The sides of thesquares used to construct a silver spiral are the Pell numbers
Inmathematics, thePell numbers are an infinitesequence of integers, known since ancient times, that comprise thedenominators of theclosest rational approximations to thesquare root of 2. Thissequence of approximations begins1/1,3/2,7/5,17/12, and41/29, so the sequence of Pell numbers begins with 1, 2, 5, 12, and 29. The numerators of the same sequence of approximations are half thecompanion Pell numbers orPell–Lucas numbers; these numbers form a second infinite sequence that begins with 2, 6, 14, 34, and 82.
As withPell's equation, the name of the Pell numbers stems fromLeonhard Euler's mistaken attribution of the equation and the numbers derived from it toJohn Pell. The Pell–Lucas numbers are also named afterÉdouard Lucas, who studied sequences defined by recurrences of this type; the Pell and companion Pell numbers areLucas sequences.
In words, the sequence of Pell numbers starts with 0 and 1, and then each Pell number is the sum of twice the previous Pell number, plus the Pell number before that. The first few terms of the sequence are
Analogously to theBinet formula, the Pell numbers can also be expressed by the closed form formula
For large values ofn, the(1 +√2)n term dominates this expression, so the Pell numbers are approximately proportional to powers of thesilver ratio1 +√2, analogous to the growth rate of Fibonacci numbers as powers of thegolden ratio.
A third definition is possible, from thematrix formula
Manyidentities can be derived orproven from these definitions; for instance an identity analogous toCassini's identity for Fibonacci numbers,
is an immediate consequence of the matrix formula (found by considering thedeterminants of the matrices on the left and right sides of the matrix formula).[2]
Rational approximations toregularoctagons, with coordinates derived from the Pell numbers.
Pell numbers arise historically and most notably in therational approximation to√2. If two large integersx andy form a solution to thePell equation
then their ratiox/y provides a close approximation to√2. The sequence of approximations of this form is
where the denominator of eachfraction is a Pell number and the numerator is the sum of a Pell number and its predecessor in the sequence. That is, the solutions have the form
The approximation
of this type was known to Indian mathematicians in the third or fourth century BCE.[3] The Greek mathematicians of the fifth century BCE also knew of this sequence of approximations:[4] Plato refers to the numerators asrational diameters.[5] In the second century CETheon of Smyrna used the term theside and diameter numbers to describe the denominators and numerators of this sequence.[6]
Truncating this expansion to any number of terms produces one of the Pell-number-based approximations in this sequence; for instance,
AsKnuth (1994) describes, the fact that Pell numbers approximate√2 allows them to be used for accurate rational approximations to a regular octagon with vertex coordinates(± Pi, ± Pi +1) and(± Pi +1, ± Pi ). All vertices are equally distant from theorigin, and form nearly uniformangles around the origin. Alternatively, the points,, and form approximate octagons in which the vertices are nearly equally distant from the origin and form uniform angles.
These indices are all themselves prime. As with the Fibonacci numbers, a Pell numberPn can only be prime ifn itself is prime, because ifd is adivisor ofn thenPd is a divisor ofPn.
However, despite having so few squares or other powers, Pell numbers have a close connection tosquare triangular numbers.[8] Specifically, these numbers arise from the following identity of Pell numbers:
The left side of this identity describes a square number, while the right side describes atriangular number, so the result is a square triangular number.
Falcón and Díaz-Barrero (2006) proved another identity relating Pell numbers to squares and showing that the sum of the Pell numbers up toP4n +1 is always a square:
For instance, the sum of the Pell numbers up toP5,0 + 1 + 2 + 5 + 12 + 29 = 49, is the square ofP2 +P3 = 2 + 5 = 7. The numbersP2n +P2n +1 forming the square roots of these sums,
Integer right triangles with nearly equal legs, derived from the Pell numbers.
If aright triangle has integer side lengthsa,b,c (necessarily satisfying thePythagorean theorema2 +b2 =c2), then (a,b,c) is known as aPythagorean triple. As Martin (1875) describes, the Pell numbers can be used to form Pythagorean triples in whicha andb are one unit apart, corresponding to right triangles that are nearly isosceles. Each such triple has the form
The sequence of Pythagorean triples formed in this way is
Thecompanion Pell numbers orPell–Lucas numbers are defined by therecurrence relation
In words: the first two numbers in the sequence are both 2, and each successive number is formed by adding twice the previous Pell–Lucas number to the Pell–Lucas number before that, or equivalently, by adding the next Pell number to the previous Pell number: thus, 82 is the companion to 29, and82 = 2 × 34 + 14 = 70 + 12. The first few terms of the sequence are (sequenceA002203 in theOEIS):2, 2,6,14,34,82, 198,478, …
The following table gives the first few powers of thesilver ratioδ =δ S = 1 + √2 and itsconjugateδ = 1 − √2.
