Qigong (/ˈtʃiːˈɡɒŋ/)[1][a] is a system of coordinated body-posture and movement, breathing, andmeditation[2] said to be useful for the purposes of health, spirituality, and martial arts training.[3] With roots inChinese medicine,philosophy, andmartial arts, qigong is traditionally viewed by the Chinese and throughout Asia as a practice to cultivate and balance the mystical life-forceqi.[4]
Qigong practice typically involves moving meditation, coordinating slow-flowing movement, deep rhythmic breathing, and a calm meditative state of mind. People practice qigong throughout China and worldwide for recreation, exercise, relaxation, preventive medicine, self-healing,alternative medicine, meditation, self-cultivation, and training for martial arts.[2]
Qigong (Pinyin),ch'i kung (Wade-Giles), andchi gung (Yale) are romanizations of two Chinese words "qì" and "gōng" (功).Qi primarily means air, gas or breath but is often translated as a metaphysical concept of 'vital energy',[4] referring to a supposed energy circulating through the body; though a more general definition is universal energy, including heat, light, and electromagnetic energy;[5] and definitions often involve breath, air, gas, or the relationship between matter, energy, and spirit.[6]Qi is the central underlying principle in traditional Chinese medicine and martial arts.Gong (orkung) is often translated as cultivation or work, and definitions include practice, skill, mastery, merit, achievement, service, result, or accomplishment, and is often used to meangongfu (kung fu) in the traditional sense of achievement through great effort.[7] The two words are combined to describe systems to cultivate and balance life energy, especially for health and wellbeing.[4]
The term qigong as currently used was promoted in the late 1940s through the 1950s to refer to a broad range of Chinese self-cultivation exercises, and to emphasize health and scientific approaches, while de-emphasizingspiritual practices,mysticism, and elite lineages.[8][9][10]
In the 1957 first edition of “Qigong Therapy Practice” by Liu Guizhen[11] - the first published and publicly available book on Qigong, it was described that Qigong was originally used to strengthen the body and promote health and longevity. Over time, it evolved into a method for treating diseases. The practice involves mastering specific postures and breathing techniques, focusing on restoring the body’s natural physiological functions without relying on medication or surgery. Maintaining a calm state and focusing on breath control are essential during therapy. In the 1982 second edition of the book, the author provided a modern definition of Qigong: "…the training of the body, breath, and mind as a means to cultivate the body's vital energy (Qi), with the aim of preventing illness and prolonging life. Based on classical theory, we named this self-exercise method, which focuses on cultivating Qi, 'Qigong'".
The physical exercise chart; a painting on silk depicting the practice ofdaoyin; unearthed in 1973 inHunan Province, China, from the 2nd-century BCWestern Han burial site ofMawangdui Han tombs site, Tomb Number 3.
With roots in ancient Chinese culture dating back more than 2,000 years, a wide variety of qigong forms have developed within different segments of Chinese society:[12] in traditional Chinese medicine for preventive and curative functions;[13] inConfucianism to promote longevity and improve moral character;[4] inTaoism andBuddhism as part of meditative practice;[14] and in Chinese martial arts to enhance self defending abilities.[9][15] Contemporary qigong blends diverse and sometimes disparate traditions, in particular theTaoist meditative practice of "internal alchemy" (neidan), the ancient meditative practices of "circulatingqi" (xingqi) and "standing meditation" (zhan zhuang), and the slow gymnastic breathing exercise of "guiding and pulling" (daoyin). Traditionally, qigong was taught by master to students through training andoral transmission, with an emphasis on meditative practice by scholars and gymnastic or dynamic practice by the working masses.[16]
Starting in the late 1940s and the 1950s, the mainland Chinese government tried to integrate disparate qigong approaches into one coherent system, with the intention of establishing a firm scientific basis for qigong practice. In 1949, Liu Guizhen established the name "qigong" to refer to the system of life-preserving practices that he and his associates developed, based ondaoyin and other philosophical traditions.[17] This attempt is considered by some sinologists as the start of the modern or scientific interpretation of qigong.[18][19][20] During theGreat Leap Forward (1958–1963) and theCultural Revolution (1966–1976), qigong, along with other traditional Chinese medicine, was under tight control with limited access among the general public, but was encouraged in state-run rehabilitation centers and spread to universities and hospitals. After the Cultural Revolution, qigong, along withtai chi, was popularized as daily morning exercise practiced en masse throughout China.
