Free‐market environmentalism: Turning a good servant into a bad master.Herman E.Daly -1992 -Critical Review: A Journal of Politics and Society 6 (2-3):171-183.detailsThe virtue of internalizing environmental costs so that prices reflect full social opportunity costs at the margin, reaffirmed by Terry Anderson and Donald Leal, is unarguable. Beyond that, however, Anderson and Leal's Free Market Environmentalism neglects the classic works in the intellectual tradition to which it is supposed to be a contribution; is unconvincing and inconsistent in the functions it ascribes to the ?environmental entrepreneur?; conflates problems of distribution and scale with the problem of allocation; ignores international dimensions; and misrepresents (...) the debate over ?sustainable development.? (shrink)
ISEW. The 'Debunking' Interpretation and the Person-in-Community Paradox: Comment on Rafael Ziegler.Herman E.Daly &John B. Cobb -2007 -Environmental Values 16 (3):287-288.detailsReply to article 'Political Perception and Ensemble of Macro Objectives and Measures: The Paradox of the Index for Sustainable Economic Welfare' by Rafael Ziegler in Environmental Values vol.16 no.1, pp.43-60.
Incorporating Values in a Bottom-Line Ecological Economy.Herman E.Daly -2009 -Bulletin of Science, Technology and Society 29 (5):349-357.detailsThe search for a social goodness function in economic systems is reviewed, especially in light of the fact that the economy is a subsystem of a biosphere that has its own rules for determining success, or at least for limiting feasibility. The frequent perversity of reductionist quantitative success indicators in economics (profit, quotas, GDP) is mainly attributed to the preanalytic vision of the economy as an isolated circular flow, and of homo economicus as an atomistic individual isolated from community, both (...) social and biological. Specific examples of such perversity are considered. (shrink)
No categories
Ethical Dimensions of Global Development.William Galston,David A. Crocker,Stephen L. Esquith,Xiaorong Li,Roland Pierik &Herman E.Daly (eds.) -2006 - Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.detailsAs a broad concept, 'globalization' denotes the declining significance of national boundaries. At a deeper level, globalization is the proposition that nation-states are losing the power to control what occurs within their borders and that what transpires across borders is rising in relative significance. The Ethical Dimensions of Global Development: An Introduction, the fifth book in Rowman & Littlefield's Institute for Philosophy and Public Policy Studies series, discusses key questions concerning globalization and its implications, including: Can general ethical principles be (...) brought to bear on questions of globalization? Do economic development and self-government require a duty of care? Is economic destiny crucial to individual autonomy? This collection provides readers with current information and useful insights into this complex topic. (shrink)
Ethics of Consumption: The Good Life, Justice, and Global Stewardship.Luis A. Camacho,Colin Campbell,David A. Crocker,Eleonora Curlo,Herman E.Daly,Eliezer Diamond,Robert Goodland,Allen L. Hammond,Nathan Keyfitz,Robert E. Lane,Judith Lichtenberg,David Luban,James A. Nash,Martha C. Nussbaum,ThomasW Pogge,Mark Sagoff,Juliet B. Schor,Michael Schudson,Jerome M. Segal,Amartya Sen,Alan Strudler,Paul L. Wachtel,Paul E. Waggoner,David Wasserman &Charles K. Wilber (eds.) -1997 - Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.detailsIn this comprehensive collection of essays, most of which appear for the first time, eminent scholars from many disciplines—philosophy, economics, sociology, political science, demography, theology, history, and social psychology—examine the causes, nature, and consequences of present-day consumption patterns in the United States and throughout the world.
The Business of Consumption: Environmental Ethics and the Global Economy.George G. Brenkert,Donald A. Brown,Rogene A. Buchholz,Herman E.Daly,Richard Dodd,R. Edward Freeman,Eric T. Freyfogle,R. Goodland,Michael E. Gorman,Andrea Larson,John Lemons,Don Mayer,William McDonough,Matthew M. Mehalik,Ernest Partridge,Jessica Pierce,William E. Rees,Joel E. Reichart,Sandra B. Rosenthal,Mark Sagoff,Julian L. Simon,Scott Sonenshein &Wendy Warren -1998 - Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.detailsAt the forefront of international concerns about global legislation and regulation, a host of noted environmentalists and business ethicists examine ethical issues in consumption from the points of view of environmental sustainability, economic development, and free enterprise.
HermanDaly's Ecological Economic Thought: Focusing on the Formation Background. 김일방 -2018 -Environmental Philosophy 25 (25):31-60.details허먼 데일리는 생태경제학의 대부로 불린다. 그 이유는 그가 1960년대 후반부터 오늘에 이르기까지 줄곧 생태경제학자로서의 길을 걸어오면서 이 분야의 기초를 다져놓았기 때문이다. 데일리의 생태경제사상의 핵심은 이른바 ‘정상상태’ 경제론이라 할 수 있다. 정상상태 경제란 원료 투입량을 최저 비율로 유지함으로써 전체 인구와 물질적 부의 축적이 항상 어떤 바람직한 수준을 유지하는 경제로 정의된다. 데일리도 한때는 경제성장을 강조하는 성장론자의 한 사람이었다. 이러한 데일리의 관점을 전환하는 데는 3명의 학자가 큰 영향을 끼친 것으로 판단된다. 그 3명의 학자란 밀(J.S. Mill), 볼딩(K.E. Boulding) 그리고 조제스쿠-뢰겐(N. Georgescu-Roegen)을 가리킨다. 본 연구의 (...) 주 목적은 데일리의 정상상태 경제론이 형성되는 데 큰 영향을 끼친 것으로 여겨지는 3인의 학자의 주장을 살펴보는 데 있다. (shrink)
For the common good?Paul Heyne -1992 -Critical Review: A Journal of Politics and Society 6 (2-3):185-209.detailsHerman E.Daly, an economist, and John B. Cobb, Jr., a theologian, have teamed up to write a book that calls for a radical restructuring of the way we organize production and exchange. They believe that the pressure of human population and production on the biosphere will soon compel thoroughgoing changes in the way we live. They also believe that we would want radical changes, with more emphasis on community and less on the pursuit of individual advantage, if (...) we correctly understood our own natures. Because they believe that the academic discipline of economics has systematically blinded us to the social and biological realities of our situation, they focus on the criticism and reform of economics. An unfortunate result is a failure to learn what economics could tell them about the evolution and functioning of the societies they want to transform. (shrink)
Logic in a Pincers.Herman E. Stark -2000 -Philosophy in the Contemporary World 7 (2-3):61-69.detailsThe essay challenges the de facto dichotomy between the discipline of logic and the activity of social criticism, i.e., it provides an illustrated reminder to philosophers that the gulf between these two areas of philosophy is not quite as wide as our curriculum andspecialization designations tend to suggest. Social criticism plays some necessary roles in certain branches of logic, and the second-order accounting of the contents of these branches leads back to social criticism. These points suggest an adjusted conception of (...) logic that would, among other things, render phrases such as “applying logic to social criticism” as misleading since certain branches of logic would not even coherently exist apart from social criticism. The lead illustrations are the identification of basic, pervasive, and thought-impeding logical errors that have been missed by numerous logic texts, and the assessment of contemporary academic logic as properly a quest for communal sanity that lies caught between communal insanity and communal mendacity. (shrink)
The Lord Scroop Fallacy.Herman E. Stark -2000 -Informal Logic 20 (3).detailsIn this paper I identify a fallacy. The fallacy is worth noting for practical and theoretical reasons. First, the rampant occurrences ofthis fallacy-especially at moments calling for careful thought-indicate that it is more pernicious to clear thinking than many of those found in standard logic texts. Second, the fallacy stands apart from most others in that it contains multiple kinds oflogical error (i.e., fallacious and non-fallacious logical errors) that are themselves committed in abnormal ways, and thus it presents a two-tiered (...) challenge to oversimplified accounts of how an argument can go bad. (shrink)
Philosophy as Wonder.Herman E. Stark -2005 -Dialogue and Universalism 15 (1-2):133-140.detailsI argue that the love of wisdom can be recovered by reawakening in humans the genuine sense of wonder, i.e., by recovering the transformed condition in which humans experience philosophical asking as a meaning-bestowing and existentially-transforming phenomenon. Wonder in this sense is primarily a metaphysical and not psychological state, and it is evoked by the transforming phenomenon of philosophical asking. Philosophical asking is not reducible to a something, e.g., a sentence in question-form, that provokes the setting up and critique of (...) theories but rather is essentially a way of existing, a dwelling, that is marked by the astonishment of watching the world, and ourselves, open up and transfigure by our very asking, i.e., by our existing as askers. (shrink)
