United States Patent [19] Armstrong 1 Oct. 1, 1974 I 1 PROSTHESIS AND MEMBRANE STRUCTURE TO REPLACE THE STAPES [75] Inventor: Beverly W. Armstrong, Charlotte,
22 Filed: Jan. 15,1973
21 Appl. No.: 323,940
OTHER PUBLICATIONS Smyth Clothespin Strut, Richards MicroSurgery Instruments and Implants Catalog, Richards Mfg. Co., Memphis, Tenn., Copyright 1965,page 31.
Scheer Teflon-Wire Prosthesis, croqSurgery Instruments & Implants Catalog, Richards Mfg. Co., Memphis, Tenn., Copyright 1965 page 36.
Primary ExaminerRichard A. Gaudet Assistant ExaminerRonald L. Frinks Attorney, Agent, or Firm.l0hn R. Walker, 111
[ 5 7 1 ABSTRACT A prosthesis for use in otological surgery to replace the stapes of the middle ear. The prosthesis is slit Richards Mitransversely to establish a pair of legs constituting the distal end thereof. The legs are resilient and may be spread apart to urge a bight portion of a membrane, e.g., a vein section, therebetween which is then gripped by the prosthesis. Accordingly, the likelihood of the prosthesis becoming detached from the membrane is substantially nil. The proximal end of the prosthesis is adapted to be attached to the incus and preferably includes a wire having the shape of a shepherds crook for encircling the incus and which may be crimped thereto.
A jig is herein disclosed to accomplish the task of urging the bight portion of the membrane between the legs of the prothesis. The jig includes a main body suitably attached to a stand and an upwardly directed ridge attached to the main body for insertion between the pair of legs of the prosthesis.
A method of attaching the prosthesis and the membrane one to the other is also disclosed herein and includes the steps of: First, providing the above-mentioned jig. Second, providing the distal end of the prosthesis with a pair of legs for gripping the membrane. Third, placing the membrane over the ridge of the jig with the ridge restingly supporting a portion of the membrane intermediate remote edges thereof. Fourth, placing the distal end of the prosthesis upon the jig with the transverse slit being aligned with the ridge and with the membrane being sandwiched therebetween. Fifth, thrusting the prosthesis downwardly so that the legs straddle the ridge and a bight portion of the membrane is urged between the legs. Sixth, withdrawing the prosthesis from the jig with the bight portion of the membrane being grippingly attached to the prosthesis.
7 Claims, 10 Drawing Figures PATENIEDUBT I m4 FIG.
FIG. 9
PROSTHESIS AND MEMBRANE STRUCTURE TO REPLACE THE STAPES BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 1. Field of the Invention This invention r elates to the field of otology implants.
2. Description of the Prior Art The Merchandino et al., U.S. Pat. No. 3,191,188 describes a method of treating otosclerotic deafness by substituting an artificial stapes for the human stapes. The artificial stapes consists of a thin laminar base adaptable to the niche of the oval window from which lamina rises a tubular strut or stem that articulates with the incus, i.e., the strut being attached to the lenticular process of the incus thus replacing the mechanical link between the incus and the oval window.
The Robinson U.S. Pat. No. 3,196,462 describes another prosthesis which comprises an enlarged proximal portion that is hollow and open at the outer end for attachment to the incus. A reduced shank portion extends axially and centrally from the proximal portion. A vein graft is positioned over the oval window and is maintained in position thereover by the pressure exerted by the distal end of the prosthesis. In other words, the prosthesis is not attached to the vein graft. However, a slightly modified technique is disclosed where instead of a vein graft being used, a fat graft is employed for blocking the oval window. In this latter embodiment a wire is looped through a transverse opening provided adjacent the distal end and around the fat graft to maintain it in proper position.
The Haase et al. U.S. Pat. No. 3,473,170 describes a prosthesis for insertion into the middle ear cavity to replace the ossicles. In other words, the foot plate of the stapes remains in the oval window. Accordingly, this prosthesis is attached to the foot plate of the stapes.
