Disclosure of Invention
In view of the above, the present invention provides an electric vehicle frequency modulation control strategy based on model prediction. The invention divides the electric automobile participating in frequency modulation into a discharging group and a charging group, realizes the control of the charging and discharging times by controlling the conversion times of the electric automobile between the charging and discharging groups in the frequency modulation process, and provides a frequency modulation power distribution scheme based on the controllable capacity of the electric automobile cluster. And predicting the controllable capacity of the electric automobile at the next moment and reporting the predicted controllable capacity to a power grid regulation and control center. And the power grid regulation and control center reports the controllable capacity distribution frequency modulation power according to the EVA so as to reduce the frequency modulation risk caused by sudden disconnection of the electric automobile from the power grid.
In order to achieve the purpose, the invention provides the following technical scheme:
the electric vehicle frequency modulation control strategy based on model prediction comprises the following steps:
s1: the method comprises the steps that a power grid regulation and control center obtains load disturbance and frequency fluctuation information from a regional substation, and obtains Electric Vehicle (EV) information of a power grid accessed in a region from an Electric Vehicle cluster (EVA);
s2: an electric automobile accessed into a power grid in the EVA collection area to participate in system frequency modulation participates in frequency modulation time period, State of Charge (SOC) and controllable capacity information;
s3: the SOC of the power grid EV is accessed according to whether the SOC reaches the grouping standard SOCmDivided into a discharge group or a charge group;
s4: according to the predicted EVA frequency modulation controllable capacity Rj+1With the required power P for frequency modulationtaskThe specific EV output in the discharging group or the charging group is distributed to participate in frequency modulation;
s5: the EVA reports the EV information to a power grid regulation and control center, the power grid regulation and control center distributes the frequency modulation power required by the system to the EVA according to the frequency fluctuation and the EV information, an instruction is given to the network-access EV through the EVA, and the EV receives the instruction and achieves the purpose of adjusting the frequency through charging and discharging.
Further, the steps S3-S4 specifically include:
EV access to the grid is accessThe controllable state is used for receiving a frequency modulation task; the EV is converted from the controllable state to the controllable state; SOCi,jThe energy storage state at the moment j is the ith EV;
EV is controlled in state and is divided into discharge groups if SOC isi,j>SOCminThe frequency modulation device is kept in a discharge group, and discharge participates in frequency modulation;
EV is controlled in state and is divided into discharge groups if SOC isi,j≤SOCminTransferring to a charging group, and charging to participate in frequency modulation;
EV is controlled to be in a charging group, if SOC isi,j<SOCmaxThe charging group is kept, and the charging participates in frequency modulation;
EV is controlled in state and is divided into discharge groups if SOC isi,j≥SOCmaxTransferring into a discharging group, and discharging to participate in frequency modulation;
the EV exits frequency modulation from the discharging group or the charging group and enters a charging state to meet the travel requirement.
Further, the EV satisfies the following conditions in the frequency modulation process:
at time j, the i-th EV charge/discharge power is P
i,j,
For the discharge power of the EV during the frequency modulation,
charging power of EV in frequency modulation process; discharging is positive and charging is negative;
number Num of charging and discharging times in EV frequency modulation processi,jThe definition is that every time the EV participates in the change of the frequency modulation form, namely the change from discharging to charging or the change from charging to discharging, the charging and discharging times are increased by 1 time:
Numi,jfrequency modulation of ith EV at time j-iNumber of charge and discharge cycles in the process, Pi,j-1Charging and discharging power in the ith EV frequency modulation process at the moment j-1;
considering the limitation of charging and discharging times of the EV, the accessed power grid EV is divided into a discharging group DC and a charging group C, and the kth discharging group and the charging group are respectively as follows:
wherein K is 1,2, …, and K is the maximum group number of the discharging groups or the charging groups;
and
are respectively a discharge group
And a charging group
The number of the medium elements, the number of the discharge resistors and the number of the EV in the charging group are respectively as follows:
and
further, the controllable capacity R of frequency modulationj+1The prediction of (a) is specifically:
at the moment j, predicting that the EV frequency modulation controllable capacities of the discharging group and the charging group in the EVA at the moment j +1 are respectively
And
then
Wherein p is
iCharging and discharging power limit for the ith EV;
the capacity is controlled by upper frequency modulation;
to down-modulate the controllable capacity.
