CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONSThis application is based upon and claims the benefit of priority from U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 61/319,873 filed Apr. 1, 2010 and U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 61/354,498 filed Jun. 14, 2010, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
FIELDEmbodiments of the present invention relate to the field of communications, and in particular an advanced digital television receiver and a corresponding method of distributing and responding to a preference, demographic and/or interest (PDI) questionnaire.
BACKGROUNDTraditional media distribution systems such as broadcasting lack the ability to effectively characterize and respond to consumer preferences in order to provide customized media content, namely content that includes targeted advertising or marketing material directed to interests of a particular user. In other words, conventional broadcasting does not account for situations where different viewers have different interests, and thus, their preferences with respect to programming and information differ vastly. For example, some viewers may want to watch sports broadcasting while other viewers may prefer a different genre (e.g. home improvement, historical fact based programs, etc.).
Furthermore, due to geographic location, some viewers may not be interested in certain media content. For example, a particular advertisement for local services may be suitable for viewers living in the geographic area served by the advertiser, but may not be suitable for viewers living in a different area.
Currently, there are no standardized methods to specify how viewers might customize their viewing preferences with respect to the content and services they receive. Existing systems may typically filter out program content based on viewer preference settings established in the receiver by the manufacturer of that receiver, with no input from the service provider as to the types of filtering criteria that might be suitable for the particular service.
Also, service providers do not have access to the viewer preference settings, and thus are unable to directly tailor the user's experience of the service based on those settings. Yet, even if service providers had access to viewer preferences, there is no mechanism that is configured to avoid redundant inquiries to learn about the viewer's preferences, as different service providers may solicit the same information through different, but highly similar inquiries.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGSEmbodiments of the present invention are illustrated by way of example, and not by way of limitation, in the figures of the accompanying drawings and in which:
FIG. 1 is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of a digital broadcasting system.
FIG. 2 is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of a digital receiver implemented within an electronic device of the digital broadcasting system.
FIG. 3A is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of a receiver receiving a triggered declarative object (TDO).
FIG. 3B is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of a receiver receiving non-real time (NRT) triggered declarative objects (TDOs).
FIG. 4 is a block diagram illustrating another embodiment of a receiver that is adapted to receive non-real time (NRT) content
FIG. 5 is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of a system for storing and manipulating a PDI questionnaire in a receiver.
FIG. 6 is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of a system for altering content based on answers to a PDI questionnaire in a receiver.
FIG. 7A is an exemplary diagram illustrating a first embodiment directed to the registration of questions within a PDI questionnaire.
FIG. 7B is an exemplary diagram illustrating a second embodiment directed to the registration of questions within a PDI questionnaire.
FIG. 8A is an exemplary diagram illustrating one embodiment of a system and method for receiving a PDI questionnaire.
FIG. 8B is an exemplary diagram illustrating one embodiment of a system and method for interacting with the viewer to receive answers to the PDI questionnaire at a receiver.
FIG. 9 is an illustration of an example of a data structure in XML format for representation of PDI questions. As illustrated, standardization of preferences, demographics, and interests (PDIs) involve definition of a standard format for a representation of a downloadable questionnaire.
FIG. 10 is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of a PDI container.
DETAILED DESCRIPTIONOne embodiment of the invention relates to a digital receiver described herein. According to this embodiment of the invention, the digital receiver comprises a storage device and logic. The storage device is configured to store both (i) questions received from at least one service provider of a digital broadcast system and (ii) answers to the questions by one or more users. The logic is configured to process data received from the at least one service provider based on answers provided by the user(s).
Herein, according to one embodiment of the invention, the questionnaire and answers are stored locally. As an example, a first eXtensible Markup Language (XML) schema may be configured to represent a first set of questions and associated answer formats registered and accessible to all service providers. Similarly, a second XML schema may be configured for answers to the first set of questions for at least one user of the digital receiver. It is contemplated that the questions set forth in the first XML schema may be subject to public redistribution to avoid duplicative questions from being posed to the user during set-up, immediately after power-on, or at another point in time while the receiver is in operation.
Alternatively, it is contemplated that the first XML schema may represent (i) the first set of registered questions that are accessible to all service providers, (ii) a second set of registered questions that are service provider specific and have access restrictions (e.g., only accessible by the specific service provider), and (iii) answers formats for both sets of questions.