The Shea prosthesis, which is disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 3,711,869 dated Jan. 23, l973,assigned to the assignee of the present application, is a prosthesis for the middle ear to replace the stapes and is attached to the under surface of the lenticular process of the incus. In other words, the distal end of the prosthesis simply touches the vein graft which closes the oval window and a gelfoam is placed adjacent the distal end to hold it to the vein graft during the healing process. It should be noted that none of the above patents or patent application show or suggest applicants device.
It should be pointed out that a particular disadvantage prevails with the above-mentioned disclosures. This disadvantage was identified in the '462 patent and the following is a quote from column 1, lines 45-49 thereof:
Should the polyethylene strut become detached from the incus, there would be no way of determining this dislocation without surgical re-exploration of the middle car since polyethylene is not radiopaque. The applicant is not aware of any prior device which grips the vein graft or is attached thereto in any other manner except by the use of the gelfoam. Accordingly, any of the prior prostheses known by the applicant are subject to becoming dislocated with respect to the vein graft.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION The present invention is directed towards overcoming the heretofore mentioned and other disadvantages in prostheses for replacing the stapes.
The concept of the present invention is to provide a prosthesis which will have substantially the same resonant frequency as the natural stapes and which efflciently and firmly attaches to the incus and to the vein graft. The prosthesis of the present invention includes a piston part which has the distal end thereof slit transversely to establish a pair of legs. The legs, being resilient, may be spread apart to urge a bight portion of a membrane therebetween, e.g., a vein graft previously removed from the patient usually from the back of his hand. Therefore, the membrane is gripped by the prosthesis. Accordingly, the likelihood of the prosthesis becoming detached from the membrane is substantially nil. The proximal end of the prosthesis is adapted to be attached to the incus in any well-known manner. How ever, I prefer that the proximal end include a wire which is attached to the Teflon piston or distal end. The wire is shaped somewhat like a shepherd s crook for encircling the incus and which may be crimped thereto.
A jig is herein disclosed to accomplish the task of urging the bight portion of the membrane between the legs of the prosthesis. The jig includes a main body suitably attached to a stand and an upwardly directed ridge attached to the main body for insertion between the pair of legs of the prosthesis.
A method of attaching the prosthesis and the membrane one to the other is also disclosed herein and includes the steps of: First, providing the above mentioned jig. Second, providing the distal end of the pros thesis with a pair of legs for gripping the membrane. Third, placing the membrane over the ridge of the jig with the ridge restingly supporting a portion of the membrane intermediate remote edges thereof. Fourth, placing the distal end of the prosthesis upon the jig with the transverse slit being aligned with the ridge and with the membrane being sandwiched therebetween. Fifth, thrusting the prosthesis downwardly so that the legs straddle the ridge and a bight portion of the membrane is urged between the legs, i.e., the exterior distal end of the prosthesis engaging the main body of the jig. Sixth, withdrawing the prosthesis from the jig with the bight portion of the membrane being grippingly attached to the prosthesis. The surgeon isnow ready to engage the proximal end of the prosthesis with the incus in the usual manner, after which he places the membrane over the oval window thus completing the mechanical link between the incus and the oval window.
DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWING FIG. 1 is a side elevational view of the prosthesis of the present invention.
FIG. 2 is a sectional view taken as on the Line 11-11 of FIG. 1 showing a transverse slit in the prosthesis extending from the distal exterior thereof to the aperture therein to establish the pair of legs which grip the membrane.
FIG. 3 is a perspective view of the jig'fixture of the present invention showing the upwardly directed ridge for insertion between the legs of the prosthesis.
FIG. 4 is a sectional view taken as on the Line IV--IV of FIG. 1.
FIG. 5 is a perspective view of a stand for supporting the jig fixture which is intended to be attached to the upper end of a post thereof as depicted in phantom therein.
FIGS. 6 through 8 depict the distal end of the prosthesis, the jig fixture, and membrane structure to sequentially illustrate the method of attaching the prosthesis and the membrane one to the other.
