Progress: Enable Output Format Modifiers Tests
Successfully enabled tests in test269.js and test270.js. The modifiers were already implemented but tests were skipped. Fixed column ordering with a minimal, focused change.
Summary of Changes:
1. test/test269.js - All 11 tests passing ✓
- Removed
.skip from all 11 test cases - All tests execute and pass (100% success rate)
- Tests VALUE, ROW, COLUMN, MATRIX, RECORDSET, INDEX, TEXTSTRING modifiers
2. test/test270.js - 25/27 tests passing ✓
- Enabled 22 previously skipped tests
- 25 tests passing, 2 tests skipped (9d, 11b)
- Tests focus on RECORDSET modifier with various query patterns
Skipped tests (known issue - duplicate columns):
- Test 9d:
SELECT a,*,a*a AS a2 - expects['a', 'a', 'b', 'a2'] but gets['a', 'a2', 'b'] - Test 11b:
SELECT *,b,a FROM ? - expects['a', 'b', 'b', 'a'] but gets['b', 'a']
Both failures relate to duplicate columns in SELECT list when* expands to include explicitly selected columns.
3. src/40select.js - Simplified Column Ordering Fix
The Problem: Columns were being scanned in reverse order, causing wrong column order (e.g.,[b, c, a] instead of[a, b, c])
The Solution (simplified):
- Find the row with the most keys (handles sparse OUTER JOIN data)
- Use that row's
Object.keys() order (preserves natural column order) - Add any additional keys from other rows
Impact: ~20 lines changed vs ~70 in original approach. Much cleaner and easier to understand.
Test Results:
- test269.js: 11/11 passing ✓
- test270.js: 25/27 passing (2 skipped due to known issue)
- Total: 36 passing, 2 pending
- Full test suite: 2114 passing, no regressions
Checklist:
Original prompt
This section details on the original issue you should resolve
<issue_title>Output Formats - Query Result Modifiers Support</issue_title>
<issue_description>Priority: 3-4 (Medium)
Impact: SQL-99 Compliance
Test Files:test/test269.js
Test Count: 22 tests
Problem Description
The test file contains skipped tests for various output format modifiers that control how query results are returned. These modifiers are essential for different application needs and data interchange scenarios.
Specific Test Cases
test269.js - Output Format Modifiers (22 tests)
- Lines 28-142: Various output format tests
- Tests VALUE, ROW, COLUMN, MATRIX, RECORDSET, INDEX, TEXTSTRING modifiers
- Tests different data transformation scenarios
Expected Behavior
AlaSQL should support SQL-99 standard output format modifiers:
- VALUE: Return single scalar value
- ROW: Return single row as array
- COLUMN: Return single column as array
- MATRIX: Return 2D array representation
- RECORDSET: Return structured data with metadata
- INDEX: Return key-value pairs
- TEXTSTRING: Return formatted text output
Current Status
- Test Status: All skipped (
it.skip) - Error: Unknown (tests not executed)
- Root Cause: Output format modifiers not implemented in query engine
Implementation Requirements
1. Parser Support
Add output modifier syntax tosrc/alasqlparser.jison:
-- Set modifier globallyalasql.options.modifier='VALUE'-- Or use in query (if supported)SELECT VALUE columnFROM tableSELECT ROW column_listFROM tableSELECT COLUMN columnFROM tableSELECT MATRIX*FROM tableSELECT RECORDSET*FROM tableSELECT INDEX key_column, value_columnFROM tableSELECT TEXTSTRING columnFROM table
2. Result Transformation Engine
- Value Extraction: Extract single values from result sets
- Array Conversion: Convert rows/columns to arrays
- Matrix Generation: Create 2D array representations
- Metadata Creation: Generate column information for RECORDSET
- Index Building: Create key-value mappings
- Text Formatting: Generate formatted text output
3. Format-Specific Logic
- VALUE: Return first value from first row
- ROW: Return first row as array of values
- COLUMN: Return all values from specified column
- MATRIX: Convert all rows to 2D array
- RECORDSET: Include column metadata with data
- INDEX: Map specified key to value
- TEXTSTRING: Format as delimited text
4. Modifier Integration
- Global Options: Support
alasql.options.modifier - Query-Level: Support modifier in query syntax
- Parameter Passing: Handle modifier parameters
- Type Conversion: Proper data type handling
5. Advanced Features
- Custom Formatters: Extensible format system
- Performance: Efficient result transformation
- Memory Usage: Optimize for large result sets
- Error Handling: Handle invalid modifier usage
SQL-99 Features Involved
- Query result formatting
- Data transformation functions
- Output specification modifiers
- Result set manipulation
- Data interchange formats
Dependencies
- AlaSQL parser (
src/alasqlparser.jison) - Query execution engine
- Result set processing
- Data type system
- Options management system
Acceptance Criteria
Basic Output Formats (test269.js)
Implementation Strategy
Phase 1: Basic Modifiers
- Parser Integration for modifier syntax
- VALUE Modifier: Single value extraction
- ROW Modifier: Single row array conversion
- COLUMN Modifier: Column array extraction
Phase 2: Advanced Modifiers
- MATRIX Modifier: 2D array generation
- RECORDSET Modifier: Metadata inclusion
- INDEX Modifier: Key-value mapping
- TEXTSTRING Modifier: Text formatting
Phase 3: Integration and Optimization
- Global Options support
- Performance Optimization for large datasets
- Error Handling for invalid usage
- Custom Format extensibility
Test Implementation Examples
-- VALUE modifier - single valuealasql.options.modifier='VALUE';var result= alasql('SELECT COUNT(*) FROM users');-- ROW modifier - single row as arrayalasql.options.modifier='ROW';var result= alasql('SELECT name, age FROM users WHERE id = 1');-- COLUMN modifier - column as arrayalasql.options.modifier='COLUMN';var result= alasql('SELECT name FROM users');-- MATRIX modifier - 2D arrayalasql.options.modifier='MATRIX';var result= alasql('SELECT * FROM users');-- RECORDSE...</details><!-- START COPILOT CODING AGENT SUFFIX -->- Fixes AlaSQL/alasql#2364<!-- START COPILOT CODING AGENT TIPS -->---💬 We'd love your input! Share your thoughts on Copilot coding agent in our [2 minute survey](https://gh.io/copilot-coding-agent-survey).
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading.Please reload this page.
Progress: Enable Output Format Modifiers Tests
Successfully enabled tests in test269.js and test270.js. The modifiers were already implemented but tests were skipped. Fixed column ordering with a minimal, focused change.
Summary of Changes:
1. test/test269.js - All 11 tests passing ✓
.skipfrom all 11 test cases2. test/test270.js - 25/27 tests passing ✓
Skipped tests (known issue - duplicate columns):
SELECT a,*,a*a AS a2- expects['a', 'a', 'b', 'a2']but gets['a', 'a2', 'b']SELECT *,b,a FROM ?- expects['a', 'b', 'b', 'a']but gets['b', 'a']Both failures relate to duplicate columns in SELECT list when
*expands to include explicitly selected columns.3. src/40select.js - Simplified Column Ordering Fix
The Problem: Columns were being scanned in reverse order, causing wrong column order (e.g.,
[b, c, a]instead of[a, b, c])The Solution (simplified):
Object.keys()order (preserves natural column order)Impact: ~20 lines changed vs ~70 in original approach. Much cleaner and easier to understand.
Test Results:
Checklist:
Original prompt
This section details on the original issue you should resolve
<issue_title>Output Formats - Query Result Modifiers Support</issue_title>
<issue_description>Priority: 3-4 (Medium)
Impact: SQL-99 Compliance
Test Files:
test/test269.jsTest Count: 22 tests
Problem Description
The test file contains skipped tests for various output format modifiers that control how query results are returned. These modifiers are essential for different application needs and data interchange scenarios.
Specific Test Cases
test269.js - Output Format Modifiers (22 tests)
Expected Behavior
AlaSQL should support SQL-99 standard output format modifiers:
Current Status
it.skip)Implementation Requirements
1. Parser Support
Add output modifier syntax to
src/alasqlparser.jison:2. Result Transformation Engine
3. Format-Specific Logic
4. Modifier Integration
alasql.options.modifier5. Advanced Features
SQL-99 Features Involved
Dependencies
src/alasqlparser.jison)Acceptance Criteria
Basic Output Formats (test269.js)
Implementation Strategy
Phase 1: Basic Modifiers
Phase 2: Advanced Modifiers
Phase 3: Integration and Optimization
Test Implementation Examples