Awind turbine is a device thatconverts thekinetic energy ofwind intoelectrical energy. As of 2020[update], hundreds of thousands oflarge turbines, in installations known aswind farms, were generating over 650gigawatts of power, with 60 GW added each year.[1] Wind turbines are an increasingly important source of intermittentrenewable energy, and are used in many countries to lower energy costs and reduce reliance onfossil fuels. One study claimed that, as of 2009,[update] wind had the "lowest relative greenhouse gas emissions, the least water consumption demands and the most favorable social impacts" compared tophotovoltaic,hydro,geothermal,coal andgas energy sources.[2]
Smaller wind turbines are used for applications such asbattery charging and remote devices such as traffic warning signs. Larger turbines can contribute to a domestic power supply while selling unused power back to the utility supplier via theelectrical grid.[3]
Windturbines are manufactured in a wide range of sizes, with either horizontal or vertical axes, though horizontal is most common.[4]
The windwheel ofHero of Alexandria (10–70 CE) marks one of the first recorded instances of wind powering a machine.[5] However, the first known practical wind power plants were built inSistan, an Eastern province ofPersia (now Iran), from the 7th century. These "Panemone" were vertical axle windmills, which had long verticaldrive shafts with rectangular blades.[6] Made of six to twelvesails covered in reed matting or cloth material, these windmills were used to grind grain or draw up water, and were used in thegristmilling and sugarcane industries.[7]
Wind power first appeared in Europe during theMiddle Ages. The first historical records of their use in England date to the 11th and 12th centuries; there are reports of Germancrusaders taking their windmill-making skills to Syria around 1190.[8] By the 14th century, Dutch windmills were in use to drain areas of theRhine delta. Advanced wind turbines were described by Croatian inventorFausto Veranzio in his bookMachinae Novae (1595). He describedvertical axis wind turbines with curved or V-shaped blades.
Illustration of the wind turbine for power generation erected by Josef Friedlaender at the International Electrical Exhibition in Vienna in 1883James Blyth's electricity-generating wind turbine, photographed in 1891
The first electricity-generating wind turbine was installed by theAustrianJosef Friedländer at theVienna International Electrical Exhibition in 1883. It was a Halladay windmill for driving adynamo. Friedländer's 6.6 m (22 ft) diameter Halladay "wind motor" was supplied by U.S. Wind Engine & Pump Co. ofBatavia,Illinois. The 3.7 kW (5 hp) windmill drove a dynamo at ground level that fed electricity into a series ofbatteries. The batteries powered various electrical tools and lamps, as well as a threshing machine. Friedländer's windmill and its accessories were prominently installed at the north entrance to the main exhibition hall ("Rotunde") in theVienna Prater.[9][10][11]
In July 1887, Scottish academicJames Blyth installed a battery-charging machine to light his holiday home inMarykirk, Scotland.[12] Some months later, American inventorCharles F. Brush was able to build the first automatically operated wind turbine after consulting local University professors and his colleagues Jacob S. Gibbs and Brinsley Coleberd and successfully getting the blueprints peer-reviewed for electricity production.[13] Although Blyth's turbine was considered uneconomical in the United Kingdom,[13] electricity generation by wind turbines was more cost effective in countries with widely scattered populations.[8]
The first automatically operated wind turbine, built in Cleveland in 1887 by Charles F. Brush. It was 60 feet (18 m) tall, weighed 4 tons (3.6 metric tonnes) and powered a 12kW generator.[14]
InDenmark by 1900, there were about 2500 windmills for mechanical loads such as pumps and mills, producing an estimated combined peak power of about 30megawatts (MW). The largest machines were on 24-metre (79 ft) towers with four-bladed 23-metre (75 ft) diameter rotors. By 1908, there were 72 wind-driven electric generators operating in the United States from 5kilowatts (kW) to 25 kW. Around the time of World War I, American windmill makers were producing 100,000 farm windmills each year, mostly for water-pumping.[15]
By the 1930s, use of wind turbines in rural areas was declining as thedistribution system extended to those areas.[16]
A forerunner of modern horizontal-axis wind generators was in service atYalta, USSR, in 1931. This was a 100kW generator on a 30-meter (98 ft) tower, connected to the local 6.3 kV distribution system. It was reported to have an annualcapacity factor of 32 percent, not much different from current wind machines.[citation needed]
In the autumn of 1941, the first megawatt-class wind turbine was synchronized to a utility grid inVermont. TheSmith–Putnam wind turbine only ran for about five years before one of the blades snapped off.[17] The unit was not repaired, because of a shortage of materials during the war.[18]
In the early 1970s, however, anti-nuclear protests in Denmark spurred artisan mechanics to develop microturbines of 22kW despite declines in the industry.[20] Organizing owners into associations and co-operatives led to the lobbying of the government and utilities and provided incentives for larger turbines throughout the 1980s and later. Local activists in Germany, nascent turbine manufacturers in Spain, and large investors in the United States in the early 1990s then lobbied for policies that stimulated the industry in those countries.[21][22][23]
It has been argued that expanding the use of wind power will lead to increasing geopolitical competition over critical materials for wind turbines, such asrare earth elementsneodymium,praseodymium, anddysprosium. However, this perspective has been critically dismissed for failing to relay how most wind turbines do not use permanent magnets and for underestimating the power of economic incentives for the expanded production of these minerals.[24]
Wind Power Density (WPD) is a quantitative measure of wind energy available at any location. It is the mean annual power available per square meter of swept area of a turbine, and is calculated for different heights above ground. Calculation ofwind power density includes the effect of wind velocity and air density.[25]
Wind turbines are classified by the wind speed they are designed for, from class I to class III, with A to C referring to the turbulence intensity of the wind.[26]
Class
Avg Wind Speed (m/s)
Turbulence
IA
10
16%
IB
10
14%
IC
10
12%
IIA
8.5
16%
IIB
8.5
14%
IIC
8.5
12%
IIIA
7.5
16%
IIIB
7.5
14%
IIIC
7.5
12%
Efficiency
Conservation of mass requires that the mass of air entering and exiting a turbine must be equal. Likewise, theconservation of energy requires the energy given to the turbine from incoming wind to be equal to that of the combination of the energy in the outgoing wind and the energy converted to electrical energy. Since outgoing wind will still possess some kinetic energy, there must be a maximum proportion of the input energy that is available to be converted to electrical energy.[27] Accordingly,Betz's law gives the maximal achievable extraction of wind power by a wind turbine, known as Betz's coefficient, as16⁄27 (59.3%) of the rate at which the kinetic energy of the air arrives at the turbine.[28][29]
The maximum theoretical power output of a wind machine is thus16⁄27 times the rate at which kinetic energy of the air arrives at the effective disk area of the machine. If the effective area of the disk is A, and the wind velocity v, the maximum theoretical power output P is:
Wind-to-rotor efficiency (including rotor bladefriction anddrag) are among the factors affecting the finalprice of wind power.[30]Further inefficiencies, such asgearbox, generator, and converter losses, reduce the power delivered by a wind turbine. To protect components from undue wear, extracted power is held constant above the rated operating speed as theoretical powerincreases as the cube of wind speed, further reducing theoretical efficiency. In 2001, commercial utility-connected turbines delivered 75% to 80% of the Betz limit of power extractable from the wind, at rated operating speed.[31][32]
Efficiency can decrease slightly over time, one of the main reasons being dust and insect carcasses on the blades, which alter the aerodynamic profile and essentially reduce thelift to drag ratio of theairfoil. Analysis of 3128 wind turbines older than 10 years in Denmark showed that half of the turbines had no decrease, while the other half saw a production decrease of 1.2% per year.[33]
In general, more stable and constant weather conditions (most notably wind speed) result in an average of 15% greater efficiency than that of a wind turbine in unstable weather conditions, thus allowing up to a 7% increase in wind speed under stable conditions. This is due to a faster recovery wake and greater flow entrainment that occur in conditions of higher atmospheric stability. However, wind turbine wakes have been found to recover faster under unstable atmospheric conditions as opposed to a stable environment.[34]
Different materials have varying effects on the efficiency of wind turbines. In an Ege University experiment, three wind turbines, each with three blades with a diameter of one meter, were constructed with blades made of different materials: A glass and glass/carbonepoxy, glass/carbon, and glass/polyester. When tested, the results showed that the materials with higher overall masses had a greater friction moment and thus a lower power coefficient.[35]
The air velocity is the major contributor to the turbine efficiency. This is the reason for the importance of choosing the right location. The wind velocity will be high near the shore because of the temperature difference between the land and the ocean. Another option is to place turbines on mountain ridges. The higher the wind turbine will be, the higher the wind velocity on average. Awindbreak can also increase the wind velocity near the turbine.[36]
Types
The three primary types: VAWTSavonius, HAWT towered; VAWTDarrieus as they appear in operation
Wind turbines can rotate about either a horizontal or a vertical axis, the former being both older and more common.[37] They can also include blades or be bladeless.[38] Household-size vertical designs produce less power and are less common.[39]
Horizontal axis
Components of a horizontal axis wind turbine (gearbox, rotor shaft and brake assembly) being lifted into positionTherotor of agearless wind turbine being set. This particular turbine was prefabricated in Germany, before being shipped to the U.S. for assembly.Offshore Horizontal Axis Wind Turbines (HAWTs) atScroby Sands Wind Farm, EnglandOnshore Horizontal Axis Wind Turbines inZhangjiakou,Hebei, China
Large three-bladed horizontal-axis wind turbines (HAWT) with the blades upwind of the tower (i.e.blades facing the incoming wind) produce the overwhelming majority of wind power in the world today.[4] These turbines have the mainrotor shaft andelectrical generator at the top of a tower and must be pointed into the wind. Small turbines are pointed by a simplewind vane, while large turbines generally use a wind sensor coupled with a yaw system. Most have a gearbox, which turns the slow rotation of the blades into a quicker rotation that is more suitable to drive an electrical generator.[40] Some turbines use a different type of generator suited to slower rotational speed input. These do not need a gearbox and are called direct-drive, meaning they couple the rotor directly to the generator with no gearbox in between. Whilepermanent magnetdirect-drive generators can be more costly due to the rare earth materials required, thesegearless turbines are sometimes preferred over gearbox generators because they "eliminate the gear-speed increaser, which is susceptible to significant accumulated fatigue torque loading, related reliability issues, and maintenance costs".[41] There is also the pseudo direct drive mechanism, which has some advantages over the permanent magnet direct drive mechanism.[42]
Most horizontal axis turbines have their rotors upwind of the supporting tower.[43] Downwind machines have been built, because they don't need an additional mechanism for keeping them in line with the wind. In high winds, downwind blades can also be designed to bend more than upwind ones, which reduces their swept area and thus their wind resistance, mitigating risk during gales. Despite these advantages, upwind designs are preferred, because the pulsing change in loading from the wind as each blade passes behind the supporting tower can cause damage to the turbine.[44]
Turbines used inwind farms for commercial production of electric power are usually three-bladed. These have lowtorque ripple, which contributes to good reliability. The blades are usually colored white for daytime visibility by aircraft and range in length from 20 to 80 meters (66 to 262 ft). The size and height of turbines increase year by year. Offshore wind turbines are built up to 8MW today and have a blade length up to 80 meters (260 ft). Designs with 10 to 12 MW were in preparation in 2018,[45] and a "15 MW+" prototype with three 118-metre (387 ft) blades is planned to be constructed in 2022.[needs update][46] The average hub height of horizontal axis wind turbines is 90 meters.[47]
Vertical axis
Vertical-axis wind turbines (or VAWTs) have the main rotor shaft arranged vertically. One advantage of this arrangement is that the turbine does not need to be pointed into the wind to be effective,[48] which is an advantage on a site where the wind direction is highly variable. It is also an advantage when the turbine is integrated into a building because it is inherently less steerable. Also, the generator and gearbox can be placed near the ground, using a direct drive from the rotor assembly to the ground-based gearbox, improving accessibility for maintenance. However, these designs produce much less energy averaged over time, which is a major drawback.[39][49]
Vertical turbine designs have much lower efficiency than standard horizontal designs.[50] The key disadvantages include the relatively low rotational speed with the consequential highertorque and hence higher cost of the drive train, the inherently lowerpower coefficient, the 360-degree rotation of the aerofoil within the wind flow during each cycle and hence the highly dynamic loading on the blade, the pulsating torque generated by some rotor designs on the drive train, and the difficulty of modelling the wind flow accurately and hence the challenges of analysing and designing the rotor prior to fabricating a prototype.[51]
When a turbine is mounted on a rooftop the building generally redirects wind over the roof and this can double the wind speed at the turbine. If the height of a rooftop mounted turbine tower is approximately 50% of the building height it is near the optimum for maximum wind energy and minimum wind turbulence. While wind speeds within the built environment are generally much lower than at exposed rural sites,[52][53] noise may be a concern and an existing structure may not adequately resist the additional stress.
"Eggbeater" turbines, or Darrieus turbines, were named after the French inventor, Georges Darrieus.[54] They have good efficiency, but produce largetorque ripple and cyclical stress on the tower, which contributes to poor reliability. They also generally require some external power source, or an additional Savonius rotor to start turning, because the starting torque is very low. The torque ripple is reduced by using three or more blades, which results in greater solidity of the rotor. Solidity is measured by the blade area divided by the rotor area.
Giromill
A subtype of Darrieus turbine with straight, as opposed to curved, blades. The cycloturbine variety has variable pitch to reduce the torque pulsation and is self-starting.[55] The advantages of variable pitch are high starting torque; a wide, relatively flat torque curve; a highercoefficient of performance; more efficient operation in turbulent winds; and a lower blade speed ratio, which lowers blade bending stresses. Straight, V, or curved blades may be used.[56]
These are drag-type devices with two (or more) scoops that are used in anemometers,Flettner vents (commonly seen on bus and van roofs), and in some high-reliability low-efficiency power turbines. They are always self-starting if there are at least three scoops.[48]
Twisted Savonius is a modified savonius, with long helical scoops to provide smooth torque. This is often used as a rooftop wind turbine and has even beenadapted for ships.[57]
Airborne wind turbines consist of wings or a small aircraft tethered to the ground.[58] They are useful for reaching faster winds above which traditional turbines can operate. There are prototypes in operation in east Africa.[59]
These are offshore wind turbines that are supported by a floating platform.[60] By having them float, they are able to be installed in deeper water allowing more of them. This also allows them to be further out of sight from land and therefore less public concern about the visual appeal.[61]
A 1.5 (MW) wind turbine of a type frequently seen in the United States has a tower 80 meters (260 ft) high. The rotor assembly (blades and hub) measures about 80 meters (260 ft) in diameter.[67] Thenacelle, which contains the generator, is 15.24 meters (50.0 ft) and weighs around 300 tons.[68]
Due to data transmission problems,structural health monitoring of wind turbines is usually performed using several accelerometers and strain gages attached to the nacelle to monitor the gearbox and equipment. Currently,digital image correlation andstereophotogrammetry are used to measure dynamics of wind turbine blades. These methods usually measure displacement and strain to identify location of defects. Dynamic characteristics of non-rotating wind turbines have been measured using digital image correlation and photogrammetry.[69] Three dimensional point tracking has also been used to measure rotating dynamics of wind turbines.[70]
Technology
Development in size and power of wind turbines, 1990–2016
Generally, efficiency increases along with turbine blade lengths. The blades must be stiff, strong, durable, light and resistant to fatigue.[71] Materials with these properties include composites such as polyester and epoxy, while glass fiber and carbon fiber have been used for the reinforcing.[72] Construction may involve manual layup or injection molding. Retrofitting existing turbines with larger blades reduces the task and risks of redesign.[73]
As of 2021, the longest blade was 115.5 m (379 ft), producing 15 MW.[74]
Blades usually last around 20 years, the typical lifespan of a wind turbine.[75]
Blade materials
Materials commonly used in wind turbine blades are described below.
The stiffness of composites is determined by the stiffness of fibers and their volume content. Typically, E-glass fibers are used as main reinforcement in the composites. Typically, the glass/epoxy composites for wind turbine blades contain up to 75% glass by weight. This increases the stiffness, tensile and compression strength. A promising composite material is glass fiber with modified compositions like S-glass, R-glass etc. Other glass fibers developed by Owens Corning are ECRGLAS, Advantex and WindStrand.[76]
Carbon fiber has more tensile strength, higher stiffness and lower density than glass fiber. An ideal candidate for these properties is the spar cap, a structural element of a blade that experiences high tensile loading.[72] A 100-metre (330 ft) glass fiber blade could weigh up to 50 tonnes (110,000 lb), while using carbon fiber in the spar saves 20% to 30% weight, about 15 tonnes (33,000 lb).[77]
Hybrid reinforcements
Instead of making wind turbine blade reinforcements from pure glass or pure carbon, hybrid designs trade weight for cost. For example, for an 8-metre (26 ft) blade, a full replacement by carbon fiber would save 80% of weight but increase costs by 150%, while a 30% replacement would save 50% of weight and increase costs by 90%. Hybrid reinforcement materials include E-glass/carbon, E-glass/aramid. The current longest blade by LM Wind Power is made of carbon/glass hybrid composites. More research is needed about the optimal composition of materials.[78]
Nano-engineered polymers and composites
Additions of small amount (0.5 weight %) of nanoreinforcement (carbon nanotubes or nanoclay) in the polymer matrix of composites, fiber sizing or inter-laminar layers can improve fatigue resistance, shear or compressive strength, and fracture toughness of the composites by 30% to 80%. Research has also shown that incorporating small amounts of carbon nanotubes (CNT) can increase the lifetime up to 1500%.[79]
Costs
As of 2019[update], thecapital cost of a wind turbine was around $1 million per megawatt ofnameplate capacity, though this figure varies by location; for example, such numbers ranged from a half million in South America to $1.7 million in Asia.[80]
For the wind turbine blades, while the material cost is much higher for hybrid glass/carbon fiber blades than all-glass fiber blades, labor costs can be lower. Using carbon fiber allows simpler designs that use less raw material. The chief manufacturing process in blade fabrication is the layering of plies. Thinner blades allow reducing the number of layers and thus the labor and in some cases, equate to the cost of labor for glass fiber blades.[81]
Offshore has significantly higher installation costs.[82]
Non-blade materials
Wind turbine parts other than the rotor blades (including the rotor hub, gearbox, frame, and tower) are largely made of steel. Smaller turbines (as well as megawatt-scale Enercon turbines) have begun using aluminum alloys for these components to make turbines lighter and more efficient. This trend may grow if fatigue and strength properties can be improved. Pre-stressed concrete has been increasingly used for the material of the tower, but still requires much reinforcing steel to meet the strength requirement of the turbine. Additionally, step-up gearboxes are being increasingly replaced with variable speed generators, which requires magnetic materials.[71]
Modern turbinesuse a couple of tons of copper for generators and cables and such.[83] As of 2018[update], global production of wind turbines use 450,000 tonnes (990 million pounds) of copper per year.[84]
A 2015 study of the material consumption trends and requirements for wind energy in Europe found that bigger turbines have a higher consumption of precious metals but lower material input perkW generated. The material consumption and stock at that time was compared to input materials for various onshore system sizes. In all EU countries, the estimates for 2020 doubled the values consumed in 2009. These countries would need to expand their resources to meet the estimated demand for 2020. For example, the EU had 3% of world supply offluorspar, and it would require 14% by 2020. Globally, the main exporting countries are South Africa, Mexico, and China. This is similar with other critical and valuable materials required for energy systems such as magnesium, silver and indium. The levels of recycling of these materials are very low, and focusing on that could alleviate supply. Because most of these valuable materials are also used in other emerging technologies, likelight emitting diodes (LEDs),photo voltaics (PVs) andliquid crystal displays (LCDs), their demand is expected to grow.[85]
A 2011 study by the United States Geological Survey estimated resources required to fulfill the US commitment to supplying 20% of its electricity from wind power by 2030. It did not consider requirements for small turbines or offshore turbines because those were not common in 2008 when the study was done. Common materials such as cast iron, steel and concrete would increase by 2%–3% compared to 2008. Between 110,000 and 115,000 metric tons of fiber glass would be required per year, a 14% increase. Rare-earth metal use would not increase much compared to available supply, however rare-earth metals that are also used for other technologies such as batteries which are increasing its global demand need to be taken into account. Land required would be 50,000 square kilometers onshore and 11,000 offshore. This would not be a problem in the US due to its vast area and because the same land can be used for farming. A greater challenge would be the variability and transmission to areas of high demand.[86]
Permanent magnets for wind turbine generators contain rare-earth metals such asneodymium (Nd),praseodymium (Pr),terbium (Tb), anddysprosium (Dy). Systems that use magnetic direct drive turbines require greater amounts of rare-earth metals. Therefore, an increase in wind turbine manufacture would increase the demand for these resources. By 2035, the demand for Nd is estimated to increase by 4,000 to 18,000 tons and for Dy by 200 to 1,200 tons. These values are a quarter to half of current production. However, these estimates are very uncertain because technologies are developing rapidly.[87]
Reliance onrare earth minerals for components has risked expense and price volatility as China has been main producer of rare earth minerals (96% in 2009) and was reducing its export quotas.[86] However, in recent years, other producers have increased production and China has increased export quotas, leading to higher supply, lower cost, and greater viability of large-scale use of variable-speed generators.[88]
Glass fiber is the most common material for reinforcement. Its demand has grown due to growth in construction, transportation and wind turbines. Its global market might reach US$17.4 billion by 2024, compared to US$8.5 billion in 2014. In 2014, Asia Pacific produced more than 45% of the market; now China is the largest producer. The industry receives subsidies from the Chinese government allowing it to export cheaper to the US and Europe. However, price wars have led to anti-dumping measures such as tariffs on Chinese glass fiber.[89]
TheNordex N50 wind turbine and visitor centre ofLamma Winds inHong Kong, ChinaWind turbines in the Bahrain World Trade Center
A few localities have exploited the attention-getting nature of wind turbines by placing them on public display, either with visitor centers around their bases, or with viewing areas farther away.[90] The wind turbines are generally of conventional horizontal-axis, three-bladed design and generate power to feed electrical grids, but they also serve the unconventional roles of technology demonstration, public relations, and education.[91]
TheBahrain World Trade Center is an example of wind turbines displayed prominently for the public. It is the first skyscraper to integrate wind turbines into its design
Small wind turbines may be used for a variety of applications including on- or off-grid residences, telecom towers, offshore platforms, rural schools and clinics, remote monitoring and other purposes that require energy where there is no electric grid, or where the grid is unstable. Small wind turbines may be as small as a fifty-watt generator for boat orcaravan use. Hybrid solar- and wind-powered units are increasingly being used for traffic signage, particularly in rural locations, since they avoid the need to lay long cables from the nearest mains connection point.[92] TheU.S. Department of Energy's National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) defines small wind turbines as those smaller than or equal to 100 kilowatts.[93] Small units often have direct-drive generators,direct current output, aeroelastic blades, and lifetime bearings and use a vane to point into the wind.[94]
Wind turbine spacing
On most horizontal wind turbine farms, a spacing of about 6–10 times the rotor diameter is often upheld. However, for large wind farms, distances of about 15 rotor diameters should be more economical, taking into account typical wind turbine and land costs. This conclusion has been reached by research[95] conducted byCharles Meneveau of Johns Hopkins University[96] and Johan Meyers of Leuven University in Belgium, based on computer simulations[97] that take into account the detailed interactions among wind turbines (wakes) as well as with the entire turbulent atmospheric boundary layer.
Research by John Dabiri of Caltech suggests that vertical wind turbines may be placed much more closely together so long as an alternating pattern of rotation is created allowing blades of neighbouring turbines to move in the same direction as they approach one another.[98]
Operability
Workers inspect wind turbine blades.
Maintenance
Wind turbines need regularmaintenance to stayreliable andavailable. In the best case turbines are available to generate energy 98% of the time.[99][100] Ice accretion on turbine blades has also been found to greatly reduce the efficiency of wind turbines, which is a common challenge in cold climates wherein-cloud icing and freezing rain events occur.[101]Deicing is mainly performed by internal heating or in some cases, by helicopters spraying clean warm water on the blades.[102]
Modern turbines usually have a small onboardcrane for hoisting maintenance tools and minor components. However, large, heavy components like generators, gearboxes, blades, and so on are rarely replaced, and aheavy lift external crane is needed in those cases. If the turbine has a difficult access road, acontainerized crane can be lifted up by the internal crane to provide heavier lifting.[103]
Installation of new wind turbines can be controversial. An alternative is repowering, where existing wind turbines are replaced with bigger, more powerful ones, sometimes in smaller numbers while keeping or increasing capacity.[104]
Demolition and recycling
Some wind turbines which are out of use arerecycled or repowered.[105][106] 85% of turbine materials are easily reused or recycled, but the blades, made of a composite material, are more difficult to process.[107]
Interest in recycling blades varies in different markets and depends on the waste legislation and local economics. A challenge in recycling blades is related to the composite material, which is made offiberglass with carbon fibers in epoxy resin, which cannot be remolded to form new composites.[108]
Several utilities, startup companies, and researchers are developing methods for reusing or recycling blades.[107] ManufacturerVestas has developed technology that can separate the fibers from the resin, allowing for reuse.[110] In Germany, wind turbine blades are commercially recycled as part of an alternative fuel mix for a cement factory.[107] In the United Kingdom, a project will trial cutting blades into strips for use as rebar inconcrete, with the aim of reducing emissions in the construction ofHigh Speed 2.[111] Used wind turbine blades have been recycled by incorporating them as part of the support structures within pedestrian bridges in Poland[112] and Ireland.[113]
Comparison with other power sources
Advantages
Wind turbines is one of the lowest-cost sources of renewable energy along withsolar panels.[114] As technology needed for wind turbines continued to improve, the prices decreased as well. In addition, there is currently no competitive market for wind energy (though there may be in the future), because wind is a freely available natural resource, most of which is untapped.[115] The main cost of small wind turbines is the purchase and installation process, which averages between $48,000 and $65,000 per installation. Usually, the total amount of energy harvested amounts to more than the cost of the turbines.[116]
Wind turbines provide a clean energy source,[117] use little water,[2] emitting no greenhouse gases and no waste products during operation. Over 1,400 tonnes (1,500 short tons) of carbon dioxide per year can be eliminated by using a one-megawatt turbine instead of one megawatt of energy from a fossil fuel.[118]
Disadvantages
Wind turbines can be very large, reaching over 260 m (850 ft) tall with blades 110 m (360 ft) long,[119] and people have often complained about their visual impact.
In the U.S. cats kill on the order of 10,000 times as many birds aswind turbines.[120]
Environmental impact of wind power includes effect on wildlife, but can be mitigated if proper strategies are implemented.[121] Thousands of birds, including rare species, have been killed by the blades of wind turbines,[122] though wind turbines contribute relatively insignificantly to anthropogenic avian mortality (birds killed by humans). Wind farms andnuclear power plants are responsible for between 0.3 and 0.4 bird deaths per gigawatt-hour (GWh) of electricity whilefossil fuel power stations are responsible for about 5.2 fatalities per GWh. In comparison, conventional coal-fired generators contribute significantly more to bird mortality.[123] A study on recorded bird populations in the United States from 2000 to 2020 found the presence of wind turbines had no significant effect on bird population numbers.[124]
Energy harnessed by wind turbines is variable, and is not a "dispatchable" source of power; its availability is based on whether the wind is blowing, not whether electricity is needed. Turbines can be placed onridges orbluffs to maximize the access of wind they have, but this also limits the locations where they can be placed.[115] In this way, wind energy is not a particularly reliable source of energy. However, it can form part of theenergy mix, which also includes power from other sources. Technology is also being developed to store excess energy, which can then make up for any deficits in supplies.[125]
Wind turbines haveblinking lights that warn aircraft, to avoid collisions.[126] Residents living near windfarms, especially those in rural areas, have complained that the blinking lights are a bothersome form oflight pollution.[126] A light mitigation approach involves Aircraft Detection Lighting Systems (ADLSs) by which the lights are turned on, only when the ADLS'sradar detects aircraft within thresholds of altitude and distance.[126]
^abEvans, Annette; Strezov, Vladimir; Evans, Tim (June 2009). "Assessment of sustainability indicators for renewable energy technologies".Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.13 (5):1082–1088.Bibcode:2009RSERv..13.1082E.doi:10.1016/j.rser.2008.03.008.
^abMorthorst, Poul Erik; Redlinger, Robert Y.; Andersen, Per (2002).Wind energy in the 21st century: economics, policy, technology and the changing electricity industry. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave/UNEP.ISBN978-0-333-79248-3.
^Hesse, Nicole (November 2021). "Visible winds: The production of new visibilities of wind energy in West Germany, 1973–1991".Centaurus.63 (4):695–713.doi:10.1111/1600-0498.12420.
^Bywaters, G.; Mattila; Costin; Stowell; John; Hoskins; Lynch; Cole; Cate; C. Badger; B. Freeman (October 2007)."Northern Power NW 1500 Direct-Drive Generator"(PDF). National Renewable Energy Laboratory. p. iii.
^Neves, C. G. C.; Flores Filho, A. F.; Dorrel, D. G. (2016). "Design of a Pseudo Direct Drive for Wind Power Applications".2016 International Conference of Asian Union of Magnetics Societies (ICAUMS). pp. 1–5.doi:10.1109/ICAUMS.2016.8479825.ISBN978-1-5090-4383-5.
^abTummala, Abhishiktha; Velamati, Ratna Kishore; Sinha, Dipankur Kumar; Indraja, V.; Krishna, V. Hari (April 2016). "A review on small scale wind turbines".Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews.56:1351–1371.Bibcode:2016RSERv..56.1351T.doi:10.1016/j.rser.2015.12.027.
^Michael C Brower; Nicholas M Robinson; Erik Hale (May 2010)."Wind Flow Modeling Uncertainty"(PDF). AWS Truepower. Archived from the original on 2 May 2013.
^Baqersad, Javad; Niezrecki, Christopher; Avitabile, Peter (2015). "Full-field dynamic strain prediction on a wind turbine using displacements of optical targets measured by stereophotogrammetry".Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing.62–63:284–295.Bibcode:2015MSSP...62..284B.doi:10.1016/j.ymssp.2015.03.021.
^Lundstrom, Troy; Baqersad, Javad; Niezrecki, Christopher; Avitabile, Peter (4 November 2012). "Using High-Speed Stereophotogrammetry Techniques to Extract Shape Information from Wind Turbine/Rotor Operating Data". In Allemang, R.; De Clerck, J.; Niezrecki, C.; Blough, J.R. (eds.).Topics in Modal Analysis II, Volume 6. Conference Proceedings of the Society for Experimental Mechanics Series. Springer New York. pp. 269–275.doi:10.1007/978-1-4614-2419-2_26.ISBN978-1-4614-2418-5.