FIG. 9 is a cross-section of the oval window of the middle ear, showing the stapes completing the link between the incus and the oval window.
FIG. 10 is a view similar to FIG. 9 with the stapes being removed and showing the prosthesis of the present invention completing the mechanical linkage between the incus and the oval window.
DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED I EMBODIMENT The prosthesis 11 of the present invention comprises in general anelongated piston member 13, a wire-likeproximal end member 15 including ashepherds crook piston 17 with themember 15 being fixedly attached to the piston member ordistal end 13, as by means of an embeddedhook 18.Piston member 13 is preferably formed from a suitable material that is somewhat flexible and has substantially the same natural resonant frequency as the replaced stapes which is shown in FIG. 9 and character referenced therein by the numeral 16.
A suitable material having the desirable characteristics for thepiston member 13 is Teflon, which is a tetrafluoroethylenehexafluoropropylene copolymer and is a registered trademark of the DuPont Company.
The wire-like member 15 preferably is formed from stainless steel, however, other inert metallic materials, such as platinum, gold and the like could be used.
It should be pointed out that theproximal end 15 may be varied in structure to conform to other wellknown otologic implants without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention, e.g., like the previously mentioned Shea prosthesis.
From FIG. 1 of the drawing it may be seen that theproximal member 15 as herein disclosed includes enough wire to completely encircle the long process of theincus 19 as shown in FIGS. 9 and 10 of the drawing. Additionally, anangled extension 21 serves as a guide to facilitate introduction over theincus 19 and provides anotch 23 to accommodate the tip of a crimper (not shown), minimizing the danger of trauma to the mucosa.
An important concept of the present invention is that the distal end, as shown at 25, of the prosthesis 11 is fixedly attached to membrane structure, characterized herein by the numeral 27 in FIGS. 6 through 8 and FIG. 10. More specifically, thepiston member 13 is preferably solid and cylindrically shaped with the distal end thereof being provided with atransverse aperture 29 for loosely receiving abight portion 31 of themembrane structure 27. Additionally, thedistal end 25 is interrupted along a line extending parallel with the bore of theaperture 29 to establish a pair oflegs 33, 35 with aninterruption 37 therebetween as best viewed in FIGS. 2 and 4 of the drawing.
Further, thedistal end 25 preferably ispr o videdwiW a pair ofnotches 39 leading in to the respective ends of theinterruption 37 for receiving and guidingly constraining certain structure yet to be disclosed. Thelegs 33, 35 have a resilient characteristic and are adapted,
to be spread in a manner yet to be disclosed while thebight portion 31 of themembrane 27 is urged therebetween and to grippingly engage and retain a double thickness of themembrane structure 27 after the withdrawal of the structure alluded to above.
Particular attention is now directed toward FIG. 9 of the drawing wherein it may be seen that the stapes I6 normally is connected to theincus 19 by the lenticular process character referenced by the numeral 41. The stapes 16 includes a foot plate portion which is slightly invaginated in anoval window 45 defined by utricle structure character referenced herein by. the numeral 47. It should be noted that the stapes 16 is SHJPOIIQCI in theoval Window 45 by liningmembrane 49.
From FIG. 10 of the drawing it may be seen that the stapes 16 (shown in FIG. 9). including thefoot plate 43, has been removed from the middle ear and replaced by'the prosthesis ll of the present invention. More specifically. the liningmembrane 49, having been previously elevated from the circumference of theoval window 45. Le. when the stapes 16 was removed. is reor the like or it may be a vein graft previously remove d from the patient. The latterusually is removed from the back of the hand and is slightly larger than theoval window 45, e.g., approximately 1 millimeter larger at each margin edge. The vein graft is usually positioned with the intima side thereof contiguously engaging theutricle structure 47 and with the adventitia up or thedistal end 25 of the prosthesis 11 being engaged therewith. Accordingly, it may be appreciated that particular care has been directed toward attaching the vein graft ormembrane 27 to thestructure 47 defining theoval window 45. Additionally, even more attention has been directed toward discovering an optimum technique for attaching the proximal end of the prosthesis to the incus, e.g., the aforementioned Shea prosthesis.
