Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


SCP Foundation

Secure, Contain, Protect

SCP-2098 / Discussion
Started by:Wikidot
Date:04 Jun 2014 23:22
Number of posts: 33
rss iconRSS:New posts
This is the discussion related to the wiki pageSCP-2098.
page 1 of 212next »
MulciberMulciber04 Jun 2014 23:24

I am aware that posting this to the mainlist means summary judgment of finished work.

Enjoy.

Unfold byMulciberMulciber,04 Jun 2014 23:24
(account deleted)04 Jun 2014 23:46

Cool.

My only nitpick: I don't think this is really a Keter. It hasn't shown an active desire to destroy human life, just edit it. In my mind, this is definitely a Euclid.

(Also, period missing at "vectors" end of the "red" segment.)

Unfold by(account deleted),04 Jun 2014 23:46
MulciberMulciber04 Jun 2014 23:49

Fixed the punctuation. Thank you.

As for the object class, I was trying to experiment with something that wouldn't destroy humanity, but rather fundamentally change it in a small way. The whole species is potentially compromised, so I went with Keter. We'll see how that pans out. Thanks for the feedback.

Unfold byMulciberMulciber,04 Jun 2014 23:49
(account deleted)04 Jun 2014 23:52

No problem, 's what I do.

Unfold by(account deleted),04 Jun 2014 23:52
FalconisFalconis09 Jun 2014 03:39

A Skip doesn't have to have an active desire to destroy humanity to be K-Class. I argue for K-Class status simply because this changes the fundamental way humans function in society.

Unfold byFalconisFalconis,09 Jun 2014 03:39
EskobarEskobar05 Jun 2014 00:04

Really fucking like this. This appeals greatly to my sensibilities. Also, I think the Keter classification is fully justified, given the amount of time, energy, manpower, and resources that have to be dedicated to containing this, combined with the fact that we have no idea what this thing is actuallydoing to people in the long term.

Unfold byEskobarEskobar,05 Jun 2014 00:04
Communism will winCommunism will win05 Jun 2014 01:07

I can't help but think that there should be a St. Simon's Day pilgrimage to the Islamic Union of East Samothrace.


if your reading this your gay

Unfold byCommunism will winCommunism will win,05 Jun 2014 01:07
ThekilleraxThekillerax05 Jun 2014 03:39

I thought it was a Republic.


And if the whole world is crashing down… fall through space out of mind with me.

Unfold byThekilleraxThekillerax,05 Jun 2014 03:39
Agent PhoebeAgent Phoebe05 Jun 2014 04:16

What are you guys talking about? There's no such place.

Unfold byAgent PhoebeAgent Phoebe,05 Jun 2014 04:16
MulciberMulciber22 Jun 2014 06:25

I'm going to consider this praise from Caesar. :)

Unfold byMulciberMulciber,22 Jun 2014 06:25
ThekilleraxThekillerax05 Jun 2014 03:41

There was a "PSC" in the Containment Procedures, but other than that, this is damn good. +1.


And if the whole world is crashing down… fall through space out of mind with me.

Unfold byThekilleraxThekillerax,05 Jun 2014 03:41
MulciberMulciber05 Jun 2014 03:48

PSC can stand for "Prime Susceptibility Communities" in the context of the article. Thank you for taking a look.

Unfold byMulciberMulciber,05 Jun 2014 03:48
ThekilleraxThekillerax05 Jun 2014 06:24

If that's what it stands for, then why is there a -2098 following it?


And if the whole world is crashing down… fall through space out of mind with me.

Unfold byThekilleraxThekillerax,05 Jun 2014 06:24
dierubikdiedierubikdie06 Jun 2014 20:36

I think it implies that in the author's headcanon, "Prime Susceptibility Communities" is standard Foundation lingo for things like this. For example, there could be instances of PSC-3427 or what have you.

That's how I understand it, anyway.

Unfold bydierubikdiedierubikdie,06 Jun 2014 20:36
ThekilleraxThekillerax08 Jun 2014 03:52

Makes sense. Thanks for the explanation.


And if the whole world is crashing down… fall through space out of mind with me.

Unfold byThekilleraxThekillerax,08 Jun 2014 03:52
Maximillius IMaximillius I05 Jun 2014 04:01

I really enjoyed this. Have an upvote.

Unfold byMaximillius IMaximillius I,05 Jun 2014 04:01
A Random DayA Random Day05 Jun 2014 11:30

I love it. Just think of the holiday that never ends.

It's like that one Jimmy Neutron episode where every day is his birthday. Only nobody, even him, would notice or care.

+1

Unfold byA Random DayA Random Day,05 Jun 2014 11:30
StevenThePotatoStevenThePotato05 Jun 2014 17:46

This is a really good read. Although not dangerous, it still manages to be a palatable Keter.

+1

Unfold byStevenThePotatoStevenThePotato,05 Jun 2014 17:46
(account deleted)05 Jun 2014 19:41

Good work. A very unique concept for an article, thoroughly documented and well-considered in terms of the ramifications of the skip. The supplemental materials are also given enough context to fit nicely within the overall narrative.

Interestingly, the comments so far have questioned the Keter classification and whether or not this is actually dangerous. When I read this, one of my favorite features of the article was its recognition of how much societal disruption would result from the entire population celebrating this anomalous holiday. If everyone in the world celebrates this holiday, and enough people become Red vectors, you have a sizable contingent of humanity that now believes it's Saint Simon. Assuming that the displacement of culturally-significant events worldwide wasn't disruptive enough in unforeseen ways.

I also found the concept of intergenerational memory fascinating. It's a nice little add-on to the article, but I think it would be interesting to see something like that explored in a little more depth, either here or elsewhere.

Overall, solid job.

Unfold by(account deleted),05 Jun 2014 19:41
TL333sTL333s05 Jun 2014 21:58

I adore articles where the skip can be summed up as something really unique, and "virulent holiday" fits that bill and how. I cannot overstate my love for this skip. It's got a semi-classic feel (really more of an early series II, oddly), and you didn't go overboard with the Keter while still making a good case for the classification. The writing is solid, the idea is sound, and…

The Red-Vectors. Oh my god, a day becomes Saint Simon's Daybecause Simon says.

Also, it's "Catechesis". Also also, I love all the event names, but I think "Saint Simon's Day Bisected Youth Vigil" is my favorite. Bravo!

Last edited on05 Jun 2014 21:58byTL333s Show more
Unfold byTL333sTL333s,05 Jun 2014 21:58
MulciberMulciber05 Jun 2014 22:15

Fixed "catechesis".

D'oh.

But I'm glad you enjoyed it. Thank you for your feedback.

Unfold byMulciberMulciber,05 Jun 2014 22:15
page 1 of 212next »
/forum/t-869676/scp-2098#post-
Powered byWikidot.com
Unless otherwise stated, the content of this page is licensed underCreative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 License
Click here to edit contents of this page.
Click here to toggle editing of individual sections of the page (if possible). Watch headings for an "edit" link when available.
Append content without editing the whole page source.
Check out how this page has evolved in the past.
If you want to discuss contents of this page - this is the easiest way to do it.
View and manage file attachments for this page.
A few useful tools to manage this Site.
See pages that link to and include this page.
Change the name (also URL address, possibly the category) of the page.
View wiki source for this page without editing.
View/set parent page (used for creating breadcrumbs and structured layout).
Notify administrators if there is objectionable content in this page.
Something does not work as expected? Find out what you can do.
General Wikidot.com documentation and help section.
Wikidot.com Terms of Service - what you can, what you should not etc.
Wikidot.com Privacy Policy.

[8]ページ先頭

©2009-2025 Movatter.jp