Herein, certain terminology is used to describe features of the invention. For example, the term “logic” is generally defined as hardware and/or software. As hardware, logic may include processing circuitry (e.g., a microprocessor, a programmable gate array, a controller, an application specific integrated circuit, etc.), semiconductor memory, combinatorial logic, or the like. As software, the logic may be one or more software modules, such as executable code in the form of an application, an application programming interface (API), an applet, a routine, or one or more instructions. These software modules may be stored in any type of a suitable non-transitory storage medium such as a programmable circuit, a semiconductor memory such as a volatile memory (e.g., random access memory (RAM), etc.) or non-volatile memory (e.g., read-only memory, power-backed RAM, flash memory, etc.), a hard disk drive, an optical disk drive, a portable memory device (e.g., a Universal Serial Bus “USB” flash drive, optical disc, etc.), or the like.
An “electronic device” generally represents electronics with information processing capabilities such as a digital receiver for example. As optional features, electronic device may include a display (e.g., liquid crystal diode (“LCD”), organic LCD (OLCD), plasma, etc.) and speakers to support video/audio playback.
An “interconnect” is generally defined as a communication pathway established over an information-carrying medium. This information-carrying medium may be a physical medium (e.g., electrical wire, optical fiber, cable, bus traces, etc.), a wireless medium (e.g., air in combination with wireless signaling technology) or a combination thereof.
A “service provider” generally represents a source and/or distributor of content. Examples of a service provider may include, but are not limited or restricted to a television network operator (e.g. local network television station, affiliate, cable television provider, telco, terrestrial, satellite TV provider, Internet service provider, etc.), an entity supplying access to stored content (e.g., Netflix®, etc.), or the like.
Certain details are set forth below in order to provide a thorough understanding of various embodiments of the invention, albeit the invention may be practiced through many embodiments other that those illustrated. Well-known logic and operations are not set forth in detail in order to avoid unnecessarily obscuring this description.
FIG. 1 is an exemplary block diagram illustrating one embodiment of a digitaltelevision service system100. Abroadcast system110 receives content from one ormore service providers120, and thereafter, transmits such content to anelectronic device130 overinterconnect140.
According to one embodiment of the invention, the transmitted content includes one or more of the following: non-real-time (NRT) content, real-time or linear content, metadata associated with content, a questionnaire, and a triggered declarative object (TDO).
Herein, the NRT content comprises content that may be delivered faster or slower than real-time or may be delivered based on a request. For instance, according to one embodiment of the invention, the NRT content may include video and/or audio, images, text (e.g., descriptions of available video and/or audio for download), and/or hyperlinks to websites that can be displayed by a web browser executed byelectronic device130.
According to one embodiment of the invention, a user can select NRT content from a list of NRT content stored atservice provider120 for later download. The user can also navigate and select NRT content from among previously downloaded content or the downloading of content may be performed in accordance with advanced services.
According to one embodiment of the invention, “advanced services” may include user-controlled downloading of non-real time content, user interactivity with the downloaded content, or any user-controlled feature supported by Advanced Television Systems Committee (ATSC) or other specifications developed for digital television transmission over terrestrial, cable and satellite networks. Of course, the invention may be applicable to advanced services in compliance with other data conveyance standards, including Internet Protocol Television (IPTV).
Herein, advanced services associated with NRT content may be request-based or automated whereelectronic device130, at least including a digital receiver, updates content associated with a service. For automated services, the receiver caches service-related content and automatically updates files as new versions are made available. For request-based “push” service, content that has been preloaded is displayed.
Metadata associated with content describes the available content and services.
The electronic questionnaire is adapted to allow users to specify various items of information about themselves, which allowselectronic device130 to tailor advanced services based on the users' individual interests and preferences. According to one embodiment of the invention, the questionnaire includes a data structure having a standardized format of preferences, demographics, and/or interests (PDIs) common to one or more service providers. For example, the format of the PDI questionnaire includes questions, each with an answer in a predefined format. Possible answer formats could include yes/no or true/false, text string (with maximum length), multiple choice, integer (with range limits), checklist, among others.FIG. 9 illustrates an example of a format and data structure of an example PDI questionnaire.
