Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


ReadThe Diplomat,Know The Asia-Pacific

Regions
Topics
Blogs
More
Newsletter
Diplomat Brief
Weekly Newsletter
The Diplomat
China Power

China’s Growing Security Relationship With Qatar

Recent Features

The Red Séance: How Xi Jinping Is Soft-Burying the Deng Era
Politics

The Red Séance: How Xi Jinping Is Soft-Burying the Deng Era

Australian Watchdog Sounds Alarm on Illicit Financial Networks
Economy

Australian Watchdog Sounds Alarm on Illicit Financial Networks

China’s ‘Low-Human-Rights’ Advantage
Economy

China’s ‘Low-Human-Rights’ Advantage

What’s Really Changed in ‘New Uzbekistan’?
Videos

What’s Really Changed in ‘New Uzbekistan’?

Palau’s Climate Paradox in the Age of Trump 2.0
Environment

Palau’s Climate Paradox in the Age of Trump 2.0

How Antisemitism Took Hold in China 
Society

How Antisemitism Took Hold in China 

Unpacking the Local Impact of China’s Mega-Projects on Kyrgyzstan’s Regions
Economy

Unpacking the Local Impact of China’s Mega-Projects on Kyrgyzstan’s Regions

The Human Cost of the Largest Electoral Roll Revision Exercise in the World 
Society

The Human Cost of the Largest Electoral Roll Revision Exercise in the World 

Japan’s Grim Demographic Reality
Politics

Japan’s Grim Demographic Reality

Hong Kong’s Grenfell Tower Moment: When Grief Became Sedition
Society

Hong Kong’s Grenfell Tower Moment: When Grief Became Sedition

Why China Can’t Make Gwadar Work – Even After Billions Spent
Videos

Why China Can’t Make Gwadar Work – Even After Billions Spent

Hat Yai Flooding Catastrophe a Massive Blow to Thailand’s PM Anutin
Politics

Hat Yai Flooding Catastrophe a Massive Blow to Thailand’s PM Anutin

Subscribe for ads-free reading

China Power

China’s Growing Security Relationship With Qatar

Despite a chill between Qatar and other GCC members, China pushes to expand counterterrorism cooperation.

Samuel Ramani
November 16, 2017
China’s Growing Security Relationship With Qatar

China’s President Xi Jinping, right, and Qatar’s Emir Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al-Thani attend a signing ceremony at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing (Nov. 3, 2014).

Credit: AP Photo/Jason Lee, Pool
Subscribe for ads-free reading

On September 27, 2017, Qatari Major General Saad Bin Jassim Al Khulaifi and Chinese Minister of Public Security Guo Shengkun met at the INTERPOL summit in Beijing todiscuss counterterrorism cooperation. After the summit, both ministers signed a deal that formalized joint efforts between Doha and Beijing to curb funding to terrorist groups, and increased Qatar-China coordination against terrorism in the Middle East and the Asia-Pacific region.

Even though Doha-Beijing ties have strengthened considerably in recent years, the timing of China’s counterterrorism deal with Qatar is intriguing, as Beijing has recently expanded its security links with Qatar’s principal strategic rivals, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates (UAE). China’s decision to upgrade its security partnership with Qatar during a period of turmoil in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) can be explained by four strategic factors.

First, China views Qatar as a lucrative destination for military technology exports. China’s decision to sell military technology to Qatar was underscored by Beijing’s active participation in the 2014 Doha International Maritime Defense Exhibition, which resulted in Qatar’s purchases of $23.89 billion worth of weaponry from various defense partners. Even though Qatar did not purchase any of China’s missile systems, Chinese ambassador to Qatar Gao Youzhen openly called for an expansion of trade links between Beijing and Doha after the exhibition.

As China is a major importer of Qatari liquefied natural gas (LNG), Beijing is keen to improve its balance of trade with Doha through military technology sales. The United States’ recent efforts tochallenge Qatar’s position as a leading LNG exporter to China could convince Doha to acquiesce to Chinese pressure and deepen its military links with Beijing in hopes of out-competing American LNG.

In particular, Qatar could purchase stealth weaponry from China to neutralize the impact of Beijing’s March 2017 establishment of a drone manufacturing company in Saudi Arabia. As many countries have criticized Qatar’s shipments of weaponry to Islamist opposition forces in Libya and Syria, China’s non-interventionist approach to arms sales makes it an attractive security partner for Qatar during a period of unprecedented economic isolation.

