 | This articleneeds additional citations forverification. Please helpimprove this article byadding citations to reliable sources. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. Find sources: "Samba spy scandal" – news ·newspapers ·books ·scholar ·JSTOR(July 2022) (Learn how and when to remove this message) |
TheSamba Military Spy Scandal[1][2] was aCold Warmilitary intelligence program which eventually emerged as a scandal in 1979. According to theIndian Army, the military program was run by theMI of Pakistan to seek information on the Indian Army's deposition inWestern India. The Indian Army and associatedintelligence agencies led the arrest of 50 active duty Army officers and personnel on suspicion of working for theMilitary Intelligence of thePakistan Army from Samba in the former state ofJammu and Kashmir.Samba, Jammu is a sleepy town in theJammu region borderingPakistan. The revelation of scandal led to a serious breach inforeign relations ofIndia and Pakistan.[3]
Between 24 August 1978 and 23 January 1979, 50-odd persons who had worked in the 168 Infantry Brigade and its subordinate units at Samba, 40 km from Jammu on the international border, were arrested on charges of spying for Pakistan at the instance of the Directorate of Military Intelligence (MI). Its investigations involved practically the whole officer cadre of the brigade. Those arrested included a brigadier, three lieutenant colonels, and a number of majors, captains, junior commissioned officers (JCOs), non-commissioned officers (NCOs), and personnel of other ranks, plus 11 civilians who had worked in the Samba sector. They were all taken into custody at the instance of two self-confessed Pakistani spies who worked as gunners in the Indian Army - Sarwan Dass and Aya Singh.
The whole story, written byA. G. Noorani, was published inFrontline. The bookThe Price of Loyalty, written by Captain Ranbir Singh Rathaur, is a first hand account of the brutal and inhuman torture inflicted on the officers and men who were falsely implicated in the Samba Spy Case.[4] In 2018, Major Nirmal Ramchand Ajwani, Major A K Rana, Captain Diwan, Captain R S Rathore, and Captain J S Yadav, claimed that they were framed under manipulated documentation and military intelligence power abuse, and demanded an independent probe.[5]
TheDelhi High Court gave judgement in favour of the accused but theSupreme Court overturned the Delhi High Court's judgement. The accused lost their case in the Supreme Court of India on 6 March 2014. But they kept moving to courts for justice.[6] In 2019, over 40 years of the alleged scandal, the Delhi High Court, sought a response from theGovernment of India following a petition filed by former Captains, Ashok Kumar Rana and Ranbir Singh Rathaur.[7][8]
The Samba spy scandal still remains a controversial issue. In December 1994, Sarwan Das swore an affidavit and appeared at a press conference to admit that he had falsely implicated the men. In December 1990, Aya Singh was killed while crossing the India-Pakistan border. The falsely implicated victims received justice only in December 2000, and not full either.[9][10]
According to MajorNavdeep Singh, the entire case is a debacle as the case was based on Aya Singh's statement where Singh claimed Captain Nagial was the initiator of the scam but a Court Martial acquitted Captain Nagial. Major Singh also brought some major issues of the case; including: Aya Singh, who was killed while trying to cross Indo-Pak border, can not be a reliable witness; Havildar Ram Swarup's confessional statement also built the case while Ram Swarup died of torture after interrogation; Swaran Dass made an under oath statement in 1994 in which Dass was forced to implicate innocent army personnel. Major Singh also raised a statement, "When the foundation itself was faulty, there was no reason for proceeding in the matter."[11]