Part of the book series:History of Mechanism and Machine Science ((HMMS,volume 27))
1603Accesses
Abstract
The development of the atomic bomb in the first half of the twentieth century marked a turning point in the history of nuclear science because it revealed the close relationships that exist among science, technology and society. In this paper the main discoveries that led to the scientific and technological development of the atomic bomb are presented together with the commitment of scientists who tried to avoid possible harmful uses of the results of their researches.
In this work a deep examination of the writings of some of these scientists is introduced, some of which are still unpublished, although already quoted by several authors, with the purpose to highlight the relevance of their position against the bomb to the present day. In this sense the content of the paper may appear as a novelty within the history of science and technology; even if it cannot be a unique story.
This is a preview of subscription content,log in via an institution to check access.
Access this chapter
Subscribe and save
- Get 10 units per month
- Download Article/Chapter or eBook
- 1 Unit = 1 Article or 1 Chapter
- Cancel anytime
Buy Now
- Chapter
- JPY 3498
- Price includes VAT (Japan)
- eBook
- JPY 17159
- Price includes VAT (Japan)
- Softcover Book
- JPY 21449
- Price includes VAT (Japan)
- Hardcover Book
- JPY 21449
- Price includes VAT (Japan)
Tax calculation will be finalised at checkout
Purchases are for personal use only
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
- 1.
1Rutherford won the Nobel Prize for Chemistry in 1908 “for his investigations into the disintegration of the elements and the chemistry of radioactive substances”, although the chemist of the team was Soddy. He gained due recognition only with the Nobel Prize in 1921 “for his contributions to our knowledge of the chemistry of radioactive substances and his investigations into the origin and nature of isotopes”. In 1913, in fact, he had found that certain elements exist in two or more forms with different atomic weights but they are chemically indistinguishable. Between 1911 and 1913, he had also formulated the Law of radioactive displacement, which refers to the fact that the emission of an α particle by an element moves it back two places in the periodic table, while the emission of a β particle situates it in one position forward. His naming to the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences was proposed by Rutherford (and supported by Thomson), as if to repay the debt contract with Soddy on the occasion of the Nobel Prize in 1908.
- 2.
In March 1903, Pierre Curie (1859–1906) and Albert Laborde (1878–1968) had measured the heat developed in a Bunsen ice calorimeter from a known amount of radio in a defined time. They found enormous values of the order of 100 calories per hour for a single gram of radium (Curie and Laborde1903). These authors, however, did not consider it possible that this heat was developed at the expense of the internal energy of the radium but they thought that it came from a source outside the atom, of unknown nature (on this topic see Soddy1904b, Chap. XI entitled “The energy of radio-active change”, pp. 165–170).
- 3.
Soddy (1953, f 282, 2, line 6).
- 4.
In this science fiction novel, H. G. Wells predicts, about 20 years in advance, the discovery of artificial radioactivity, the industrial use of atomic energy and a global conflict resulting from the use of “atomic bombs”, with the devastation of the main cities of the planet (Wells1914).
- 5.
See the 6th paragraph and Cioci (2008).
- 6.
Soddy (1915, p. 13, line 19).
- 7.
The Sydney Morning Herald (1935, f 124, line 43).
- 8.
- 9.
Heavy water was considered to be slow motion par excellence because deuterium has a light nucleus, suitable to subtract kinetic energy from neutrons, and being already formed by a neutron and a proton it was believed to be not “inclined” to absorb neutrons. The research started eventually in Montreal after the war with construction of the atomic pile ZEEP, the origin of the CANDU reactors.
- 10.
- 11.
Ivi, line 4.
- 12.
Battimelli (2002), Maltese (2003). These authors reported Edoardo Amaldi’s assessments; he considered the decision to work in the Manhattan Project as a necessary assumption of responsibility by scientists to prevent the world being conquered by the Nazis using nuclear weapons: “If I had found myself there (in front of this dramatic dilemma), after deep and painful considerations on which it was my moral duty of man asked to decide whether cooperate in the defense of democracies … or lock myself in my private life, doing nothing to fight the dictatorship, I would have eventually opted for the first solution” (Amaldi1997, p. 98, line 32).
- 13.
Amaldi (1979, p. 199, column 2, line 13).
- 14.
Associated Press (1933, p. 1, line 18). A summary of the presentation at the British Association is published in the Times of September 12, 1933, p. 7 and of Nature, no. 132, pp. 432–433 (16 September 1933).