^Panduranga, Raghu; Alamoudi, Yasser; Ferrah, Azzeddine (2019). "Nanoengineered Composite Materials for Wind Turbine Blades".2019 Advances in Science and Engineering Technology International Conferences (ASET). pp. 1–7.doi:10.1109/ICASET.2019.8714217.ISBN978-1-5386-8271-5.
^Frost and Sullivan, 2009, cited in Wind Generator Technology, by Eclareon S.L., Madrid, May 2012; www.eclareon.com; Available at Leonardo Energy – Ask an Expert;Fernando Nuno (30 May 2012)."Ask an expert".Leonardo ENERGY. Archived fromthe original on 26 November 2012. Retrieved12 December 2012.
^Kim, Junbeum; Guillaume, Bertrand; Chung, Jinwook; Hwang, Yongwoo (February 2015). "Critical and precious materials consumption and requirement in wind energy system in the EU 27".Applied Energy.139:327–334.Bibcode:2015ApEn..139..327K.doi:10.1016/j.apenergy.2014.11.003.
^Buchholz, Peter; Brandenburg, Torsten (January 2018). "Demand, Supply, and Price Trends for Mineral Raw Materials Relevant to the Renewable Energy Transition Wind Energy, Solar Photovoltaic Energy, and Energy Storage".Chemie Ingenieur Technik.90 (1–2):141–153.doi:10.1002/cite.201700098.
^Dabiri, John O. (July 2011). "Potential order-of-magnitude enhancement of wind farm power density via counter-rotating vertical-axis wind turbine arrays".Journal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy.3 (4): 043104.arXiv:1010.3656.doi:10.1063/1.3608170.
^Barber, S.; Wang, Y.; Jafari, S.; Chokani, N.; Abhari, R. S. (February 2011). "The Impact of Ice Formation on Wind Turbine Performance and Aerodynamics".Journal of Solar Energy Engineering.133 (1).doi:10.1115/1.4003187.
^Nilsen, Jannicke (1 February 2015)."Her spyler helikopteret bort et tykt lag med is".Tu.no (in Norwegian).Teknisk Ukeblad.Archived from the original on 20 January 2021.These work .. by blowing hot air into the rotor blades so that the ice melts, or by using heating cables on the front edge of the rotor blades where the ice sticks. No chemicals are added to the water, in contrast to aircraft de-icing, which often involves extensive use of chemicals. The price tag for de-icing a wind turbine is equivalent to the value of two days' turbine production.
^Rueter, Gero (27 December 2021)."How sustainable is wind power?".Deutsche Welle. Retrieved28 December 2021.An onshore wind turbine that is newly built today produces around nine grams of CO2 for every kilowatt hour (kWh) it generates ... a new offshore plant in the sea emits seven grams of CO2 per kWh ... solar power plants emit 33 grams CO2 for every kWh generated ... natural gas produces 442 grams CO2 per kWh, power from hard coal 864 grams, and power from lignite, or brown coal, 1034 grams ... nuclear energy accounts for about 117 grams of CO2 per kWh, considering the emissions caused by uranium mining and the construction and operation of nuclear reactors.
Robert Gasch, Jochen Twele (ed.),Wind power plants. Fundamentals, design, construction and operation, Springer 2012ISBN978-3-642-22937-4.
Erich Hau,Wind turbines: fundamentals, technologies, application, economics, Springer, 2013ISBN978-3-642-27150-2 (preview on Google Books)
Siegfried Heier,Grid integration of wind energy conversion systems, John Wiley & Sons, 3rd edition (2014),ISBN978-1-119-96294-6
Peter Jamieson,Innovation in Wind Turbine Design. Wiley & Sons 2011,ISBN978-0-470-69981-2
J. F. Manwell, J. G. McGowan, A. L. Roberts,Wind Energy Explained: Theory, Design and Application, John Wiley & Sons, 2nd edition (2012),ISBN978-0-47001-500-1
David Spera (ed,)Wind Turbine Technology: Fundamental Concepts in Wind Turbine Engineering, Second Edition (2009), ASME Press,ISBN978-0-7918-0260-1
Alois Schaffarczyk (ed.),Understanding wind power technology, John Wiley & Sons, (2014),ISBN978-1-118-64751-6
Hermann-Josef Wagner, Jyotirmay Mathur,Introduction to wind energy systems. Basics, technology and operation. Springer (2013),ISBN978-3-642-32975-3
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.svg)