Further, the required power P of frequency modulationtaskThe calculation is specifically as follows:
at the moment j +1, the EV frequency modulation output is determined by the frequency modulation controllable capacity of the moment j +1 predicted at the moment j, and if delta f is the system frequency variation, when delta f is less than 0, PtaskWhen the frequency is more than 0, EV discharge participates in frequency modulation, and the frequency modulation rate is increased:
(1) if it is not
Discharge group EV discharge power is
(2) If it is not
The EV frequency modulation controllable capacity of the discharge group exceeds the system frequency modulation required power; in the frequency modulation process, EV participates in the contribution degree of time according to the unit
Selective discharge defined as
In the formula (d)
iGiving a controllable time for the ith vehicle EV;SOC
i,j+1Is composed of
Wherein E isevThe total energy stored for a single EV battery; etacAnd ηdcEV charge efficiency and discharge efficiency, respectively;
of EVs
The larger the EVA is, the better the EVA is to call and participate in discharge frequency modulation,
sort from big to small
Is composed of
In the formula (I), the compound is shown in the specification,
representing the maximum value of the contribution degree of the discharge group EV unit participation time at the moment j + 1;
in the discharge group for indicating j +1 moment
The contribution degree of the unit participation time of the theta-th EV is sorted from large to small, and satisfies
Wherein [ P ]
task]Represents a pair P
taskGetting the whole;
then the set of EVs participating in the discharge
Is composed of
Discharge group EV discharge power is
Frequency-modulated output on EVA discharge set
Is composed of
When Δ f > 0, PtaskWhen the frequency is less than 0, the EV charging participates in frequency modulation, and the frequency is adjusted downwards:
(1) if it is not
EV charging power of charging group is
(2) If it is not
The controllable capacity of the charging group EV exceeds the system frequency modulation required power;
in the frequency modulation process, EV participates in the contribution degree of time according to the unit
Selective charging, defined as
Of EVs
The larger the EVA is, the better the EVA is to call and participate in charging frequency modulation,
sort from big to small
Comprises the following steps:
in the formula (I), the compound is shown in the specification,
representing the maximum value of the contribution degree of the charging group EV unit participation time;
indicating charging group at
time j +1
The contribution degree of the unit participation time of the theta-th EV is sorted from large to small, and satisfies
Then the set of EVs participating in charging
Is composed of
EV charging power of charging group is
Frequency modulation output under EVA charging set
Is composed of
The invention has the beneficial effects that:
(1) by adjusting the distributed power of the electric automobile cluster in real time, the electric automobile can effectively complete the frequency modulation power task distributed by the system, and the problems of poor frequency modulation effect or resource waste caused by unreasonable frequency modulation power distribution are avoided.
(2) By controlling the charging and discharging conversion times, each electric automobile is ensured to participate in service by limited charging and discharging times in the frequency modulation process, and the damage of frequent charging and discharging to the battery can be reduced.
(3) The control strategy provided by the invention can ensure that the driving requirements of electric automobile users are not influenced while the electric automobile participates in the frequency modulation task, and is beneficial to the popularization of the V2G technology.
The invention provides a model prediction-based electric vehicle cluster frequency modulation control strategy aiming at the problems that the frequency modulation power fixedly distributed to an electric vehicle cluster by a system is unreasonable and the electric vehicle is frequently charged and discharged in the frequency modulation process. Under the condition that historical data information of the large-scale electric automobile is lack at present, the example simulation proves that the provided frequency modulation control strategy can reasonably distribute the frequency modulation power of the electric automobile cluster, control the charging and discharging conversion times of the electric automobile and effectively realize regional frequency adjustment.
