the early eighties through musical innovation, image building, murder, suicide and church burnings, and international recognition. With more focus on the history of the music and people involved, rather than just the scandals.[370]
The cartoon showMetalocalypse is about an extreme metal band calledDethklok, with many references to leading black metal artists on the names of various businesses, such as Fintroll's convenience store, Dimmu Burger, Gorgoroth's electric wheelchair store, Carpathian Forest High School, Marduk's Putt & Stuff, Burzum's hot-dogs and Behemoth studios (the man who owns Behemoth studios is also named Mr. Grishnackh). In the episode "Dethdad", Dethklok travels to Norway to both visit Toki's dying father and the original black metal record store, much to the dismay of the band members when they find out the store does not sell any of their music, described by the owner as being "too digital".
A Norwegian commercial for a laundry detergent once depicted black metal musicians as part of the advertisement.[371]
ComedianBrian Posehn made a visual reference to Norwegian black metal bands in the music video for his comedy song "Metal by Numbers".[372]
A KFC commercial screened in Canada (2008) and Australia (2010) featuring a fictional black metal band called Hellvetica. Onstage, the band's singer does a fire-eating trick. Once backstage, he takes a bite of the spicy KFC chicken and declares, "Oh man, that is hot".
The twenty-first episode of the fourth season ofBones, "Mayhem on a Cross", featured the discovery of a human skeleton at a black metal concert in Norway.
There are many references to black/extreme metal bands (Bathory,Marduk,Cradle of Filth andDimmu Borgir) inÅke Edwardson's 1999 crime novelSun and Shadow (Sol och skugga). The plot involves the music of a fictional Canadian black metal band called Sacrament. As part of the inquiry, Inspector Winter tries to distinguish between black and death metal artists.[373]
A recurring theme inThe IT Crowd (seasons 1 and 2) is the conversion of a character (Richmond) from executive to pariah through his exposure toCradle of Filth.
A black metal act is used to advertise "ZYX Sitruuna", a Finnish remedy for throat pain.[374]
Jonas Åkerlund's 2018 horror-thriller film,Lords of Chaos, based on the 1998 non-fictionbook of the same name, centres around a series of crimes that occurred inOslo, Norway in the early 1990s surrounding the black metal bands Mayhem and Burzum.
^"Bio/Manifesto". Gorgoroth official website. Archived fromthe original on 21 October 2007.Gorgoroth was founded by Infernus in 1992 as a strategy to perpetrate sonic and spiritual violence upon the world in order to bring forth change in peoples perception of being therein. Thus, through metal music, Satans minister on earth summoned an avatara of the forces of darkness and did let it manifestate through a variety of attempts on creating what was perceived as ultimate black metal taking form on stage as well as in a variety of studio recordings. [...] With the devoted presence of the new full time members Gaahl and King, as well as a not a day too early achieved social and mental fundament for future work, a deal was inked with the german label Nuclear Blast and the band to a bigger extent adopted the position as a live performance act taking upon them several tours worldwide bringing its sinister presence and the word of Satan to new territories...
^Hagen, Ross (2011).Musical Style, Ideology, and Mythology in Norwegian Black Metal (Book chapter in: Metal Rules the Globe: Heavy Metal Music Around the World). Durham, NC, USA: Duke University Press. pp. 180–199.
^abcEbner, Arne (25 July 2010).Ästhetik des Doom(PDF) (Bachelor) (in German). Macromedia University of Applied Sciences for Media and Communication – Cologne. Archived fromthe original(PDF) on 4 March 2016. Retrieved18 August 2018.
^abcdePatterson, Dayal.Black Metal: Evolution of the Cult. Feral House, 2013. pp. 1–5.
^J. Bennett, "Procreation of the Wicked",Precious Metal: Decibel Presents the Stories Behind 25 Extreme Metal Masterpieces, Albert Mudrian, ed., Da Capo Press, pp. 34f.
^Sharpe-Young, Garry.Metal: The Definitive Guide. p. 208.
^Bille, Torben, ed. (2002).Dansk rockleksikon (in Danish) (1st ed.).Politikens Forlag. p. 314.ISBN87-567-6525-8.En af grundlæggerne af 'black metal': heavy metal med udtalt satanistiske tekster. [English: One of the founders of 'black metal': heavy metal with pronouncedly satanic lyrics.]