Popularity of qigong grew rapidly through the 1990s, during ChairmanDeng Xiaoping andJiang Zemin eras afterMao Zedong's death in 1976, with estimates of between 60 and 200 million practitioners throughout China. In 1985, the state-run China Qigong Science and Research Society was established to regulate the nation's qigong denominations and activities of Qigong Masters.[8]: 59 [10]: 42, 44
With the backing of prominent figures including several senior ranking party officials and most notably the atomic scientistQian Xuesen,[10]: 63–64 research into the paranormal aspects of Qigong gained traction within the Chinese scientific community during the 1980s.[8]: 67–68 Qian advocated for the creation of "somatic science" (人体科学, renti kexue) which would address supernatural powers in its research of latent human body potentials that can be cultivated via Qigong practice.[8]: 65, 107
Along with popularity and state sanction came controversy and problems: claims of extraordinary abilities bordering on the supernatural, pseudoscience explanations to build credibility,[21] a mental condition labeledqigong deviation,[20] formation of cults, and exaggeration of claims by masters for personal benefit.[8][22]
In 1999, in response to widespread revival of old traditions of spirituality, morality, and mysticism, and perceived challenges to State control, the Chinese government took measures to enforce control of public qigong practice, including shutting down qigong clinics and hospitals, and banning groups such asZhong Gong andFalun Gong.[10]: 161–174 [23]Since the 1999 crackdown, qigong research and practice have only been officially supported in the context of health and traditional Chinese medicine. The Chinese Health Qigong Association, established in 2000, strictly regulates public qigong practice, with limitation of public gatherings, requirement of state approved training and certification of instructors, and restriction of practice to state-approved forms.[24][25]
Qigong comprises a diverse set of practices that coordinate body (調身), breath (調息), and mind (調心) based on Chinese philosophy.[26][27] Practices include moving and still meditation, massage, chanting, sound meditation, and non-contact treatments, performed in a broad array of body postures. Qigong is commonly classified into two foundational categories: 1) dynamic or active qigong (dong gong), with slow flowing movement; and 2) meditative or passive qigong (jing gong), with still positions and inner movement of the breath.[28]: 21770–21772 From a therapeutic perspective, qigong can be classified into two systems:1) internal qigong, which focuses on self-care and self-cultivation, and;2) external qigong, which involves treatment by a therapist who directs or transmitsqi.[28]: 21777–21781
As moving meditation, qigong practice typically coordinates slow stylized movement, deepdiaphragmatic breathing, and calm mental focus, with visualization of guidingqi through the body. While implementation details vary, generally qigong forms can be characterized as a mix of four types of practice: dynamic, static, meditative, and activities requiring external aids.
