More
chatterbox
columns

Chris DeMuth, Hack Extraordinaire
The leader of President Bush's favorite think tank bidsadieu.
Timothy Noah
posted Oct. 11, 2007
Bush Cabinet Quiz, Part 3
The White House fixes two erroneous entries on its Cabinet Web page but creates a new one.
Timothy Noah
posted Oct. 10, 2007
Clawing Your Way to the Nobel Peace Prize
A former vice president, a Holocaust hero, and a right-wing broadcaster duke it out with 10,000 Burmese monks.
Timothy Noah
posted Oct. 9, 2007
Bush Cabinet Quiz, Part 2
Wherein your quizmaster admits error, but the White House does not.
Timothy Noah
posted Oct. 8, 2007
Why Bush Was Dumb To Veto SCHIP
It greases the skids for universal health care.
Timothy Noah
posted Oct. 3, 2007
Search for morechatterbox in our archive
Subscribe to thechatterbox RSS feed

featured advertiser links

chatterbox:Gossip, speculation, and scuttlebutt about politics.

What About Byrd?Unlike Thurmond, he renounced his racist past.

By Timothy Noah
Posted Wednesday, Dec. 18, 2002, at 2:28 PM ET

Since posting anitem pointing out that, contrary to Washington legend, Strom Thurmondnever renounced his segregationist past, Chatterbox has been inundated with rude e-mails. The theme of these e-mails is: What about former Senate Majority Leader Robert Byrd? Byrd, a Democrat who still represents West Virginia, belonged to the Ku Klux Klan when he was a young man. Past membership in the Klan is heavier moral baggage than past advocacy of segregation. But Byrd, unlike Thurmond, renounced his youthful participation in a racist cause. See, for example, this exchange with CNN's Bernard Shaw in Dec. 1993:

Q: What has been your biggest mistake and your biggest success?

A: Well, it's easy to state what has been my biggest mistake. The greatest mistake I ever made was joining the Ku KluxKlan. And I've said that many times. But one cannot erase what he has done. He can only change his ways and his thoughts. That was an albatross around my neck that I will always wear. You will read it in my obituary that I was a member of the Ku KluxKlan.

Contrast that with an interview Thurmond gave Joseph Stroud of theCharlotte Observerin July 1998 to commemorate the 50^th anniversary of his presidential bid on the segregationist Dixiecrat ticket. Asked if he wanted to apologize, Thurmond said, "I don't have anything to apologize for," and "I don't have any regrets." Asked if he thought the Dixiecrats were right, Thurmond said, "Yes, I do." Thurmond said thisfour years ago!

Chatterbox has not yet received any rude e-mails asking: What about Senate Democrat Ernest Hollings? Hollings ran for governor of South Carolina in 1958 pledging to protect "the Southern way of life," which in those days meant segregation. Once in office, though, Hollings switched sides and supported integration. When Howell Raines of theNew York Times asked Hollings in 1983 about his brief career as a segregationist, Hollings didn't just say he knew it was wrong now. He said, "I knew it was wrong"then.

Have Byrd and Hollings atoned sufficiently for their previous views and policies? Probably not. But they have renounced them. Thurmond never will.