However, it should be pointed out that heretofore the usual technique for attaching the distal end of the prosthesis to the vein graft was with the use of gelfoam as clearly disclosed in said Shea prosthesis. In other words, the state of the art has developed the mechani- .cal link of the prosthesis so that it is positive in its attachment of the proximal end to theincus 19 and in some instances to thelenticular process 41, but has not "been as positive in attaching the distal end to the vein 'graft ormembrane 27.
Ajig fixture 51 is herein disclosed for facilitating the attachment of the vein graft ormembrane structure 27 to the distal end of the otological prosthesis 11 of the present invention. It should be understood that the prosthesis used herewith has been provided with the pair oflegs 33, 35 for straddling and gripping a portion of the vein graft ormembrane 27. Thejig fixture 51 includes amain body 53 and an upwardly directedridge 55 fixedly attached to themain body 53 for insertion between the pair oflegs 33, 35 to urge thebight portion 31 of the vein graft ormembrane 27 between thelegs 33, 35 for the retention thereof after withdrawal of theridge 55. Thejig 51 preferably includes a pair or remotely disposedledges 57 which are attached to themain body 53 for restingly supporting remote margin portion of the vein graft ormembrane structure 27, i.e., the margin portions shown by the numerals 27' and 27 (FIG. 6). prior to attachment of the membrane to the prosthesis 11. From FIG. 3 of the drawing it may readily be seen that theledges 57 extend parallel with theridge 55 and are disposed at predetermined spaced apart distances therefrom. thus defining a pair ofchannels 56, 58 for receiving therespective legs 33. 35 in a manner yet to be fully disclosed.
It should be pointed out that the structure depicted in FIGS. 1 through 10 of the drawing is several times the actual size. In'this regard,th efiht effuption 37 appears exaggerated in width. In other words, theactual piston member 13 may suitably be provided with theaperture 29 and the interruption may be formed with a very thin knife (not shown) or razor blade, i.e., preferably removing none of the Teflon in the severing process. More specifically, typical diameters for thepiston member 13 are 0.6 millimeters and 0.8 millimeters. Further, typical lengths for the prosthesis 11 not including theshepherds crook 17 are: 3.5 millimeters; 3.75 millimeters; 4.0 millimeters ranging on up to 5.75- millimeters or the like. Accordingly, thejig fixture 51 is compatibly sized with the prosthesis l1 and in itself would be very small and have little mass. Therefore, stand means 59, as shown in FIG. 5, is herein disclosed for supporting thejig fixture 51 in a fixed position to facilitate the utilization thereof, thejig fixture 51 being phantomized in a preferred position therein. More specifically, the stand means 59 includes a substantiallyheavy base portion 61 having astanchion 63 for suitably receiving and supporting thejig fixture 51. From FIGS. 6 through 8 of the drawing it may be seen that thejig fixture 51 is provided with abore 65 for receiving thestanchion 63.
Several advantages are gained by attaching the distal e to the. ve.i n...g.@ ft czt. mmbrane al? First. thepiston member 13 and the vein graftor mem branestructure 27 are held together during the healing or growth period during which time the vein graft attaches itself permanently to thepiston 13. Second, thedistal end 25 of thepiston 13 is positioned substantially in the center of theoval window 45 with assurance that it will remain intact. Heretofore when the gelfoam was packed in the oval window or when the gelfoam was packed on the vein graft it was difficult if not impossible to determine exactly whether the piston was centrally positioned or for that matter whether it actually is in contact with the vein graft. Third, thepiston member 13 is supported in an upright manner, i.e., supported in an axis perpendicular to the general plane of the vein graft ormembrane 27, thus making the task of placing the prosthesis in the proper position easier.