Dynamic practice
involves fluid movement, usually carefully choreographed, coordinated with breath and awareness. Examples include the slow stylized movements oftai chi,baguazhang, andxingyiquan.[29] Other examples include graceful movement that mimics the motion of animals in Five Animals (Wu Qin Xi qigong),[30][self-published source?] White Crane,[31] and Wild Goose (Dayan) Qigong.[32][33] As a form of gentle exercise, qigong is composed of movements that are typically repeated, strengthening and stretching the body, increasing fluid movement (blood, synovial, and lymph), enhancing balance andproprioception, and improving the awareness of how the body moves through space.[34]
Static practice
involves holding postures for sustained periods of time.[35] In some cases this bears resemblance to the practice ofYoga and its continuation in the Buddhist tradition.[36] For exampleYiquan, a Chinese martial art derived fromxingyiquan, emphasizes static stance training.[37] In another example, the healing form Eight Pieces of Brocade (Baduanjin qigong) is based on a series of static postures.[38]
Meditative practice
utilizes breath awareness, visualization,mantra, chanting, sound, and focus on philosophical concepts such asqi circulation, aesthetics, or moral values.[39] In traditional Chinese medicine and Daoist practice, the meditative focus is commonly on cultivatingqi indantian energy centers and balancingqi flow inmeridian and other pathways. In various Buddhist traditions, the aim is to still the mind, either through outward focus, for example on a place, or through inward focus on the breath, a mantra, akoan, emptiness, or the idea of the eternal. In the Confucius scholar tradition, meditation is focused on humanity and virtue, with the aim of self-enlightenment.[12]
Use of external agents
Many systems of qigong practice include the use of external agents such as ingestion of herbs, massage, physical manipulation, or interaction with other living organisms.[14] For example, specialized food and drinks are used in some medical and Daoist forms, whereas massage and body manipulation are sometimes used in martial arts forms. In some medical systems a qigong master uses non-contact treatment, purportedly guidingqi through his or her own body into the body of another person.[40]
There are numerous qigong forms. 75 ancient forms that can be found in ancient literature and also 56 common or contemporary forms have been described in a qigong compendium.[41]: 203–433 The list is by no means exhaustive. Many contemporary forms were developed by people who had recovered from their illness after qigong practice.
Whether viewed from the perspective of exercise, health, philosophy, or martial arts training, several main principles emerge concerning the practice of qigong:[4][34][42][43]
Over time, five distinct traditions or schools of qigong developed in China, each with its own theories and characteristics: Chinesemedical qigong, Daoist qigong, Buddhist qigong, Confucian qigong, and "martial" qigong.[44]: 30–80 All of these qigong traditions include practices intended to cultivate and balanceqi.[12][45][46][47]
The theories of ancient Chinese qigong include theyin and yang andFive Elements Theory, theThree Treasures Theory, Zang-Xiang Theory, Meridians, and theqi-Blood Theory, which have been synthesized as part ofTraditional Chinese Medicine (TCM).[44]: 45–57 TCM aims to identify and correct underlying disharmony, addressing deficiency and excess by utilizing the complementary and opposing forces of yin and yang, to create a balanced flow ofqi.Qi is believed to be cultivated and stored in three maindantian energy centers and to travel through the body along twelve mainmeridians, with numerous smaller branches and tributaries. The main meridians correspond totwelve main organs.Qi is balanced in terms of yin and yang in the context of the traditional system of Five Elements.[12][13] It is understood that illness and disease emerge whenqi becomes diminished, unbalanced, or stagnant. Health is believed to be returned and maintained by rebuildingqi, eliminatingqi blockages, and correctingqi imbalances. Although not all TCM concepts align with modern science and medicine, they are widely adopted by practitioners throughout East Asia and are increasingly used in the West to treat patients.[48]
In Daoism, various practices now known as Daoist qigong are claimed to provide a way to achieve longevity and spiritual realization,[49] as well as a closer connection with the natural world.[50] Daoist Qigong found it philosophical roots in theDao De Jing. Its featured techniques of internal elixir emerged in the Eastern Han dynasty and reached a level of maturity in the Ming and Qing dynasty.[44]: 36–38 TheMing dynasty compendiumChifeng sui, written by a Daoist ascetic, lists various qigong-based "longevity methods".
In Confucianism practices now known as Confucian qigong provide a means to become aJunzi (君子) through awareness of morality.[52][53] Confucian qigong can include dynamic exercise or static meditation, as well as cultivation of the mind to achieve "noble spirit".[44]: 40–41
In contemporary China, the emphasis of qigong practice has shifted away from traditional philosophy, spiritual attainment, and folklore, and increasingly to health benefits, traditional medicine and martial arts applications, and a scientific perspective.[8][10] Qigong is now practiced by millions worldwide, primarily for its health benefits, though many practitioners have also adopted traditional philosophical, medical, or martial arts perspectives, and even use the long history of qigong as evidence of its effectiveness.[12][42]
Qigong has been recognized as a "standard medical technique" in China since 1989, and is sometimes included in the medical curriculum of major universities in China.[54]: 34 The 2013 English translation of the official Chinese medical gigong textbook used in China[44]: iv, 385 defines CMQ as "the skill of body-mind exercise that integrates body, breath, and mind adjustments into one" and emphasizes that qigong is based on "adjustment" (tiao调, also translated as "regulation", "tuning", or "alignment") of body, breath, and mind.[44]: 16–18 As such, qigong is viewed by practitioners as being more than common physical exercise, because qigong combines postural, breathing, and mental training in one to produce a particular psychophysiological state of being.[44]: 15 While CMQ is still based on traditional and classical theory, modern practitioners also emphasize the importance of a strong scientific basis.[44]: 81–89 According to the 2013 CMQ textbook, physiological effects of qigong are numerous, and include improvement of respiratory and cardiovascular function, and possibly neurophysiological function.[44]: 89–102
Integrative, complementary, and alternative medicine
Integrative medicine (IM) refers to "the blending of conventional and complementary medicines and therapies with the aim of using the most appropriate of either or both modalities to care for the patient as a whole",[55]: 455–456 whereascomplementary is using a non-mainstream approach together with conventional medicine, whilealternative is using a non-mainstream approach in place of conventional medicine.[56] Qigong is used by integrative medicine practitioners to complement conventional medical treatment, based on complementary and alternative medicine interpretations of the effectiveness and safety of qigong.[28]: 22278–22306
People practice qigong for many different reasons, including for recreation, exercise and relaxation,preventive medicine andself-healing,meditation andself-cultivation, and training for martial arts. Practitioners range from athletes to people with disabilities. Because it is low impact and can be done lying, sitting, or standing, qigong is accessible for people with disabilities, seniors, and people recovering from injuries.[4]
Qigong is practiced for meditation and self-cultivation as part of various philosophical and spiritual traditions. As meditation, qigong is a means to still the mind and enter a state of consciousness that brings serenity, clarity, and bliss.[14] Many practitioners find qigong, with its gentle focused movement, to be more accessible than seated meditation.[42]
Qigong for self-cultivation can be classified in terms of traditional Chinese philosophy: Daoist, Buddhist, and Confucian.
The practice of qigong is an important component in bothinternal andexternal styleChinese martial arts.[14] Focus onqi is considered to be a source of power as well as the foundation of the internal style of martial arts (neijia).Tai chi,xingyiquan, andbaguazhang are representative of the types of Chinese martial arts that rely on the concept ofqi as the foundation.[57] Extraordinary feats of martial arts prowess, such as the ability to withstand heavy strikes (Iron Shirt,鐵衫)[58][page needed] and the ability to break hard objects (Iron Palm,鐵掌; alt.鐵絲掌,鐵沙掌, or鐵砂掌)[59][page needed][60][page needed] are abilities attributed to qigong training.
