Max Blumenthal | |
|---|---|
.jpg) Blumenthal in 2019 | |
| Born | (1977-12-18)December 18, 1977 (age 48) Boston, Massachusetts, U.S. |
| Occupation |
|
| Alma mater | University of Pennsylvania (BA) |
| Subject |
|
| Years active | 2002–present |
| Notable works |
|
| Spouse | [1] |
| Relatives | Sidney Blumenthal (father) |
Max Blumenthal (born December 18, 1977) is an American journalist, author, blogger, and filmmaker. He was a writer forThe Nation,AlterNet,[2]The Daily Beast,Al Akhbar,Mondoweiss,[3] andMedia Matters for America,[4][5] and has contributed toAl Jazeera English,The New York Times and theLos Angeles Times.[4] He has been a writing fellow of theNation Institute.[6] He was also a contributor toSputnik andRT as of 2022.[7][8][9]
Blumenthal is the editor ofThe Grayzone website, described by many asfringe[10][11][12][13] and known for its criticism of US foreign policy and its positive, often apologetic coverage of the Chinese, Russian, Venezuelan, and Ba'athist Syrian governments, including itsdenial ofchemical attacks by the Syrian government and ofhuman rights abuses against Uyghurs.[14][15][16] He has written extensively about Israel, and is sharply critical of the conduct of its government.
Blumenthal has written four books. His first,Republican Gomorrah: Inside the Movement That Shattered the Party (2009), made theLos Angeles Times andNew York Times bestsellers lists.[17] He was awarded the 2014Lannan Foundation Cultural Freedom Award for an Especially Notable Book forGoliath: Life and Loathing in Greater Israel, which was published in 2013.[18][19]
Blumenthal was born on December 18, 1977, inBoston, Massachusetts, to Jacqueline (née Jordan) andSidney Blumenthal. He isJewish.[20] His father is a journalist and writer who served as an aide to PresidentBill Clinton. Blumenthal attendedGeorgetown Day School in Washington, D.C.[21] He graduated from theUniversity of Pennsylvania in 1999 with aBachelor of Arts degree in history.[22]
Prior to 2015, Blumenthal's articles and video reports were published byWashington Monthly (in 2003 and 2005),[23]The Nation (2005–2015),[4]The Daily Beast (2008–09),[24]The Huffington Post (2009–2011),[25]The New York Times (in 2009 and 2014), theLos Angeles Times (2009),Columbia Journalism Review (2011)[26] andAl Jazeera English (2013).[27]
In late 2011, Blumenthal joined Lebanon'sAl Akhbar newspaper primarily to write about theIsraeli–Palestinian conflict and foreign-policy debates in Washington, D.C. When he left the publication in June 2012 in protest at its coverage of theSyrian Civil War, he considered the newspaper to have a pro-Assad editorial line followed by such individuals asAmal Saad-Ghorayeb. He wrote that it "gave me more latitude than any paper in the United States to write about... Israel and Palestine", but he had ultimately tired of "jousting with Assad apologists". He added: "In the end, Assad will be remembered as an authoritarian tyrant."[28][29][30] Blumenthal formerly contributed weekly articles to theAlterNet website, serving as a senior writer from September 2014.[2]
Since his visit to Moscow, Blumenthal has contributed to broadcasts onRT (formerly known as Russia Today) on many occasions.[9] In December 2015, during a visit to Moscow presumed by multiple sources to have been paid for by the Kremlin,[28][31] Blumenthal was a guest at RT's10 Years On Air anniversary party attended by PresidentVladimir Putin, then-Lieutenant GeneralMichael Flynn of the United States and English politicianKen Livingstone.[28][9][32] In an interview withTucker Carlson onFox News in November 2017, Blumenthal defended RT against "the charge that it's Kremlin propaganda."[9][33]
He has contributed on multiple occasions to Russia's state ownedSputnik radio,[31][34] as well as to Iran's state ownedPress TV[35][36] and China's state-runCGTN.[37] Blumenthal foundedThe Grayzone website within a month after his visit to Moscow.[38] In an October 2019 article forNew Politics magazine, London-based Lebanese academicGilbert Achcar wrote that Blumenthal'sGrayzone, along with theWorld Socialist Web Site, has "the habit of demonizing all left-wing critics of Putin and the likes of Assad by describing them as 'agents of imperialism' or some equivalent".[39]
Blumenthal won theOnline News Association's Independent Feature Award for his 2002Salon article, "Day of the Dead".[40][41] In the article, he concluded thehomicides of hundreds of women inCiudad Juárez, Chihuahua, Mexico were connected to the policies of corporate interests in the border city.[42] Blumenthal wrote about the rise of the so-called "Minuteman" movement forSalon in 2003, describing its members as "border vigilantes" who "have harassed and detained hundreds, perhaps thousands, of migrants suspected of entering the country illegally."[43]
