Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


[RFC Home] [TEXT|PDF|HTML] [Tracker] [IPR] [Info page]

DRAFT STANDARD
Network Working Group                                      R. WatermanRequest for Comments: 2613                         Allot Networks Inc.Category: Standards Track                                    B. Lahaye                                                           Xylan Corp.                                                          D. Romascanu                                                   Lucent Technologies                                                         S. Waldbusser                                                                   INS                                                             June 1999Remote Network Monitoring MIB Extensions for Switched NetworksVersion 1.0Status of this Memo   This document specifies an Internet standards track protocol for the   Internet community, and requests discussion and suggestions for   improvements.  Please refer to the current edition of the "Internet   Official Protocol Standards" (STD 1) for the standardization state   and status of this protocol.  Distribution of this memo is unlimited.Copyright Notice   Copyright (C) The Internet Society (1999).  All Rights Reserved.Abstract   This memo defines a portion of the Management Information Base (MIB)   for use with network management protocols in TCP/IP-based internets.   In particular, it defines objects for managing remote network   monitoring devices in switched networks environments.Table of Contents   1 The Network Management Framework                             2   2 Overview                                                     3     2.1 Remote Network Management Goals                          3     2.2 Switched Networks Monitoring                             5     2.3 Mechanisms for Monitoring Switched Networks              5         2.3.1 DataSource Objects                                 6         2.3.2 Copy Port                                          7         2.3.3 VLAN Monitoring                                    7     2.4  Relationship to Other MIBs                              8          2.4.1 The RMON and RMON 2 MIBs                          8          2.4.2 The Interfaces Group MIB                          8          2.4.3 The Entity MIB                                    8          2.4.4 The Bridge MIB                                    9Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                     [Page 1]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999     2.5 Relationship with IEEE 802.1 Standards                   9   3 SMON/RMON Groups                                             9     3.1 SMON ProbeCapabilities                                   9     3.2 smonVlanStats                                           10     3.3 smonPrioStats                                           10     3.4 dataSourceCaps                                          10     3.5 portCopyConfig                                          11   4 Control of Remote Network Monitoring Devices                12   5 Definitions                                                 13   6 References                                                  39   7 Intellectual Property                                       41   8 Security Considerations                                     41   9 Authors' Addresses                                          44   A Full Copyright Statement                                    441. The Network Management Framework   The SNMP Management Framework presently consists of five major   components:   - An overall architecture, described inRFC 2571 [1].   - Mechanisms for describing and naming objects and events for the     purpose of management. The first version of this Structure of     Management Information (SMI) is called SMIv1 and described in STD     16,RFC 1155 [2], STD 16,RFC 1212 [3] andRFC 1215 [4]. The second     version, called SMIv2, is described in STD 58,RFC 2578 [5],RFC2579 [6] andRFC 2580 [7].   - Message protocols for transferring management information. The     first version of the SNMP message protocol is called SNMPv1 and     described in STD 15,RFC 1157 [8]. A second version of the SNMP     message protocol, which is not an Internet standards track     protocol, is called SNMPv2c and described inRFC 1901 [9] andRFC1906 [10].  The third version of the message protocol is called     SNMPv3 and described inRFC 1906 [10],RFC 2572 [11] andRFC 2574     [12].   - Protocol operations for accessing management information. The first     set of protocol operations and associated PDU formats is described     in STD 15,RFC 1157 [8]. A second set of protocol operations and     associated PDU formats is described inRFC 1905 [13].   - A set of fundamental applications described inRFC 2573 [14] and     the view-based access control mechanism described inRFC 2575 [15].Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                     [Page 2]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999   Managed objects are accessed via a virtual information store, termed   the Management Information Base or MIB.  Objects in the MIB are   defined using the mechanisms defined in the SMI.   This memo specifies a MIB module that is compliant to the SMIv2. A   MIB conforming to the SMIv1 can be produced through the appropriate   translations. The resulting translated MIB must be semantically   equivalent, except where objects or events are omitted because no   information in SMIv2 will be converted into textual descriptions in   SMIv1 during the translation process. However, this loss of machine   readable information is not considered to change the semantics of the   MIB.   The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT",   "SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED","MAY", and "OPTIONAL" in this   document are to be interpreted as described inRFC 2119 [24].2. Overview   This document continues the architecture created in the RMON MIB [17]   by providing RMON analysis for switched networks (SMON).   Remote network monitoring devices, often called monitors or probes,   are instruments that exist for the purpose of managing a network.   Often these remote probes are stand-alone devices and devote   significant internal resources for the sole purpose of managing a   network.  An organization may employ many of these devices, one per   network segment, to manage its internet. In addition, these devices   may be used for a network management service provider to access a   client network, often geographically remote.   The objects defined in this document are intended as an interface   between an RMON agent and an RMON management application and are not   intended for direct manipulation by humans.  While some users may   tolerate the direct display of some of these objects, few will   tolerate the complexity of manually manipulating objects to   accomplish row creation.  These functions should be handled by the   management application.2.1 Remote Network Management Goals   o Offline Operation     There are sometimes conditions when a management station will not     be in constant contact with its remote monitoring devices.  This is     sometimes by design in an attempt to lower communications costsWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                     [Page 3]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999     (especially when communicating over a WAN or dialup link), or by     accident as network failures affect the communications between the     management station and the probe.     For this reason, this MIB allows a probe to be configured to     perform diagnostics and to collect statistics continuously, even     when communication with the management station may not be possible     or efficient.  The probe may then attempt to notify the management     station when an exceptional condition occurs.  Thus, even in     circumstances where communication between management station and     probe is not continuous, fault, performance, and configuration     information may be continuously accumulated and communicated to the     management station conveniently and efficiently.   o Proactive Monitoring     Given the resources available on the monitor, it is potentially     helpful for it continuously to run diagnostics and to log network     performance.  The monitor is always available at the onset of any     failure.  It can notify the management station of the failure and     can store historical statistical information about the failure.     This historical information can be played back by the management     station in an attempt to perform further diagnosis into the cause     of the problem.   o Problem Detection and Reporting     The monitor can be configured to recognize conditions, most notably     error conditions, and continuously to check for them.  When one of     these conditions occurs, the event may be logged, and management     stations may be notified in a number of ways.   o Value Added Data     Because a remote monitoring device represents a network resource     dedicated exclusively to network management functions, and because     it is located directly on the monitored portion of the network, the     remote network monitoring device has the opportunity to add     significant value to the data it collects.  For instance, by     highlighting those hosts on the network that generate the most     traffic or errors, the probe can give the management station     precisely the information it needs to solve a class of problems.   o Multiple Managers     An organization may have multiple management stations for different     units of the organization, for different functions (e.g.     engineering and operations), and in an attempt to provide disasterWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                     [Page 4]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999     recovery.  Because environments with multiple management stations     are common, the remote network monitoring device has to deal with     more than one management station, potentially using its resources     concurrently.2.2 Switched Networks Monitoring   This document addresses issues related to applying "Remote   Technology" to Switch Networks. Switches today differ from standard   shared media protocols:   1)   Data is not, in general, broadcast.  This MAY be caused by the        switch architecture  or by the connection-oriented nature of the        data. This means, therefore, that monitoring non-broadcast        traffic needs to be considered.   2)   Monitoring the multiple entry and exit points from a switching        device requires a vast amount of resources - memory and CPU, and        aggregation of the data in logical packets of information,        determined by the application needs.   