Tai chi is a widely practiced Chineseinternalmartial style based on the theory oftaiji, closely associated with qigong, and typically involving more complex choreographed movement coordinated with breath, done slowly for health and training, or quickly for self-defense. Many scholars consider tai chi to be a type of qigong, traced back to an origin in the seventeenth century. In modern practice, qigong typically focuses more on health and meditation rather than martial applications, and plays an important role in training for tai chi, in particular used to build strength, develop breath control, and increase vitality ("life energy").[29][61]
Qigong has shown therapeutic benefits in various health conditions. Research suggests in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), Qigong has been found to improve lung function, exercise capacity, and quality of life.[62] Qigong exercise shows therapeutic efficacy in alleviating fibromyalgia symptoms including pain, sleep quality, fatigue, anxiety, depression, and fibromyalgia impact, as per a pilot randomized clinical trial.[63] Moreover, studies have indicated Qigong-based exercises may be effective for alleviating depression symptoms in individuals with major depressive disorder and future well-designed, randomized controlled trials with large sample sizes are needed to confirm these findings.[64]
Qigong is generally viewed as safe.[65] No adverse effects have been observed in clinical trials, such that qigong is considered safe for use across diverse populations. Cost for self-care is minimal, and cost efficiencies are high for group delivered care.[66] Typically the cautions associated with qigong are the same as those associated with any physical activity, including risk of muscle strains or sprains, advisability of stretching to prevent injury, general safety for use alongside conventional medical treatments, and consulting with a physician when combining with conventional treatment.[2][67]
Only a limited number of studies on Qigong meet accepted medical and scientific standards ofrandomized controlled trials (RCTs).[2][66] Clinical research concerning qigong has been conducted for a wide range of medical conditions, including bone density,cardiopulmonary effects, physical function, falls and related risk factors, quality of life, immune function, inflammation,[66] hypertension,[68] pain,[69] and cancer treatment.[2][70]
Especially since the 1990s, conventional or mainstream Western medicine often strives to heed the model ofevidence-based medicine, EBM, which demotes medical theory, clinical experience, and physiological data to prioritize the results of controlled, and especially randomized, clinical trials of the treatment itself.[71][72] Although some clinical trials support qigong's effectiveness in treating conditions diagnosed in Western medicine, the quality of these studies is mostly low and, overall, their results are mixed.[73]
A 2009 systematic review on the effect of qigong exercises on reducing pain concluded that "the existing trial evidence is not convincing enough to suggest that internal qigong is an effective modality for pain management."[69]
A 2010 systematic review of the effect of qigong exercises on cancer treatment concluded "the effectiveness of qigong in cancer care is not yet supported by the evidence from rigorous clinical trials."[70] A separate systematic review that looked at the effects of qigong exercises on various physiological or psychological outcomes found that the available studies were poorly designed, with a high risk of bias in the results. Therefore, the authors concluded, "Due to limited number of RCTs in the field and methodological problems and high risk of bias in the included studies, it is still too early to reach a conclusion about the efficacy and the effectiveness of qigong exercise as a form of health practice adopted by the cancer patients during their curative, palliative, and rehabilitative phases of the cancer journey."[74]
A 2011 overview ofsystematic reviews of controlled clinical trials, Lee et al. concluded that "the effectiveness of qigong is based mostly on poor quality research" and "therefore, it would be unwise to draw firm conclusions at this stage."[73] Although a 2010comprehensive literature review found 77 peer-reviewed RCTs,[66] Lee et al.'s overview of systematic reviews as to particular health conditions found problems like sample size, lack of proper control groups, with lack ofblinding associated with high risk of bias.[73]
A 2015 systematic review of the effect of qigong exercises on cardiovascular diseases and hypertension found no conclusive evidence for effect.[68] Also in 2015, a systemic review into the effects on hypertension suggested that it may be effective, but that the evidence was not conclusive because of the poor quality of the trials it included, and advised more rigorous research in the future.[75] Another 2015 systematic review of qigong onbiomarkers of cardiovascular disease concluded that some trials showed favorable effects, but concludes, "Most of the trials included in this review are likely to be at high risk of bias, so we have very low confidence in the validity of the results.[68]
Many claims have been made that qigong can benefit or ameliorate mental health conditions,[66] including improved mood, decreased stress reaction, and decreased anxiety and depression. Most medical studies have only examined psychological factors as secondary goals, although various studies have shown decreases in cortisol levels, a chemical hormone produced by the body in response to stress.[66]
Basic and clinical research in China during the 1980s was mostly descriptive, and few results were reported inpeer-reviewed English-language journals.[28]: 22060–22063 Qigong became known outside China in the 1990s, and clinical randomized controlled trials investigating the effectiveness of qigong on health and mental conditions began to be published worldwide, along with systematic reviews.[28]: 21792–21798
Most existing clinical trials have small sample sizes and many have inadequate controls. Of particular concern is the impracticality ofdouble blinding using appropriate sham treatments, and the difficulty of placebo control, such that benefits often cannot be distinguished from theplacebo effect.[28]: 22278–22306 [76] Also of concern is the choice of which qigong form to use and how to standardize the treatment or amount with respect to the skill of the practitioner leading or administering treatment, the tradition of individualization of treatments, and the treatment length, intensity, and frequency.[28]: 6869–6920, 22361–22370 [77]
^abcde"Tai chi and qi gong: In depth". National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, US National Institutes of Health. October 2016. Retrieved13 July 2019.
