Pinus, thepines, is a genus of approximately 110–120extant tree and shrub species. The genus is currently split into twosubgenera, subgenusPinus (hard pines), and subgenusStrobus (soft pines). Each of the subgenera have been further divided intosections and subsections based in the past on morphology, ecology and biogeography, and more recently increasingly fromchloroplast DNA sequencing[1] and wholeplastid genomic analysis.[2] While the genetic analysis has given robust results at the higher levels, they often give conflicting results lower in the phylogenetic trees, with species allocated to different subsections (and sometimes different sections) by different studies or even within a study.[3] Within subsections, the genetic relationships between species can be even more complex and conflicting; in one study, three samples of the very distinctive and morphologically constantPinus lambertiana were placed in three differentclades of the subsectionStrobus, and similar problems with many other species with widespread nonmonophyly.[4]
| Pinus |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Several features are used to distinguish the subgenera, sections, and subsections of pines; the number of leaves (needles) perfascicle, whether thefascicle sheaths aredeciduous orpersistent, the number offibrovascular bundles per needle (two inPinus, one inStrobus), the position of theresin ducts in the needles (internal or external), the presence or shape of the seed wings (rudimentary or effective, articulate or adnate), and the position of theumbo (dorsal or terminal) and presence of a prickle on the scales of theseed cones.[5]
The two subgenera are thought to have ancient divergence from each other, having diverged at some point between the lateJurassic (around 160 million years ago),[6] the midCretaceous (around 125 million years ago),[7] to the late Cretaceous (around 100 million years ago).[8]
SubgenusPinus includes the yellow and hard pines. Pines in this subgenus have two to five needles per fascicle (rarely as many as eight, inP. durangensis).[9] They have twofibrovascular bundles per needle, and the fascicle sheaths arepersistent, except inP. leiophylla andP. lumholtzii. The cone scales are thicker and more rigid than those of subgenusStrobus, and have a resin sealing band before opening (resulting in the cones opening with an audible crack); thecones either open soon after they mature or areserotinous.[10]
SectionPinus has two or three needles per fascicle. The cones have moderately thin to thick scales; in most they open at maturity, but are weakly serotinous in some species in subsectionPinaster. Species in this section are native toEurope,Asia, and theMediterranean, except forP. resinosa in northeasternNorth America andP. tropicalis in westernCuba.[10]
SubsectionIncertae sedis


All but two species (P. resinosa andP. tropicalis) inSubsectionPinus are native to Eurasia.[10] The cones have moderate thickness scales, and are characterised by a slighty off-centre prickle ('excentromucronate') on the umbo.[12]
This pine is commonly resolved into subsectionPinaster by genetic studies, but this is in strong conflict with its morphology and ecology, which is much closer to subsectionPinus, or alternatively placed in its own subsectionLeucodermes close to subsectionPinus.[15]
These pines are placed in subsectionPinus by some genetic studies,[8] but in subsectionPinaster by others.[2] In morphology and ecology, they belong in the latter group.[16] The subsectionMerkusia has also been proposed for them.[15]

SubsectionPinaster contains species native to warm climates in the Mediterranean region at low altitudes, as well asP. roxburghii from theHimalayas. The cones are thick-scaled and orange-brown to red-brown, and the cone scales are glossy and lack umbo spines.[5] It is named afterP. pinaster.
SectionTrifoliae (American hard pines), despite its name (which means "three-leaved"), has two to five needles per fascicle, or rarely eight. The cones of most species open at maturity, but a few areserotinous. All but two American hard pines belong to this section.[10]
The timing of divergences within this section is disputed, with subsectionsAustrales andPonderosae having diverged during the midCretaceous (about 110 million years ago) according to one study,[6] but not until the midOligocene (about 30–35 million years ago) in others.[7][8]

The three closed-cone (serotinous) and fire adapted species of California and Baja California form a small subsection;[18] closely related to, and often included within subsectionAustrales. Some studies suggestPinus glabra may also belong here (despite its morphological dissimilarity)[2] though others include it in subsectionAustrales.[8]

This subsection is native toNorth andCentral America and islands in theCaribbean.[5][19][20] It has 26 living species.[18]
TheContortae are native to North America and Mexico.[5] It contains four accepted species.[18]


This subsection is native toCentral America,Mexico, the westernUnited States, and southwesternCanada,[5][26] although its former range was possibly much wider as evidenced by upper Miocene fossils belonging to this subsection found in Japan[27] It contains at least 13 living species and may contain five more if the disputed species become widely accepted.[18]
These are pines of the western United States and Mexico with four existing species. Within the subsection the Coulter pine is closely related with the Jeffery pine and the gray pine is likewise paired with the Torrey pine.[18]
SubgenusStrobus includes the white and soft pines. Pines in this subgenus have one to five needles per fascicle and onefibrovascular bundle per needle, and the fascicle sheaths aredeciduous, except inP. nelsonii, where they are persistent. Cone scales are thinner and more flexible than those of subgenusPinus, except in some species likeP. maximartinezii, andcones usually open soon after they mature.[10]

This unique pine is remarkable in differing from all other pines in multiple cone and foliage characters. Genetically, its position has varied between and within studies; three nuclear genes and chloroplast DNA placed it assister taxon to the rest of SectionParrya, while a late embryogenesis abundant (LEA)-like gene (IFG8612) resolved it as sister to SectionQuinquefoliae;[4] another study resolved it as sister to SubsectionBalfourianae.[8] It has probably evolved separately from the rest of the genus since the lateEocene, with itsmost recent common ancestor around 37 million years ago.[8] These unique characters warrent recognition as a monotypic section.[15]
SubsectionNelsonianae is native to northeastern Mexico. It consists of the single species with persistent fascicle sheaths.
Section Parrya has one to five needles per fascicle. The seeds havearticulate (jointed) wings; in most, the wing is vestigial, and remains attached to the cone scale when the seed is released apparently wingless. In all species, the fascicle sheaths curl back to form arosette before falling away. The cones have thick scales (thin in subsectionBalfourianae) and release the seeds at maturity. This section is native to the southwestern United States and Mexico.[10]
Subsection Balfourianae (bristlecone and foxtail pines) is native to southwestUnited States.
The 'big-cone' pinyons, with larger cones than subsectionCembroides.[18]

SubsectionCembroides (pinyons or piñons) is native toMexico and the southwesternUnited States.
SectionQuinquefoliae (white pines), as its name (which means "five-leaved") suggests, has five needles per fascicle except forP. krempfii, which has two, andP. gerardiana andP. bungeana, which have three. All species have cones with thin or thick scales that open at maturity or do not open at all; none are serotinous. Species in this section are found in Eurasia and North America, and one species,P. chiapensis reaches Guatemala.[36][37]
SubsectionGerardianae is native to East Asia. It has three or five needles per fascicle.
SubsectionKrempfianae is currently native to Vietnam, with a fossil record extending into the Oligocene. It has two needles per fascicle, and they are atypically flattened. The cone scales are thick and have no prickles. Until 2021, the subsection was considered monotypic, when an Oligocene fossil species was described from Yunnan Province, China.

SubsectionStrobus has five needles per fascicle and thin cone scales with no prickles. Needles tend to be flexible and soft with slightly lighter side underneath.[39] It is native to North and Central America, Europe, and Asia.[5]

Species which are not placed in a subgenus at this time.