3)   Switching incorporates logical segmentation such as Virtual LANs        (VLANs).   4)   Switching incorporates packet prioritization.   5)   Data across the switch fabric can be in the form of cells. Like        RMON, SMON is only concerned with the monitoring of packets.   Differences such as these make monitoring difficult.  The current   RMON and RMON 2 standards do not provide for things that are unique   to switches or switched environments.   In order to overcome the limitations of the existing standards, new   monitoring mechanisms have been implemented by vendors of switching   equipment. All these monitoring strategies are currently proprietary   in nature.   This document provides the framework to include different switching   strategies and allow for monitoring operations consistent with the   RMON framework. This MIB is limited to monitoring and control   operations aimed at providing monitoring data for RMON probes.2.3 Mechanisms for Monitoring Switched Networks   The following mechanisms are used by SMON devices, for the purpose of   monitoring switched networks.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                     [Page 5]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 19992.3.1 DataSource Objects   The RMON MIB standard [17] defines data source objects which point to   MIB-II interfaces, identified by instances of ifIndex objects.   The SMON MIB extends this concept and allows for other types of   objects to be defined as data sources for RMON and/or SMON data.   Three forms of dataSources are described:      ifIndex.<I>         Traditional RMON dataSources. Called 'port-based' for         ifType.<I> not equal to 'propVirtual(53)'. <I> is the ifIndex         value (see [22]).      smonVlanDataSource.<V>         A dataSource of this form refers to a 'Packet-based VLAN' and         is called a 'VLAN-based' dataSource. <V> is the VLAN ID as         defined by the IEEE 802.1Q standard [19]. The value is between         1 and 4094 inclusive, and it represents an 802.1Q VLAN-ID with         global scope within a given bridged domain, as defined by [19].      entPhysicalEntry.<N>         A dataSource of this form refers to a physical entity within         the agent and is called an 'entity-based' dataSource. <N> is         the value of the entPhysicalIndex in the entPhysicalTable (see         [18]).   In addition to these new dataSource types, SMON introduces a new   group called dataSourceCapsTable to aid an NMS in discovering   dataSource identity and attributes.   The extended data source mechanism supported by the SMON MIB allows   for the use of external collection points, similar to the one defined   and supported by the RMON and RMON 2 MIBs, as well as internal   collection points (e.g. propVirtual ifTable entry, entPhysicalEntry).   The latter reflects either data sources which MAY be the result of   aggregation (e.g. switch-wide) or internal channels of physical   entities, which have the capability of being monitored by an SMON   probe.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                     [Page 6]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 19992.3.2 Copy Port   In order to make the switching devices support RMON statistics, many   vendors have implemented a port copy feature, allowing traffic to be   replicated from switch port to switch port. Several levels of   configuration are possible:      1) 1 source port to 1 destination port      2) N source ports to 1 destination port      3) N source ports to M destination ports   The SMON standard presents a standard MIB interface which allows for   the control of this function.   Note that this function can apply to devices that have no other SMON   or RMON functionality than  copy port. The agent of such a device   would support only the portCopyCaps and the portCopyConfig MIB   groups, out of the whole SMON MIB.  Switch vendors are encouraged to   implement this subset of the SMON MIB, as it would allow for standard   port copy configuration from the same NMS application that does RMON   or SMON.   Port copy may cause congestion problems on the SMON device. This   situation is more likely occur when copying from a port of higher   speed to a port of lower speed or copy from multiple port to a single   port.   Particular implementations MAY chose to build protection mechanisms   that would prevent creation of new port copy links when the capacity   of the destination port is exceeded. The MIB allows for   implementations to (if supported) instrument a destination drop count   on port copy to provide NMS applications a sense of the quality of   data presented at the destination port.2.3.3 VLAN Monitoring   VLAN monitoring can be accomplished by using a VLAN-based dataSource   and/or by configuring smonVlanIdStats and/or smonPrioStats   collections.  These functions allow VLAN-ID or user priority   distributions per dataSource. VLAN monitoring provides a high-level   view of total VLAN usages and relative non-unicast traffic usage as   well as a profile of VLAN priority as defined in the 3-bit   user_priority field.   NOTE: priority statistics reflect what was parsed from the packet,   not what priority, if any, was necessarily granted by the switch.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                     [Page 7]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 19992.4  Relationship to Other MIBs2.4.1 The RMON and RMON 2 MIBs   The Remote Monitoring MIB (RMON) [17] provides several management   functions that MAY be directly or indirectly applicable to switched   networks.   The port copy mechanisms defined by the SMON MIB allow for the   destination ports to become a data source for any RMON statistics.   However, an NMS application SHOULD check whether it is in the device   capability (portCopyCap) to filter errors from a source to a   destination port and whether this capability is enabled, in order to   provide a correct interpretation of the copied port traffic.   RMON host and matrix group statistics entries MAY be aggregated by   use of the extended dataSource capability defined in SMON. RMON 2   groups are similarly extended through the use of SMON's dataSource   definition.   RMON also defines a simple thresholding monitoring mechanism, event-   logging and event-notification for any MIB instance; SMON utilizes   the alarms and events groups from RMON without modification.  These   groups SHOULD be implemented on SMON devices if a simple thresholding   mechanism is desired.   The RMON 2 usrHistory group (user-defined history collection) SHOULD   be implemented by an SMON device if a history collection mechanism is   desired for smonStats entries.2.4.2 The Interfaces Group MIB   The SMON MIB utilizes the propVirtual(53) ifType defined in the   Interfaces Group MIB [22] to provide SMON and RMON with new   dataSources such as VLANs and internal monitoring points. NMS   applications SHOULD consult the SMON dataSource capabilities group   (dataSourceCap) for a description of these virtual interfaces.2.4.3 The Entity MIB   The SMON MIB does not mandate Entity MIB [18] support, but allows for   physical entities, as defined by this MIB to be defined as SMON data   sources. For such cases, the support for the entPhysicalTable is   required.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                     [Page 8]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 19992.4.4 The Bridge MIB   One of the important indicators for measuring the effectiveness of a   switching device is the ratio between the number of forwarded frames   and the number of dropped frames at the switch port.   It is out of the scope of this MIB to provide instrumentation   information relative to switching devices. However, such indication   may be part of other MIB modules.   For instance the Bridge MIB [23] provides such MIB objects, for the   802.1 bridges (dot1dTpPortInFrames, dot1dTpPortInDiscards) and   switches managed according to the 802.1 bridge model MAY provide this   information.2.5 Relationship with IEEE 802.1 Standards   The SMON MIB provides simple statistics per VLAN and priority levels.   Those two categories of statistics are important to managers of   switched networks.  Interoperability for those features is ensured by   the use of the IEEE 802.1 p/Q standards ([19], [20]) defined by the   IEEE 802.1 WG. Interoperability from the SMON MIB point of view is   ensured by referencing the IEEE definition of VLANs and priority   levels for the SMON statistics.3. SMON Groups3.1 SMON ProbeCapabilities   The SMON probeCapabilities BITS object covers the following four   capabilities.      - smonVlanStats(0)        The probe supports the smonVlanStats object group.      - smonPrioStats(1)        The probe supports the smonPrioStats object group.      - dataSource(2)        The probe supports the dataSourceCaps object group.      - portCopy(4)        The probe supports the portCopyConfig object group.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                     [Page 9]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 19993.2 smonVlanStats   The smonVlanStats MIB group includes the control and statistics   objects related to 802.1Q VLANs. Specific statistics per 802.1Q   virtual LAN are supported. The group provides a high level view of   total VLAN usage, and relative non-unicast traffic usage.   It is an implementation-specific matter as to how the agent   determines the proper default-VLAN for untagged or priority-tagged   frames.3.3 smonPrioStats   The smonPrioStatsTable provides a distribution based on the   user_priority field in the VLAN header.   Note that this table merely reports priority as encoded in VLAN   headers, not the priority (if any) given the frame for actual   switching purposes.3.4 dataSourceCaps   The dataSourceCaps MIB group identifies all supported data sources on   an SMON device. An NMS MAY use this table to discover the RMON and   Copy Port attributes of each data source.   Upon restart of the agent, the dataSourceTable, ifTable and   entPhysicalTable are initialized for the available data sources. The   agent MAY modify these tables as data sources become known or are   removed (e.g. hot swap of interfaces, chassis cards or the discovery   of VLAN usage). It is understood that dataSources representing VLANs   may not always be instantiated immediately upon restart, but rather   as VLAN usage is detected by the agent.  The agent SHOULD attempt to   create dataSource and interface entries for all dataSources as soon   as possible.   For each dataSourceCapsEntry representing a VLAN or entPhysicalEntry,   the agent MUST create an associated ifEntry with a ifType value of   associated dataSourceCapsIfIndex object.   