Detailed Description
Preferred embodiments of the present invention will be described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings.
1. Framework for analyzing frequency modulation strategy of electric vehicle
The system frequency modulation strategy framework of EV participation is shown in FIG. 1. And the power grid regulation and control center respectively acquires load disturbance and frequency fluctuation information from the regional transformer substation and acquires EV information of the power grid accessed in the region from the EVA. And specific information such as a power grid participating system frequency modulation participating time period, a state of charge (SOC), controllable capacity and the like of the electric vehicle accessed into the EVA collection region is provided. And dividing the electric automobile into a charging group and a discharging group according to the SOC state of the EV accessed to the power grid. The EVA reports the EV information to a power grid regulation and control center, the power grid regulation and control center distributes the frequency modulation power required by the system to the EVA according to the frequency fluctuation and the EV information, an instruction is given to the network-access EV through the EVA, and the EV receives the instruction and achieves the purpose of adjusting the frequency through charging and discharging.
The frequency modulation control strategy idea of the electric automobile is shown in fig. 2. When the electric automobile is connected to a power grid, the electric automobile enters a controllable state (called as a controllable state) and receives a frequency modulation task. In addition, the electric vehicle in the controllable state is turned out from the controllable state to be called an out-controllable state. The SOC of the power grid EV is accessed according to whether the SOC reaches the grouping standard SOCmAnd dividing into a discharging group or a charging group. According to the prediction of EVA controllable capacity Rj+1With the required power P for frequency modulationtaskAnd distributing the specific EV output in the discharging group or the charging group to participate in frequency modulation.
2. Electric automobile frequency modulation grouping
The principle of minimizing EV charging and discharging times is that the EVs participating in frequency modulation in the EVA are divided intoA discharge group and a charge group. The EV FM packet rule is shown in Table 1, where SOCi,jAnd the energy storage state at the j moment is the ith EV.
TABLE 1EV FM packet rules
In the process that the EV participates in system frequency modulation, at the time j, the charging and discharging power of the ith EV is Pi,jWhere discharge is assumed herein to be positive and charge is negative.
Number Num of charging and discharging times in EV frequency modulation processi,jThe definition is that every time the EV participates in the change of the frequency modulation form, namely the change from discharging to charging or the change from charging to discharging, the charging and discharging times are increased by 1 time.
Considering the limitation of charging and discharging times of the EV, the accessed power grid EV is divided into a discharging group DC and a charging group C, and the kth discharging group and the charging group are respectively as follows:
wherein K is 1,2, …, K.
And
are respectively a discharge group
And a charging group
The number of the elements in the Chinese character 'Zhongqin'. The discharge resistance and the number of EVs in the charging group are respectively as follows:
3. model prediction based frequency modulated power allocation
In the real-time frequency modulation process, charging and discharging of EVA are carried out according to a frequency modulation distribution power instruction EV to participate in frequency modulation. And the discharging group and the charging group are respectively sequenced according to the contribution degree of the unit participation time of the electric automobile so as to determine the specific vehicle participating in frequency modulation and the output power thereof. EVA and traditional unit frequency modulation power distribution is by system frequency modulation demand power PtaskAnd EVA controllable capacity model prediction decision. PtaskCan be obtained by the load frequency control model. The flow chart of the system frequency modulation is shown in fig. 3.
3.1EVA controlled Capacity prediction
And at the moment j, predicting the controllable capacities of the discharge group and the charging group EV in the EVA at the moment j +1 respectively as shown in the formulas (7) and (8):
wherein p is
iCharging and discharging power limit for the ith EV;
the capacity is controlled by upper frequency modulation;
to down-modulate the controllable capacity. R
j+1Is a frequency modulation controllable capacity.
3.2EV FM Power distribution
Attime j +1, the EV FM output is determined by the controllable capacity at time j +1 of the forecast. Let Δ f be the system frequency variation.
3.2.1EV upper frequency modulation output
When Δ f < 0, PtaskAnd > 0, discharge is needed to participate in frequency modulation, and the frequency modulation rate is increased:
(1) if it is not
The discharge power of the discharge group EV is shown as the formula (10):
(2) if it is not
The controllable capacity of the discharge group EV exceeds the required power of system frequency modulation. In the frequency modulation process, EV participates in the contribution degree of time according to the unit
Selective discharge, defined as shown in equation (11):
in the formula (d)iOutputting a controllable moment for the ith EV; SOCi,j+1From formula (12):
in the formula, EevThe total energy stored for a single EV battery; etacAnd ηdcEV charge efficiency and discharge efficiency, respectively.
Of EVs
The larger the EVA is, the better the EVA is to call and participate in discharge frequency modulation,
sort from big to small
As shown in formula (13):
in the formula (I), the compound is shown in the specification,
representing the maximum value of the contribution degree of the discharge group EV unit participation time at the moment j + 1;
in the discharge group for indicating j +1 moment
The contribution degree of the unit participation time of the theta-th EV is sorted from large to small, and the formula shown in the formula (14) is satisfied.
In the formula, [ P ]task]Represents a pair PtaskAnd (6) taking the whole.
Then the set of EVs participating in the discharge
As shown in equation (15):
the discharge group EV discharge power is shown as the formula (16):
frequency-modulated output on EVA discharge set
As shown in equation (17):
3.2.2EV Down-regulated output
When Δ f > 0, PtaskLess than 0, charging is needed to participate in frequency modulation, and the frequency is adjusted downwards:
(1) if it is not
Charging group EV charging power is as shown in equation (18):
(2) if it is not
The controllable capacity of the charging group EV exceeds the required power of system frequency modulation. In the frequency modulation process, EV participates in the contribution degree of time according to the unit
Selective charging, defined as shown in equation (19):
of EVs
The larger the EVA is, the better the EVA is to call and participate in charging frequency modulation,
sort from big to small
As shown in equation (20):
in the formula (I), the compound is shown in the specification,
representing the maximum value of the contribution degree of the charging group EV unit participation time;
indicating charging group at
time j +1
The contribution degree of the unit participation time of the theta-th EV is sorted from large to small, and the formula shown in the formula (21) is satisfied.
Then the set of EVs participating in charging
As shown in formula (22):
Charging group EV charging power is as shown in equation (23):
frequency modulation output under EVA charging set
As shown in equation (24):
3.3 frequency modulated Power distribution for conventional units
The EVA and the traditional unit coordinate frequency modulation, the EV charging and discharging are preferably called to participate in the frequency modulation, the EVA cannot independently complete the power required by the frequency modulation, and the traditional unit is called to participate in the frequency modulation. j +1 moment EVA frequency modulation output P
j+1Distributing frequency modulation power to traditional units
Respectively, as shown in formulas (25) and (26):
4. electric automobile frequency modulation model based on model prediction
The load frequency control model is a basic model of the frequency modulation of the power system. The present document is based on a model of a two-zone interconnected system based on a model predictive frequency modulation control strategy, as shown in fig. 4. Wind power random fluctuation and load disturbance modelThe thermal power generating unit adopts a traditional frequency modulation generator set model, a generator-load model 1/(Ms + D) is expressed by adopting a first-order transfer function, and M and D are respectively an inertia constant and a load damping coefficient of the generator. And the frequency modulation control strategy controls charging and discharging of the charging group and the discharging group EV to participate in frequency modulation. 1/(s + T)delay) Representing the effect of delays, T, on system control and communicationdelayReferred to as the system delay time constant. And the LFC Control centers of the two areas adopt a Tie-line frequency deviation Control (TBC) to combine a Control mode of the TBC-TBC to obtain an LFC signal.
Assume that the reference capacity of the whole power system is 50000kVA and the reference frequency is 50 Hz. The simulation parameters of the system model and the simulation parameters of the electric vehicle are shown in tables 2 and 3, respectively.