- 15.
Szilard (1972, pp. 729–732; 1978, pp. 45–46).
- 16.
E. Amaldi (1984, p. 160, line 27).
- 17.
The exact critical mass for uranium 235 is 52 kg. The critical mass for plutonium 239 is 10 Kg.
- 18.
Frisch and Peierls (1940b, p. 86, line 15).
- 19.
United States Atomic Energy Commission (1971, p. 12, line 4).
- 20.
Weisskopf (1967, p. 40, column 1, line 19; 42, column 1, line 11).
- 21.
Smyth (1945, p. 254, line 16).
- 22.
Rotblat (1985, p. 18, line 22).
- 23.
Committee on Social and Political Implications (1946, p. 3, column 3, line 34).
- 24.
Oppenheimer (1948, p. 66, line 45).
- 25.
The account of A. K. Smith is entitled “A peril and a Hope” by a famous expression of Oppenheimer according to which nuclear weapons would constitute a danger and a hope for humanity because given the power of these terrible means of destruction humankind would have to give up war to settle international disputes and would have to create a united world under the law and humanity.
- 26.
Smith and Weiner (1980).
- 27.
Oppenheimer (1966, line 20).
- 28.
Lilienthal et al. (1946, p. 24, line 15).
- 29.
For further arguments in favour of this conclusion see Cioci (2004).
- 30.
General Advisory Committee (1949, p. 155, line 39).
- 31.
Ivi, line 21.
- 32.
Ibidem, 156, line 6.
- 33.
See Capuozzo and Cioci (2010).
- 34.
E.g. see: Teller (1950).
References
Amaldi E (1979) Gli anni della ricostruzione (The years of reconstruction). Giornale di Fisica 20(3):186–225
Amaldi E (1984) From the discovery of the neutron to the discovery of nuclear fission. Physics Reports 111(Sept):1–332
Amaldi E (1990) The case of physics (Il caso della fisica. Le conseguenze culturali delle leggi razziali. Atti dei convegni lincei, Roma 84: 107–133). In: Battimelli G, Paoloni G (eds) 20th century physics: essays and recollections. A selection of historical writings by Edoardo Amaldi (1998). World Scientific, Singapore
Amaldi E (1997) Da via Panisperna all’America (From via Panisperna to America). Editori Riuniti, Roma
Anderson HL, Fermi E, Hanstein HB (1939) Production of neutrons in uranium bombarded by neutrons. Physical Review 55:797–798.
Associated Press (September 1933) Atom-powered world absurd, scientists told. New York Herald Tribune, pp 1, 37
Battimelli G (2002) Era un ragazzo di via Panisperna (He was a boy from via Panisperna). Lett Matematica 42:15–21
Bohr N (1936) Neutron capture and nuclear constitution. Nature 137:344–348, 351
Bohr N (1939) Disintegration of heavy. Nuclei. Nature 143:330.
Bohr N, Kalckar F (1937) On the transmutation of atomic nuclei by impact of material particles. I. General theoretical remarks. Mat-Fys Medd Dan Vidensk Selsk 14(10):1–40
Bohr N, Wheeler JA (1939) The mechanism of nuclear fission. Physical Review 56:426–450
Brown A (2012) Keeper of the nuclear conscience. The life and works of Joseph Rotblat. Oxford University Press, New York
Butcher SI (2005) The origins of the Russell-Einstein Manifesto. Pugwash History Series 1:3–35
Capuozzo L, Cioci V (2010) La Fisica, le origini della biologia molecolare e dell’Ingegneria genetica: il caso della conferenza di asilomar (Physics, the origins of molecular biology and genetic engineering: the case of the Asilomar Conference). In: Giannetto E, Giannini G, Toscano M (eds) Relatività, quanti, chaos e altre rivoluzioni della fisica (Proceedings of the XXVII SISFA Congress). Guaraldi, Rimini, pp 357–364
Cioci V (2004) Una rivisitazione del caso Oppenheimer (A review of Oppenheimer case). In: Tucci P, Garuccio A, Nigro M (eds) Proceedings of the XXIII SISFA Congress. Progedit, Bari, pp 131–144
Cioci V (2007) Storia e confronto di tre diverse posizioni di fisici contro la bomba atomica (History and comparison of three different positions of physicists against the atomic bomb). In: Leone M, Preziosi B, Robotti N (eds) L’eredità di Fermi Majorana e altri temi. Atti del XXIV Congresso della Società Italiana degli Storici della Fisica e dell’Astronomia. Proceedings of the XXIV SISFA Congress. Bibliopolis, Naples, pp 211–215
