Dogged throughout by a shifting point of view, tale starts out with banal retrospective narration by the Ryan family’s young daughter, Judith (Julia Weldon), who explains that certain events can mark one’s life decisively, creating a terrible divide between before and after. As inane and pointless as this commentary may seem, it’s actually the first of the film’s cop-outs as it slyly signals that, like Judith, we’ll end up safely on the drama’s far shore.
As the opening scenes show, the Ryans are well-off residents of a picture-book slice of Massachusetts. Carolyn (Streep) is anestablished pediatrician, Ben (Neeson) a successful artist. Their well-ordered life is upended one winter’s eve when a local policeman brings the news that their son, Jacob (Edward Furlong), was the last person seen with a teenage girl who’s been murdered, and he’s now missing.
Ben reacts with an instant vehemence that the film never satisfactorily explains, then looks in his garage and finds blood-covered car implements, which he cleans before the police return with a search warrant. Though this evidence has been destroyed, Jacob remains the prime suspect, and his disappearance heightens community suspicion and animosity toward the Ryans.
After five agonizing weeks — which pass like five surprised seconds because, evidently, a section of the story didn’t make pic’s final cut — the boy is apprehended in Boston. Back at home, Jacob is withdrawn to the point of catatonia until the facade cracks and he explains his actions on the day of the murder, saying that he and the girl had a lovers’ spat that ended when she accidentally fell on a car jack and killed herself — a preposterous touch, but one in keeping with the rest of the story.
For the second time, Ben attempts to skirt the law by persuading Jacob to assert that he was away from the scene when the girl died, a claim the boy relates to the high-priced lawyer the Ryans have engaged, Panos Demeris (Alfred Molina). That Demeris, who’s supposed to be a world-class defender, doesn’t question Jacob’s doozy of a story is yet another strain on the tale’s credibility.
Other blows come when pic declines to show Ben’s and Carolyn’s separate appearances before the court, both of which are significant and prompt explosive reactions. Were these scenes shot and then cut because they didn’t work, or did the filmmakers think it would be clever to allow audiences to imagine their contents? Whatever the reasoning, the results are startlingly clumsy, creating dramatic gaps that never get filled.
Ultimately the story struggles to say something about the different responsibilities people have to their families and to the world beyond.
Yet no coherent message comes through, partly because the Ryans are so poorly drawn that none ends up a believable individual, but also because the script at every turn falls back on mushy affirmations of family rather than taking the risk of exploring conflicts that reveal the bitterest divisions between one family member and another, and between family and community.
Apart from Molina’s sharp performance as Demeris, none of the main actors comes off particularly well. While Streep displays her usual exacting intelligence, the generic mom role allows for little that’s distinctive or memorable.
Beyond looking dyspeptic and vaguely artsy, Neeson seems to lack the leading-man heft required in Ben; his work is wan and unfocused. And though Furlong has presence in spades, this is one too many films where he’s gotten by on that trademark woebegone stare and monotone delivery; it’s about time the boy started to act.
Schroeder nonetheless has turned out a visually pleasing film thanks to contributions such as Luciano Tovoli’s crisp lensing and Stuart Wurtzel’s vivid production design. Other tech credits are similarly high-caliber.
Before and After
(Drama -- Color)
- Production:A Hollywood Pictures presentation in association with Caravan Pictures of a Schroeder/Hoffman production. Produced by Barbet Schroeder, Susan Hoffman. Executive producers, Roger Birnbaum, Joe Roth. Co-producer, Chris Brigham. Directed by Barbet Schroeder. Screenplay, Ted Tally, based on the novel by Rosellen Brown.
- Crew:Camera (Technicolor), Luciano Tovoli; editor, Lee Percy; music, Howard Shore; production design, Stuart Wurtzel; art direction, Steve Saklad; set decoration, Gretchen Rau; costume design, Ann Roth; associate producer, Jonathan Glickman; assistant director, Henry Bronchtein; unit production manager , Chris Brigham; casting, Howard Feuer. Reviewed at Walt Disney screening room, New York, Feb. 21, 1996. Running time: 107 min.
- With:Carolyn Ryan ... Meryl StreepBen Ryan ... Liam NeesonJacob Ryan ...Edward FurlongJudith Ryan ... Julia WeldonPanos Demeris ... Alfred MolinaFran Conklin ... Daniel Von BargenWendell Bye ... John HeardTerry Taverner ... Ann MagnusonMartha Taverner ... Alison FollandMarian Raynor, Prosecutor ... Kaiulani Lee
More from Variety
Loading comments...
Most Popular
Must Read
- Music
COVER | ‘My Job Is to F—ing Sing’: Bad Bunny on the 'Pride, Pain and Love' Behind His Massive Puerto Rico Residency
By Andrew Wallenstein
- Film
How Steven Spielberg’s ‘Jaws’ Endured a Hellish Production to Become Hollywood’s First Summer Blockbuster
- TV
‘This Is Real Life’: How Bravo’s ‘The Valley’ Navigated Drug Addiction, a Violent Incident and a Cast Member in a Mental Health…
- Music
Barbra Streisand on Her New Album, Not Being Paid Enough for ‘Meet the Fockers’ and if She’ll Ever Direct or Perform Live Again
Sign Up for Variety Newsletters
By providing your information, you agree to ourTerms of Use and ourPrivacy Policy.We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services. // This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the GooglePrivacy Policy andTerms of Service apply.
Variety Confidential
A Variety and iHeartRadio Podcast
