Rose Rehert Kushner (June 22, 1929 – January 7, 1990) was an Americanjournalist and pioneering advocate forbreast cancer patients. She wrote the 1975 bookWhy Me? What Every Woman Should Know About Breast Cancer to Save Her Life.
Rose Rehert was born on June 22, 1929, inBaltimore, Maryland. Her parents wereEastern European immigrants Israel and Fannie Gravitz Rehert, both of whom died by the time she was 10 years old. As a child, she aspired to a career as aphysician, but her family was unable or unwilling to send her to college. Afterhigh school she worked at theJohns Hopkins School of Medicine from 1947 to 1951 and tookpre-med courses atBaltimore Junior College in 1949.[1][2]
In 1951 she married Harvey Kushner and had three children, born between 1952 and 1958. She returned to college in the 1960s, changing her concentration to journalism, and in 1972 receiving an A.B. degreesumma cum laude from theUniversity of Maryland. In the late 1960s and early 1970s she didmedical writing andfreelance journalism work, including work inBolivia andVietnam, as well as coverage of the 1973Yom Kippur war.[1]
After Rose Kushner's June 1974 discovery of a cancerous lump in herbreast, breast cancer became the focus of her life. On the basis of her library research into breast cancer treatment, she objected to the treatment which was then standard, in which a tumorbiopsy andradical mastectomy were performed in a single surgical operation while the patient was underanesthesia. However, she had difficulty finding a doctor who would perform a diagnostic biopsy and allow her to decide what action to take next.[3][4] After a biopsy determined that her tumor was cancerous, she resisted the then-standard radical mastectomy procedure, in which muscle tissue andlymph nodes were removed along with the breast. In order to have a less invasive procedure, she traveled from herKensington, Maryland home toBuffalo, New York, where she had found a doctor (Dr. Thomas Dao) who was willing to do a modified radical mastectomy.[2][3][5]
As Kushner recovered from her surgery, she started writing about her experiences with breast cancer. She was outspoken in her criticism ofBetty Ford's September 1974 treatment for breast cancer, using personal connections inWashington, DC, in an unsuccessful effort to convince theFirst Lady not to undergo a one-step biopsy and radical mastectomy. After being told that "the President has made his decision" (regarding his wife's medical treatment) she railed against the "male-chauvinist-piggery" represented by that statement, writing in a letter: "That statement has got to be engraved somewhere as the all-timesexist declaration of no-woman rights."[4][5]
Her first major article on the topic of breast cancer was published inThe Washington Post on October 6, 1974. She traveled toEurope to learn about breast cancer treatment there, finding that the radical mastectomy was not used as widely as in the United States. Upon her return home, she started a book about the causes, diagnosis, and treatment of breast cancer, completing the manuscript in just seven weeks. The book, published in 1975 under the titleBreast Cancer: A Personal History and Investigative Report, contained extensive medical information and advice for patients, including strong criticism of radical mastectomies and the practice of performing a biopsy and a mastectomy as a one-step surgical procedure. In her critique of prevalent medical practices she used rhetoric familiar to the 1970sfeminist movement, with statements such as "No man is going to make another impotent while he's asleep without his permission, but there's no hesitation if it's a woman's breast."[5] The book was strongly endorsed by Dr. Dao, who had conducted research on breast cancer treatment and had performed Rose Kushner's surgery, but it was widely criticized by other doctors and theAmerican Cancer Society.[5]
In 1975 Kushner and Dorothy Johnston, established atelephone hotline called the Breast Cancer Advisory Center, based inKensington, Maryland, that operated until 1982, responding to calls and letters from thousands of women wanting information about breast cancer and its treatment.[2][5] The center's establishment was motivated in part by Kushner's desire to promote patient self-help and mutual support, thus displacing the medical profession and the American Cancer Society from their roles as information "gatekeepers".[6]
Kusher became a relentless critic of the treatment of breast cancer by the medical profession. She attended numerous meetings of medical professionals, interrupting presentations, questioning conclusions, and speaking against the prevalent practices of one-step breast cancer surgery and radical mastectomy.[5] In 1975 she was "booed off the stage" at a meeting of the Society of Surgical Oncology, whose members objected to her challenges to traditional treatments.[3]
In spite of her unpopularity with the mainstream medical profession, Kushner's work was well received in the public and won increasing respect in official circles. In June 1977, she was the onlylay member appointed to a ten-memberNational Institutes of Health (NIH) panel that evaluated treatment options for primary breast cancer. In 1979, the panel issued its findings, concluding that the Halsted radical mastectomy should no longer be the standard treatment for suspected cases of breast cancer, instead recommending total simple mastectomy as the primary surgical treatment.[1][4][5] Additionally, Kushner convinced her fellow panel members to include a statement calling for an end to the one-step surgical procedure.[4] At the time of her death, Dr. Bruce A. Chabner of theNational Cancer Institute said she was "probably the single most important person" in ending the practice of one-step surgery for breast cancer, because of her persistence and because she brought medical information to a wide public audience that otherwise might have remained unaware of the options.[3]
Following her service on the NIH panel, PresidentJimmy Carter appointed Kushner to theNational Cancer Advisory Board as the board's first lay member, and she was engaged by the NIH to review grant applications. She took pleasure in the fact that she was working within the system, joking "I'm a full-fledged member ofthe Establishment."[4]
After Kushner's cancer recurred in 1981, she refusedchemotherapy, which she considered to be unacceptably toxic, and was treated withtamoxifen. In the 1980s she campaigned against aggressive use of chemotherapy.[1][4] In a 1984 article "Is Aggressive Adjuvant Chemotherapy the Halsted Radical of the '80s?" she suggested that chemotherapy was being used as indiscriminately as radical mastectomy surgery had been in earlier decades, saying that doctors gave insufficient attention to the serious side effects of chemotherapy, and calling chemotherapy "therapeutic overkill."[7][8] Barron Lerner has suggested that the vehemence of her attack on chemotherapy may have reflected aconflict of interest, related both to her personal interest in the implications of her own decision to refuse chemotherapy and a "close working and financial relationship with the manufacturers of tamoxifen."[7]
She continued to advocate for the interests of breast cancer patients for the rest of her life. In 1986 she was a cofounder of theNational Alliance of Breast Cancer Organizations, anumbrella organization on whose board she served from 1986 to 1989. In 1989 she was appointed to the Breast Cancer Task Force of theAmerican Cancer Society.[2] Up until a few days before her death in 1990, at the age of 60, she was actively lobbying for theU.S. federal government to requirehealth insurance to covermammograms.[4]
The following are among Rose Kushner's published writings:
Kushner received awards from theAmerican Medical Writers Association in 1980 and 1985 for her books and articles about breast cancer. TheAmerican Cancer Society honored her with its Medal of Honor in 1987 and its Courage Award in 1988.[1]
In 1990 she was the posthumous recipient of theJames Ewing Award of theSociety of Surgical Oncology, recognizing outstanding contributions by a lay person to the fight against cancer.[3]
| International | |
|---|---|
| National | |
| Other | |
