Shouldn't this be added to the bundle instead? The bridge doesn't force using the TranslationExtension - the bundle does. WDYT?

My reasoning would be that the extension was usable without installing any other package before and would now also break other potential consumers of it that do not use the bundle.

My reasoning would be that the extension was usable without installing any other package

symfony/translation was required, isn't it? and this one links to symfony/contracts in 4.2

we usedstrtr() as a fallback:https://github.com/symfony/symfony/blob/4.1/src/Symfony/Bridge/Twig/Extension/TranslationExtension.php#L94

yes, twig bridge suggests:"symfony/translation": "For using the TranslationExtension".

IIUC the issues is wedont havesymfony/translation and it fallbacks to the contract implementation.. but that's still a soft-dependency 🤔

edit:@xabbuh was faster :)

Thank you@xabbuh.