Multifunctionality of Crystalline MoV(TeNb) M1 Oxide Catalysts in Selective Oxidation of Propane and Benzyl Alcohol

Article in ACS Catalysis 3(6):1103-1113 · June 2013 with 900 Reads
DOI:10.1021/cs400010q
Show more authors
Hide
Abstract
Propane oxidation at 653-673 K and benzyl alcohol oxidation at 393 K over phase-pure MOV(TeNb) M1 oxide catalysts were studied to gain insight into the multiple catalytic functions of the surface of the M1 structure. Electron microscopy and X-ray diffraction confirmed the phase purity of the M1 catalysts. Propane oxidation yields acrylic acid via propene as intermediate, while benzyl alcohol oxidation gives benzaldehyde, benzoic acid, benzyl benzoate, and toluene. The consumption rates of benzyl alcohol and propane level in the same range despite huge difference in reaction temperature, suggesting high activity of M1 for alcohol oxidation. Metal-oxygen sites on the M1 surface are responsible for the conversion of the two reactants. However, different types of active sites and reaction mechanisms may be involved. Omitting Te and Nb from the M1 framework eliminates acrylic acid selectivity in propane oxidation, while the product distribution in benzyl alcohol oxidation remains unchanged. The results suggest that the surface of M1 possesses several types of active sites that likely perform a complex interplay under the harsh propane oxidation condition. Possible reaction pathways and mechanisms are discussed.

Do you want toread the rest of this article?

Request full-text
Request Full-text Paper PDF
  • Article
    • Oct 2018
    Here, we have described the synthesis, characterization and catalytic activity of a dioxo-molybdenum(VI) complex supported on functionalized Merrifield resin (MR-SB-Mo). The functionalization of Merrifield resin (MR) was achieved in two-steps viz. carbonylation (MR-C) and Schiff base formation (MR-SB). The compounds, MR-C, MR-SB and MR-SB-Mo, were characterized at each step of the synthesis by elemental, SEM, EDX, thermal, BET and different spectroscopic analysis. The catalyst, MR-SB-Mo, efficiently and selectively oxidized a wide variety of alcohols to aldehydes or ketones using 30% H2O2 as an oxidant with reasonably good TOF (660 h⁻¹ in case of benzyl alcohol). The catalyst acted heterogeneously under solventless reaction conditions and did not lead to over oxidized products under optimized conditions. The catalyst afforded regeneration and can be reused for at least five reaction cycles without loss of efficiency and product selectivity. A reaction mechanism for the catalytic activity of MR-SB-Mo was proposed and a probable reactive intermediate species isolated.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    • Sep 2018
    The catalytic performance of Mo8V2Nb1-based mixed-oxide catalysts for ethane partial oxidation is highly sensitive to the doping of elements with redox and acid functionality. Specifically, control over product distributions to ethylene and acetic acid can be afforded via the specific pairing of redox elements (Pd, Ni, Ti) and acid elements (K, Cs, Te) and the levels at which these elements are doped. The redox element, acid element, redox/acid ratio, and dopant/host ratio were investigated using a three-level, four-factor factorial screening design to establish relationships between catalyst composition, structure, and product distribution for ethane partial oxidation. Results show that the balance between redox and acid functionality and overall dopant level is important for maximizing the formation of each product while maintaining the structural integrity of the host metal oxide. Overall, ethylene yield was maximized for a Mo8V2Nb1Ni0.0025Te0.5 composition, while acetic acid yield was maximized for a Mo8V2Nb1Ti0.005Te1 catalyst.
  • Article
    • Sep 2017
    Exploiting efficient photocatalysts with strengthened structure properties for solar-driven alcohol oxidation is of great significance. Herein, we found that the photocatalytic performance of graphitic carbon nitrides can be sharply promoted by modulating the crystallinity. Results confirmed that the high crystallinity accelerates the separation and transfer of photogenerated charge carriers, thus providing more free-charges for photoredox reactions. More importantly, the crystallinity facilitated the adsorption of benzyl alcohol and desorption of benzyl aldehyde, and simultaneously lowered the energy barrier for O2 activation. As a result, the crystalline carbon nitride exhibited ~ 12-fold promotion with respect to the normal carbon nitride. The remarkable enhancement of activity can be attributed to the synergistic effects of the increased electron/hole separation and boosted surface reaction kinetic. These findings will open up new opportunities in modulating the structure of the polymers for a wide variety of organic transformations.
  • Article
    An efficient oxidation catalyst has been synthesized by anchoring oxo-vanadium (IV) onto the amino-functional microporous organic nanotube frameworks (NH2-MONFs). The amino groups are used to immobilize oxo-vanadium (IV) into the porous organic polymer supporter. The resulting oxo-vanadium (IV) complexes have a high surface area, large pore volume, hierarchically porous structure and robust organic network, which have great potential application in heterogeneous catalysis. The introduction of mesoporous tubular channels in the network units improves mass transfer in the catalytic system and the well distribution of catalytic sites in the channels facilitates the accessibility of active sites, which will be beneficial for good catalytic performance in heterogeneous catalysis. The prepared oxo-vanadium heterogeneous catalyst shows high catalytic activity and excellent stability in the selective oxidation reactions of thiols to disulfides.
  • Article
    • Jul 2017
    The oxidation of propane has been studied over silica-supported vanadium oxide and polycrystalline, bulk MoVTeNb oxide with M1 structure. Temperature-programmed reaction experiments were performed, and the reactivity of propane molecules labeled with deuterium and 13C, respectively, was analyzed under steady-state conditions. The measurement of kinetic isotope effects reveals fundamental differences in the activation of propane over the two catalysts. The reaction network of consecutive and parallel reactions of the formed propylene is comparable. However, oxygen insertion into the CHO group of acrolein under formation of acrylic acid is faster over M1 than oxidation at the CH2 group and decarbonylation to acetaldehyde. In contrast, the latter process is preferred over silica-supported vanadium oxide resulting in lower selectivity to unsaturated oxygenates.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    • Jan 2017
    A sustainable catalyst for the selective oxidation of benzyl alcohol (BnOH) to benzaldehyde (BzH) was developed by mineralizing Ti(SO4)2 on graphene oxide foam (GOF) surface. The Ti(SO4)2/GOF was characterized by scanning electron microscopy (SEM), energy disperse spectroscopy (EDS), X-ray diffraction (XRD), solid-state NMR (SSNMR), thermal gravimetric analysis (TGA), infrared (IR) and BET analysis. Recycling experiments proved that Ti(SO4)2/GOF possessed excellent reusability and durability. The industrial perspective of Ti(SO4)2/GOF was demonstrated by the preparation of BzH in a large-scale and solvent-free oxidation process.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    • Dec 2016
    A series of magnesium-doped MoVTeNbOx (MVTN-Mg) catalysts, as well as undoped sample (MVTN) was prepared by microwave-assisted slurry method followed by calcination in nitrogen at 873 K for 2 hours. The catalysts were further post-treated in aqueous hydrogen peroxide. The physicochemical properties of the catalysts were investigated using X-ray diffraction (XRD), surface area measurement using Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) method, Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) and Field Emission Scanning Electron Microscopy (FESEM) which showed the formation of orthorhombic M1 phase, Te2M20O57 (M = Mo, V or Nb) when doped with Mg at a molar ratio of Mg/Mo of 0.06. Temperature Programmed Reduction in hydrogen (H2-TPR) results indicated the enhanced reducibility of the Mg doped catalysts as opposed to the undoped ones, signifying the apparent high activity of the catalyst. © 2016, Malaysian Society of Analytical Sciences. All rights reserved.