TABLE 2 simulation System parameters
TABLE 3 parameters of electric vehicles
5 example simulation
5.1 example background
Considering EV user driving habits and daily work driving requirements, the unit time of EV morning arrival follows normal distribution arrival-N (8.5, 0.5)2) Leaving unit time department-N (17.5, 0.5) at night2) And distance traveled follow a lognormal distribution with a mean and variance of 17.9km and 4.9km, respectively. The EV driving speed is 28.5km/h and the energy consumption is 15kWh per hundred kilometers. In the calculation example, the EV participates in frequency modulation in three periods, namely, before work (0-7 periods), in work (8.5-16.8 periods) and after work (18.5-24 periods). EV participation in frequency modulation in each time intervalIndependent single EV charge-discharge conversion times Numi,jThe limit is 2, i.e. the EV is only allowed to be divided into charging and discharging groups at most once in this period: numi,j>And 2, the EV exits the frequency modulation. EV packet standard SOCmVarying with the number of EVs. Example SOCmThe value is 0.431, and the value can be modified according to actual conditions.
Under the influence of wind power random fluctuation and load disturbance, the system frequency modulation required power P is 0-24 hourstaskAs shown in fig. 5.
5.2 example analysis
5.2.1EV frequency modulation output
Zone 1EVs number 3000. In order to prove that the frequency modulation control strategy provided by the method effectively limits the charging and discharging times of the EVs in the frequency modulation process, 4 EVs are randomly taken out for explanation. The frequency modulated output conditions are shown in fig. 6-9.
Fig. 6shows 4 EVSOC variations. The SOC values of 4 EVs attime 0 are 0.644, 0.351, 0.23, and 0.698, respectively. Among them, the SOC values of EV1 and EV4 are higher and divided into the discharge group, and EV2 and EV3 are divided into the charge group. If the higher SOC value is divided into the charging group, the SOC participating in the frequency modulation for a shorter time reaches the upper limit SOCmaxThen, the battery is scratched into a discharging group, the charging and discharging conversion times of the EV are increased, and the damage to the battery is increased; meanwhile, the variable frequency capacity of the EV is reduced, and resources cannot be efficiently utilized. Therefore, the higher SOC EV1 and EV4 were assigned to the discharge group and the lower SOC EV2 and EV3 were assigned to the charge group. Taking EV4 as an example, the specific tuned output is shown in FIGS. 7-9.
Fig. 7, 8 and 9 show the SOC change, power change and number of charge-discharge transitions of EV4 from 0 to 24, respectively. Since the EV is separated from the power grid due to the fact that the owner gets on and off the duty, the EV participates in frequency modulation in 3 time intervals in one day. The initial SOC values of the frequency modulation time interval 1(0-7 time interval) and the frequency modulation time interval 2(8.5-16.8 time interval) are higher, and the discharge groups are divided, and the discharge participates in the up-frequency modulation; and in the frequency modulation period 3(18.5-24 periods), the initial SOC value is lower, the charging group is divided, and the charging participates in frequency modulation.
Takingfrequency modulation period 2 as an example, two states,frequency modulation state 1 andfrequency modulation state 2, are included. SOC remains unchanged inState 1, during which the system frequency increases, PtaskNegative, the frequency needs to be adjusted downwards, and the EV4 is in the discharge group at the moment, so the EV4 does not participate in frequency modulation; SOC decreases inState 2, during which the system frequency decreases, PtaskSince the frequency needs to be adjusted up to positive, the EV4 discharge participates in the frequency adjustment, and the SOC value decreases. SOC of EV4 reaches SOCminEV4 shifts from the discharge bank to the charge bank, stopping the discharge frequency modulation. The running state refers to that the EV is separated from a power grid and runs to consume electric quantity; the charging state refers to that the EV exits the frequency modulation state before entering the driving state and is charged. In fig. 7, the EV4 reasonably selects the charging time according to the self-driving distance to meet the self-driving demand.