n
(1 +√2)n
(1 −√2)n
0
1 + 0√2 = 1
1 − 0√2 = 1
1
1 + 1√2 = 2.41421…
1 − 1√2 = −0.41421…
2
3 + 2√2 = 5.82842…
3 − 2√2 = 0.17157…
3
7 + 5√2 = 14.07106…
7 − 5√2 = −0.07106…
4
17 + 12√2 = 33.97056…
17 − 12√2 = 0.02943…
5
41 + 29√2 = 82.01219…
41 − 29√2 = −0.01219…
6
99 + 70√2 = 197.9949…
99 − 70√2 = 0.0050…
7
239 + 169√2 = 478.00209…
239 − 169√2 = −0.00209…
8
577 + 408√2 = 1153.99913…
577 − 408√2 = 0.00086…
9
1393 + 985√2 = 2786.00035…
1393 − 985√2 = −0.00035…
10
3363 + 2378√2 = 6725.99985…
3363 − 2378√2 = 0.00014…
11
8119 + 5741√2 = 16238.00006…
8119 − 5741√2 = −0.00006…
12
19601 + 13860√2 = 39201.99997…
19601 − 13860√2 = 0.00002…
Thecoefficients are the half-companion Pell numbersHn and the Pell numbersPn which are the (non-negative) solutions toH 2 − 2P 2 = ±1.Asquare triangular number is a number
which is both thet-th triangular number and thes-th square number. Anear-isosceles Pythagorean triple is an integer solution toa 2 +b 2 =c 2 wherea + 1 =b.
The next table shows that splitting theodd numberHn into nearly equal halves gives a square triangular number whenn is even and a near isosceles Pythagorean triple whenn is odd. All solutions arise in this manner.
Since√2 is irrational, we cannot haveH/P = √2, i.e.,
The best we can achieve is either
The (non-negative) solutions toH 2 − 2P 2 = 1 are exactly the pairs(Hn,Pn) withn even, and the solutions toH 2 − 2P 2 = −1 are exactly the pairs(Hn,Pn) withn odd. To see this, note first that
so that these differences, starting withH 2 0 − 2P 2 0 = 1, are alternately 1 and −1. Then note that every positive solution comes in this way from a solution with smaller integers since
The smaller solution also has positive integers, with the one exception:H =P = 1 which comes fromH0 = 1 andP0 = 0.
is equivalent towhich becomesH 2 = 2P 2 + 1 with the substitutionsH = 2t + 1 andP = 2s. Hence then-th solution is
Observe thatt andt + 1 are relatively prime, so thatt (t + 1)/2 = s 2 happens exactly when they are adjacent integers, one a squareH 2 and the other twice a square 2P 2. Since we know all solutions of that equation, we also have
and
This alternate expression is seen in the next table.
^For instance, Sellers (2002) proves that the number ofperfect matchings in theCartesian product of apath graph and thegraphK4 − e can be calculated as the product of a Pell number with the corresponding Fibonacci number.
^For the matrix formula and its consequences see Ercolano (1979) and Kilic and Tasci (2005). Additional identities for the Pell numbers are listed by Horadam (1971) and Bicknell (1975).
^As recorded in theShulba Sutras; see e.g. Dutka (1986), who cites Thibaut (1875) for this information.
^See Knorr (1976) for the fifth century date, which matchesProclus' claim that the side and diameter numbers were discovered by thePythagoreans. For more detailed exploration of later Greek knowledge of these numbers see Thompson (1929), Vedova (1951), Ridenhour (1986), Knorr (1998), and Filep (1999).
^For instance, as several of the references from the previous note observe, inPlato's Republic there is a reference to the "rational diameter of 5", by whichPlato means 7, the numerator of the approximation7/5 of which 5 is the denominator.
^Pethő (1992); Cohn (1996). Although the Fibonacci numbers are defined by a very similar recurrence to the Pell numbers, Cohn writes that an analogous result for the Fibonacci numbers seems much more difficult to prove. (However, this was proven in 2006 by Bugeaud et al.)
Kilic, Emrah; Tasci, Dursun (2005). "The linear algebra of the Pell matrix".Boletín de la Sociedad Matemática Mexicana, Tercera Serie.11 (2):163–174.MR2207722.
Pethő, A. (1992). "The Pell sequence contains only trivial perfect powers".Sets, graphs, and numbers (Budapest, 1991). Colloq. Math. Soc. János Bolyai, 60, North-Holland. pp. 561–568.MR1218218.