The rationale of the above derives from the fact that according to   [16] and [17] an RMON dataSource MUST be associated with an ifEntry.   Specifically, the dataSourceCapsTable allows for an agent to map   Entity MIB physical entities (e.g., switch backplanes) and entire   VLANs to ifEntries with ifType "propVirtual(53)". This ifEntry values   will be used as the actual values in RMON control table dataSource   objects.  This allows for physical entities and VLANs to be treated   as RMON data sources, and RMON functions to be applied to this typeWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 10]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999   of data sources.3.5 portCopyConfig   The portCopyConfig MIB group includes the objects defined for the   control of the port copy functionality in a device.   The standard does not place a limit on the mode in which this copy   function may be used:   Mode 1 --  1:1 Copy      Single dataSource copied to a single destination dataSource.      Agent MAY limit configuration based on ifTypes, ifSpeeds, half-      duplex/full-duplex, or agent resources.  In this mode the single      instance of the portCopyDestDropEvents object refers to dropped      frames on the portCopyDest interface.   Mode 2 --  N:1 Copy      Multiple dataSources copied to a single destination dataSource.      Agent MAY limit configuration based on ifTypes, ifSpeeds, half-      duplex/full-duplex, portCopyDest over-subscription, or agent      resources.  In this mode all N instances of the      portCopyDestDropEvents object SHOULD contain the same value, and      refer to dropped frames on the portCopyDest interface.   Mode 3 --  N:M Copy      Multiple dataSources copied to multiple destination dataSources.      Agent MAY limit configuration based on ifTypes, ifSpeeds, half-      duplex/full-duplex, portCopyDest over-subscription, or agent      resources.  Since portCopyDestDropEvents is kept per destination      port, all instances of the portCopyDestDropEvents object      associated with (indexed by) a given portCopyDest SHOULD have the      same value (i.e. replicated or aliased for each instance      associated with a given portCopyDest).   The rows do not have an OwnerString, since multiple rows MAY be part   of the same portCopy operation. The agent is expected to activate or   deactivate entries one at a time, based on the rowStatus for the   given row.  This can lead to unpredictable results in Modes 2 and 3   in applications utilizing the portCopy target traffic, if multiple   PDUs are used to fully configure the operation.  It is RECOMMENDED   that an entire portCopy operation be configured in one SetRequest PDU   if possible.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 11]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999   The portCopyDest object MAY NOT reference an interface associated   with a packet-based VLAN (smonVlanDataSource.<V>), but this   dataSource type MAY be used as a portCopySource.4.  Control of Remote Network Monitoring Devices   Due to the complex nature of the available functions in these   devices, the functions often need user configuration.  In many cases,   the function requires parameters to be set up for a data collection   operation.  The operation can proceed only after these parameters are   fully set up.   Many functional groups in this MIB have one or more tables in which   to set up control parameters, and one or more data tables in which to   place the results of the operation.  The control tables are typically   read/write in nature, while the data tables are typically read-only.   Because the parameters in the control table often describe resulting   data in the data table, many of the parameters can be modified only   when the control entry is not active.  Thus, the method for modifying   these parameters is to de-activate the entry, perform the SNMP Set   operations to modify the entry, and then re-activate the entry.   Deleting the control entry causes the deletion of any associated data   entries, which also gives a convenient method for reclaiming the   resources used by the associated data.   Some objects in this MIB provide a mechanism to execute an action on   the remote monitoring device.  These objects MAY execute an action as   a result of a change in the state of the object.  For those objects   in this MIB, a request to set an object to the same value as it   currently holds would thus cause no action to occur.   To facilitate control by multiple managers, resources have to be   shared among the managers.  These resources are typically the memory   and computation resources that a function requires.   The control mechanisms defined and used in this MIB are the same as   those defined in the RMON MIB [17], for control functionality and   interaction with multiple managers.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 12]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 19995. Definitions   SMON-MIB DEFINITIONS ::= BEGIN   IMPORTS        MODULE-IDENTITY, OBJECT-TYPE, Counter32,        Integer32, Counter64                FROM SNMPv2-SMI        RowStatus, TEXTUAL-CONVENTION                FROM SNMPv2-TC        rmon, OwnerString                FROM RMON-MIB        LastCreateTime, DataSource, rmonConformance, probeConfig                FROM RMON2-MIB        InterfaceIndex                FROM IF-MIB        MODULE-COMPLIANCE, OBJECT-GROUP                FROM SNMPv2-CONF;   switchRMON MODULE-IDENTITY        LAST-UPDATED "9812160000Z"        ORGANIZATION "IETF RMON MIB Working Group"        CONTACT-INFO        "IETF RMONMIB WG Mailing list: rmonmib@cisco.com                Rich Waterman                Allot Networks Inc.                Tel:  +1-408-559-0253                Email: rich@allot.com                Bill Lahaye                Xylan Corp.                Tel: +1-800-995-2612                Email:  lahaye@ctron.com                Dan Romascanu                Lucent Technologies                Tel:  +972-3-645-8414                Email: dromasca@lucent.com                Steven Waldbusser                International Network Services (INS)                Tel: +1-650-318-1251                Email: waldbusser@ins.com"        DESCRIPTION                "The MIB module for managing remote monitoring device                 implementations for Switched Networks"Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 13]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999         -- revision history        REVISION    "9812160000Z"     -- 16 Dec 1998 midemight        DESCRIPTION "Initial Version, published asRFC 2613."        ::= { rmon 22 }   smonMIBObjects OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { switchRMON 1 }   dataSourceCaps          OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= {smonMIBObjects 1}   smonStats               OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= {smonMIBObjects 2}   portCopyConfig          OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= {smonMIBObjects 3}   smonRegistrationPoints  OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= {smonMIBObjects 4}   -- Textual Conventions   --   SmonDataSource ::= TEXTUAL-CONVENTION    STATUS        current    DESCRIPTION        "Identifies the source of the data that the associated function         is configured to analyze. This Textual Convention         extends the DataSource Textual Convention defined by RMON 2         to the following data source types:         - ifIndex.<I>         DataSources of this traditional form are called 'port-based',         but only if ifType.<I> is not equal to 'propVirtual(53)'.         - smonVlanDataSource.<V>         A dataSource of this form refers to a 'Packet-based VLAN'         and is called a 'VLAN-based' dataSource. <V> is the VLAN         ID as defined by the IEEE 802.1Q standard [19]. The         value is between 1 and 4094 inclusive, and it represents         an 802.1Q VLAN-ID with global scope within a given         bridged domain, as defined by [19].        - entPhysicalEntry.<N>         A dataSource of this form refers to a physical entity within         the agent (e.g. entPhysicalClass = backplane(4)) and is called         an 'entity-based' dataSource."    SYNTAX      OBJECT IDENTIFIER   -- The smonCapabilities object describes SMON agent capabilities.   smonCapabilities OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX BITS {      smonVlanStats(0),Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 14]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999      smonPrioStats(1),      dataSource(2),      smonUnusedBit(3),      portCopy(4)      }    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS current    DESCRIPTION        "An indication of the SMON MIB groups supported         by this agent."    ::= { probeConfig  15 }   -- dataSourceCaps MIB group - defines SMON data source and port   -- copy capabilities for devices supporting SMON.   -- A NMS application will check this MIB group and retrieve   -- information about the SMON capabilities of the device before   -- applying SMON control operations to the device.   -- dataSourceCapsTable: defines capabilities of RMON data sources   dataSourceCapsTable OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF DataSourceCapsEntry    MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "This table describes RMON data sources and port copy        capabilities. An NMS MAY use this table to discover the        identity and attributes of the data sources on a given agent        implementation. Similar to the probeCapabilities object,        actual row-creation operations will succeed or fail based on        the resources available and parameter values used in each        row-creation operation.        Upon restart of the RMON agent, the dataSourceTable, ifTable,        and perhaps entPhysicalTable are initialized for the available        dataSources.        For each dataSourceCapsEntry representing a VLAN or        entPhysicalEntry the agent MUST create an associated ifEntry        with a ifType value of 'propVirtual(53)'. This ifEntry will be        used as the actual value in RMON control table dataSource        objects. The assigned ifIndex value is copied into the        associated dataSourceCapsIfIndex object.        It is understood that dataSources representing VLANs may not        always be instantiated immediately upon restart, but rather asWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 15]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999        VLAN usage is detected by the agent. The agent SHOULD attempt        to create dataSource and interface entries for all dataSources        as soon as possible."   ::= { dataSourceCaps 1 }   dataSourceCapsEntry  OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      DataSourceCapsEntry    MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "Entries per data source containing descriptions of data         source and port copy capabilities. This table is populated by         the SMON agent with one entry for each supported data         source."   INDEX { IMPLIED dataSourceCapsObject }   ::= { dataSourceCapsTable 1 }   DataSourceCapsEntry ::= SEQUENCE {        dataSourceCapsObject                SmonDataSource,        dataSourceRmonCaps                BITS,        dataSourceCopyCaps                BITS,        dataSourceCapsIfIndex                InterfaceIndex        }   dataSourceCapsObject OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      SmonDataSource    MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "Defines an object that can be a SMON data source or a          source or a destination for a port copy operation."    ::= { dataSourceCapsEntry 1  }   dataSourceRmonCaps OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX BITS {           countErrFrames(0),           countAllGoodFrames(1),           countAnyRmonTables(2),           babyGiantsCountAsGood(3)           }    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS current    DESCRIPTIONWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 16]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999        " General attributes of the specified dataSource. Note that        these are static attributes, which SHOULD NOT be adjusted        because of current resources or configuration.      - countErrFrames(0)          The agent sets this bit for the dataSource if errored frames          received on this dataSource can actually be monitored by the          agent The agent clears this bit if any errored frames are          not visible to the RMON data collector.      - countAllGoodFrames(1)          The agent sets this bit for the dataSource if all good          frames received on this dataSource can actually be monitored          by the agent. The agent clears this bit if any good frames          are not visible for RMON collection, e.g., the dataSource is          a non-promiscuous interface or an internal switch interface          which may not receive frames which were switched in hardware          or dropped by the bridge forwarding function.      - countAnyRmonTables(2)          The agent sets this bit if this dataSource can actually be          used in any of the implemented RMON tables, resources          notwithstanding. The agent clears this bit if this          dataSourceCapsEntry is present simply to identify a          dataSource that may only be used as portCopySource and/or a          portCopyDest, but not the source of an actual RMON data          collection.      - babyGiantsCountAsGood(3)          The agent sets this bit if it can distinguish, for counting          purposes, between true giant frames and frames that exceed          Ethernet maximum frame size 1518 due to VLAN tagging ('baby          giants'). Specifically, this BIT means that frames up to          1522 octets are counted as good.          Agents not capable of detecting 'baby giants' will clear          this bit and will view all frames less than or equal to 1518          octets as 'good frames' and all frames larger than 1518          octets as 'bad frames' for the purpose of counting in the          smonVlanIdStats and smonPrioStats tables.          Agents capable of detecting 'baby giants' SHALL consider          them as 'good frames' for the purpose of counting in the          smonVlanIdStats and smonPrioStats tables."    ::= { dataSourceCapsEntry 2  }   dataSourceCopyCaps OBJECT-TYPEWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 17]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999    SYNTAX BITS {        copySourcePort(0),        copyDestPort(1),        copySrcTxTraffic(2),        copySrcRxTraffic(3),        countDestDropEvents(4),        copyErrFrames(5),        copyUnalteredFrames(6),        copyAllGoodFrames(7)        }    MAX-ACCESS   read-only    STATUS       current    DESCRIPTION        "PortCopy function capabilities of the specified dataSource.    Note that these are static capabilities, which SHOULD NOT be    adjusted because of current resources or configuration.      - copySourcePort(0)          The agent sets this bit if this dataSource is capable of          acting as a source of a portCopy operation. The agent clears          this bit otherwise.      - copyDestPort(1)          The agent sets this bit if this dataSource is capable of          acting as a destination of a portCopy operation. The agent          clears this bit otherwise.     - copySrcTxTraffic(2)          If the copySourcePort bit is set:                The agent sets this bit if this dataSource is capable of              copying frames transmitted out this portCopy source. The              agent clears this bit otherwise. This function is needed              to support full-duplex ports.           Else:               this bit SHOULD be cleared.      - copySrcRxTraffic(3)          If the copySourcePort bit is set:            The agent sets this bit if this dataSource is capable of            copying frames received on this portCopy source. The agent            clears this bit otherwise. This function is needed to            support full-duplex ports.          Else:            this bit SHOULD be cleared.      - countDestDropEvents(4)          If the copyDestPort bit is set:              The agent sets this bit if it is capable of incrementingWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 18]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999              portCopyDestDropEvents, when this dataSource is the              target of a portCopy operation and a frame destined to              this dataSource is dropped (for RMON counting purposes).          Else:              this BIT SHOULD be cleared.      - copyErrFrames(5)          If the copySourcePort bit is set:              The agent sets this bit if it is capable of copying all              errored frames from this portCopy source-port, for              errored frames received on this dataSource.          Else:              this BIT SHOULD be cleared.      - copyUnalteredFrames(6)          If the copySourcePort bit is set:              The agent sets the copyUnalteredFrames bit If it is              capable of copying all frames from this portCopy              source-port without alteration in any way;          Else:              this bit SHOULD be cleared.      - copyAllGoodFrames(7)          If the copySourcePort bit is set:              The agent sets this bit for the dataSource if all good              frames received on this dataSource are normally capable              of being copied by the agent. The agent clears this bit              if any good frames are not visible for the RMON portCopy              operation, e.g., the dataSource is a non-promiscuous              interface or an internal switch interface which may not              receive frames which were switched in hardware or              dropped by the bridge forwarding function.           Else:              this bit SHOULD be cleared."    ::= { dataSourceCapsEntry 3  }   dataSourceCapsIfIndex OBJECT-TYPE   SYNTAX       InterfaceIndex   MAX-ACCESS   read-only   STATUS       current   DESCRIPTION        "This object contains the ifIndex value of the ifEntry         associated with this smonDataSource. The agent MUST create         'propVirtual' ifEntries for each dataSourceCapsEntry of type         VLAN or entPhysicalEntry."    ::= { dataSourceCapsEntry 4  }Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 19]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999   -- The SMON Statistics MIB Group   -- aggregated statistics for IEEE 802.1Q VLAN environments.   -- VLAN statistics can be gathered by configuring smonVlanIdStats   -- and/or smonPrioStats collections. These functions allow a   -- VLAN-ID or user priority distributions per dataSource,   -- auto-populated by the agent in a manner similar to the RMON   -- hostTable.   -- Only good frames are counted in the tables described in this   -- section.   -- VLAN ID Stats   -- smonVlanStatsControlTable allows configuration of VLAN-ID   -- collections.   smonVlanStatsControlTable OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF SmonVlanStatsControlEntry    MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "Controls the setup of VLAN statistics tables.         The statistics collected represent a distribution based on         the IEEE 802.1Q VLAN-ID (VID), for each good frame attributed         to the data source for the collection."    ::= { smonStats 1 }   smonVlanStatsControlEntry OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      SmonVlanStatsControlEntry    MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "A conceptual row in the smonVlanStatsControlTable."    INDEX { smonVlanStatsControlIndex }    ::= { smonVlanStatsControlTable 1 }   SmonVlanStatsControlEntry ::= SEQUENCE {    smonVlanStatsControlIndex                 Integer32,    smonVlanStatsControlDataSource           DataSource,    smonVlanStatsControlCreateTime       LastCreateTime,    smonVlanStatsControlOwner               OwnerString,    smonVlanStatsControlStatus                RowStatus   }Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 20]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999   smonVlanStatsControlIndex OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      Integer32 (1..65535)    MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "A unique arbitrary index for this smonVlanStatsControlEntry."    ::= { smonVlanStatsControlEntry 1 }   smonVlanStatsControlDataSource OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      DataSource    MAX-ACCESS  read-create    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "The source of data for this set of VLAN statistics.        This object MAY NOT be modified if the associated        smonVlanStatsControlStatus object is equal to active(1)."    ::= { smonVlanStatsControlEntry 2 }   smonVlanStatsControlCreateTime OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     LastCreateTime    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The value of sysUpTime when this control entry was last        activated. This object allows to a management station to        detect deletion and recreation cycles between polls."    ::= { smonVlanStatsControlEntry 3 }   smonVlanStatsControlOwner OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      OwnerString    MAX-ACCESS  read-create    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "Administratively assigned named of the owner of this entry.        It usually defines the entity that created this entry and is        therefore using the resources assigned to it, though there is        no enforcement mechanism, nor assurance that rows created are        ever used."    ::= { smonVlanStatsControlEntry 4 }   smonVlanStatsControlStatus OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      RowStatus    MAX-ACCESS  read-create    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "The status of this row.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 21]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999        An entry MAY NOT exist in the active state unless all        objects in the entry have an appropriate value.        If this object is not equal to active(1), all associated        entries in the smonVlanIdStatsTable SHALL be deleted."    ::= { smonVlanStatsControlEntry 5 }   -- The VLAN Statistics Table   smonVlanIdStatsTable  OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF SmonVlanIdStatsEntry    MAX-ACCESS not-accessible    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "Contains the VLAN statistics data.         The statistics collected represent a distribution based         on the IEEE 802.1Q VLAN-ID (VID), for each good frame         attributed to the data source for the collection.         This function applies the same rules for attributing frames         to VLAN-based collections. RMON VLAN statistics are collected         after the Ingress Rules defined insection 3.13 of the VLAN         Specification [20] are applied.         It is possible that entries in this table will be         garbage-collected, based on agent resources, and VLAN         configuration. Agents are encouraged to support all 4094         index values and not garbage collect this table."   ::= { smonStats 2 }   smonVlanIdStatsEntry  OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     SmonVlanIdStatsEntry    MAX-ACCESS not-accessible    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "A conceptual row in smonVlanIdStatsTable."    INDEX { smonVlanStatsControlIndex, smonVlanIdStatsId }    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsTable 1 }   SmonVlanIdStatsEntry ::= SEQUENCE {    smonVlanIdStatsId                             Integer32,    smonVlanIdStatsTotalPkts                      Counter32,    smonVlanIdStatsTotalOverflowPkts              Counter32,    smonVlanIdStatsTotalHCPkts                    Counter64,    smonVlanIdStatsTotalOctets                    Counter32,    smonVlanIdStatsTotalOverflowOctets            Counter32,    smonVlanIdStatsTotalHCOctets                  Counter64,    smonVlanIdStatsNUcastPkts                     Counter32,Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 22]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999    smonVlanIdStatsNUcastOverflowPkts             Counter32,    smonVlanIdStatsNUcastHCPkts                   Counter64,    smonVlanIdStatsNUcastOctets                   Counter32,    smonVlanIdStatsNUcastOverflowOctets           Counter32,    smonVlanIdStatsNUcastHCOctets                 Counter64,    smonVlanIdStatsCreateTime                     LastCreateTime   }   smonVlanIdStatsId OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Integer32 (1..4094)    MAX-ACCESS not-accessible    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The unique identifier of the VLAN monitored for         this specific statistics collection.        Tagged packets match the VID for the range between 1 and 4094.        An external RMON probe MAY detect VID=0 on an Inter Switch        Link, in which case the packet belongs to a VLAN determined by        the PVID of the ingress port. The VLAN to which such a packet        belongs can be determined only by a RMON probe internal to the        switch."    REFERENCE        "Draft Standard for Virtual Bridged Local Area Networks,          P802.1Q/D10, chapter 3.13"    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 1 }   smonVlanIdStatsTotalPkts OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "packets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of packets counted on this VLAN."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 2 }   smonVlanIdStatsTotalOverflowPkts OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "packets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The number of times the associated smonVlanIdStatsTotalPkts         counter has overflowed."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 3 }   smonVlanIdStatsTotalHCPkts OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter64Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 23]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999    UNITS "packets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of packets counted on this VLAN."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 4 }   smonVlanIdStatsTotalOctets OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "octets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of octets counted on this VLAN."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 5 }   smonVlanIdStatsTotalOverflowOctets OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "octets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The number of times the associated smonVlanIdStatsTotalOctets         counter has overflowed."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 6 }   smonVlanIdStatsTotalHCOctets OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter64    UNITS "octets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of octets counted on this VLAN."   ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 7 }   smonVlanIdStatsNUcastPkts OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "packets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of non-unicast packets counted on this         VLAN."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 8 }   smonVlanIdStatsNUcastOverflowPkts OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "packets"Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 24]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The number of times the associated smonVlanIdStatsNUcastPkts         counter has overflowed."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 9 }   smonVlanIdStatsNUcastHCPkts OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter64    UNITS "packets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of non-unicast packets counted on         this VLAN."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 10 }   smonVlanIdStatsNUcastOctets OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "octets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of non-unicast octets counted on         this VLAN."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 11 }   smonVlanIdStatsNUcastOverflowOctets OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "octets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The number of times the associated         smonVlanIdStatsNUcastOctets counter has overflowed."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 12 }   smonVlanIdStatsNUcastHCOctets OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter64    UNITS "octets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of Non-unicast octets counted on         this VLAN."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 13 }   smonVlanIdStatsCreateTime OBJECT-TYPEWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 25]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999    SYNTAX     LastCreateTime    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The value of sysUpTime when this entry was last        activated. This object allows to a management station to        detect deletion and recreation cycles between polls."    ::= { smonVlanIdStatsEntry 14 }   -- smonPrioStatsControlTable   smonPrioStatsControlTable OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF SmonPrioStatsControlEntry    MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "Controls the setup of priority statistics tables.         The smonPrioStatsControlTable allows configuration of         collections based on the value of the 3-bit user priority         field encoded in the Tag Control Information (TCI) field         according to [19],[20].         Note that this table merely reports priority as encoded in         the VLAN headers, not the priority (if any) given to the         frame for the actual switching purposes."    ::= { smonStats 3 }   smonPrioStatsControlEntry OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      SmonPrioStatsControlEntry    MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "A conceptual row in the smonPrioStatsControlTable."    INDEX { smonPrioStatsControlIndex }    ::= { smonPrioStatsControlTable 1 }   SmonPrioStatsControlEntry ::= SEQUENCE {    smonPrioStatsControlIndex                 Integer32,    smonPrioStatsControlDataSource           DataSource,    smonPrioStatsControlCreateTime       LastCreateTime,    smonPrioStatsControlOwner               OwnerString,    smonPrioStatsControlStatus                RowStatus   }   smonPrioStatsControlIndex OBJECT-TYPEWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 26]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999    SYNTAX      Integer32 (1..65535)    MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "A unique arbitrary index for this smonPrioStatsControlEntry."    ::= { smonPrioStatsControlEntry 1 }   smonPrioStatsControlDataSource OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      DataSource    MAX-ACCESS  read-create    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "The source of data for this set of VLAN statistics.        This object MAY NOT be modified if the associated        smonPrioStatsControlStatus object is equal to active(1)."    ::= { smonPrioStatsControlEntry 2 }   smonPrioStatsControlCreateTime OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     LastCreateTime    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION         "The value of sysUpTime when this entry was created.        This object allows to a management station to        detect deletion and recreation cycles between polls."    ::= { smonPrioStatsControlEntry 3 }   smonPrioStatsControlOwner OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      OwnerString    MAX-ACCESS  read-create    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION         "Administratively assigned named of the owner of this entry.        It usually defines the entity that created this entry and is        therefore using the resources assigned to it, though there is        no enforcement mechanism, nor assurance that rows created are        ever used."    ::= { smonPrioStatsControlEntry 4 }   smonPrioStatsControlStatus OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      RowStatus    MAX-ACCESS  read-create    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "The status of this row.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 27]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999        An entry MAY NOT exist in the active state unless all        objects in the entry have an appropriate value.        If this object is not equal to active(1), all associated        entries in the smonPrioStatsTable SHALL be deleted."    ::= { smonPrioStatsControlEntry 5 }   -- The Priority Statistics Table   smonPrioStatsTable  OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     SEQUENCE OF SmonPrioStatsEntry    MAX-ACCESS not-accessible    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "Contains the priority statistics. The collections are based         on the value of the 3-bit user priority field encoded in the         Tag Control Information (TCI) field according to [19], [20].         Note that this table merely reports priority as encoded in         the VLAN headers, not the priority (if any) given to the         frame for the actual switching purposes.         No garbage collection is designed for this table, as there         always are at most eight rows per statistical set, and the         low memory requirements do not justify the implementation of         such a mechanism."    ::= { smonStats 4 }   smonPrioStatsEntry  OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     SmonPrioStatsEntry    MAX-ACCESS not-accessible    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "A conceptual row in smonPrioStatsTable."    INDEX { smonPrioStatsControlIndex, smonPrioStatsId }    ::= { smonPrioStatsTable 1 }   SmonPrioStatsEntry ::= SEQUENCE {    smonPrioStatsId                       Integer32,    smonPrioStatsPkts                     Counter32,    smonPrioStatsOverflowPkts             Counter32,    smonPrioStatsHCPkts                   Counter64,    smonPrioStatsOctets                   Counter32,    smonPrioStatsOverflowOctets           Counter32,    smonPrioStatsHCOctets                 Counter64   }   smonPrioStatsId OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Integer32 (0..7)Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 28]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999    MAX-ACCESS not-accessible    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The unique identifier of the priority level monitored for         this specific statistics collection."    REFERENCE        " Draft Standard for Virtual Bridged Local Area Networks,          P802.1Q/D10, chapter 4.3.2.1"    ::= { smonPrioStatsEntry 1 }   smonPrioStatsPkts OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "packets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of packets counted on         this priority level."    ::= { smonPrioStatsEntry 2 }   smonPrioStatsOverflowPkts OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "packets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The number of times the associated smonPrioStatsPkts         counter has overflowed."    ::= { smonPrioStatsEntry 3 }   smonPrioStatsHCPkts OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter64    UNITS "packets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of packets counted on         this priority level."    ::= { smonPrioStatsEntry 4 }   smonPrioStatsOctets OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "octets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of octets counted on         this priority level."Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 29]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999    ::= { smonPrioStatsEntry 5 }   smonPrioStatsOverflowOctets OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter32    UNITS "octets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The number of times the associated smonPrioStatsOctets         counter has overflowed."    ::= { smonPrioStatsEntry 6 }   smonPrioStatsHCOctets OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX     Counter64    UNITS "octets"    MAX-ACCESS read-only    STATUS     current    DESCRIPTION        "The total number of octets counted on         this priority level."    ::= { smonPrioStatsEntry 7 }   portCopyTable  OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      SEQUENCE OF PortCopyEntry    MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        " Port Copy provides the ability to copy all frames from a         specified source to specified destination within a switch.         Source and destinations MUST be ifEntries, as defined by [22].         One to one, one to many, many to one and many to many source to         destination relationships may be configured.         Applicable counters on the destination will increment for all         packets transiting the port, be it by normal bridging/switching         or due to packet copy.         Note that this table manages no RMON data collection by itself,         and an agent may possibly implement no RMON objects except         objects related to the port copy operation defined by the         portCopyCompliance conformance macro. That allows for a switch         with no other embedded RMON capability to perform port copy         operations to a destination port at which a different external         RMON probe is connected.         One to one, many to one and one to many source to destination         relationships may be configured.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 30]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999         Each row that exists in this table defines such a         relationship. By disabling a row in this table the port copy         relationship no longer exists.         The number of entries and the types of port copies (1-1,         many-1, 1-many) are implementation specific and could         possibly be dynamic due to changing resource availability.         In order to configure a source to destination portCopy         relationship, both source and destination interfaces MUST be         present as an ifEntry in the ifTable and their respective         ifAdminStatus and ifOperStatus values MUST be equal to         'up(1)'. If the value of any of those two objects changes         after the portCopyEntry is activated, portCopyStatus will         transition to 'notReady(3)'.         The capability of an interface to be source or destination of         a port copy operation is described by the 'copySourcePort(0)'         and 'copyDestPort(1)' bits in dataSourceCopyCaps. Those bits         SHOULD be appropriately set by the agent, in order to allow         for a portCopyEntry to be created.         Applicable counters on the destination will increment for all         packets transmitted, be it by normal bridging/switching or         due to packet copy."   ::= { portCopyConfig 1 }   portCopyEntry  OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX      PortCopyEntry    MAX-ACCESS  not-accessible    STATUS      current    DESCRIPTION        "Describes a particular port copy entry."   INDEX { portCopySource, portCopyDest }   ::= { portCopyTable 1 }   PortCopyEntry ::= SEQUENCE {        portCopySource                InterfaceIndex,        portCopyDest                InterfaceIndex,        portCopyDestDropEvents                Counter32,        portCopyDirection                INTEGER,        portCopyStatus                RowStatus        }Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 31]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999   portCopySource OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX       InterfaceIndex    MAX-ACCESS   not-accessible    STATUS       current    DESCRIPTION        "The ifIndex of the source which will have all packets         redirected to the destination as defined by portCopyDest."    ::= { portCopyEntry 1 }   portCopyDest OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX       InterfaceIndex    MAX-ACCESS   not-accessible    STATUS       current    DESCRIPTION        "Defines the ifIndex destination for the copy operation."    ::= { portCopyEntry 2 }   portCopyDestDropEvents OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX       Counter32    UNITS "events"    MAX-ACCESS   read-only    STATUS       current    DESCRIPTION         "The total number of events in which port copy packets were         dropped by the switch at the destination port due to lack of         resources.         Note that this number is not necessarily the number of         packets dropped; it is just the number of times this         condition has been detected.         A single dropped event counter is maintained for each         portCopyDest. Thus all instances associated with a given         portCopyDest will have the same portCopyDestDropEvents         value."     ::= { portCopyEntry 3 }   portCopyDirection OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX       INTEGER {        copyRxOnly(1),        copyTxOnly(2),        copyBoth(3)    }    MAX-ACCESS   read-create    STATUS       current    DESCRIPTION        "This object affects the way traffic is copied from a switch          source port, for the indicated port copy operation.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 32]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999         If this object has the value 'copyRxOnly(1)', then only         traffic received on the indicated source port will be copied         to the indicated destination port.         If this object has the value 'copyTxOnly(2)', then only         traffic transmitted out the indicated source port will be         copied to the indicated destination port.         If this object has the value 'copyBoth(3)', then all traffic         received or transmitted on the indicated source port will be         copied to the indicated destination port.         The creation and deletion of instances of this object is         controlled by the portCopyRowStatus object. Note that there         is no guarantee that changes in the value of this object         performed while the associated portCopyRowStatus object is         equal to active will not cause traffic discontinuities in the         packet stream."   DEFVAL { copyBoth }   ::= { portCopyEntry 4 }   portCopyStatus OBJECT-TYPE    SYNTAX       RowStatus    MAX-ACCESS   read-create    STATUS       current    DESCRIPTION        "Defines the status of the port copy entry.         In order to configure a source to destination portCopy         relationship, both source and destination interfaces MUST be         present as an ifEntry in the ifTable and their respective         ifAdminStatus and ifOperStatus values MUST be equal to         'up(1)'. If the value of any of those two objects changes         after the portCopyEntry is activated, portCopyStatus will         transition to 'notReady(3)'.         