In the SOC value change period in fig. 7, the corresponding frequency modulation power changes as shown in fig. 8. In the 3-4.5 time period of the frequencymodulation time period 1, the up frequency modulation power of the EV4 is 6kW, the charge and discharge power of the EV4 is 0 in the 4.5-7 time period, and the frequency modulation does not output power because the required power of the system frequency modulation is negative, as shown in figure 5, the charging is required to participate in the frequency modulation, and the discharging group stops outputting power at the moment. Frequencymodulation time interval 1, EV4 charge-discharge conversion times Numi,jAt 0, only discharges participate in the frequency modulation, as in periods 0-7 in fig. 9. During the period 7-7.5, the EV4 was in a charged state with a charging power of-6 kW.
In thefrequency modulation period 2, EV4 is in afrequency modulation state 1 in a period of 8.5-13, and the discharge power is 0; EV4 discharge frequency modulation in a period of 13-15.3, the power is-6 kW, and then the SOC of EV4 reaches the off-line SOCminThen the charge and discharge are switched to a charge group, and the number of charge and discharge conversion times is Numi,jNum of EV4,period 1, as in fig. 9, 15.3-18.2i,jRemains at 1. At time 18.2, EV4 entersfm period 3, Numi,jClear 0, i.e. number Num of charge-discharge transitions per fm periodi,jIndependent of each other, and the charging and discharging conversion times Num of each frequency modulation time intervali,jThe maximum is 2. Then entering EV4 entersfm period 3, as above. 7-9 show that the EV charge and discharge times are controlled under the frequency modulation control strategy provided by the invention, so that the damage to the battery is reduced.
The EV is divided into the discharging group and the charging group, so that the reasonable discharging/charging of the EV can participate in frequency modulation within 0-24 hours a day, the driving requirements of an owner on and off duty can be met, and the phenomenon that the SOC of the EV is too low to influence the traveling condition of the owner due to the unclear frequency modulation condition is avoided. Because the work and rest of the car owner on duty and off duty are different, the participating frequency modulation time of each EV is different.
5.2.2EVA frequency modulation output
Based on model prediction, the variation of EVA frequency modulation output inregion 1 is shown in FIGS. 10-14.
The variation of the number of EVs involved in frequency modulation within the EVA charge/discharge cells is shown in fig. 10. In thefrequency modulation period 2, as the system requires continuous discharging in the corresponding period shown in fig. 4, the SOC of the discharging group EV is reduced, the corresponding amount is reduced, the charging group EV is switched to participate in frequency modulation, and the amount of the charging group EV reaches 3000 vehicles at maximum. During the rest of the time period, although the discharging bank and the charging bank EV participate in the frequency modulation, the number of EVs converted between the discharging bank and the charging bank is small, so that the number of each bank is kept relatively stable.
Fig. 11 and fig. 12 show the predicted controllable capacity and actual frequency modulation output of EVA, respectively. The waveform of the upper frequency modulation predicted controllable capacity is consistent with that of the EV number curve of the discharge group in thegraph 10, the waveform of the lower frequency modulation predicted controllable capacity is just opposite to that of the EV number curve of the charge group, the lower frequency modulation predicted controllable capacity is a negative value due to the fact that charging is negative, the maximum value of the absolute value of the lower frequency modulation controllable capacity is 18000kW, and the maximum number of the corresponding charge group is 3000. In comparison to FIG. 12, the predicted controllable capacity value is greater than the actual FM power output, which is represented by PtaskThe value is determined.
FIG. 12 frequency modulated Power output vs. P of FIG. 5 during frequency modulatedperiods 1 and 3taskThe waveforms are consistent, and the frequency modulation control strategy provided by the scheme is shown to control reasonable charging and discharging of the EV to participate in frequency modulation, so that the situation that the EVA is excessively charged and discharged due to unclear frequency modulation instructions is avoided. Within 15-20 periods offrequency modulation period 2, PtaskThe discharging groups are required to discharge frequency modulation, and at the moment, the number of the discharging groups EV is 0, so that the EVA cannot provide power output to participate in frequency modulation, and the EVA frequency modulation power output is 0. Therefore, the frequency modulation task in this time period is completed by the conventional unit, as shown in fig. 13.