^Nielsen, Jens-Emil (2014).80'er rock: Dansk rock 1980–1990 (in Danish) (1st ed.).Her & Nu. p. 74.ISBN978-87-93093-85-0.[...] sataniske tekster, som gør, at de er med til at skabe undergenren black metal. [English: [...] satanic lyrics, which entails that they are involved in creating the subgenre black metal.]
^Daniel Ekeroth:Swedish Death Metal. Second edition. Brooklyn, NY: Bazillion Points 2009, p. 249, accessed on 8 October 2012.
^Ekeroth, Daniel (2008).Swedish Death Metal.Bazillion Points. p. 67.ISBN978-0-9796163-1-0.Up to this point, no Swedish band had really followed in Bathory's footsteps. The pioneers Obscurity and Mefisto faded after just a couple of demos. The first to break the ice were the soon-to-be classic Merciless, from the small and idyllic town of Strängnäs, sixty-five miles west of Stockholm. Merciless was formed in 1986 by the very young metalheads Fredrik Karlén on bass, Stefan "Stipen" Karlsson on drums, and Erik Wallin on guitar. Fredrik had previously been in a punk band, while Stipen and Erik used to play heavy metal... Unlike Obscurity and Mefisto, Merciless also started to play live gigs very early in their career-probably one of the primary reasons why Merciless eventually succeeded where Obscurity and Mefisto had failed.
^Daniel Ekeroth:Swedish Death Metal. Second edition. Brooklyn, NY: Bazillion Points 2009, p. 162f., accessed on 24 September 2012.
^abcdefghijRobert Müller:Wollt Ihr den ewigen Krieg?.Der tote Winkel. In:Metal Hammer, November 2011.
^abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvWolf-Rüdiger Mühlmann:War Black Metal: Die Extremsten der Extremen.Was bleibt, ist Schutt und Asche. In:Rock Hard, no. 279, pp. 71–73.
^abcdeWolf-Rüdiger Mühlmann:SARCOFAGO.I.N.R.I. In:Rock Hard, Nr. 304, September 2012, p. 73.
^Campion, Chris (20 February 2005)."In the face of death".The Guardian.London. Retrieved30 December 2018.'Øystein was always sending death threats to people,' says Necro Butcher. 'It was his reaction to everything. But he didn't put so much into it. And then when he met you, he was like, "OK. You're cool!". Then you were best friends. So when eventually he got to be unfriendly with Varg, he threatened him like he did everyone else. Øystein told him, "I'm going to send some people to torture you. Until you die." But Varg Vikernes saw this as a real threat. He probably thought, "better him than me. I'll just go down and do him".'
^abcdWolf-Rüdiger Mühlmann:Impaled Nazarene.Tol Cormpt Norz Norz Norz. In:Rock Hard, no. 307, December 2012, p. 77.
^abcWolf-Rüdiger Mühlmann:Die Könige vom Westwall.Die legendären Protagonisten von damals im exklusiven Interview. In:Rock Hard, no. 269, October 2009, p. 92.
^Wolf-Rüdiger Mühlmann:Deutschland, deine Schwarzmetall-Bands. In:Rock Hard, no. 269, October 2009, p. 89.
^abcdefgTornado:Up Against the Wall Motherfucker!!!!. A Worst Case Scenario Written by Tornado!. In: Jon Kristiansen:Metalion: The Slayer Mag Diaries. Brooklyn, NY: Bazillion Points Books 2011, pp. 406f.
^"C: Do you think that FUKPIG has founded a style of his own? Misery: Nah its just d-beat crust, with added horror C: and then What difference to FUKPIG from the rest of the bands? Misery: We add more black metal / horror influences, but are still inspired by the same things C: Is Necro-Punk your style? Misery: Yeah, necro in the black metal style playing crust punk, so yeah Necro Punk."Interview: FukpigArchived 10 November 2013 at theWayback Machine
^Lee, Cosmo (21 February 2006)."Akercocke – Words That Go Unspoken, Deeds That Go Undone – Review – Stylus Magazine".Stylus Magazine. Archived fromthe original on 9 May 2012. Retrieved22 October 2012.Death metal and black metal are notoriously insular, but Akercocke has distinguished itself by freely drawing from both. Death metal tends to emphasize the low end, while black metal mainly resides in the midrange and treble, so Akercocke's 'blackened death' hybrid is rich and full-bodied.