  • Article
    • Nov 2016
    The catalytic performance of (i) crystalline MoVTeNb oxide that exhibits the electronic properties of a n-type semiconductor, (ii) sub-monolayer vanadium oxide supported on meso-structured silica (SBA-15) as an insulating support, and (iii) surface-functionalized carbon nanotubes that contain neither a redox active metal nor bulk oxygen, but only surface oxygen species have been compared in the oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane and propane under equal reaction conditions. The catalytic results indicate similarities in the reaction network over all three catalysts within the range of the studied reaction conditions implying that differences in selectivity are a consequence of differences in the rate constants. Higher activity and selectivity to acrylic acid over MoVTeNb oxide as compared to the other two catalysts are attributed to the higher density of potential alkane adsorption sites on M1 and the specific electronic structure of the semiconducting bulk catalyst. Microcalorimetry has been used to determine and quantify different adsorption sites revealing a low Vsurface/C3H8ads ratio of 4 on M1 and a much higher ratio of 150 on silica-supported vanadium oxide. On the latter catalyst less than one per cent of surface vanadium atoms adsorb propane. Barriers of propane activation increase in the order P/oCNT (139 kJ mol-1) ≤ M1 (143 kJ mol-1) < 6V/SBA-15 (162 kJ mol-1), which is in agreement with trends predicted by theory.
  • Article
    • Aug 2016
    Effective control of surface composition of bimetallic catalysts is challenging yet important, as synergistic effects between two metals play vital roles in heterogeneous catalysis. This study involves methods of loading control, thermal activation, and selective surface etching to modify the bimetallic surface on the Au-Ag/SBA-15 catalyst and gains insight into the nature of the promotional effect of Ag modification over Au catalysts. The binary Au-Ag/SBA-15 catalyst prepared following a stepwise metal-loading procedure is found for the first time to be active in benzyl alcohol dehydrogenation without oxidant or hydrogen acceptor. A direct correlation is established between the surface compositions of the Au-Ag nanoparticles and their intrinsic catalytic activities. Au-Ag element analytical techniques, including X-ray fluorescence, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and high-sensitivity low-energy ion scattering spectroscopy, are applied to acquire compositional information in bulk and on the surface. As a result, the pronounced improvement of Au catalyst by Ag is from an ensemble with a specific surface composition rather than the bulk composition. The synergy between Au and Ag for benzyl alcohol dehydrogenation is the most pronounced in the case of 4:1 Au-Ag surface compositions, corresponding to the prepared Au1-Ag0.111 catalyst. The electronic promoting effect is suggested as the natural origin of compositional enhancement by differentiating it from the structural effect. This work demonstrates the importance of surface composition control at an atomic level in developing highly efficient multicomponent catalysts.
  • Book
    • Apr 2008
    The first comprehensive survey of the principles and applications of heterogeneous catalysis! With contributions from more than two hundred leading scientists, this book is indispensable for every scientist concerned with heterogeneous catalysis.
  • Chapter
    • Jun 2003
    Reactions Involving Carbon MonoxideReactions with the Participation of HydrocarbonsTransformations of Aldehydes and KetonesTransformations of AlcoholsTransformations of Nitrogen-containing Compounds
  • Article
    • Oct 2011
    Reliable procedures for the controlled synthesis of phase-pure MoVTeNb mixed oxides with M1 structure (ICSD 55097) and tunable crystal dimensions were developed to study the structure sensitivity of the selective oxidation of propane to acrylic acid. A series of powdered M1 catalysts was successfully prepared on a gram scale by using a hydrothermal-based route, purification of biphasic M1-M2 (M2 phase – ICSD 55098) oxide systems, and an innovative approach utilizing a superheated water vapor treatment of calcined precursors. The influence of the preparation technique on the particle morphology and the size is discussed. Detailed experimental studies highlight that the as-derived catalytic materials were indeed phase-pure and compositionally uniform MoVTeNb oxide M1 powders, composed of single-crystalline and structural defect-free crystals grown along the c axis. The morphologically different catalysts were studied in the selective oxidation of propane to acrylic acid, revealing that active sites appear on the entire M1 surface and illustrating the high sensitivity of catalyst performance on the catalyst synthesis method.