This is because the vein graft ormembrane 27 is' aligned with the periphery of thejig 51. Thepiston member 13 is placed in the center of thejig 51 when made to engage the graft in a manner yet to be described.
From FIG. 4 of the drawing it may be seen that the extreme distal end of thepiston member 13 defines oval-like foot portions 67. Thefoot portions 67 prefer ably do not have sharp corners so as to avoid rupturing the vein graft ormembrane 27. It should also be pointed out that the prosthesis 11 of the present invention performs more closely to thestapes 16 than prior known devices. More specifically, from FIG. 9 of the drawing it may be seen that the stapes 16 includes a pair oflegs 69, 71 which transmit the vibrations from theincus 19 to thefoot plate 43. Thus, thelegs 33, I
correspond to thelegs 69, 71 and vibrate in a manner similar thereto and aid in transmitting the sound waves with the inner car.
A method of attaching the prosthesis I1 and the vein graft ormembrane 27 one to the other is also disclosed herein as sequentially depicted in FIGS. 6 through 8 of the drawing. Morespecifically, t he rn ethod herein dis closed includes the steps of: First, providing theabovedisclosed jig fixture 51. Second, providing thedistal end 25 of the prosthesis 11 with the above-describedlegs 33, 35 for gripping the vein graft ormembrane 27. Third, placing the vein graft ormembrane 27 over theridge 55 of the fixture 51 (FIG. 6) with theridge 55 restingly supporting a portion of the vein graft ormembrane 27 intermediate remote edges or margins 37'27" thereof. Care should be taken to place the advantitia thereof upward so that the vein graft will be properly oriented when placed over the oval window. Fourth, placing thedistal end 25 of the prosthesis 11 upon thejig fixture 51 with theinterruption 37 being aligned with theridge 55 and with the vein graft ormembrane structure 27 being sandwiched therebetween as indicated in FIG. 6 of the drawing. Fifth, thrusting the prosthesis 11 downwardly, while being supported in a substantially upright position, to drive theridge 55 and thebight portion 31 of the vein graft ormembrane structure 27 between thelegs 33, 35 of the prosthesis 11, as clearly shown in FIG. 7 of the drawing. In this connection, it will be understood that thenotches 39 aid in performing this step since theridge 55 is guided into position between thelegs 33, 35 by thenotches 39. Sixth, withdrawing the prosthesis 11 from thejig 51 with thebight portion 31 of the vein graft ormembrane structure 27 being grippingly attached to the prosthesis 11 as indicated in FIG. 8 of the drawing.
Although the invention has been described and illustrated with respect to a preferred embodiment thereof, it is to be understood that it is not to be so limited since changes and modifications may be made therein which I claim:
1. In combination with membrane structure of a prosthesis for use in otological surgery to replace the stapes of the middle ear, said prosthesiscomprising a proximal end including means for attachment to the incus, a distal end fixedly attached to said proximal end and including a pair of leg means straddling a bight portion of the membrane structure, said distal end being interrupted along a line extending transversely of said prosthesis to establish said pair of legs, portions of said pair of legs defining a pair of remotely disposed notches respectively leading into remote ends of said interruption for initially receiving and guidingly constraining the bight portion of the membrane structure and certain jig structure for subsequent entry into said interruption whereby said pair of legs may be spread apart to straddle the bight portion of the membrane structure.
2. In combination with membrane structure of a prosthesis for use in otological surgery to replace the stapes of the middle ear, said prosthesis comprising a proximal end including means for attachment to the incus, and a distal end fixedly attached to said proximal end and including a pair of leg means straddling a bight portion are within thefull inte nded scope ofthe invention.
.of the membrane structure, said distal end being interloosely receives the bight portion of the membrane structure, the interruption of said prosthesis extending from the distal exterior thereof to said aperture therein with said pair of leg means grippingly engaging therebetween a double thickness of the membrane structure.