Fig. 13 is a comparison of the frequency modulation duty and frequency modulation output of a conventional unit. It can be seen from fig. 5 and 12 that, in the time periods of 8-11 and 15-20, the frequency modulation tasks allocated by the conventional unit make up for the EVA output defect, increase the system frequency modulation power output, and enhance the stability of the system frequency modulation. However, due to the problems of the conventional unit such as start-up and ramp rate, the power output of the conventional unit cannot respond to the frequency change accurately and timely like the EV frequency modulation output, and the actual frequency modulation output is not completely matched with the frequency modulation task, as shown in fig. 13. Because the system frequency is instantaneously changeable, energy storage equipment which is similar to an EV and can quickly respond to the frequency should be added in the frequency modulation system structure, and the efficiency of the system for adjusting the frequency is enhanced.
Fig. 14 shows the system frequency variation. As can be seen, the frequency deviation of V2G is smaller than the frequency deviation of V2G during 3 fm periods. In the interval of the frequency modulation period, the electric automobile is separated from the power grid and cannot participate in system frequency modulation, so that the system frequency deviation is the same. The rms values of the frequency deviations of the system taking account of V2G and not taking account of V2G were 0.0754Hz and 0.08Hz, respectively. Therefore, the adjustment effect of the EV participation system frequency is better than that of the traditional unit.
5.2.3 model predictive comparison
In order to prove the effectiveness of the model prediction strategy provided by the invention on system frequency modulation, the model prediction strategy is particularly compared with a conventional frequency modulation strategy, namely a strategy for distributing the required power of the frequency modulation by adopting a fixed proportion. Setting scenario one as a model prediction strategy proposed herein; and a second scenario is a fixed proportion frequency modulation power distribution strategy. The other related parameters of the two scenarios are the same as the background of the calculation example 5, wherein the EVA and the traditional unit in the second scenario distribute the frequency modulation power in a fixed ratio of 8: 2. The two scenario frequency modulated force pairs are shown in fig. 15-18.
Fig. 15 is a comparison of the required power for system frequency modulation, and the required power for system frequency modulation in 0-24 period is different because the frequency modulation strategies are different and the corresponding frequency modulation effects are also different, as the difference between scenario one and scenario two.
Fig. 16 is a comparison of EVA frequency modulation output, and it can be seen from fig. 15 that, since the frequency modulation period is more in scenario two, the discharge period in scenario two is more than in scenario one in fig. 16. In the 12-15 period, because the two frequency modulations require high power, a large number of EVs are required to be called to participate in the frequency modulation, but a fixed proportion allocation strategy is adopted in the second scenario, and a part of EVs are not called to participate in the frequency modulation and are in an idle state, and the frequency modulation of the traditional unit is called, as shown in fig. 17, the EVA output of the first scenario is larger than that of the second scenario, and the distribution power of the traditional unit of the second scenario is larger than that of the first scenario. Therefore, the EV resources cannot be fully called by adopting a fixed proportion allocation strategy, and resource waste is caused.
Fig. 18 shows a comparison of frequency deviations for two scenarios. The root mean square values of the frequency deviations of the scene one and the scene two are 0.0754Hz and 0.1722Hz respectively. And as the scene two adopts a fixed proportion allocation strategy, EV resources are not fully utilized, and the output of the EV is relatively less, so that the output of the traditional unit is increased. And the traditional unit frequency modulation has the characteristic of slow self response signal rate, the power output of the traditional unit frequency modulation cannot make accurate and timely response to frequency change like EV frequency modulation output, so that the frequency modulation power is not matched, the frequency deviation fluctuation of the scene two is greater than that of the scene one, and the frequency modulation effect of the scene one is better.
Finally, it is noted that the above-mentioned preferred embodiments illustrate rather than limit the invention, and that, although the invention has been described in detail with reference to the above-mentioned preferred embodiments, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes in form and detail may be made therein without departing from the scope of the invention as defined by the appended claims.