Cioci V (2008) Science fiction e realtà: La liberazione del mondo di H. G. Wells e il suo influsso sugli scienziati atomici. (Science fiction and reality: The world set free by HG Wells and his influence on the atomic scientists). In: Pitrelli N, Ramani D, Sturloni G (eds) Proceedings of the VI Italian national conference on science communication. Polimetrica, Monza, pp 97–102
Cioci V (2009a) Frederick Soddy, un chimico alle frontiere della conoscenza, fra Fisica, Economia, Matematica ed Ecologia (Frederick Soddy, a chemist at the frontiers of knowledge, among physics, economics, mathematics and ecology). In: Calascibetta F (ed) Proceedings of the XIII National Congress of History and Fundamentals of Chemistry, Excerpt from vol 127, Memoirs of Physical and Natural Sciences, Proceedings of the Italian National Academy of Sciences called Academy of Forty, ser. 5, vol 33, part II, vol II, pp 319–330
Cioci V (2009b) Edoardo Amaldi e il rifiuto delle applicazioni militari della fisica nucleare (Edoardo Amaldi and the refusal of the military applications of nuclear physics). Proceedings of the XLVII AIF Congress, Supplement to LNFS 42(3): 50–58
Committee on Social and Political Implications (1946) A report to the secretary of war (Frank report). Bulletin of Atomic Scientists 1(10):2–4, 16
Curie P, Laborde A (1903) Sur la chaleur dégagée spontanément par les sels de radium. Comptes Rendus 136(sem.1):673–675
Einstein A (1905) Does the inertia of a body depend upon its energy content? (Ist die Trägheit eines Körpers von seimen Eneirgieinhalt abhängig? Annalen der Physik, ser. 4, 18:639–641). In: Einstein A (1989) Collected papers of Albert Einstein, vol 2. Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp 172–174
Einstein A (1907) On the relativity principle and the conclusion drawn from it (Relativitätsprinzip und die aus demselben gezogenen Folgerungen, Jahrbuch der Radioaktivität 4:411–62; 5:98–99). In: Einstein A (1989) Collected papers of Albert Einstein, vol 2. Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp 252–311
Einstein A (1910) Principe de relativité et ses conséquences dans la physique moderne. Archives des sciences physiques et naturelles (Series 4), 29:5–28,125–244
Einstein A (1989) Collected Papers of Albert Einstein, vol 2. The Swiss years: writings, 1900–1909. Princeton University Press, Princeton. (English translation supplement. Beck A (tr), Havas P (con), Buchwald DK (g ed))
Fermi E (1934) Possible production of elements of atomic number higher than 92. Nature 133:898–899
Fermi E, Amaldi E, D’Agostino O, Rasetti F, Segré E (1934) Artificial radioactivity produced by neutron bombardment—I. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A 146(857):483–500
Frisch O (1939) Physical evidence for the division of heavy nuclei under neutron bombardment. Nature 143:276
Frisch O, Peierls R (1940a) Memorandum on the properties of a radioactive “superbomb”. In: Serber R (ed) The Los Alamos primer. University of California Press, Berkeley, pp 80–83
Frisch O, Peierls R (1940b) On the construction of a “super-bomb”; based on a nuclear chain reaction in uranium. In: Serber R (ed) The Los Alamos primer. University of California Press, Berkeley, pp 83–88
General Advisory Committee (1949) Report of GAC to the U. S. atomic energy commission, October 30. In: York HF (ed) The advisors. Oppheneimer, teller and the superbomb (1976). Freeman and Company, San Francisco, pp 150–159
Hahn O, Strassmann F (1939) Concerning the existence of alkaline earth metals resulting from neutron irradiation of uranium (Über den Nachweis und das Verhalten der bei der Bestrahlung des Urans mittels Neutronen entstehenden Erdalkalimetalle. Die Naturwissenschaften 27:11–15). Am J Phys 32:9–15 (English Translation)
Hinshaw VGJ (1949) Einstein’s social philosophy. In: Schilpp AP (ed) Albert Einstein: philosopher-scientist. Volume VII in the Library of Living Philosophers, MJF Books, New York, pp 649–661
Jonas H (1984) The imperative of responsibility: in search of an ethics for the technological age (Das Prinzip Verantwortung, Insel Verlag, Frankfurt am Main, 1979) (trans: H Jonas, D Herr). University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Jonas H (1997) Tecnica medicina ed etica. Prassi del principio responsabilità. (Technik, Medizin und Ethik: Zur Praxis des Prinzips Verantwortung. Insel Verlag, Frankfurt am Main, 1985) (trans: P Becchi, A Benussi). Einaudi, Torino. (Not translated into English yet)