A Thematic Unity for Heidegger’s Was Heisst Denken?Herman E. Stark -1998 -The Paideia Archive: Twentieth World Congress of Philosophy 6:242-248.detailsThis essay is primarily an analysis of Heidegger's Was Heisst Denken? I aim to provide a thematic unity for this enigmatic text, thereby rendering Heidegger's thoughts on thinking more available to those investigating the nature of human rationality and thinking. The procedure is to gather together some of the sundry themes and puzzling features resolved by unpacking this sentence: 'Most thought-provoking in our thought-provoking time is that we are still not thinking.' The chief results of this study include the establishment (...) of a global logic to the text, the identification of 'beingthoughtful' as the proper phenomenon to be studied, and receptivity as the distinguishing mark of the thoughtful. (shrink)
No categories
Fallacies and Logical Errors.Herman E. Stark -2000 -Inquiry: Critical Thinking Across the Disciplines 20 (1):23-32.detailsI explore a distinction that is philosophically significant but rarely a cynosure. The distinction is betvveen fallacies and logical errors, and I approach it by advancing overlooked albeit deleterious logical errors that are not fallacies but that fall squarely within the purview of Critical Thinking if not also Informal Logic. One key claim to emerge is that these logical errors -- just as basic and thought-impeding as the fallacies -- demand that we take a hard look at what is and (...) what should be guiding our activity in teaching such courses. Another is that although philosophers appeal to the notion of logical error in their explications of fallacies, the former notion is anything but clear and indeed usually explained in terms of the latter. Yet another is that the distinction illustrates why the oft encountered “false premise or bad inference” account of how thinking can go bad is oversimplified. (shrink)
Expertise and Rationality.Herman E. Stark -1998 -The Paideia Archive: Twentieth World Congress of Philosophy 45:242-247.detailsI explore the connection between expertise and rationality. I first make explicit the philosophically dominant view on this connection, i.e., the ‘expert-consultation’ view. This view captures the rather obvious idea that a rational way of proceeding on a matter of importance when one lacks knowledge is to consult experts. Next, I enumerate the difficulties which beset this view, locating them to some extent in the current philosophical literature on expertise and rationality. I then propose that different lessons should be drawn (...) for rationality from the fact of expertise. One is that some empirical and phenomenological studies of the nature of expertise can be fruitfully applied by analogy to theories of the rational agent. (shrink)
No categories
Reasons without principles.Herman E. Stark -2004 -Inquiry: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy 47 (2):143 – 167.detailsWhat is required for one thing to be a reason for another? Must the reason, more precisely, be or involve a principle? In this essay I target the idea that justification via reasons of one's beliefs (e.g., epistemic or moral) requires that the 'justifying reasons' be or involve (substantive and significant) principles. I identify and explore some potential sources of a principles requirement, and conclude that none of them (i.e., the normative function of reasons, the abstract structure of reasons, the (...) universalizability constraint on [moral] reasons, and even the pragmatic considerations that attenuate 'real-world' reason-giving) mandate that reasons be principles. I then explore implications of this conclusion, and note especially the resultant and paradoxical permissibility of justifying reasons that manage to be lawlike (a sine qua non for justifying reasons) even while consisting of highly-detailed and situation-specific proposition sets, e.g., novel-length narratives. (shrink)
On Wilfred Beckerman's Critique of Sustainable Development.HermanDaly,Michael Jacobs &Henryk Skolimowski -1995 -Environmental Values 4 (1):49-55.detailsThe 'Discussion' section of this issue contains the following responses to Wilfred Beckerman's article 'Sustainable Development: Is it a Useful Concept?' Environmental Values 3,3 (1994): 191-209.HermanDaly, 'On Wilfred Beckerman's Critique of Sustainable Development'; Michael Jacobs, 'Sustainable Development, Capital Substitution and Humility: A Response to Beckerman'; and Henryk Skolimowski, 'In Defence of Sustainable Development'. These criticisms are answered by Beckerman in Environmental Values 4,2.