^Plaugher, Noel (2015).Standing Qigong for health and martial arts, Zhan Zhuang. Ebooks Corporation.ISBN978-0-85701-204-3.
^abcdefCohen, K. S. (1999).The Way of Qigong: The Art and Science of Chinese Energy Healing. Random House of Canada.ISBN978-0-345-42109-8.
^Yang, Jwing-Ming (1987).Chi Kung: health & martial arts. Yang's Martial Arts Association.ISBN978-0-940871-00-7.
^Ho, Peng Yoke (Oct 2000).Li, Qi, and Shu: An Introduction to Science and Civilization in China. Dover Publications.ISBN978-0-486-41445-4.
^abYeYoung, Bing."Origins of Qi Gong". YeYoung Culture Studies: Sacramento, CA. Archived fromthe original on 17 October 2011. Retrieved14 October 2011.
^abcdeYang, Jwing-Ming. (1989).The root of Chinese Chi kung: the secrets of Chi kung training. Yang's Martial Arts Association.ISBN978-0-940871-07-6.
^abHolland, Alex (2000).Voices of Qi: An Introductory Guide to Traditional Chinese Medicine. North Atlantic Books.ISBN978-1-55643-326-9.
^abcdLiang, Shou-Yu; Wu, Wen-Ching; Breiter-Wu, Denise (1997).Qigong Empowerment: A Guide to Medical, Taoist, Buddhist, and Wushu Energy Cultivation. Way of the Dragon Pub.ISBN978-1-889659-02-2.
^Miura, Kunio (1989). "The Revival of Qi". In Livia Kohl (ed.).Taoist Meditation and Longevity Techniques. Center For Chinese Studies: University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.ISBN978-0-89264-085-0.
^Voigt, John (Autumn 2013)."The Man Who Invented "Qigong""(PDF).Qi: The Journal of Traditional Eastern Health & Fitness.23 (3):28–33.Archived(PDF) from the original on 19 October 2014.
^Despeux, C. (1997). "Le qigong, une expression de la modernité Chinoise". In J. Gernet; M. Kalinowski (eds.).En suivant la Voie Royale: Mélanges en homage à Léon Vandermeersch. École Française d'Extrême-Orient. pp. 267–281.
^Penny, Benjamin (1993). "Qigong, Daoism and Science: some contexts for the qigong boom". In Lee, M.; Syrokomla-Stefanowska, A.D. (eds.).Modernisation of the Chinese Past. Sydney: Wild Peony. pp. 166–179.ISBN978-0-86758-658-9.
^Scheid, Volker (2002).Chinese medicine in contemporary China: plurality and synthesis. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.ISBN978-0-8223-2872-8.
^Yang, Bai Long杨柏龙 (2006).气功标准教程 [A Standard Guide on Qigong]. Beijing Sport University Press北京体育大学出版社.ISBN978-7-81100-540-0.
^Lam Kam-Chuen, Master; Lam, Kam Chuen (1991).The way of energy: mastering the Chinese art of internal strength with chi kung exercise. New York: Simon Schuster.ISBN978-0-671-73645-3.
^abcdefgMicozzi, Marc S. (2010).Fundamentals of Complementary and Alternative Medicine. Elsevier Health Sciences, Kindle Edition.