Jones VC (1985) Manhattan: the army and the atomic bomb. United States Army, Washington (Center of military history)
Kipphardt H (1964) In the matter of J. Robert Oppenheimer; a play freely adapted on the basis of the documents. Hill & Wang, New York
Lilienthal DE (Chairman), Barnard CI, Oppenheimer JR, Thomas CA, Winne HA (1946) A report on the international control of atomic energy prepared for the secretary of state’s committee on atomic energy (Acheson-Lilienthal report). U. S. Government Printing Office, Washington
Maltese G (2003) Enrico Fermi in America. Una biografia scientifica: 1938–1954 (Enrico Fermi in America. A scientific biography: 1938–1954). Zanichelli, Bologna
Meitner L, Frisch OR (1939) Disintegration of uranium by neutrons: a new type of nuclear reaction. Nature 143:239–40
Oppenheimer JR (1948) Physics in the contemporary world. Bulletin of Atomic Scientists 4(3):65–68, 85–86
Oppenheimer JR (1966) Draft letter to David Bohm, 2 December Library of congress. Manuscript division, Papers of J. R. Oppenheimer, box 20
Pais A (1982) Subtle is the lord. The science and the life of Albert Einstein. Oxford University Press, New York
Peierls R (1974) Oppenheimer J. Robert. In: Gillispie CC (ed) Dictionary of scientific biography, vol X. Charles Scribner’s Sons, New York, pp 213–218
Ramsay W, Soddy F, (1904) Further experiments on the production of helium from radium. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 73:346–358
Rasetti F (1955) Fermi. Science 121(1344):449–451
Rasetti F (1958–1968) Biographical notes and scientific work of Franco Rasetti, unpublished typescript preserved in the Amaldi Archives, Department of Physics, Rome University “La Sapienza”, sc. 1E, fasc. 22
Rasetti F (1968) Enrico Fermi e la fisica italiana (Enrico Fermi and the Italian physics). In: Celebrazioni Lincee in ricordo di Enrico Fermi. Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, Roma, pp 11–19
Rhodes R (1986) The making of atomic bomb. Simon & Schuster, New York
Rotblat J (1985) Leaving the bomb project. The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists 41(7):16–19
Russell BAW, Einstein A (1955) Texts of scientists’ appeal for abolition of war. The New York Times, 10 July, p 25. (The Russell-Einstein Manifesto). Issued in London, 9 July 1955, and signed also by Born M, Bridgman PW, Infeld AL, Joliot-Curie F, Muller HJ, Pauling L, Powell CF, Rotblat J, Yukawa H. Reprinted in: Bone AG (ed) The Collected Papers of Bertrand Russell, vol 28. Man’s Peril, 1954–1955. Routledge, London and New York, pp 259–262
Rutherford E, Soddy F (1902a) The cause and nature of radioactivity, parts I and II. Philosophical Magazine (Series 6) 4:370–396, 569–585
Rutherford E, Soddy F (1902b) The radioactivity of thorium compounds, parts I and II. Transactions of Journal of the Chemical Society 81:837–860, 837–851
Rutherford E, Soddy F (1903) Radioactive change. Philosophical Magazine (Series 6) 5:576–591
Smith AK (1971) A peril and a hope. The scientists’ movement in America 1945–47. The MIT Press, Cambridge
Smith AK, Weiner C (eds) (1980) Robert Oppenheimer. Letters and recollections. Harvard University Press, Cambridge
Smyth HD (1945) Atomic energy for military purposes. The official report on the development of the atomic bomb under the auspices of the United States Government, 1940–1945. Princeton University Press, Princeton. (Reprinted by Maple Press, York, Pennsylvania)
Soddy F (1903a) Some recent advances in radioactivity. Contemporary Review 83(May):708–720
Soddy F (1903b) Possible future applications of radium. Times Literature Supplement 17:225–226
Soddy F (1904a) Radium. Professional Papers of the Royal Corps of Engineers 29:237–251
Soddy F (1904b) Radio-activity: an elementary treatise from the standpoint of the disintegration theory. The electrician, London
Soddy F (1906) The internal energy of elements. Journal of the Institution of Electrical Engineers 37:140–147
Soddy F (1909) The interpretation of radium. G. P. Putnam’s Sons, New York