The capability of an interface to be source or destination of         a port copy operation is described by the 'copySourcePort(0)'         and 'copyDestPort(1)' bits in dataSourceCopyCaps. Those bits         SHOULD be appropriately set by the agent, in order to allow         for a portCopyEntry to be created."    ::= { portCopyEntry 5 }   -- smonRegistrationPoints   -- defines a set of OIDs for registration purposes of entities   -- supported by the SMON MIB.   smonVlanDataSourceWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 33]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999         OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { smonRegistrationPoints 1}   -- Defined for use as an SmonDataSource. A single integer parameter   -- is appended to the end of this OID when actually encountered in   -- the dataSourceCapsTable, which represents a positive, non-zero   -- VLAN identifier value.   -- Conformance Macros   smonMIBCompliances      OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rmonConformance 3}   smonMIBGroups           OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rmonConformance 4}   smonMIBCompliance       MODULE-COMPLIANCE        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Describes the requirements for full conformance with the SMON        MIB"        MODULE -- this module        MANDATORY-GROUPS                 {dataSourceCapsGroup,                                          smonVlanStatsGroup,                                          smonPrioStatsGroup,                                          portCopyConfigGroup,                                          smonInformationGroup}        GROUP         smonHcTo100mbGroup        DESCRIPTION        "This group of VLAN statistics counter are mandatory only for         those network interfaces for which the corresponding ifSpeed         can be greater than 10MB/sec and less than or equal to         100MB/sec."        GROUP         smonHc100mbPlusGroup        DESCRIPTION        "This group of VLAN statistics counters are mandatory only for         those network interfaces for which the corresponding ifSpeed         can be more than 100MB/sec. This group of VLAN statistics is         also mandatory for smonDataSources of type VLAN or         entPhysicalEntry."   ::= { smonMIBCompliances 1 }   smonMIBVlanStatsCompliance        MODULE-COMPLIANCE        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Describes the requirements for conformance with the SMON MIB         with support for VLAN Statistics. Mandatory for a SMON probe         in environment where IEEE 802.1Q bridging is implemented."        MODULE -- this moduleWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 34]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999        MANDATORY-GROUPS                 {dataSourceCapsGroup,                                          smonVlanStatsGroup,                                          smonInformationGroup}        GROUP         hcVlanTo100mbGroup        DESCRIPTION        "This group of VLAN statistics counter are mandatory only         for those network interfaces for which the corresponding         ifSpeed can be up to and including 100MB/sec."        GROUP         hcVlan100mbPlusGroup        DESCRIPTION        "This group of VLAN statistics counters are mandatory only for         those network interfaces for which the corresponding ifSpeed         is greater than 100MB/sec. This group of VLAN statistics is         also mandatory for smonDataSources of type VLAN or         entPhysicalEntry."   ::= { smonMIBCompliances 2 }   smonMIBPrioStatsCompliance         MODULE-COMPLIANCE        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Describes the requirements for conformance with the SMON MIB         with support for priority level Statistics. Mandatory for a         SMON probe in a environment where IEEE 802.1p         priority-switching is implemented."        MODULE -- this module        MANDATORY-GROUPS                 {dataSourceCapsGroup,                                          smonPrioStatsGroup,                                          smonInformationGroup}        GROUP         hcPrioTo100mbGroup        DESCRIPTION        "This group of VLAN priority statistics counters are mandatory         only for those network interfaces for which the corresponding         ifSpeed can be up to and including 100MB/sec."        GROUP         hcPrio100mbPlusGroup        DESCRIPTION        "This group is mandatory only for those network         interfaces for which the corresponding ifSpeed is greater         than 100MB/sec. This group of VLAN priority         statistics is also mandatory for smonDataSources of type         VLAN or entPhysicalEntry"   ::= { smonMIBCompliances 3 }   portCopyCompliance                 MODULE-COMPLIANCEWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 35]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Describes the requirements for conformance with the port copy         functionality defined by the SMON MIB"        MODULE  -- this module        MANDATORY-GROUPS                 {dataSourceCapsGroup,                                          portCopyConfigGroup,                                          smonInformationGroup}         ::= { smonMIBCompliances 4}   dataSourceCapsGroup     OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS          { dataSourceRmonCaps,                          dataSourceCopyCaps,                          dataSourceCapsIfIndex}        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Defines the objects that describe the capabilities of RMON         data sources."   ::= {smonMIBGroups 1 }   smonVlanStatsGroup      OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS         { smonVlanStatsControlDataSource,                         smonVlanStatsControlCreateTime,                         smonVlanStatsControlOwner,                         smonVlanStatsControlStatus,                         smonVlanIdStatsTotalPkts,                         smonVlanIdStatsTotalOctets,                         smonVlanIdStatsNUcastPkts,                         smonVlanIdStatsCreateTime}        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Defines the switch monitoring specific statistics - per VLAN         Id on interfaces of 10MB or less."   ::= { smonMIBGroups 2 }   smonPrioStatsGroup      OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS         { smonPrioStatsControlDataSource,                         smonPrioStatsControlCreateTime,                         smonPrioStatsControlOwner,                         smonPrioStatsControlStatus,                         smonPrioStatsPkts,                         smonPrioStatsOctets}        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Defines the switch monitoring specific statistics - per VLAN         Id on interface."Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 36]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999   ::= { smonMIBGroups 3 }   smonHcTo100mbGroup        OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS         { smonVlanIdStatsTotalOverflowOctets,                         smonVlanIdStatsTotalHCOctets,                         smonPrioStatsOverflowOctets,                         smonPrioStatsHCOctets}        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Defines the additional high capacity statistics needed to be         kept on interfaces with ifSpeed greater than 10MB/sec and         less than or equal to 100MB/sec."   ::= { smonMIBGroups 4 }   smonHc100mbPlusGroup      OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS         { smonVlanIdStatsTotalOverflowPkts,                         smonVlanIdStatsTotalHCPkts,                         smonVlanIdStatsTotalOverflowOctets,                         smonVlanIdStatsTotalHCOctets,                         smonVlanIdStatsNUcastOverflowPkts,                         smonVlanIdStatsNUcastHCPkts,                         smonPrioStatsOverflowPkts,                         smonPrioStatsHCPkts,                         smonPrioStatsOverflowOctets,                         smonPrioStatsHCOctets}        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Defines the additional high capacity statistics needed to be         kept on interfaces with ifSpeed of more than 100MB/sec. These         statistics MUST also be kept on smonDataSources of type VLAN         or entPhysicalEntry."   ::= { smonMIBGroups 5 }   hcVlanTo100mbGroup        OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS         { smonVlanIdStatsTotalOverflowOctets,                         smonVlanIdStatsTotalHCOctets}        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Defines the additional high capacity VLAN statistics         needed to be kept on interfaces with ifSpeed greater than         10MB/sec and less than or equal to 100MB/sec."   ::= { smonMIBGroups 6 }   hcVlan100mbPlusGroup      OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS         { smonVlanIdStatsTotalOverflowPkts,                         smonVlanIdStatsTotalHCPkts,                         smonVlanIdStatsTotalOverflowOctets,                         smonVlanIdStatsTotalHCOctets,Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 37]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999                         smonVlanIdStatsNUcastOverflowPkts,                         smonVlanIdStatsNUcastHCPkts}        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Defines the additional high capacity VLAN statistics         needed to be kept on interfaces with ifSpeed of more than         100MB/sec.  These statistics MUST also be kept on         smonDataSources of type VLAN or entPhysicalEntry."   ::= { smonMIBGroups 7 }   hcPrioTo100mbGroup        OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS         { smonPrioStatsOverflowOctets,                         smonPrioStatsHCOctets }        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Defines the additional high capacity VLAN priority         statistics needed to be kept on interfaces with         ifSpeed of greater than 10MB/sec and less than or equal         to 100MB/sec."   ::= { smonMIBGroups 8 }   hcPrio100mbPlusGroup      OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS         { smonPrioStatsOverflowPkts,                         smonPrioStatsHCPkts,                         smonPrioStatsOverflowOctets,                         smonPrioStatsHCOctets}        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Defines the additional high capacity VLAN priority         statistics needed to be kept on interfaces with         ifSpeed of greater than 100MB/sec. These statistics MUST         also be kept on smonDataSources of type VLAN or         entPhysicalEntry."   ::= { smonMIBGroups 9 }   smonVlanStatsExtGroup   OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS         {smonVlanIdStatsNUcastOctets,                         smonVlanIdStatsNUcastOverflowOctets,                         smonVlanIdStatsNUcastHCOctets}        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Defines the switch monitoring specific statistics for systems         capable of counting non-unicast octets for a given dataSource         (as described in the dataSourceRmonCaps object)."   ::= { smonMIBGroups 10 }   smonInformationGroup    OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS         { smonCapabilities }Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 38]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "An indication of the SMON capabilities supported by this        agent."   ::= { smonMIBGroups 11 }   portCopyConfigGroup     OBJECT-GROUP        OBJECTS         { portCopyDestDropEvents,                          portCopyDirection,                          portCopyStatus                        }        STATUS      current        DESCRIPTION        "Defines the control objects for copy port operations."   ::= { smonMIBGroups 12 }   END6.  References   [1]  Harrington, D., Presuhn, R., and B. Wijnen, "An Architecture for        Describing SNMP Management Frameworks",RFC 2571, April 1999.   [2]  Rose, M. and K. McCloghrie, "Structure and Identification of        Management Information for TCP/IP-based Internets", STD 16,RFC1155, May 1990.   [3]  Rose, M. and K. McCloghrie, "Concise MIB Definitions", STD 16,RFC 1212, March 1991.   [4]  Rose, M., "A Convention for Defining Traps for use with the        SNMP",RFC 1215, March 1991.   [5]  McCloghrie, K., Perkins, D., Schoenwaelder, J., Case, J., Rose,        M. and S. Waldbusser, "Structure of Management Information        Version 2 (SMIv2)", STD 58,RFC 2578, April 1999.   [6]  McCloghrie, K., Perkins, D., Schoenwaelder, J., Case, J., Rose,        M. and S. Waldbusser, "Textual Conventions for SMIv2", STD 58,RFC 2579, April 1999.   [7]  McCloghrie, K., Perkins, D., Schoenwaelder, J., Case, J., Rose,        M. and S. Waldbusser, "Conformance Statements for SMIv2", STD        58,RFC 2580, April 1999.   [8]  Case, J., Fedor, M., Schoffstall, M. and J. Davin, "Simple        Network Management Protocol", STD 15,RFC 1157, May 1990.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 39]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999   [9]  SNMPv2 Working Group, Case, J., McCloghrie, K., Rose, M. and S.        Waldbusser, "Introduction to Community-based SNMPv2",RFC 1901,        January 1996.   [10] SNMPv2 Working Group, Case, J., McCloghrie, K., Rose, M. and S.        Waldbusser, "Transport Mappings for Version 2 of the Simple        Network Management Protocol (SNMPv2)",RFC 1906, January 1996.   [11] Case, J., Harrington D., Presuhn R., and B. Wijnen, "Message        Processing and Dispatching for the Simple Network Management        Protocol (SNMP)",RFC 2572, April 1999.   [12] Blumenthal, U., and B. Wijnen, "User-based Security Model for        Version 3 of the Simple Network Management Protocol (SNMPv3)",RFC 2574, April 1999.   [13] SNMPv2 Working Group, Case, J., McCloghrie, K., Rose, M. and S.        Waldbusser, "Protocol Operations for Version 2 of the Simple        Network Management Protocol (SNMPv2)",RFC 1905, January 1996.   [14] Levi, D., Meyer, P., and B. Stewart, "SNMP Applications",RFC2573, April 1999.   [15] Wijnen, B., Presuhn, R., and K. McCloghrie, "View-based Access        Control Model for the Simple Network Management Protocol        (SNMP)",RFC 2575, April 1999.   [16] Waldbusser, S., "Remote Network Monitoring Management        Information Base Version 2 using SMIv2",RFC 2021, January 1997.   [17] Waldbusser, S., "Remote Network Monitoring Management        Information Base",RFC 1757, February 1995.   [18] McCloghrie, K. and A. Bierman, "Entity MIB",RFC 2037, October        1996.   [19] ISO/IEC Final CD 15802-3, ANSI/IEEE Std 802.1D-1998 "Information        technology - Telecommunications and information exchange between        systems - Local and metropolitan area networks - Common        specifications - Part 3: Media Access Control (MAC) Bridges:        Revision (Incorporating IEEE P802.1p: Traffic Class Expediting        and Dynamic Multicast Filtering)", March 1998.   [20] ANSI/IEEE Draft Standard P802.1Q/D10, "IEEE Standards for Local        and Metropolitan Area Networks: Virtual Bridged Local Area        Networks", March 1998.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 40]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999   [21] De Graaf, K., Romascanu, D., McMaster, D. and K. McCloghrie,        "Definition of Managed Objects for IEEE 802.3 Repeater Devices        using SMIv2",RFC 2108, February 1997.   [22] McCloghrie, K. and F. Kastenholz," The Interfaces Group MIB        using SMIv2",RFC 2233, November 1997.   [23] Decker, E. Langille, P., Rijsinghani, A. and K. McCloghrie..  -        "Definitions of Managed Objects for Bridges",RFC 1493, July        1993   [24] Bradner, S., "Key words for use in RFCs to Indicate Requirement        Levels",BCP 14,RFC 2119, March 1997.   [25] McCloghrie, K. and M. Rose, Editors, "Management Information        Base for Network Management of TCP/IP-based internets: MIB-II",        STD 17,RFC 1213, March 1991.7. Intellectual Property   The IETF takes no position regarding the validity or scope of any   intellectual property or other rights that might be claimed to   pertain to the implementation or use of the technology described in   this document or the extent to which any license under such rights   might or might not be available; neither does it represent that it   has made any effort to identify any such rights.  Information on the   IETF's procedures with respect to rights in standards-track and   standards-related documentation can be found inBCP-11.  Copies of   claims of rights made available for publication and any assurances of   licenses to be made available, or the result of an attempt made to   obtain a general license or permission for the use of such   proprietary rights by implementors or users of this specification can   be obtained from the IETF Secretariat.   The IETF invites any interested party to bring to its attention any   copyrights, patents or patent applications, or other proprietary   rights which may cover technology that may be required to practice   this standard.  Please address the information to the IETF Executive   Director.8.  Security Considerations   There are a number of management objects defined in this MIB that   have a MAX-ACCESS clause of read-write and/or read-create.  Such   objects may be considered sensitive or vulnerable in some network   environments.  The support for SET operations in a non-secure   environment without proper protection can have a negative effect on   network operations.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 41]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999   There are a number of managed objects in this MIB that may contain   sensitive information. These are:       smonCapabilities       dataSourceCapsTable       portCopyTable   It is thus important to control even GET access to these objects and   possibly to even encrypt the values of these object when sending them   over the network via SNMP.  Not all versions of SNMP provide features   for such a secure environment.   SNMPv1 by itself is not a secure environment.  Even if the network   itself is secure (for example by using IPSec), even then, there is no   control as to who on the secure network is allowed to access and   GET/SET (read/change/create/delete) the objects in this MIB.   It is RECOMMENDED that the implementors consider the security   features as provided by the SNMPv3 framework.  Specifically, the use   of the User-based Security ModelRFC 2574 [12] and the View-based   Access Control ModelRFC 2575 [15] is RECOMMENDED.   It is then a customer/user responsibility to ensure that the SNMP   entity giving access to an instance of this MIB, is properly   configured to give access to the objects only to those principals   (users) that have legitimate rights to indeed GET or SET   (change/create/delete) them.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 42]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 19999.  Authors' Addresses   Richard Waterman   Allot Communications   292 E. Main St.   Los Gatos, CA.  95030   USA   Phone: +1-408-399-3154   EMail: rich@allot.com   Bill Lahaye   Xylan Corporation   26707 W. Agoura Rd.   Calabasas, CA 91302   USA   Phone:  +1-800-995-2612   EMail bill.lahaye@xylan.com   Dan Romascanu   Lucent Technologies   Atidim Technology Park, Bldg. #3   Tel Aviv, 61131   Israel   Phone: +972-3-645-8414   EMail: dromasca@lucent.com   Steven Waldbusser   International Network Services (INS)   1213 Innsbruck Dr.   Sunnyvale, CA 94089   Phone: +1-650-318-1251   EMail: waldbusser@ins.comWaterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 43]

RFC 2613                        SMON MIB                       June 1999A.  Full Copyright Statement   Copyright (C) The Internet Society (1999).  All Rights Reserved.   This document and translations of it may be copied and furnished to   others, and derivative works that comment on or otherwise explain it   or assist in its implementation may be prepared, copied, published   and distributed, in whole or in part, without restriction of any   kind, provided that the above copyright notice and this paragraph are   included on all such copies and derivative works.  However, this   document itself may not be modified in any way, such as by removing   the copyright notice or references to the Internet Society or other   Internet organizations, except as needed for the purpose of   developing Internet standards in which case the procedures for   copyrights defined in the Internet Standards process must be   followed, or as required to translate it into languages other than   English.   The limited permissions granted above are perpetual and will not be   revoked by the Internet Society or its successors or assigns.   This document and the information contained herein is provided on an   "AS IS" basis and THE INTERNET SOCIETY AND THE INTERNET ENGINEERING   TASK FORCE DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING   BUT NOT LIMITED TO ANY WARRANTY THAT THE USE OF THE INFORMATION   HEREIN WILL NOT INFRINGE ANY RIGHTS OR ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF   MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.Acknowledgement   Funding for the RFC Editor function is currently provided by the   Internet Society.Waterman, et al.            Standards Track                    [Page 44]

[8]ページ先頭

©2009-2025 Movatter.jp