Echo phonology: Signs of a link between gesture and speech.Bencie Woll &Jechil S. Sieratzki -1998 -Behavioral and Brain Sciences 21 (4):531-532.detailsThis commentary supports MacNeilage's dismissal of an evolutionary development from sign language to spoken language but presents evidence of a feature in sign language (echo phonology) that links iconic signs to abstract vocal syllables. These data provide an insight into possible mechanism by which iconic manual gestures accompanied by vocalisation could have provided a route for the evolution of spoken language with its characteristically arbitrary form–meaning relationship.
An evolutionary model for the learning of language.Jechil S. Sieratzki &Bencie Woll -1998 -Behavioral and Brain Sciences 21 (4):530-530.detailsThis commentary deals with the relation between human language and nonverbal signals used by nonhuman primates. It suggests that human language could have developed through the interaction of procedural learning with a preexisting system for socio-affective communication. The introduction of “content” into existing “frames” requires a neurobiologically plausible learning mechanism.
Why homolaterality of language and hand dominance may not be the expression of a specific evolutionary link.Bencie Woll &Jechil S. Sieratzki -2003 -Behavioral and Brain Sciences 26 (2):241-241.detailsAlthough gestures have surface similarities with language, there are significant organisational and neurolinguistic differences that argue against the evolutionary connection proposed by Corballis. Dominance for language and handedness may be related to a basic specialisation of the left cerebral hemisphere for target-directed behaviour and sequential processing, with the right side specialised for holistic-environmental monitoring and spatial processing.