Second, China possesses normative solidarity with Qatar in the security sphere, as Qatar is the Arab country that is most willing to negotiate with Islamist non-state actors without preconditions. As China believes that promoting all-inclusive diplomatic dialogue helps resolve international security crises, Beijing views Qatar as a highly useful partner in the Arab world.

The synergy between China and Qatar on diplomatic norms is evident in both countries’ responses to the crises in Palestine and Afghanistan. Since the election of Hamas in the Gaza Strip in 2006, China hasrefused to label the group as a terrorist organization and described Hamas as a legal entity that can legitimately represent the Palestinian people.

Qatar has embraced a similar position on Hamas. Since the mid-2000s, Qatar has insisted that its aid to the Palestinian organization is aimed at improving socioeconomic conditions in the Gaza Strip and that Doha does not endorse the violent objectives of Hamas’s military wing. China’s efforts to promote an all-inclusive settlement to the Israel-Palestine conflict will benefit greatly from Qatar’s assistance, as Qatar possesses considerable influence in the Palestinian territories.

The synergy between Qatar and China’s position on Palestine is mirrored by similarities between Beijing and Doha’s approaches to Afghanistan. In recent years, China has emerged as a leading advocate of a political settlement between the Afghan government and Taliban, and has held diplomatic dialogues with both major factions in the conflict.

Therefore, Chinese officials viewed the establishment of a Taliban office in Doha in 2013 as a positive development. China’s support for the legitimacy of Qatar’s Taliban office was underscored by the visit of Abbas Stanikzai, thehead of Doha’s Taliban office, to Beijing in August 2015. These actions explain China’s tacit support for Qatar’s decision to keep its Taliban office open, in spite of rising international pressure, and Beijing’s rejection of Saudi allegations that Qatar’s Taliban links are a form of state-sponsored terrorism.

Third, the Chinese government believes that enhancing counterterrorism cooperation with Qatar will cause Doha to prevent its Islamist allies from threatening the security of China’s Muslim majority Xinjiang province. Even though Qatar has not been directly linked toIslamic extremist elements in Xinjiang, Beijing is circumspect about Doha’s links with Sunni Islamist movements in Syria and Iraq, as Uyghur forces have fought alongside Qatar-aligned factions in these conflicts.

If Qatar can reassure China that its activities will not cause violent unrest among Xinjiang’s Uyghur population, China will be able to cooperate with Qatar on security issues with little risk of backlash. Even though China had previously expressed concerns about Qatar’s links to Islamist movements during the Arab Spring, Beijing’s non-interventionist position during the Arab uprisings ensures that China can tolerate Qatar’s Islamic extremist connections in the Arab world with a greater degree of impunity than other great powers.

Fourth, China’s strengthened security partnership with Qatar bolsters its case to act as a mediator in the rapidly intensifying GCC security crisis. China’s official commitment to supporting the cohesion of the GCC has been a central tenet of Beijing’s Middle East strategy since Wen Jiabao’s 2012 visit to Qatar.

While China’s normative desire to preserve the GCC’s cohesion has contributed to its cautious approach to the Qatar crisis, Beijing’s interest in a peaceful resolution to the Saudi Arabia-Qatar standoff is also motivated by economic considerations. As China’s One Belt, One Road vision includes the promotion of tradeacross the Arabian Peninsula, instability in the GCC is a highly concerning prospect for Beijing.

Even though China has insisted that regional actors should resolve the Saudi Arabia-Qatar dispute, Beijing could attempt to facilitate dialogue between the two countries by emphasizing their shared interest in economic development and highlighting the pernicious implications of a long-term GCC schism on regional stability. While the dynamics of the Qatar crisis are unlikely to change drastically as a result of Chinese mediation, Beijing’s close relations with Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Iran, and the UAE give it exceptional arbitration leverage in a region marred by extensive polarization.

While China’s economic and security links with Qatar remain significantly smaller than those with Saudi Arabia, Beijing’s decision to strengthen its security links with Doha can be explained by normative synergies, threat containment desires, and China’s growing interest in extra-regional diplomacy. The rapid intensification of strains within the GCC will severely test China’s neutral position on the Qatar crisis, but it is likely that Beijing will continue to balance between Qatar and Saudi Arabia in the months to come.

Samuel Ramani is a DPhil candidate in International Relations at St. Antony’s College, University of Oxford. He is also a journalist who contributes regularly to the Washington Post and Huffington Post. He can be followed onTwitter at samramani2 and onFacebook at Samuel Ramani.

Already have an account?.
You have reached the limit of2 free articles this month.

Get to the bottom of the story

Subscribe today and join thousands of diplomats, analysts, policy professionals and business readers who rely onThe Diplomat for expert Asia-Pacific coverage.

Get unlimited access to in-depth analysis you won't find anywhere else, from South China Sea tensions to ASEAN diplomacy to India-Pakistan relations. More than 5,000 articles a year.

  • Unlimited articles and expert analysis
  • Weekly newsletter with exclusive insights
  • 16-year archive of diplomatic coverage
  • Ad-free reading on all devices
  • Support independent journalism
Subscribe NowViewSubscriptionOptions

Already have an account?.

discuss counterterrorism cooperation. After the summit, both ministers signed a deal that formalized joint efforts between Doha and Beijing to curb funding to terrorist groups, and increased Qatar-China coordination against terrorism in the Middle East and the Asia-Pacific region.

Even though Doha-Beijing ties have strengthened considerably in recent years, the timing of China’s counterterrorism deal with Qatar is intriguing, as Beijing has recently expanded its security links with Qatar’s principal strategic rivals, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates (UAE). China’s decision to upgrade its security partnership with Qatar during a period of turmoil in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) can be explained by four strategic factors.

First, China views Qatar as a lucrative destination for military technology exports. China’s decision to sell military technology to Qatar was underscored by Beijing’s active participation in the 2014 Doha International Maritime Defense Exhibition, which resulted in Qatar’s purchases of $23.89 billion worth of weaponry from various defense partners. Even though Qatar did not purchase any of China’s missile systems, Chinese ambassador to Qatar Gao Youzhen openly called for an expansion of trade links between Beijing and Doha after the exhibition.

As China is a major importer of Qatari liquefied natural gas (LNG), Beijing is keen to improve its balance of trade with Doha through military technology sales. The United States’ recent efforts tochallenge Qatar’s position as a leading LNG exporter to China could convince Doha to acquiesce to Chinese pressure and deepen its military links with Beijing in hopes of out-competing American LNG.

In particular, Qatar could purchase stealth weaponry from China to neutralize the impact of Beijing’s March 2017 establishment of a drone manufacturing company in Saudi Arabia. As many countries have criticized Qatar’s shipments of weaponry to Islamist opposition forces in Libya and Syria, China’s non-interventionist approach to arms sales makes it an attractive security partner for Qatar during a period of unprecedented economic isolation.

Second, China possesses normative solidarity with Qatar in the security sphere, as Qatar is the Arab country that is most willing to negotiate with Islamist non-state actors without preconditions. As China believes that promoting all-inclusive diplomatic dialogue helps resolve international security crises, Beijing views Qatar as a highly useful partner in the Arab world.

The synergy between China and Qatar on diplomatic norms is evident in both countries’ responses to the crises in Palestine and Afghanistan. Since the election of Hamas in the Gaza Strip in 2006, China hasrefused to label the group as a terrorist organization and described Hamas as a legal entity that can legitimately represent the Palestinian people.

Qatar has embraced a similar position on Hamas. Since the mid-2000s, Qatar has insisted that its aid to the Palestinian organization is aimed at improving socioeconomic conditions in the Gaza Strip and that Doha does not endorse the violent objectives of Hamas’s military wing. China’s efforts to promote an all-inclusive settlement to the Israel-Palestine conflict will benefit greatly from Qatar’s assistance, as Qatar possesses considerable influence in the Palestinian territories.

The synergy between Qatar and China’s position on Palestine is mirrored by similarities between Beijing and Doha’s approaches to Afghanistan. In recent years, China has emerged as a leading advocate of a political settlement between the Afghan government and Taliban, and has held diplomatic dialogues with both major factions in the conflict.

Therefore, Chinese officials viewed the establishment of a Taliban office in Doha in 2013 as a positive development. China’s support for the legitimacy of Qatar’s Taliban office was underscored by the visit of Abbas Stanikzai, thehead of Doha’s Taliban office, to Beijing in August 2015. These actions explain China’s tacit support for Qatar’s decision to keep its Taliban office open, in spite of rising international pressure, and Beijing’s rejection of Saudi allegations that Qatar’s Taliban links are a form of state-sponsored terrorism.

Third, the Chinese government believes that enhancing counterterrorism cooperation with Qatar will cause Doha to prevent its Islamist allies from threatening the security of China’s Muslim majority Xinjiang province. Even though Qatar has not been directly linked toIslamic extremist elements in Xinjiang, Beijing is circumspect about Doha’s links with Sunni Islamist movements in Syria and Iraq, as Uyghur forces have fought alongside Qatar-aligned factions in these conflicts.

If Qatar can reassure China that its activities will not cause violent unrest among Xinjiang’s Uyghur population, China will be able to cooperate with Qatar on security issues with little risk of backlash. Even though China had previously expressed concerns about Qatar’s links to Islamist movements during the Arab Spring, Beijing’s non-interventionist position during the Arab uprisings ensures that China can tolerate Qatar’s Islamic extremist connections in the Arab world with a greater degree of impunity than other great powers.

Fourth, China’s strengthened security partnership with Qatar bolsters its case to act as a mediator in the rapidly intensifying GCC security crisis. China’s official commitment to supporting the cohesion of the GCC has been a central tenet of Beijing’s Middle East strategy since Wen Jiabao’s 2012 visit to Qatar.

While China’s normative desire to preserve the GCC’s cohesion has contributed to its cautious approach to the Qatar crisis, Beijing’s interest in a peaceful resolution to the Saudi Arabia-Qatar standoff is also motivated by economic considerations. As China’s One Belt, One Road vision includes the promotion of tradeacross the Arabian Peninsula, instability in the GCC is a highly concerning prospect for Beijing.

Even though China has insisted that regional actors should resolve the Saudi Arabia-Qatar dispute, Beijing could attempt to facilitate dialogue between the two countries by emphasizing their shared interest in economic development and highlighting the pernicious implications of a long-term GCC schism on regional stability. While the dynamics of the Qatar crisis are unlikely to change drastically as a result of Chinese mediation, Beijing’s close relations with Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Iran, and the UAE give it exceptional arbitration leverage in a region marred by extensive polarization.

While China’s economic and security links with Qatar remain significantly smaller than those with Saudi Arabia, Beijing’s decision to strengthen its security links with Doha can be explained by normative synergies, threat containment desires, and China’s growing interest in extra-regional diplomacy. The rapid intensification of strains within the GCC will severely test China’s neutral position on the Qatar crisis, but it is likely that Beijing will continue to balance between Qatar and Saudi Arabia in the months to come.

Samuel Ramani is a DPhil candidate in International Relations at St. Antony’s College, University of Oxford. He is also a journalist who contributes regularly to the Washington Post and Huffington Post. He can be followed onTwitter at samramani2 and onFacebook at Samuel Ramani.

Subscribe for ads-free reading
Advertisement

Latest Stories

National Cabinet Agrees to Sweeping Overhaul of Australia’s Gun Laws in Response to Bondi Massacre

National Cabinet Agrees to Sweeping Overhaul of Australia’s Gun Laws in Response to Bondi Massacre

Hong Kong Pro-Democracy Publisher Convicted of Sedition in Major Blow to Press Freedom

Hong Kong Pro-Democracy Publisher Convicted of Sedition in Major Blow to Press Freedom

Australia: Regionalism as a Nexus to Great Power Politics

Australia: Regionalism as a Nexus to Great Power Politics

China’s 2025 White Paper on Latin America Sets the Stage for Renewed Competition With the US

China’s 2025 White Paper on Latin America Sets the Stage for Renewed Competition With the US

Advertisement

Diplomat Brief

Weekly Newsletter

Get briefed on the story of the week, and developing stories to watch across the Asia-Pacific.

Get the Newsletter
Advertisement

Related

What the Gulf States Think of 'One Belt, One Road'

What the Gulf States Think of 'One Belt, One Road'

ByGiorgio Cafiero andDaniel Wagner
Saudi Arabia, UAE, Qatar, and Oman have mixed feelings about China's ambitious project.
China’s AI Push in the Persian Gulf Region

China’s AI Push in the Persian Gulf Region

ByBehrouz Ayaz
Chinese AI companies are changing the nature of China’s influence in Saudi Arabia, the UAE, and Qatar.

Can China Sustain Its Diplomatic Balance as Middle East Tensions Escalate?

Can China Sustain Its Diplomatic Balance as Middle East Tensions Escalate?

ByAparna Divya
China has long enjoyed cordial relations with Israel, Iran, and the Arab states. That balance is more and more difficult to sustain.
Will China Replace the US As Saudi Arabia’s Main Ally?

Will China Replace the US As Saudi Arabia’s Main Ally?

ByAparna Divya
Riyadh is trying to strike a balance between short-term economic benefits from China and its long-standing strategic alliance with the United States. 

Most Read

What’s Really Changed in ‘New Uzbekistan’?

What’s Really Changed in ‘New Uzbekistan’?

Since the 2016 death of the country’s first president, Islam Karimov, his successor, Shavkat Mirziyoyev, has strived to present himself as a reformer forging a “New Uzbekistan."
Japan’s Grim Demographic Reality

Japan’s Grim Demographic Reality

ByJames Pach
Can an anti-immigration turn really be compatible with a ‘Japan is Back’ narrative?

Why China Can’t Make Gwadar Work – Even After Billions Spent

Why China Can’t Make Gwadar Work – Even After Billions Spent

Gwadar port has often been touted as CPEC’s “crown jewel.” Yet almost two decades after the port began operations, business has been lackluster.
Malaysia’s Rare Earth Transition

Malaysia’s Rare Earth Transition

BySribala Subramanian
An early adopter hopes to make “super magnets” for electric cars by 2030.

Features

The Red Séance: How Xi Jinping Is Soft-Burying the Deng Era

The Red Séance: How Xi Jinping Is Soft-Burying the Deng Era

ByYoulun Nie
The CCP’s resurrection of Hu Yaobang is not about greenlighting new reforms. It is about undermining Deng Xiaoping’s place in history.
Australian Watchdog Sounds Alarm on Illicit Financial Networks

Australian Watchdog Sounds Alarm on Illicit Financial Networks

ByAdam Rousselle andBrett Erickson
The promise of frictionless money has matured into something far more consequential: a liquidity system powerful enough to reorder economies, and elusive enough to escape the laws meant to govern it.

China’s ‘Low-Human-Rights’ Advantage

China’s ‘Low-Human-Rights’ Advantage

ByQin Hui andPerry Link
People in the West say they must avoid a new Cold War without realizing that they are already in one – and China is winning.
Palau’s Climate Paradox in the Age of Trump 2.0

Palau’s Climate Paradox in the Age of Trump 2.0

ByRohan Kocharekar
The same U.S. administration Palau relies on for its security is openly dismissing the climate crisis that threatens Palau’s very existence.

Latest Stories

National Cabinet Agrees to Sweeping Overhaul of Australia’s Gun Laws in Response to Bondi Massacre

National Cabinet Agrees to Sweeping Overhaul of Australia’s Gun Laws in Response to Bondi Massacre

ByMichelle Grattan
After the attack on Australia’s Jewish community, the government is undertaking the biggest overhaul of national gun laws since 1996. Critics say it's a deflection from the real issue: antisemitism.
Hong Kong Pro-Democracy Publisher Convicted of Sedition in Major Blow to Press Freedom

Hong Kong Pro-Democracy Publisher Convicted of Sedition in Major Blow to Press Freedom

ByYao-Tai Li
Jimmy Lai and his Apple Daily once symbolized Hong Kong’s free press. His conviction under the National Security Law is the death knell for that democratic ideal.

Australia: Regionalism as a Nexus to Great Power Politics

Australia: Regionalism as a Nexus to Great Power Politics

ByEdward Sing Yue Chan andGuangyi Pan
The alliance with the U.S. remains central to Canberra’s strategy, but it is also attempting to construct more independent, regionally-led security initiatives.
China’s 2025 White Paper on Latin America Sets the Stage for Renewed Competition With the US

China’s 2025 White Paper on Latin America Sets the Stage for Renewed Competition With the US

ByR. Evan Ellis
The new document declared China’s intention to expand its influence on all fronts, even as the U.S. is turning its focus to the Western Hemisphere.

[8]ページ先頭

©2009-2025 Movatter.jp