New Westminster council voted Monday to accept the ethics commissioner’s recommendation for Mayor Patrick Johnstone to receive training after he breached the city’s code of conduct by accepting an all-expenses paid trip to Dubai.

Commissioner Jennifer Devins found Johnstone violated council’s code of conduct by accepting a “personal benefit” in the form of business-class travel, accommodations and meals while attending the COP28 Local Climate Action Summit in Dubai in December 2023, but did so inadvertently and in good faith.

Devins recommended Johnstone receive training on the relevant provisions of the charter related to the acceptance of gifts.

Couns. Paul Fontaine and Paul Minhas voted against the recommendation, arguing that the mayor shouldn’t get the keep the gift.

Fontaine put forward an amendment to ask the mayor to donate $5,000 — a portion of the value of the airfare, hotel, and meals he received — to charity in order to send a message. The amendment was voted down.

Devins launched an investigation after a complaint filed by Fontaine and Minhas in February, alleging Johnstone breached the city’s ethics code when he attended the COP28 Local Climate Action Summit in Dubai from Dec. 1 to 6, 2023 by “knowingly accepting an extravagant gift from a third-party organization.”

Costs for the conference, travel and accommodations were paid for by the C40 Cities Climate Leadership Group, a global network of nearly 100 mayors working to fight climate change that is headed by U.S. philanthropist and former New York Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg.

In a summary report, issued in October, Devins said Johnstone was invited to, and attended the event in his capacity as mayor of New Westminster and the trip qualified as a gift and personal benefit, which councillors are prohibited from accepting.

There are exceptions laid out in the community charter, including if the gift or benefit was received “as an incident of the protocol or social obligations that normally accompany the responsibilities of the office.”

Devins made a distinction between Johnston’s attendance at the conference and the meals, travel and lodging associated with attending the conference.

While Johnstone’s attendance and conference fees qualified under the exemption, the meals, travel and accommodations did not.

“Unlike attendance at the conference, these gifts lack a connection to the respondent’s duties as a member of council and as mayor,” wrote Devins in the report.

She noted Johnstone flew business class, considered luxury travel. The report also said Johnstone stayed six nights at the five-star Waldorf Astoria hotel.

“The level of luxury suggests that attendance was more of a personal benefit than the fulfilment of a social obligation.”

While organizers are not lobbyists, they have a stated goal of influencing government policies, said Devins, adding even if those goals aligned with the city of New West’s stated objectives to fight climate change there is still a potential conflict of interest.

“Public perception, rightly or wrongly, may be that by accepting the trip, (Johnstone) could be more easily influenced to implement climate change initiatives if approached by C40 Cities,” she said.

However, Devins found Johnstone acted in good faith.

He had informed the acting mayor and city’s chief administrative officer of his intention to attend the conference, she noted. He did not hide his acceptance of the trip, but posted publicly about it on his personal Instagram account and blog.

Once Johnstone became aware of concerns from other councillors, he sought legal advice and was told that the exceptions would apply to his case. He also filed a disclosure statement after he returned from his trip on the advice of counsel, the report said.

In a statement to council, Johnstone said he agreed with the bulk of the findings, saying the report “provides a clear outline of the concern raised and fairly describes my actions.

“I fully support the recommendation made by the ethics commissioner.”

He suggested the commissioner conduct a workshop with council on the relevant sections in the community charter.

On Monday, Fontaine made an amendment, which was passed, that Johnstone receive “individualized” training from the ethics commissioner.

chchan@postmedia.com

Bookmark our website and support our journalism:Don’t miss the news you need to know — addVancouverSun.com andTheProvince.com to your bookmarks andsign up for our newsletters here.

You can also support our journalism by becoming a digital subscriber. With a subscription, you’ll get unlimited access to The Vancouver Sun online, as well as the ePaper and our app. Support us by subscribing today:The Vancouver Sun.