^Pretorious, Neil (30 July 2009). "Review – Sacramentum – Far Away from the Sun"].The Metal Observer. "If you think that Blackened Death Metal begins and ends with DISSECTION, then think again. SACRAMENTUM seriously dropped the (snow) ball with 'The Coming of Chaos' and 'Thy Black Destiny', but on 'Far Away from the Sun' they really delivered the goods on all fronts."
^Roel F., Interview with Treachery,Lords of Metal issue 87, December 2008.[2]Archived 9 October 2012 at theWayback Machine Access date: 3 December 2008.
^Chris Dick, "Blut Aus Nord",Decibel, December 2006."Blut Aus Nord". Archived fromthe original on 5 February 2007. Retrieved9 February 2016. Access date: 22 July 2008.
^Mooring, Matt (28 March 2005)."Review of The Axis Of Perdition".www.metalreview.com. Archived fromthe original on 27 February 2012. Retrieved25 January 2010. Access date: 4 January 2009.
^abcHagen, Ross; Barratt-Peacock, Ruth, eds. (6 September 2019).Medievalism and Metal Music Studies. Emerald Publishing Limited. p. 216.ISBN9781787563971.
^Murphy, David (2012). "Chapter 25: Extreme Neo-nationalist Music Scenes at the Heart of Europe". In Ullrich Kockel (ed.).A Companion to the Anthropology of Europe. Blackwell Publishing. p. 437.
^Noys, Benjamin (2010). "'Remain True to the Earth!': Remarks on the Politics of Black Metal". In Nicola Masciandaro (ed.).Hideous Gnosis: Black Metal Theory Symposium. Glossator. pp. 106–108.
^Lesourd, Elodie (2013). "Baptism or Death: Black Metal in Contemporary Art". In Amelia Ishmael (ed.).Helvete: a Journal of Black Metal Theory. Punctum Books. p. 36.
^Kristiansen, Jon (2011). "Worship Him!".Metalion: The Slayer Mag Diaries.Brooklyn, New York: Bazillion Points Books: 467.
^Mulvany, Aaron Patrick (May 2000).'Re-Awakening Pride Once Lost': Indigeneity and European Folk Metal. Middletown, Connecticut: Wesleyan University. p. IV.
^Kapelovitz, Dan (February 2001)."Heavy Metal Jesus Freaks – Headbanging for Christ".Mean Magazine. Archived fromthe original on 5 August 2007. Retrieved6 September 2007.And where secular black metal thrived, so did its Christian counterpart, unblack metal, with names likeSatanicide, Neversatan, and Satan's Doom.
^Liam Dee (2016). "The Brutal Truth: Grindcore as the extreme realism of heavy metal". In Bayer, Gerd (ed.).Heavy Metal Music in Britain. Routledge. p. 59.
^Hagen, Ross (2011).Musical Style, Ideology, and Mythology in Norwegian Black Metal (Book chapter in: Metal Rules the Globe: Heavy Metal Music Around the World). Duke University Press. p. 175.
^abKelly, Kim (17 April 2013)."Skagos: Anarchic Album Review".Pitchfork. Retrieved10 May 2016.The anarchist black metal movement forms a small but fascinating pocket in the extreme metal scene.
Partridge, Christopher H.; Christianson, Eric S. (2014).The Lure of the Dark Side: Satan and Western Demonology in Popular Culture. Routledge.ISBN9781317490791.
Kugelberg, John, ed. (2008).True Norwegian Black Metal. Beste, Peter (photographer). New York: Power House Books.ISBN978-1-57687-435-6.
Lilja, Esa (2009).Theory and Analysis of Classic Heavy Metal Harmony. Helsinki: IAML Finland.ISBN978-952-5363-35-7.
Metalphoto, Chérie, ed. (2011).Chants of Evil: The Visions of the Breathing Darkness. Metalphoto, Chérie (photographer). Metalphoto Publisher.ISBN978-90-816734-1-9.