Towards a phenomenology of caregiving: growth in the caregiver is a vital component.M. E.Daly -1987 -Journal of Medical Ethics 13 (1):34-39.detailsThe classical notions of 'virtue' and 'leisure' offer excellent insights into the essentially moral nature of medical practice. This is especially evident in the understanding that professional caregiving has the potential to enhance the moral character as well as the moral awareness of the practitioner. Reflective awareness of the moral nature of the caregiving process can also contribute to coping with negative stress, which almost always has its origins in frustrations rooted in moral quandaries and evaluations. Understanding the process required (...) arises from implementation of caregiving in combination with deliberate, conscious development of spiritual awareness and reflection on moral meaning. (shrink)
Ethical review and the assessment of research proposals using qualitative research methods.JeanneDaly,Mridula Bandyopadhyay,E. Riggs &L. Williamson -2008 -Monash Bioethics Review 27 (3):S43-S53.detailsThe role of Human Research Ethics Committees (HRECs) in health research is well established. Ethics committees have the good of research participants in mind but they must also assess scientific merit including the design and conduct of studies. In this article the authors’ focus is on qualitative research method and the challenge that the National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research (2007) poses for ethics committees when they assess proposals using the methods outlined in the National Statement.We set out (...) a process for judging the standard of qualitative research proposals and propose that qualitative health research can be assessed using a hierarchy designed for evaluating interview studies. We contrast well-designed studies with those that have design flaws in order to focus on the hallmarks of research merit in studies that use qualitative research methods. Finally, we show that our proposal is compatible with the National Statement.Ethics review provides an early opportunity to identify and redesign inadequate studies that will not contribute to our knowledge base. The challenge for members of ethics committees with little experience in qualitative studies is to be able to assess research excellence by assessing research merit in proposals, recognising the special design features of qualitative research methods. (shrink)
How Acts of Infidelity Promote DNA Break Repair: Collision and Collusion Between DNA Repair and Transcription.Priya Sivaramakrishnan,Alasdair J. E. Gordon,Jennifer A. Halliday &ChristopheHerman -2018 -Bioessays 40 (10):1800045.detailsTranscription is a fundamental cellular process and the first step in gene regulation. Although RNA polymerase (RNAP) is highly processive, in growing cells the progression of transcription can be hindered by obstacles on the DNA template, such as damaged DNA. The authors recent findings highlight a trade‐off between transcription fidelity and DNA break repair. While a lot of work has focused on the interaction between transcription and nucleotide excision repair, less is known about how transcription influences the repair of DNA (...) breaks. The authors suggest that when the cell experiences stress from DNA breaks, the control of RNAP processivity affects the balance between preserving transcription integrity and DNA repair. Here, how the conflict between transcription and DNA double‐strand break (DSB) repair threatens the integrity of both RNA and DNA are discussed. In reviewing this field, the authors speculate on cellular paradigms where this equilibrium is well sustained, and instances where the maintenance of transcription fidelity is favored over genome stability. (shrink)
Getting off the Back Burner: Impact of Testing Elementary Social Studies as Part of a State-Mandated Accountability Program.Kenneth E. Vogler,Timothy Lintner,George B. Lipscomb,Herman Knopf,Tina L. Heafner &Tracy C. Rock -2007 -Journal of Social Studies Research 31 (2):20-34.detailsSocial studies and social studies education is in the midst of what aptly can be described as a crisis of relevancy. In today's post-‘No Child Left Behind’ curriculum defined by test scores and proficiency targets, social studies has, as some have said, “been placed on the backburner” to make room for seemingly more important (tested) subjects such as reading and mathematics. The purpose of this study is to provide a picture of the state of social studies in South Carolina, a (...) state which tests social studies in elementary grades, while trying to understand the impact of state-mandated testing in greater depth. Its focus is on elementary teachers' beliefs about the role of social studies in the curriculum and their perception of time spent on social studies instruction. (shrink)
