Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


Wayback Machine
15 captures
01 Mar 2020 - 15 Jul 2025
DecJANFeb
31
202020212022
success
fail
COLLECTED BY
TIMESTAMPS
loading
The Wayback Machine - https://web.archive.org/web/20210131194121/https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/51689916
Homepage

Accessibility links

BBC Account
Notifications
Search

Offside and handball laws under Ifab review along with concussion substitutions

Last updated on.From the sectionFootballcomments79

Wolverhampton Wanderers defender Conor Coady questions referee Mike Dean about an offside decision
Wolverhampton Wanderers have had four goals ruled out by VAR this season due to offside decisions

Football's rule-makers are to review the offside law in order to "foster the spirit of attacking play".

The decision was made at the annual general meeting of The International Football Association Board (Ifab).

The organisation, meeting in Belfast, also approved clarifications to the handball law to "differentiate more clearly" between the arm and shoulder.

And substitutions for concussion cases are to be trialled, potentially at the Tokyo Olympics this summer.

It appears likely that permanent substitutions would be the preferred option rather than a temporary substitution while a 10-minute assessment is carried out.

Offside decisions have come under closer scrutiny in the Premier League this season following the introduction of the video assistant referee.

The time spent reaching a decision over marginal calls earlier in the season prompted Ifab general secretary Lukas Brud to reiterate that VAR systems should only be used to correct "clear and obvious errors".

Earlier this month, Fifa's chief of global football development Arsene Wenger said there might be room to the change the offside law "a little bit" in response to video assistant referee controversy.

The former Arsenal manager wants to refine the rules to favour the attacking player, saying they should be deemed onside if any part of their body that can score a goal is at least level with the defender, even if other parts are in front.

Wenger's calls for the introduction of what has been dubbed a 'daylight' offside rule have since been backed by Fifa president Gianni Infantino.

He said that principle was backed by the rest of the Ifab.

"It has been received very positively," said Infantino after Saturday's meeting. "That is why we decided to study this further, to debate it in different panels and with different stakeholders to elaborate a protocol.

"Obviously the philosophy of fostering attacking football always has to guide us. We have to be aware of tradition but it is true the offside rule has evolved over time.

"We will look into providing strikers more goalscoring opportunities and that's why I think the feeling in the room and the feedback in the room was positive. But we have to test it."

Concussion substitutes set to be trialled at Olympics

Jan Vertonghen
The head injury suffered by Tottenham's Jan Vertonghen during last season's Champions League semi-final against Ajax strengthened calls for concussion substitutes to be introduced

The Ifab's decision to trial the use of concussion substitutes has been welcomed by Football Association chief executive Mark Bullingham.

He said the FA and Premier League both favoured the permanent substitution model and are keen to be part of any future trials.

The first step looks likely to be made at this summer's Olympics, in both the men's and women's competitions.

Irish Football Association chief executive Patrick Nelson, who chaired the meeting, said: "We agreed it would be a sensible move to draw up some protocols for trials.

"More research data is needed before we could consider any permanent changes to the laws."

The current guidelines allow a three-minute assessment period for concussion and Infantino is keen to assess alternatives in any future trials after criticism over Fifa's handling of the issue.

"If there is any doubt you have to keep the player out, and for the coach to have another possibility, he knows there is an additional substitution," he said.

"Often we were criticised for being slow (on concussion). Now, we move, we try, and then we'll see."

Brain injury charity Headway led calls for temporary concussion substitutions to be introducedfollowing the head injury suffered by Tottenham defender Jan Vertonghen during last season's Champions League semi-final against Ajax.

He was treated for five minutes on the pitch and tried to play on but was led off after appearing unwell.

Peter McCabe, the chief executive of Headway, said today's ruling was "just another example of football failing to act".

"This latest announcement just doesn't go far enough to protect players from the dangers of returning to play following a concussion," he said.

"In practical terms nothing will actually change for the injured player."

Handball rule adopts the 'T-shirt line'

Bournemouth manager Eddie Howe on the way VAR decisions affected his side against Burnley

The most significant change to the laws of the game to come out of today's Ifab annual general meeting concerned the handball rule.

From the start of the 2020/21 season, the point at which the arm stops and the shoulder begins will now be written into the laws of the game as the "T-shirt line".

The new ruling aims to allow match officials to "differentiate more clearly" between the arm and shoulder.

Confusion about where the line is drawn was evident inBurnley's 3-0 win at home to Bournemouth last weekend.

The Cherries had a Joshua King goal ruled out by a VAR check for a handball by Philip Billing that manager Eddie Howe claimed came off his shoulder.

And the match swung in the second-half on another handball decision, again made by VAR, against Bournemouth's Adam Smith, who was judged to have used his upper arm to control the ball.

The "T-shirt line" is the latest in a number of clarifications to the handball rules, which, like the offside laws, have been put under the microscope by the use of VAR.

Thelast amendment, which has been in force since last season's Champions League final, said handball would be given against a player if their arms extend "beyond a natural silhouette" - even if it is accidental.

