Movatterモバイル変換


[0]ホーム

URL:


Black Friday deals are live: Shop only the best.Start saving >>Black Friday deals are live: Shop only the bestStart saving >>
CloseShare this Story :Brian Cox: Singh, Carney help perpetuate lie that Israel's committing 'genocide'
Subscribe $12 for 1 year
Subscribe $12 for 1 year
NewslettersCanadaCanadian True CrimeCanadian PoliticsHealthWorldIsrael & Middle EastFinancial PostNP CommentLongreadsPuzzmoDiversionsPuzzlesComicsNP News QuizNew York Times CrosswordHoroscopesLifeEating & DrinkingStyleSponsoredPlay for OntarioTravelTravel CanadaTravel USATravel InternationalCruisesTravel EssentialsCultureBooksCelebrityMoviesMusicTheatreTelevisionBusiness EssentialsAdviceLives ToldShoppingBuy CanadianHome LivingOutdoor LivingTechStyle & BeautyKitchen & DiningPersonal CareEntertainment & HobbiesGift GuideTravel GuideDealsSavingsNational Post StoreMoreSportsHockeyBaseballBasketballFootballSoccerGolfTennisDrivingVehicle ResearchReviewsNewsGear GuideObituariesPlace an ObituaryPlace an In MemoriamClassifiedsPlace an AdCelebrationsWorkingBusiness AdsArchivesHealthingEpaperManage Print Subscription
Advertisement 1
  • Brian Cox: Singh, Carney help perpetuate lie that Israel's committing 'genocide'

    It is imperative to clarify whether the military campaign against Hamas actually does qualify as a genocide under international law

    Article content

    As the sprint of the shortest election period allowed under Canadian law nears the finish line, one aspect of the campaign that has stood out is the central role that international law has played in political messaging. The unsubstantiated claim that Israel is committing genocide while fighting against Hamas has surfaced several times.

    THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS

    Enjoy the latest local, national and international news.

    • Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events.
    • Unlimited online access to National Post.
    • National Post ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on.
    • Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword.
    • Support local journalism.
    SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE ARTICLES

    Enjoy the latest local, national and international news.

    • Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay and others. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events.
    • Unlimited online access to National Post.
    • National Post ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on.
    • Daily puzzles including the New York Times Crossword.
    • Support local journalism.
    REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES

    Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience.

    • Access articles from across Canada with one account.
    • Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments.
    • Enjoy additional articles per month.
    • Get email updates from your favourite authors.
    THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK.

    Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience.

    • Access articles from across Canada with one account
    • Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments
    • Enjoy additional articles per month
    • Get email updates from your favourite authors

    Sign In or Create an Account

    Continue
    or
    Article content

    During the French-language leaders debate last week, for example, NDP LeaderJagmeet Singh asked Liberal Leader Mark Carney, “Why don’t you call it what it is? It’s a genocide.” Carney responded that he prefers not to use the word “genocide” in a manner that will “politicize” the situation in Gaza.

    Article content
    Article content
    Article content

    The next evening, during the English-language debate,Singh criticized Carney for not acknowledging that “what’s going on in Gaza has now clearly become a genocide.”

    Article content
    We encountered an issue signing you up. Please try again

    Article content

    This time, Carney did not directly address the genocide claim. Instead, hestuck to theLiberal platform of calling for an immediate ceasefire, the release of all hostages, more humanitarian aid for civilians in Gaza and a lasting two-state solution.

    Article content

    Earlier in the month, during a Carney campaign rally, an attendeeshouted, “There’s a genocide happening in Palestine.” Rather than confronting the assertion, Carney responded, “I’m aware, which is why we have an arms embargo.” When asked later by a reporter if he concedes there is a genocide in Gaza,Carney claimed he “didn’t hear that word” during the rally.

    Article content

    While Carney’s assertion seems rather implausible based onvideo of the exchange, his campaigndid not return repeated requests to clarify his position on the “genocide” issue following the rally and aftera video surfaced of Liberal candidate Adam van Koeverden telling a group of constituents that their voices will help “end the genocide in Gaza.”

    Article content
    Article content

    With the NDP leader stridently insisting Israel is committing genocide and the Liberal leader’s position on the matter unclear, the characterization of Israel’s conflict against Hamas in Gaza has emerged as a central — perhaps even pivotal — issue in the federal election. It is imperative to clarify whether the military campaign against Hamas actually does qualify as one of the worst possible crimes under international law.