^abYang, Jwing-Ming (1998).The Essence of Taiji Qigong, Second Edition : The Internal Foundation of Taijiquan (Martial Arts-Qigong). YMAA Publication Center.ISBN978-1-886969-63-6.
^Fick, Franklin (2005).Five Animal Frolics Qi Gong: Crane and Bear Exercises. Lulu.com.ISBN978-1-4116-2776-5.
^Zhang, Hong-Chao (2000).Wild Goose Qigong: Natural Movement for Healthy Living. YMAA Publication Center.ISBN978-1-886969-78-0.
^Connor, Danny; Tse, Michael (1992).Qigong: Chinese movement meditation for health. York Beach, Me.: S. Weiser.ISBN978-0-87728-758-2.
^abFrantzis, Bruce Kumar (2008).The Chi Revolution: Harnessing the Healing Power of Your Life Force. Blue Snake Books.ISBN978-1-58394-193-5.
^Diepersloot, Jan (2000).The Tao of Yiquan: The Method of Awareness in the Martial Arts. Center For Healing & The Arts.ISBN978-0-9649976-1-5.
^Dumoulin, Heinrich; Heisig, James W.; McRae, John M.; Knitter, Paul F. (2005).Zen Buddhism: a history. Bloomington, Ind.: World Wisdom.ISBN978-0-941532-89-1.
^Dong, Paul; Raffill, Thomas (2005-12-10).Empty Force: The Power of Chi for Self-Defense and Energy Healing. Blue Snake Books/Frog, Ltd.ISBN978-1-58394-134-8.
^Yang, Jwing-Ming; Jwing-Ming, Yang (1997).Eight Simple Qigong Exercises for Health: The Eight Pieces of Brocade. YMAA Publication Center.ISBN978-1-886969-52-0.
^Lu, Kuan Yü (1969).The secrets of Chinese meditation: self-cultivation by mind control as taught in the Ch'an, Mahāyāna and Taoist schools in China. S. Weiser.
^Xu, Xiangcai (2000).Qigong for Treating Common Ailments. YMAA Publication Center.ISBN978-1-886969-70-4.
^Ma Ji Ren馬濟人 (1992).實用中醫氣功學 [Practical Qigong for Traditional Chinese Medicine]. Shanghai Scientific and Technical Publishers上海科学枝术出版社. p. 466.ISBN978-7-5323-2720-1.
^Réquéna, Yves (1996).Chi Kung: The Chinese Art of Mastering Energy. Healing Arts Press. p. 4.ISBN978-0-89281-639-2.
^Bucknell, Roderick S.; Stuart-Fox, Martin (1993).The twilight language: explorations in Buddhist meditation and symbolism. London: Curzon Press.ISBN978-0-7007-0234-3.
^Hook, Mary, Van; Hugen, Beryl; Aguilar, Marian Angela (2001).Spirituality within religious traditions in social work practice. Australia: Brooks/Cole-Thomson Learning.ISBN978-0-534-58419-1.
^Richey, Jeffrey Edward (2008).Teaching Confucianism. New York: Oxford University Press.ISBN978-0-19-531160-0.
^Kotsirilos, Vicki; Luis Vitetta; Avni Sali (2011).A Guide to Evidence-based Integrative and Complementary Medicine. Elsevier Health Sciences APAC. Kindle Edition.
^Li, Lu; Yun, Zhang (2006).The Combat Techniques of Tai Ji, Xing Yi, and Ba Gua : Principles and Practices of Internal Martial Arts. Frog, Ltd./Blue Snake Books.ISBN978-1-58394-145-4.
^"Clinical trials and CAM"(PDF). National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, US National Institutes of Health. August 2010.Archived(PDF) from the original on 21 December 2016. Retrieved27 October 2018.
^Antonishen, Kevin (2015). "Exercise mode heterogeneity among reported studies of the qigong practice baduanjin".Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies.19 (2):278–283.doi:10.1016/j.jbmt.2014.05.013.PMID25892384.