'Sugar, Butter, Broadway': Sara Bareilles Taking Over the Lead Role in Her Musical 'Waitress'

The singer – who wrote the music and lyrics forWaitress – will start her tenure as Jenna on March 31

By
Lindsay Kimble
lindsay-kimble-headshot
Lindsay Kimble is the Executive Editor, News at PEOPLE. She have been working at PEOPLE for seven years. Her work has previously appeared in POPSUGAR, Us Weekly and Entertainment Weekly.
Published on February 16, 2017 11:15AM EST
Build Presents Sara Bareilles and Jessie Mueller Discussing "Waitress"
Credit : Jim Spellman/WireImage

Sara Bareilles is officially headed to Broadway – and this time, she’s taking the stage.

The “Brave” singer will take over the lead role of Jenna in the musical Waitress on March 31, she announced on social media on Thursday.

It’s a perfect fit for the star, who actually wrote the music and lyrics for the show – which is based on the 2007 movie of the same name.

“Sugar, Butter, Broadway,” Bareilles wrote on Instagram. “It is with unabashed delight that I announce that my childhood dream is coming true and I’m gonna be on Broadway!!!! I am joining the cast of WAITRESS!!”

Alongside the excited message, Bareilles posted a throwback photo of herself side-by-side with a picture of her in costume for the musical.

Her note continued, “In a few short weeks I will be stepping into the role of Jenna Hunterson, and I’m just beside myself! This show, the people who made it, and these characters have become more precious to me than I could ever say. It will be an incredible privilege to join the cast onstage and tell this beautiful story.”

After revealing her start date, the singer joked, “Panic attacks available now.”

Waitress is the first Broadway musical ever to feature an all-female creative team. In addition to Bareilles’ music and lyrics, the show was written by Jessie Nelson, Lorin Latarro served as choreographer, and Tony Award winner Diane Paulus directed.

RELATED VIDEO: How Does the Broadway MusicalWaitress Make Their Theaters Smell Like Pie!?

In the show, Jenna — a waitress and pie maker living in a small town with a husband she no longer cares for — finds herself unexpectedly pregnant and not sure where to turn. Grammy and Tony winner Jessie Mueller has been playing the role since the show opened on March 25, 2016.

Bareilles also released an album featuring the songs she wrote for the musical, calledWhat’s Inside: Songs from Waitress — so, needless to say, she’s certainly prepared for the role.

Waitress currently plays multiple times a week at New York City’s Brooks Atkinson Theatre. Tickets can be purchased here. Bareilles’ run starts March 31 and lasts 10 weeks.

Read more:
You Might Like
Jason Kelce's annual celebrity bartending event takes over Sea Isle City Credit: Jamal Cooley/Philadelphia Eagles and Eagles Autism Foundation
Newlyweds Party with Teeny Swimsuit-Clad Jason Kelce and Philadelphia Eagles Players on Their Honeymoon: 'It Was Awesome'
Human Interest
June 27, 2025
Woman smiling at man standing by dining table, friends in background
Woman Thinks Her Newly-Single Neighbor Is After Her Husband — But Her Hubby Says She's Being 'Silly'
Human Interest
11 hours ago
man and woman in bed
Woman Says Her Husband Always Oversleeps, and It Might Destroy Their Marriage
Human Interest
June 28, 2025

Related Articles

A person holding a gift box.
Woman Says Husband Has 'Never' Given Her a Birthday or Holiday Gift in the 3 Years They've Been Married
Woman finds lost wedding ring 20 years later.
After 20 Years, Woman Finds Lost Wedding Ring in the Spot She Always Suspected (Exclusive)
Boy and girl argument in the kitchen. He thinks that she is out of her mind, that she is crazy. He is not sure what is wrong. He puts his finger on his head.
Woman Accuses Her Husband of Being ‘Sleazy’ After He Commented on Another Woman’s Body — Others Think He Was Just Being Nice
 John Travolta attends the 2024 Academy Museum Gala at Academy Museum of Motion Pictures on October 19, 2024 in Los Angeles, California. John Travolta leads Grease sing-along at Hollywood Bowl.
John Travolta Makes Surprise Appearance atGrease Sing-Along Event in L.A. — While Dressed Like Danny Zuko
Husband talking with mother at home, not paying attention on offended wife
Woman Worries Her 40-Year-Old 'Big Mama's Boy' Husband Will Never Be Independent 
Rearview shot of an unrecognizable young woman looking distressed with her husband in the background
Woman Says Husband ‘Exploded’ at Her After She Questioned Him About a Woman at the Supermarket — Wonders If He's Cheating
A woman is carrying cardboard moving boxes into her new apartment.
Woman Left Her Husband and Says His Mother Now Wants to Clear Out the Home They Shared 'ASAP' — She’s Not Happy About It
Amanda Seyfried attends the Lancome X Louvre photocall on September 26, 2023 in Paris, France ; Ariana Grande as Glinda in 'Wicked' (2024) ; Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba in 'Wicked' (2024) ; Cristin Milioti attends the 30th Annual Critics Choice Awards on February 07, 2025 in Santa Monica, California.
12 Surprising Stars Who Auditioned forWicked(Including a Pair of Famous Brothers Who Both Read for Fiyero!)
Amanda Seyfried
Amanda Seyfried Candidly Revealed She Auditioned 6 Times forWicked:'I Worked My Ass Off'
Funeral, death and man carry coffin with family in grief, mourning and sad during church service for peace.
Woman Is 'Livid' After Her Husband ‘Got Absolutely Off His Face’ at His Dad’s Funeral
Farmer Spends Months Planning Epic 20th Anniversary Surprise for Wife — See Her Emotional Reaction
Farmer Spends Months Planning Epic 20th Anniversary Surprise for His Wife — See the Reveal!
Arguing with In-Law mother
Woman Doesn't Want to Have Kids Out of Fear They'll 'Inherit' Future Mother-in-Law's Personality
Stephen Schwartz at the 54th Annual Songwriters Hall of Fame Induction and Awards Gala held at the Marriott Marquis Hotel on June 12, 2025 in New York, New York., Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo in Wicked
Stephen Schwartz Is 'Still Working' on Music forWicked: For Good — and His Deadline Is 'Very Soon' (Exclusive)
Lin-Manuel Miranda at the opening night of 'Hamilton' at Victoria Palace Theatre on Dec. 21, 2017, in London; Renée Elise Goldsberry at the opening night of 'Hamilton' at The Public Theater on Feb. 17, 2015, in New York City; Leslie Odom Jr. at the 'Hamilton' Broadway opening night afterparty at Pier 60 on Aug. 6, 2015, in New York City
The Cast ofHamilton: Where Are They Now?
Woman Treasures Late Dad's T-Shirt, So She Doesn't Wear It. Her Husband Finds a Way for Her to Do Both
She Was Scared of Ruining Her Late Dad's T-Shirt. Her Husband Surprised Her with a Gift That Made Her Cry (Exclusive)
HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL,Lucas Grabeel, 2005
Lucas Grabeel Recalls 'Hard' Times BeforeHigh School Musical Role: 'I Had Just $3 in My Account'