Analysis

BBC sports news reporter Laura Scott

The introduction of concussion substitutes, as a trial at first, is a big step forward and follows years of campaigning.

Fifa president Gianni Infantino noted that they have been accused of acting slowly on this, but this decision will be welcomed by many, including brain injury charities.

How exactly they will work in practice will be the subject of discussions over the next few months, as the protocol is drawn up.

On VAR, Infantino said that people "need to relax", adding that "there is only one league in the world today where this issue seems to be a big problem".

Perhaps reflecting this, there weren't any concrete changes, but they'll continue reviewing it, particularly around communication of decisions.

Comments

Join the conversation

These comments are now closed.

79 comments
  • Offside is only "black and white" in so much as an attacker getting a clear advantage. It was never meant to be measuring toenails, shoulder blades and pinky fingers! As a fan, all I wanted was VAR to overturn the "clear and obvious" errors that officials only very rarely make.
  • Some years ago football's rule-makers reviewed the offside law in order to foster the spirit of attacking play! So what happened since?
  • VAR works. It's the chumps reviewing the footage that don't seem to have a clue. I'd like to see it scrapped though. For me, it adds very little to the game.
  • VAR and the laws were perfectly fine until the English started using VAR lol

    Just shows how bad English officials are and why none of them went to the World Cup! Tweaking the laws to make up for their incompetence is just embarrassing.

    Webb's failure to send De Jong off for his assault on Xabi Alonso in the 2010 WC final has made English officials the laughing stock of the world ever since.
  • Please tell me whilst we are moaning about refereeing, when did it become ok for a player to stand over the free kick to prevent it being taken ? (It used to be a bookable offence and is time wasting\ bad sportsmanship). Nuno disciple
  • At one time, you had to be beyond the last defender....now if your toe or little finger is beyond the last defender....it's a ridiculous rule now.
  • I agree with #35, diving is a sickness in the beautiful game and Z rated pundits like Jermaine Jenus saying things like "he felt a hand touch him so had every right to go down"!

    Condoning cheating is as bad as actually doing it!
  • VAR has made it a game of different laws. Offside as identified by VAR is only possible using cameras. The Assitant Referee cannot possibly tell that a player is offside by a millimetre when the ball is played. Mind you I don't think the cameea can either but that's another argument.

    The good news is I've got my life back now as I've stopped watching live Premiership games on TV.
  • The change I'd like to see introduced is using 'time off' from the clock, like in rugby, while decisions are made, injuries assessed and substitutions made.

    The amount of time fans get to see the ball actually in play is getting less and less and this would save on all sorts of time wasting by players, managers and VAR.
  • The people UPSTAIRS are killing the game with VAR. Now low and behold the FA CUP is losing its status by having it moved from traditional saturdays to midweek to suit the SUITS. Please do not worry about the thousands of supporters that have to go to work the next day after travelling back from Portsmouth, Chelsea, Reading, West Bromwich,Tottenham this coming week. SHAME ON YOU F.A.Money grabbers
  • VAR unofficially changed the offside law in that the old sensible concept of 2 players being more or less level, giving the attacking player/side the benefit of the doubt, went out the window, introducing in its place the insane concept of a part of a player's body being a millimetre offside for 1/10th of a second.

    It should have been obvious from the start that this was a crazy move.
  • VAR has proved how poor our referees really are. Now they have time to review situations from several angles they are still making glaring errors. Many of these refs have obviously not even played football to a Sunday league level.
  • Daylight rule makes sense. If any part of the players torso (body & legs) is at least in line with a defenders torso then its onside. Simple. Crack on.
  • How about reviewing the diving law too, so if a diver causes his team to win they get a retrospective loss PLUS a six point deduction?

    Diving; STAMP IT OUT!!!!!
  • Wenger's got it wrong - the use VAR needs to be changed - not meddling with the laws of football to accommodate it! It's just ridiculous!!
  • And it takes a FIFA committee to decide scoring goals is the most important part of the game?
  • hand ball is easy, just put it back to deliberate hand ball, Leicester last night were robbed.
  • As part of resolving this issue, with clearer rules, they need to enforce a time limit on the decision too. With just a few seconds between where offside usually occurs and the player striking the ball or passing and a shot being taken VAR has to come to a decision much quicker than it is currently afforded. 15 seconds should be the absolute maximum time allowed. If that!
  • The two blantant red cards recently (Chelsea v Man Utd & Spurs v Chelsea) were scandalous. In the latter, the VAR ref even admitted he was wrong during the match. Madness....
  • "deemed onside if any part of their body that can score a goal is at least level with the defender"

    so attacker running towards goal trailing foot is level with the trailing foot of a defender heading towards the half way line - thats a full metre and some between the bodies but onside - really?

    Keep the rule the same widen the lines and require daylight between the lines = clear and obvious

Top Stories

Also in Sport

Explore the BBC

  • Tailenders

    Fresh off a series victory Jimmy Anderson reveals the fate of the Moose Cup

Explore the BBC


[8]ページ先頭

©2009-2026 Movatter.jp