Soddy F (1915) The social effect of recent advances in physical sciences. In: Professor Frederick Soddy Papers, Bodleian Library, Oxford, MS Eng Misc b179, ff. 542–556
Soddy F (1926) Wealth, virtual wealth and debt. The solution of the economic paradox. George Allen & Unwin Ltd, London
Soddy F (1934) Suggestion to the ordinary fellows of the royal society for a reform group to uphold their rights. In: Professor Frederick Soddy Papers, Bodleian Library, Oxford, MS. Eng. misc. b170, f 147
Soddy F ( 1945) The moving finger writes […] Cavalcade, August 18, pp 8–9
Soddy F (1949) The story of atomic energy. Nova Atlantis, London
Soddy F (1953) Correspondence with Sir Harold Hartley. In: Professor Frederick Soddy Papers, Bodleian Library, Oxford, MS Eng Misc b189, ff 281–285
Szilard L (1972) The collected works of Leo Szilard: scientific papers. Edited by Feld BT, Weiss Szilard G. The MIT Press, Cambridge
Szilard L (1978) His Version of the Facts. Selected Recollections and Correspondence. Edited by Weart SR, Weiss Szilard G. The Mit Press, Cambridge
Szilard L, Zinn WH (1939) Instantaneous emission of fast neutrons in the interaction of slow neutrons with uranium. Physical Review 55:799–800
Teller E (1950) Back to the laboratories. Bulletin of Atomic Scientists 6(3):71
The Sydney Morning Herald (1935) Royal society. Demand for Reform., December 23, N.S.W., Australia. In: Professor Frederick Soddy Papers, Bodleian Library, Oxford, MS. Eng. misc. b170, f 124
United States Atomic Energy Commission (1971) In the matter of J. Robert Oppenheimer. Transcript of hearing before personnel security board and texts of principal documents and letters. Foreword by Stern PM. The MIT Press, Cambridge
von Halban H, Joliot F, Kowarski L (1939) Liberation of neutrons in the nuclear explosion of uranium. Nature 143:470–471
Weart S (1982) The road to Los Alamos. Journal De Physique (Colloque C8, suppl au n 12) 43:301–313
Weisskopf V (1967) The Los Alamos years. In: A memorial to Oppenheimer. Physics Today 20(10):39–42
Wells HG (1914) The world set free. A story of mankind. Macmillan and Company, London
Acknowledgments
I thank Professor Giovanni Battimelli, Referent for Documents and Sources for the History of Physics, Department of Physics, University “La Sapienza” of Rome, who helped me in the consultation of the Edoardo Amaldi Archives.
My special thanks is addressed to Colin Harris, Superintendent of the Special Collections Reading Rooms, for his help in finding the unpublished writings of Frederick Soddy , to Dr. Chris Fletcher, Keeper of Special Collections, and to the Bodleian Library, Oxford University, which owns them, for permission given on the basis of ‘non-exclusive rights’ to quote and to paraphrase them.
I am grateful to Bonnie Coles for helping me in the examination and retrieval of the writings of Robert Oppenheimer at the Manuscript Division of the Library of Congress (USA).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Research Centre for the Theory and History of Science, University of West Bohemia, Pilsen, Czech Republic
Vincenzo Cioci
Research Group on Physics Education and History of Physics, University of Calabria, Cosenza, Italy
Vincenzo Cioci
- Vincenzo Cioci
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar
Corresponding author
Correspondence toVincenzo Cioci.
Editor information
Editors and Affiliations
Department of Physics, Lille 1 University Science and Technology, Villeneuve d’Ascq, France
Raffaele Pisano
Rights and permissions
Copyright information
© 2015 Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht
About this chapter
Cite this chapter
Cioci, V. (2015). On the History and Technology of the Atomic Bomb. The Commitment of the Scientists. In: Pisano, R. (eds) A Bridge between Conceptual Frameworks. History of Mechanism and Machine Science, vol 27. Springer, Dordrecht. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-9645-3_7
Download citation
Published:
Publisher Name:Springer, Dordrecht
Print ISBN:978-94-017-9644-6
Online ISBN:978-94-017-9645-3
eBook Packages:EngineeringEngineering (R0)
Share this chapter
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative