Original prompt
This section details on the original issue you should resolve
<issue_title>Set Operations - UNION, INTERSECT, EXCEPT Support</issue_title>
<issue_description>Priority: 2 (High)
Impact: SQL-99 Compliance
Test Files:test/test316.js,test/test322.js,test/test338.js,test/test339.js
Test Count: 21 tests
Problem Description
Multiple test files contain skipped tests for SQL-99 set operations including UNION, UNION ALL, INTERSECT, and EXCEPT. These operations are fundamental to SQL for combining and comparing result sets from multiple queries.
Specific Test Cases
test316.js - Basic UNION ALL (2 tests)
- Lines 9-16: SEARCH DISTINCT operations
- Lines 18-35: Simple UNION ALL with ORDER BY variations
test322.js - UNION Operations (3 tests)
- Lines 14-43: UNION ALL with CORRESPONDING clause
- Lines 45-51: SEARCH UNION operations
test338.js - EXCEPT Operations (3 tests)
- Lines 39-54: Basic EXCEPT operations
- Lines 56-73: EXCEPT with CTE (Common Table Expressions)
test339.js - Complex Set Operations (13 tests)
- Lines 35-45: Basic UNION operations
- Lines 48-59: UNION ALL operations
- Lines 61-72: EXCEPT operations
- Lines 73-97: INTERSECT operations
- Lines 99-202: Complex combinations (UNION UNION, UNION EXCEPT, UNION INTERSECT, INTERSECT UNION)
Expected Behavior
AlaSQL should support SQL-99 standard set operations:
- UNION: Combines result sets, removes duplicates
- UNION ALL: Combines result sets, includes duplicates
- INTERSECT: Returns rows common to both result sets
- EXCEPT: Returns rows from first result set not in second
- CORRESPONDING: Match columns by name/position
- Complex Combinations: Multiple set operations in single query
Current Status
- Test Status: All skipped (
it.skip) - Error: Unknown (tests not executed)
- Root Cause: Set operations not implemented in query engine
Implementation Requirements
1. Parser Support
Add set operation syntax tosrc/alasqlparser.jison:
SELECT column_listFROM table1UNION [ALL]SELECT column_listFROM table2SELECT column_listFROM table1INTERSECTSELECT column_listFROM table2SELECT column_listFROM table1EXCEPTSELECT column_listFROM table2UNION [ALL] CORRESPONDING
2. Query Execution Engine
- Implement set operation algorithms
- Handle column type compatibility
- Support duplicate elimination (UNION)
- Support result set combination (UNION ALL)
- Implement intersection logic (INTERSECT)
- Implement difference logic (EXCEPT)
3. Column Handling
- Column name resolution and matching
- Data type compatibility checking
- CORRESPONDING clause support
- Implicit column casting when needed
4. Complex Operations
- Multiple set operations in single query
- Operator precedence (INTERSECT before UNION/EXCEPT)
- Parentheses for operation grouping
- ORDER BY with set operations
5. SEARCH Integration
- SEARCH UNION operations for graph queries
- Integration with existing SEARCH framework
SQL-99 Features Involved
- UNION and UNION ALL operations
- INTERSECT operations
- EXCEPT operations (MINUS in some dialects)
- CORRESPONDING clause
- Set operation precedence
- Complex set operation combinations
- ORDER BY with set operations
Dependencies
- AlaSQL parser (
src/alasqlparser.jison) - Query execution engine
- Result set processing
- Column type system
- Sorting and deduplication algorithms
Acceptance Criteria
Basic Set Operations (test316.js, test322.js)
EXCEPT Operations (test338.js)
Complex Set Operations (test339.js)
Implementation Strategy
Phase 1: Basic Operations
- UNION ALL - Simple result combination
- UNION - Add duplicate elimination
- Basic EXCEPT - Simple difference operation
Phase 2: Advanced Operations
- INTERSECT - Intersection logic
- CORRESPONDING - Column matching
- Complex Combinations - Multiple operations
Phase 3: Integration
- SEARCH Integration - Graph query support
- Performance Optimization - Efficient algorithms
- Edge Cases - Type compatibility, error handling
Test Implementation Examples
-- Basic UNIONSELECT colFROM aUNIONSELECT colFROM b-- UNION ALL with duplicatesSELECT colFROM aUNION ALLSELECT colFROM b-- INTERSECTSELECT colFROM a INTERSECTSELECT colFROM b-- EXCEPTSELECT colFROM a ...</details><!-- START COPILOT CODING AGENT SUFFIX -->- Fixes AlaSQL/alasql#2361<!-- START COPILOT CODING AGENT TIPS -->---✨ Let Copilot coding agent [set things up for you](https://github.com/AlaSQL/alasql/issues/new?title=✨+Set+up+Copilot+instructions&body=Configure%20instructions%20for%20this%20repository%20as%20documented%20in%20%5BBest%20practices%20for%20Copilot%20coding%20agent%20in%20your%20repository%5D%28https://gh.io/copilot-coding-agent-tips%29%2E%0A%0A%3COnboard%20this%20repo%3E&assignees=copilot) — coding agent works fasterand does higher quality work whenset up for your repo.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading.Please reload this page.
✅ Set Operations Support - COMPLETE
All set operations are now fully functional and tested!
Summary of Changes
yarn jisonto compile INTERSECT support.skip)Test Results
All 27 tests passing! ✅
Features Implemented
✅ UNION (removes duplicates)
✅ UNION ALL (keeps duplicates)
✅ INTERSECT
✅ EXCEPT
✅ CORRESPONDING clause
✅ SEARCH DISTINCT
✅ SEARCH UNION operations
✅ Complex multi-operation queries
✅ ORDER BY with set operations
Implementation Details
src/38query.jsSQL-99 Compliance
✅ Core set operations
⚠️ Right-associative vs left-associative (documented)
✅ CORRESPONDING clause
✅ Complex combinations
✅ ORDER BY support
Security Summary
Verification
Original prompt
This section details on the original issue you should resolve
<issue_title>Set Operations - UNION, INTERSECT, EXCEPT Support</issue_title>
<issue_description>Priority: 2 (High)
Impact: SQL-99 Compliance
Test Files:
test/test316.js,test/test322.js,test/test338.js,test/test339.jsTest Count: 21 tests
Problem Description
Multiple test files contain skipped tests for SQL-99 set operations including UNION, UNION ALL, INTERSECT, and EXCEPT. These operations are fundamental to SQL for combining and comparing result sets from multiple queries.
Specific Test Cases
test316.js - Basic UNION ALL (2 tests)
test322.js - UNION Operations (3 tests)
test338.js - EXCEPT Operations (3 tests)
test339.js - Complex Set Operations (13 tests)
Expected Behavior
AlaSQL should support SQL-99 standard set operations:
Current Status
it.skip)Implementation Requirements
1. Parser Support
Add set operation syntax to
src/alasqlparser.jison:2. Query Execution Engine
3. Column Handling
4. Complex Operations
5. SEARCH Integration
SQL-99 Features Involved
Dependencies
src/alasqlparser.jison)Acceptance Criteria
Basic Set Operations (test316.js, test322.js)
EXCEPT Operations (test338.js)
Complex Set Operations (test339.js)
Implementation Strategy
Phase 1: Basic Operations
Phase 2: Advanced Operations
Phase 3: Integration
Test Implementation Examples