Issues: Fix#52898

I don't think that's really the case. This "fix" changes something which didn't work into something which still doesn't work, but just for a different reason. So while it does relate to my feature request, it doesn't fix it. And I'm not even sure that the acceptation of this change would also answer my feature request. It does close of one possibility to support / implement the feature request. But it doesn't void the feature request to be able to "shortcut"#[AsMessageHandler] so not to have to repeat (for example) thebus for every usage of the attribute. So personally I would prefer a separate discussion on whether such a feature would be possible, with or withoutAsMessageHandler beingfinal. While such discussion would be ended "automatically" when the fixes / closes "tag" is applied.

Furthermore, for the reasons given by@chalasr in#52898 it is my believe thatall attribute classes should be madefinal. While when only checking theDependencyInjection\Attribute namespace there are more attribute classesnotfinal than ones which actuallyare final. And as a matter of fact, there are also some attributes which are "open" on purpose as other attributes extend from them (for exampleAutowire which is extended byAutowireCallable,AutowireIterator,AutowireLocator andAutowireServiceClosure). So while I understand the reasoning to make attribute classes final (as extending them and adding extra properties / functionality doesn't magically work), it would be my believe thatall attribute classes should be final.

So to conclude it is my believe that Symfony should have some guideline / "code style" on whether (all) attribute classes must always be final, or whether they may or should be open. And in that discussion the point made by@chalasr obviously should be taken into consideration (but also that fact that said argument is already "violated" by for example all the mentionedAutowire* tags where it previously was considered fine to extend the attribute class).

Thank you@Valmonzo.