A TDO is a downloadable object created by one ofservice providers120 in a content distribution chain, ranging from an original creator or source of the content to the manufacturer of the electronic device adapted to receive the content. According to one embodiment of the invention, a TDO comprises declarative content (e.g., scripts, text, descriptive markup, graphics, etc.) whose function and behavior are tied in some way to the television programming they accompany. For example, a TDO may be adapted with multiple functions such as to collect user response data such as voting on a game show or contest, feedback on televised programming or commercials, feedback on anticipated future events by the user (e.g. activities, upcoming purchases, etc.), or the like.
Referring still toFIG. 1, according to one embodiment of the invention,electronic device130 may be implemented as a set-top box or a display device (e.g., television) that comprises adigital receiver150.Digital receiver150 includeslogic160 configured to process content received frombroadcast system110 as further described below. In one embodiment,logic160 includes a processor capable of handling services broadcast according to Advanced Television Systems Committee (ATSC) standards.
FIG. 2 is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment ofdigital receiver150 implemented withinelectronic device130.Digital receiver150 is adapted to receive both real-time television broadcasts and NRT content.Receiver150 includes a tuner/demodulator200, ademultiplexer210, an audio/video decoder220,processing logic230, and astorage device240.
Tuner200 receives a modulated input signal, tunes and demodulates the signal to produce an output transport stream.Demultiplexer210 demultiplexes the stream to produce data toprocessing logic230. In the case of conventional real-time (linear) TV content, audio and video packets from tuner/demodulator200 are supplied, viademultiplexer210, to A/V decoder220 for decoding. A/V decoder220 supplies an audio output signal and a video output signal to audio and video circuitry of the display device (not shown).
Content including audio/video, PDI questionnaires, NRT files, metadata, and TDOs received atdemultiplexer210 is routed viaprocessing logic230 tostorage device240. According to one embodiment of the invention,storage device240 stores one ormore PDI questionnaires250,answers260 to PDI questionnaire(s)250, as well as content andmetadata270. Herein, aPDI questionnaire250 is a downloadable list of questions that is generated by at least one service provider and has a standardized data structure. These questions can be presented to the user as selective, displayable images or as audio.
Storage device240 may include a disc drive, a non-volatile memory, or any other types of data storage device. When a user instructs the system to play a selected item of NRT content, that content is then processed by processinglogic230 and the processed content is demultiplexed bydemultiplexer210 to provide audio and video packets to A/V decoder220. These audio and video packets are eventually presented to the user.
FIG. 3A is an exemplary block diagram illustrating one embodiment ofreceiver150 receiving triggered declarative objects (TDOs). As previously discussed, TDOs are downloadable objects configured to interact with a user to enhance his/her viewing experience. A user may be notified that an enhanced (interactive) experience is being offered and accompanies a given program.
For instance, according to one illustrative example, a user viewing an advertisement is offered the option to visit a website pertinent to the product or service being advertised. If the questionnaire includes an entry for “what is your zip code,” a Detailed Product Info TDO can condition the response to the user's interest in the product or service on that viewer's physical location. Thus, if the user lives on the west side of the city, the link could take him or her to a dealer located on the west side of the city, or if he or she lives somewhere else, to a different web page.
In another example, the playback of NRT content can be conditioned on answers to the PDI questionnaire. Again using the zip code as an item of personal information known to the system, when the user plays NRT content, specific items of content can be selected based on the viewer's physical location. Thus, an advertisement for a car dealer located in the viewer's neighborhood can be placed into the output stream for that viewer, while other viewers residing in different locations could get alternative advertisements as appropriate.
TDO300 (e.g., scripts and associated data such as graphics, text, audio files, HTML, etc.) may be stored instorage device240.Processing logic230 executes an operation ofTDO300 with aTDO engine310. For example,processing logic230 executes a script of Detailed Product Info TDO to display the option to visit websites in which further information about a product or service may be found.
Storage device240 also includes one ormore PDI questionnaires250 and PDI answers260. PDI answers260 contain answers to the questions in PDI questionnaire(s)250 such as, for this example, the viewer's zip code. PDI questionnaire(s)250 andanswers260 may be in a standardized data structure format common to various service providers.
According to one embodiment of the invention, when executed byTDO engine310,TDO300 accesses PDI answers260 through an Application Programming Interface (API) and exhibits actions and behaviors conditionally based on responses recorded in PDI answers260. A script inTDO300 could, for example, create one user experience if the age of the oldest TV-watching member of the household is 35 or less and a different experience otherwise. Different user experiences can include display of different text or graphics, branching to different audio/video content, and including different choices in a list.
In another embodiment of the invention, selectedcontent320 from theTDO300 in response to PDI answers260 may be stored withinstorage device240.
FIG. 3B is an exemplary block diagram illustrating one embodiment ofreceiver150 receiving non-real time (NRT) triggered declarative objects (TDOs). Similarly,processing logic230 executes a script fromNRT TDO350 with aNRT TDO engine360. For example,NRT TDO350 includes all the functionality of aregular TDO300 ofFIG. 3A, and in addition may include references to NRT content and scripted control objects that, if activated,cause receiver150 to set up a future download of an NRT content item, and/or hyperlinks that allow playback of previously downloaded content.
In one embodiment, when executed inengine360, the script inNRT TDO350 accessesPDI questionnaire250 and PDI answers260 through an API and behaves based on PDI answers260. For example, a script in aNRT TDO350 could offer the user with a choice to select and purchase a baseball game program for a particular team based the user's interest in sports and baseball as captured in PDI answers260 (assuming questions in these categories are included in the questionnaire).
FIG. 4 is a block diagram illustrating another embodiment ofreceiver150 that is adapted to receive non-real time (NRT) content.Processing logic230 filters content according to PDI answers260 toPDI questionnaire250 using a content filter/matching engine400 in lieu of TDOs. For example,processing logic230 matches a local advertisement based on a geographic region of the user as specified in his/her PDI answers260. Metadata received atprocessing logic230 is tied to questions withinPDI questionnaire250 that are assigned an ID value. As such,filter engine400 is able to know which PDI answer relates to the PDI question directed to the geographic location of the user.
In one embodiment,processing logic230 filters and stores NRT content ofinterest410 based on the interest of the user. For example, movie previews or trailers matching the preference (e.g., action, drama, comedy, etc. . . . ) of the user as set forth in PDI answers260 are stored instorage device240.
FIG. 5 is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of a system for storing and manipulating PDI questionnaires in a receiver. Aservice provider120 generates aPDI questionnaire250 that is transmitted todigital receiver150. An API forPDI manipulation500 allows forreceiver150 to storePDI questionnaire250 instorage device240. A user (e.g., viewer) is able to generate, update, and deletePDI answers260 to questions withinPDI questionnaire250 viaPDI manipulation application510. In one example,PDI manipulation application510 takes the form of a set-up screen on a display device coupled toreceiver150.
In another embodiment, aweb browser520 ofreceiver150 includes ascript530 configured to write and generatePDI answers260 toPDI questionnaire250.
FIG. 6 is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of a system for altering content based on answers to a PDI questionnaire in a receiver. Atblock600, the PDI questionnaire is displayed via the user's interaction with one or more set-up screens to solicit answers pertaining to preferences, demographics and interests of one or more users of the electronic device.
Thereafter, when in operation, the digital receiver within the electronic device receives content from a service provider (block610). The receiver captures, matches, or filters such content based on PDI answers (block620). The content of interest (e.g. content that matches the preferences of the user as specified in the PDI answers) can be stored in the storage device240 (block630).
It is contemplated that these PDI questions and corresponding answers may be collected as the user interacts with the receiver via a set-up menu, and may be stored in the receiver for use by provider-supplied applications, including the TDOs (block640). This collection (and subsequent registration) of PDI questions/answers provide a platform to avoid duplicate query questions from multiple service providers.
One technique for avoiding question duplication is to utilize a registration entity and registration process for questions (and the associated answer format). Once registered, a question is assigned a question identifier. As a result, service providers can use the same question identifier to solicit the desired information in lieu of issuing substantially similar questions. This avoids the need for the digital receiver to recognize and handle duplicate questions, and eliminates the possibility that a user would be asked multiple times essentially the same question in different ways (or in exactly the same way).