  • Article
    • Apr 2012
    The phase evolution of MoVTeNb mixed oxides derived from a novel acrylamide-gelation approach combined with subsequent washing by hydrogen peroxide and/or annealing in argon was investigated by using powder X-ray diffraction and scanning electron microscopy in conjunction with energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy. The calcination of acrylamide-gelation derived carbon-based xerogels in air at 410 °C afforded at unexpected low temperature the formation of a phase mixture containing a significant amount of small MoVTeNb oxide crystallites consisting of the M1 phase (ICSD no. 55097). Hydrogen peroxide treatment drastically changed the phase evolution upon annealing in argon at 600 °C. Whereas further enrichment of the M1 phase took place for the untreated precursor, annealing of the washed material resulted in complete collapse of the M1 phase, yielding a ternary MoVNb mixed oxide with tetragonal Mo5O14-type structure (ICSD no. 27202). The reducing effect of organic residues on phase evolution during calcination of the carbon-inorganic xerogel in air is discussed. The presence of side phases and the deficiency in tellurium upon annealing have a critical impact on the phase composition of the final product. The catalysts exhibit significant activity in partial oxidation of propane to acrylic acid. The analysis of the product distribution suggested that the activation of both propane and propylene intermediates proceed exclusively over the M1 phase, while side phases do not play a significant role in the reaction.
  • Article
    • Jul 2011
    In the mix with metals: Multi-component MoVNbTe mixed oxides, in contrast to three-component MoVNb and MoVTe oxides show exclusive efficiency in selective oxidation of ethanol by molecular oxygen to obtain acetic acid.
  • Article
    • May 2012
    Bulk mixed oxide catalysts are widely used for various applications (selective oxidation catalysts, electrocatalysts for solid oxide fuel cells, and solid oxide electrolyzers for the production of hydrogen), but fundamental understanding of their structure–performance relationships have lagged in the literature. The absence of suitable surface composition and surface structural characterization techniques and methods to determine the number of catalytic active sites, with the latter needed for determination of specific reaction rates (e.g., turnover frequency (1/s)), have hampered the development of sound fundamental concepts in this area of heterogeneous catalysis. This Perspective reviews the traditional concepts that have been employed to explain catalysis by bulk mixed oxides (molybdates, vanadates, spinels, perovskites, and several other specific mixed oxide systems) and introduces a modern perspective to the fundamental surface structure–activity/selectivity relationships for bulk mixed oxide catalysts. The new insights have recently been made available by advances in surface characterization techniques (low-energy ion scattering, energy-resolved XPS, and CH3OH-IR) that allow for direct analysis of the outermost surface layer of bulk mixed metal oxide catalysts. The new findings sound a note of caution for the accepted hypotheses and concepts, and new catalysis models need to be developed that are based on the actual surface features of bulk mixed oxide catalysts.
  • Article
    Novel crystalline MoVO oxide was employed as the catalyst in the aerobic oxidation of alcohols to the corresponding carbonyl compounds. Reactions were mainly conducted at 353 K in pure oxygen or air (1 atm). The selectivities for benzaldehydes were more than 95% in all cases. The conversions of benzyl alcohols varied from 10% to 99% depending on the substituent. A Hammett plot gave a moderate ρ-value of −0.249 (r2 = 0.98), suggesting that the reaction processes may involve hydride abstraction. The oxidation of primary alkanols afforded aldehydes, and secondary alcohols were mainly dehydrated to olefins. It was found that the conversion of linear alkanols decreased with the length of alkanols. Kinetic analysis showed that catalytic reaction rate was first-order dependent on the concentrations of substrate and of catalyst. The apparent activation energy was estimated to be 45.7 kJ mol−1. Catalytic reactions took place on the 6- or 7-member rings on the a–b basal plane, where highly dense unsaturated metal cation centers and oxygen anion might serve as catalytic active sites.
  • Article
    The reaction pathways for the oxidation of propane over VO-H-beta and Mo1V0.3Te0.23Nb0.12Ox are investigated. Two methods are used in this study: (i) overall product selectivities are recorded as a function of conversion, and (ii) those species observed or speculated to exist are reacted individually over the catalysts. With VO-H-beta, propene is the primary product of propane oxidation and acetic acid is a sequential oxidation product of the propene, possibly forming through an acetone intermediate. Mo1V0.3Te0.23Nb0.12Ox also gives propene as the primary product of propane oxidation, and the propene thus formed oxidizes further to acrylic acid and acetone. Reactions of individual oxygenated compounds, e.g., propanal, acrolein, etc., confirm the superior oxidation features of the mixed metal oxide catalyst relative to the zeolite-based catalyst.
  • Article
    The M1 phase of the MoV(Nb,Ta)TeO system is one of the most effective catalysts for the ammoxidation and selective oxidation of propane to acrylonitrile (AN) and acrylic acid, respectively. The active centers of the M1 phase reside on the ab planes of this crystalline material (i.e., the (001) lattice face). Early on we proposed that the thus located active centers contain all key catalytic elements strategically placed for the conversion of propane to AN. These seven element comprising active centers contain: five metal oxide octahedra (2 V0.325+/Mo0.686+, 1 V0.624+/Mo0.386+, 2Mo0.56+/Mo0.55+) and two Te4+—oxygen sites. In this contribution we analyze the various compositional probabilities of the seven element active centers and their additional eight element surroundings and conclude that there are 32 possible compositional arrangements of this 15 element assembly. From the diverse structural arrangements, diverse catalytic properties can be assigned to the individual sites, leading to diverse propane reaction pathways. We conclude that there are 22% AN forming, 22% propylene, 10% waste and 46% inert sites. After normalization these sites are deemed to lead to the following product yields: 41% AN, 41% propylene and 18% waste. The highest experimentally attained AN yield from propane is 42%, employing M1 phase only, which coincides with the predicted value of a concerted mechanism. Higher AN yields are, however, anticipated, up to a lofty upper limit of 82%, by allowing also for a consecutive mechanism (C3° → C3=→AN). This possibility can be rationalized on the basis of the existence of vicinal C3° → C3=/C3=→AN sites whose presence is plentiful on the catalytically important ab planes of M1. The placement and efficiency of these sites is, however, not perfect; therefore the upper AN yield limit is not realized in practice. Our analysis of the elemental distribution at the active centers and their immediate surroundings provides us with new insights into the relationship between structure and catalytic reaction mechanisms of the M1 phase and might serve as a guide towards a redesign of the M1 composition, so as to attain higher AN yields from propane. It provides a challenging task for the synthetic chemist.
  • Article
    The selective oxidation of propane to acrylic acid is studied over a series of nearly pure M1-phase MoVTeNbOxcatalysts. Quantitative analysis of the reaction network shows that the ratio of the rate constants for propane oxidative dehydrogenation to propene and for the further oxidation of propene is constant. The rates towards acrolein and acetone, however, vary subtly with the concentration of vanadium and the location of its substitution. The reaction of acrolein to acetic acid and carbon oxides, associated with accessible metal cations, contributes two-thirds towards the non-selective pathway. The other third is associated with acetone formation. Vanadium is first substituted selectively at sites that are inactive for propane activation. Depending on the selectivity of this substitution two groups of materials have been identified, which show a distinctly different dependence on the concentration of vanadium. Statistic distribution of vanadium in the M1 phase appears to be the most promising strategy to improve the performance of MoVTeNbOxcatalysts for a given vanadium concentration.
Ad