Parental Investment by Birth Fathers and Stepfathers.Jenni E. Pettay,Mirkka Danielsbacka,Samuli Helle,Gretchen Perry,MartinDaly &Antti O. Tanskanen -2023 -Human Nature 34 (2):276-294.detailsThis study investigates the determinants of paternal investment by birth fathers and stepfathers. Inclusive fitness theory predicts higher parental investment in birth children than stepchildren, and this has consistently been found in previous studies. Here we investigate whether paternal investment varies with childhood co-residence duration and differs between stepfathers and divorced birth fathers by comparing the investment of (1) stepfathers, (2) birth fathers who are separated from the child’s mother, and (3) birth fathers who still are in a relationship with (...) her. Path analysis was conducted using cross-sectional data from adolescents and younger adults (aged 17–19, 27–29, and 37–39 years) from the German Family Panel (pairfam), collected in 2010–2011 (_n_ = 8326). As proxies of paternal investment, we used financial and practical help, emotional support, intimacy, and emotional closeness, as reported by the children. We found that birth fathers who were still in a relationship with the mother invested the most, and stepfathers invested the least. Furthermore, the investment of both separated fathers and stepfathers increased with the duration of co-residence with the child. However, in the case of financial help and intimacy, the effect of childhood co-residence duration was stronger in stepfathers than in separated fathers. Our findings support inclusive fitness theory and mating effort theory in explaining social behavior and family dynamics in this population. Furthermore, social environment, such as childhood co-residence was associated with paternal investment. (shrink)
No categories
Nietzsche e a sociofisiologia do eu.Herman Siemens -2016 -Cadernos Nietzsche 37 (1):185-218.detailsResumo Este artigo examina as considerações de Nietzsche acerca das fontes sociais e históricas do eu como um contra-argumento à concepção liberal de indivíduo. Defendo que Nietzsche oferece não apenas uma crítica contundente à concepção associal e previamente individuada de pessoa, à qual se conecta a noção liberal de liberdade, como ainda um contra-conceito alternativo de pessoa e de soberania. Seus argumentos visam mostrar, em sua dimensão crítica, que o indivíduo ou pessoa é inseparável de seus objetivos ou valores, que (...) são socialmente constituídos, e que nossa capacidade como indivíduos, especialmente para a agência soberana, é o produto de uma longa história e pré-história social. Em sua dimensão construtiva, encontramos em Nietzsche a contra alegação de que a manutenção e o cultivo de nossas capacidades são dependentes de relações de um antagonismo ponderado entre nós mesmos enquanto indivíduos, ou antes: como dividua. Esses argumentos serão desenvolvidos no que se segue em consonância com quatro principais linhas de pensamento: sobre as origens sociais e o caráter da consciência ; sobre a história e a constituição social de nossa capacidade como indivíduos soberanos [sovereign] ; sobre as origens sociais do fenômeno moral ; e sobre a destruição fisiológica do sujeito moral substancial, seguida da reconstrução fisiológica.This essay examines Nietzsche's thought on the social and historical sources of the self as a counter-argument against the liberal concept of the individual. Nietzsche, it is argued, offers a powerful critique of the asocial, antecedently individuated concept of personhood, to which the liberal notion of freedom is attached, but also an alternative counter-concept of personhood and sovereignty. On the critical side are arguments to the effect that the individual or person is inseparable from its ends or values, which in turn are socially constituted, and that our capacities as individuals, especially for sovereign agency, are the product of a long social history and pre-history. On the positive side is the constructive counter-claim that the maintenance and cultivation of our capacities for productive, autonomous agency is dependent on relations of measured antagonism both between and within us as individuals, or rather: as dividua. These arguments are reconstructed along four main lines of thought: on the social origins and character of consciousness ; on the history and social constitution of our capacities as sovereign individuals ; on the social origins of moral phenomena, understood as internalisations of communal norms ; and Nietzsche's physiological destruction of the substantial moral subject, coupled with the physiological reconstruction of the subject as dividuum. (shrink)
No categories