FIG. 7A is an exemplary diagram illustrating a first embodiment directed to the registration of questions within a PDI questionnaire. Herein, according to one embodiment of the invention, in efforts to develop aquestion registry700,service provider120 transmits aquestion inquiry request710 to aregistration entity720. The “registration entity” may be a governmental agency, a third-party entity (e.g., Advanced Television Systems Committee “ATSC” or other standards body, bank or trusted institution, etc.) or any entity assigned the responsibility of receiving questions that are to be used for a PDI questionnaire, checking for duplicates, and (assuming the request is accepted) assigning question identifiers for each of these questions.
Question inquiry request710 is information that identifies a proposed question for registration and subsequent inclusion in the PDI questionnaire downloaded to (or stored by manufacturer within) receivers. As an example,question inquiry request710 comprises (i)information730 that identifies a reply format to the question (e.g., Boolean, integer type, single/multiple selection, variable text, etc.), and (ii) the proposedquestion735.
In response toquestion inquiry request710,service provider120 receives a returnedresponse740 that identifies whether thequestion inquiry request710 has been granted or denied. In particular, upon granting the request,response740 includes (i)information750 to identify whether the request has been granted, and (ii) aquestion identifier755 that uniquely identifies the registered question. For instance,question identifier755 may include a registration number forquestion735.
Alternatively, upon denying the request,response740 includes (i)information760 to identify whether the request has been denied, and (ii)information765 to identify the reason(s) for the denial. For instance,information765 may be a code value that indicates that the question has already been registered, and perhaps the unique question identifier of the pre-existing item may be provided. Alternatively,information765 may be a code value that indicates that the question contains inappropriate language or subject matter and is denied registration for this reason.
It is contemplated that, as an optional feature,registration entity720 may be adapted to receive anappeal inquiry770 that includes information within inquiry request710 (e.g.,reply format information730 and proposed question735),information765 to identify the reason(s) for the denial, andinformation775 provided by service provider as to the errors associated with the denial. Information may be a code value (e.g., mistaken relatedness with proposed question, etc.) or may include a textual description of the registration error.Appeal inquiry770 can be evaluated separately (and in more detail) than inquiry requests.
Referring now toFIG. 7B, an exemplary diagram illustrating a second embodiment directed to the registration of questions within the PDI questionnaire is shown. Herein,question registry700 is developed similar to the operations set forth inFIG. 7A. However,question inquiry request780 features a different format. More specifically,question inquiry request780 comprises (i)optional information730 that identifies a reply format to the question (e.g., Boolean, integer type, single/multiple selection, variable text, etc.), (ii) the proposedquestion735, and (iii)information785 to identify particulars (e.g. question types and sub-types) ofquestion735 such as the following: type of question (e.g. what preference, demographic or interest), or question sub-type (e.g., is question directed to racial inquiries with respect to demographics, is question directed to financial means with respect to demographics, is question directed to preference such as sports one likes to watch, etc.). Theseparticulars785 are used to categorize the question inquiry requests received from the receiver to assist in producing more timely (and accurate) responses to these requests.
Referring now toFIG. 8A, an exemplary diagram illustrating one embodiment of a portion of a system and method for receiving a PDI questionnaire at a receiver is shown. At decision block810, the receiver checks to see if any PDI questionnaire is present in storage in the receiving device. If not, the questionnaire is retrieved and the process completes (block820). If a PDI questionnaire was downloaded previously, the receiver checks to see if a newer version is available (block830). If not, the process completes, otherwise the existing stored questionnaire is updated to overwrite it with the new version (block840).
Referring now toFIG. 8B, an exemplary diagram illustrating one embodiment of processing of the PDI questionnaire in the receiver is shown. Herein, at block850, a receiver accesses and sends a signal for displaying a set-up or preference screen. The receiver determines whether a PDI questionnaire is available at block860. If the receiver does not currently have a PDI questionnaire in storage, the receiver displays a screen indicating that personalization cannot occur until a later time, and the process ends.
At block870, questions from the PDI questionnaire are displayed to the user. At block880, the user inputs answers in response to the PDI questions. At block890, the PDI answers are stored in a storage device of the receiver.
Herein, according to this embodiment of the invention, the registration entity provides unique identifiers for each submitted question/answer format. For this embodiment of the invention, the registration entity is publicly accessible so that if another provider wishes to ask the same question, the question identifier associated with the desired question can be used as a reference. The registration process also allows service providers to use common wording for a given question.