3. The combination of claim 2 in which the extreme distal ends of said pair of leg means respectively define a pair of oval-like foot portions restingly engaging the membrane structure, said pair of leg means including said pair of foot portions being void of sharp corners so as to avoid rupturing the membrane structure.
4. In combination with membrane structure and a jig fixture of a prosthesis for use in otological surgery to replace the stapes of the middle ear, said prosthesis comprising a wirelike proximal end and a cylindrical distal end fixedly attached one to the other, said proximal end including a shepherds crook portion for encircling certain structure of the incus and attachment thereto, said distal end being provided with a transverse aperture which loosely receives a bight portion of the membrane structure, said distal end additionally being interrupted along a transverse line extending parallel with the bore of said aperture and extending longitudinally from the distal exterior of said prosthesis to said aperture therein to establish in part a pair of legs with an interruption therebetween, said distal end further being provided with a pair of notches respectively disposed adjacent the remote ends of said aperture and leading into said interruption for selectively initially receiving and guidingly constraining the bight portion of the membrane structure and certain structure of the jig fixture for subsequent entry into said interruptiomsaid legs being resilient and adapted to be spread by saidjig fixture while the bight portion of the membrane is urged therebetween and to grippingly engage and retain a double thickness of the membrane structure after. the withdrawal of said jig fixture.
5. An improvement in a prosthesis for use in otological surgery to replace the stapes of the middle ear, said prosthesis being for use in conjunction with certain membrane structure and including a proximal end having means thereon for attachment to the incus, said improvement comprising a pair of leg means disposed adjacent the distal end of said prosthesis and depending therefrom for gripping engagement with a bight portion of the membrane structure, the distal end of said prosthesis being interrupted along a line extending transversely thereof to establish said pair of legs with an interruption space therebetween to receive a bight portion of the membrane structure, said distal end further being provided with a transverse aperture for loosely receiving the bight portion of the membrane structure, said interruption space of said prosthesis extending longitudinally from the distal exterior thereof to said aperture therein for grippingly engaging a double thickness of the membrane structure.
6. A prosthesis for use in otological surgery to replace the stapes of the middle ear, said prosthesis being for use in conjunction with a jig fixture and certain membrane structure and comprising a wirelike proximal end and cylindrical distal end fixedly attached one to the other, said proximal end including a shepherds crook portion for encircling certain structure of the incus and attachment thereto, said distal end being provided with a transverse aperture for loosely receiving a bight portion of the membrane structure, said distal end additionally being interrupted along a transverse line extending parallel with the bore of said aperture and extending longitudinally from the distal exterior of said prosthesis to said aperture therein to establish in part a pair of legs with an interruption therebetween, said distal end further being provided with a pair of notches respectively disposed adjacent the remote ends of said aperture and leading into said interruption for selectively initially receiving and guidingly constraining the bight portion of the membrane structure and certain structure of the jig fixture for subsequent entry into said interruption, and said legs being resilient and adapted to be spread by said jig fixture while the bight portion of the membrane is urged therebetween and to grippingly engage and retain a doublethickness of the membrane structure after the withdrawal of said jig tixture.
7. An improvement in a prosthesis for use in otological surgery to replace the stapes of the middle ear, said prosthesis being for use in conjunction with certain membrane structure and including a proximal end having means thereon for attachment to the incus, said improvement comprising a pair of leg means disposed adjacent the distal end of said prosthesis and depending therefrom for gripping engagement with a bight portion of the membrane structure, the distal end of said prosthesis being interrupted along a line extending transversely thereof to establish said pair of legs with an interruption therebetween to receive a bight portion of the membrane structure, said distal end further being provided with a transverse aperture for loosely receiving the bight portion of the membrane structure, said interruption of said prosthesis extending longitudinally from the distal exterior thereof to said aperture therein for grippingly engaging a double thickness of the membrane structure and the extreme distal ends of said pair of leg means respectively defining a pair of oval-like foot portions for restingly engaging the membrane structure, said pair of leg means including said pair of foot portions being void of sharp corners so as to avoid rupturing the membrane structure.