    Article content
    Read More
  • Pro-Palestinian activists hold a rally at Union Station on November 17, 2023 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)
    NP View: No truth behind claim that Israel is committing genocide
  • Liberal Leader Mark Carney during a rally at the Red and White Club in Calgary on Tuesday, April 8, 2025.
    Lisa MacLeod: Mark Carney's flippant remarks on 'genocide'
  • Advertisement 1
    Story continues below
  • In short, no, Israel is not committing genocide. Canada’s political leaders should be clear about this, or they should be held accountable for misleading the electorate.

    The crime of genocide is established in theGenocide Convention of 1948 and clarified in theRome Statute of 1998, both of which Canada has adopted. It is committed when prohibited acts are carried out “with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.”

    Article content

    Israel’s political leaders have repeatedly affirmed that the strategic objectives of the campaign in Gaza are to destroy Hamas’s military and governing capabilities, thereby ending the enduring security threat posed by the terrorist group, and the return of all the hostages.

    Advertisement 1
    Trending
  • Canadians visiting U.S. parks to pay more than triple starting next year
    trump
  • Advertisement 2
    Story continues below
  • Canadians won't need to take out laptops, liquids from bags during security checks at these airports
    airport
  • FIRST READING: Mark Carney's slow-motion purge of the Trudeau old guard
    Carney and Joly
  • John Robson: This museum may cause unconsciousness from extreme wokeness
    Canadian Museum of History
  • Advertisement 2
    Advertisement
    Article content

    Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahureiterated this message earlier this month, and these remain consistent with thegoals announced in October 2023, during the early stages of the ground offensive in Gaza.

    Article content

    Seeking to destroy a transnational terrorist group that promises a repeat of the October 7 massacre is not genocide — it’s war.

    Article content

    A significant number of civilian casualties are, unfortunately, predictable given that Hamas deliberately hides and fights among the civilian population. But harm to civilians that is incidental to attacks in pursuit of the destruction of a terrorist group during armed conflict does not constitute genocide.

    Article content

    To date, Turkey is the only NATO member that hasofficially concluded that Israel is committing genocide. Some activist groups, such asHuman Rights Watch andAmnesty International, have also characterized Israel’s conduct as genocide.

    Article content

    However, these assertions are based almost entirely on comments from various Israeli political leaders that were taken out of context, coupled with observed effects of the conflict that can be consistent with the intent to destroy Hamas rather than the population of Gaza.

    Article content
    Article content

    When it comes tothe genocide case initiated by South Africa at the International Court of Justice (ICJ), it iscommonly suggested that the court’sprovisional measuresconcluded that Israel’s conduct in Gaza amounts to a “plausible genocide.” However, this is anincorrect interpretation of thepurpose of ICJ provisional measures.

    Article content

    Israel is not committing genocide in Gaza. When Canadians head to the polls, they should consider each party’s record on countering this pernicious disinformation directed against Canada’s closest ally in the Middle East.

    Article content

    National Post
    Twitter.com/BrianCox_RLTW

    Article content

    Brian L. Cox is an adjunct professor of law at Cornell Law School, a retired U.S. army judge advocate, a journalism graduate student at Carleton University and a contributor to the Macdonald-Laurier Institute in Ottawa.

    Article content
    Latest from Shopping Essentials
  • These are 5 of the best holiday beauty gift sets of 2025

    Beauty gift sets to gift this holiday season

    3 hours agoFashion & Beauty
    Sephora Favorites Women's Deluxe Fragrance Sampler Set
  • Every must-shop Sephora Black Friday deal: Editor-vetted

    Sephora Black Friday 2025: Viral skincare, makeup & fragrance deals in Canada

    4 hours agoBlack Friday
    Shop Sephora's Black Friday sale.
  • Advertisement 3
    Story continues below
  • Black Friday deal: Everything is on sale at celeb-favourite brand Reformation

    Shop jeans, sweaters, special occasion dresses and more on sale

    6 hours agoBlack Friday
    reformation black friday canada
  • 2025's trendiest gifts for women

    From skincare gadgets to buzz-worthy beauty launches, here are some of the top trending gifts for her this holiday season

    6 hours agoLifestyle
    The Super Puff cliMATTE in magnolia.
  • Close drawer

    You've reached the 20 article limit.

    You can manage saved articles in your account.

    and save up to 100 articles!

    Looks like you've reached your saved article limit!

    You can manage your saved articles in youraccount and clicking the X located at the bottom right of the article.


    [8]ページ先頭

    ©2009-2025 Movatter.jp