FIG. 9 is an illustration of an example of a data structure in XML format for representation of PDI questions. As illustrated, standardization of preferences, demographics, and interests (PDIs) involve definition of a standard format for a downloadable questionnaire. The format of the questionnaire may include, but are not limited or restricted toquestion type identifier900,question identifier910,question920, and candidate answer(s)930 for the question.
Question type identifier900 identifies possible reply formats such as yes/no or true/false (QBA—Question Boolean Answer), text string (with maximum length) (QTA—Question Text Answer), multiple choice (QSA—Question Selection Answer), integer (with range limits) (QIA—Question Integer Answer), checklist, etc. Moreover, each question type identifier may further include an optional lifetime parameter to denote a lifetime of the answer to the question (or perhaps the question itself).
For instance, as shown inFIG. 9,QIA940 concerning the oldest member of the household includes alifetime attribute950 that may be used to identify the number of time units (e.g., minutes, hours, days, weeks, months, years, etc.) before the applicability of the answer expires. Of course,lifetime attribute950 alternatively may be used to identify the duration of the question. Upon expiration of the question, the PDI questionnaire may be updated to seek alternative questions for use in subsequent filtering of content.
The checklist reply format allows a user to provide a yes/no response to a number of different small items. For example, as shown inFIG. 9, the query string might be “in which of the following sports are you interested in viewing?” The checklist might include baseball, basketball, soccer, and hockey. Each of the items in the checklist may be selected or not selected. As previously discussed, access by receiver applications and TDOs to the PDI answers are made available via an API.
Question identifier910 allows the receiver to identify the question. For example, a question common to all service provider may feature a predetermined range (e.g., identification value≦255). Furthermore,question identifier910 allows a question to be associated with a particular service provider. For example, a service provider may be interested in asking if the user has any ideas to make interactive TV services more valuable or attractive. Likewise, question identifier910 (id value≧256) allows the service provider to uniquely identify and associate the question with one or more service provider.
Question element “q”920 includes the actual question (e.g. “are you currently employed?”).
Candidate answers930 associated withquestion920 are listed. For instance, a multiple choice reply format would allow the user to select from among a fixed number of identified choices or a single choice. As an example, a query string could be “Do you enjoy camping and outdoor recreation?” The corresponding multiple choice answer might include the possibilities “Never,” “Occasionally,” or “Frequently.”
It is noted that, for questions having multiple section or checklist formats, each answer may be associated with an identifier as well. For instance, the sport “hockey” may be identified by an answer value “413” while “baseball” may be identified by an answer value “411”. These values may be used to produce an answer compilation for the question. Alternatively, in lieu of the specific answers themselves, the collection of answers (e.g. candidate answers930) may be assigned an answer value.
FIG. 10 is a block diagram illustrating one embodiment of a structure of aPDI container1000. Generated and manipulated through an API implemented on the receiver,PDI container1000 comprises a plurality of PDI data structures10101-1010M(M≧2). More specifically, according to this embodiment of the invention, each PDI data structure1010i(1≦i≦M) includes defined syntax, representation and matching schema utilized by one or more service providers. For instance, PDI data structure1010Mcomprises aquestion identifier value910Mthat is used to identify the particular question registered withregistration entity920 ofFIG. 9. It is further contemplated that PDI data structure1010Mmay further comprise at least q-element920Mthat identifies the question per se, andquestion type identifier900Mthat identifies possible reply formats such as Boolean answers (QBA), text string (QTA), multiple choice (QSA), integer (QIA), checklist, etc.
It is contemplated thatPDI container1000 may be configured with a format for the storage of PDI answers. As an example, each of the PDI data structures (e.g., data structure1010M) may include, but are not limited or restricted toquestion type identifier900M,question identifier910M, and an answer value (not shown). The answer value represents those items selected by the user at the receiver.
It is to be understood that the above description is intended to be illustrative, and not restrictive. Many other embodiments will be apparent to those of skill in the art upon reading and understanding the above description. The scope of the invention should, therefore, be determined with reference to the appended claims, along with the full scope of equivalents to which such claims are entitled.