In 2010, Blumenthal covered the federal immigration enforcement program known asOperation Streamline forTruthdig. "The program represents the entrenchment of a parallel nonproductive economy promoting abuse behind the guise of law enforcement and crime deterrence", he wrote.[44]
Blumenthal testified as a prosecution witness for theMexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund in their civil suit, known asVicente v. Barnett, against Arizona businessmanRoger Barnett. Barnett was ordered to pay $73,000 in damages for assaulting a group of migrants near the US–Mexico border.[45]
In 2014, Blumenthal covered hunger strikes by undocumented migrants held in theprivatizedNorthwest Detention Center forThe Nation.[46]
In June 2007, Blumenthal attended theTake Back America Conference (sponsored by theCampaign for America's Future), where he interviewed both supporters ofBarack Obama (D-Illinois) and9/11 conspiracy theorists. Blumenthal said that conference organizers were angered by the video, and refused to air it.[47]
Blumenthal made a short video titledGeneration Chickenhawk (2007). It featured interviews with attendees at the July 2007College Republican National Convention in Washington, D.C. Blumenthal asked why they, asIraq War supporters, had not enlisted in theUnited States Armed Forces.[47][48]
In August 2007, Blumenthal made a short video calledRapture Ready, about AmericanChristian fundamentalists' support for the State of Israel.[47]
Blumenthal's book,Republican Gomorrah: Inside the Movement That Shattered the Party (2009),[49] was a bestseller on both theLos Angeles Times andNew York Times bestsellers lists.[17] The work was inspired by the psychologistErich Fromm who analyzed the personality of those "eager to surrender their freedom" via an identification with authoritarian causes and powerful leaders.[50]
For Blumenthal, a "culture of personal crisis" has defined the American "radical right".[51] In a 2009 interview withCNN, he commented: "The GOP has become subsumed by dysfunctional personalities with no capacity for restraining themselves, either from acting out hysterically or from their most devious urges. For these internally conflicted figures, who will continue to produce new and increasingly bizarre scandals, right-wing political crusading is simply a form of self-medication."[52]
In early June 2009, Blumenthal posted a 3-minute video onYouTube, titledFeeling the Hate in Jerusalem on the Eve of Obama's Cairo Address. The video was recorded the day before PresidentBarack Obama's Cairo address on June 4 and showedman-on-the-street interviews with possibly drunk Jewish-American young people in Jerusalem. According toTablet, the Americans interviewed "spewed racist vitriol about the president while asserting a strikingly meatheaded brand of Jewish pride".[53] Some of those interviewed used obscenities and racist rhetoric about President Obama andArabs, referring to Obama as a "nigger" and "like a terrorist".[54] According toThe Jerusalem Post, the video "garnered massive exposure and caused a firestorm in the media and the Jewish world".[55] ABradley Burston op-ed inHaaretz described the video as "an overnight Internet sensation".[54]
Blumenthal's video gained 400,000 views before YouTube removed it for unspecified terms-of-use violations.The Huffington Post had refused to publish it, and its Tel Aviv sequel was briefly on that website, before it resurfaced onMondoweiss.[53] Referring to the Jerusalem video, theJewish Telegraphic Agency quoted Blumenthal as stating: "I won't ascribe motives to YouTube I am unable to confirm, but it is clear there is an active campaign by right-wing Jewish elements to suppress the video by filing a flood of complaints with YouTube".[56]
Referring to death threats he had received for publishing the video, he ascribed individuals "emotional need to stop this video by eliminating" him as "a feature of right-wing psychology around the world".[57] Blumenthal saw his interviewees as part of the "indoctrination" ofTaglit-Birthright tours intended fordiaspora Jews, in which he had himself participated in 2002.[57] Around 2009, he described himself as a "non-Zionist" liberal, and considered the identification of anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism as a "cynical ploy by the Israel lobby".[53]
In 2011, Blumenthal reported that Israeli occupation forces and Bahraini monarchy guards trained American police departments in anti-protester techniques, including torture, and quotedFordham University Law ProfessorKaren J. Greenberg.[58] Contacted byJeffrey Goldberg ofThe Atlantic andAdam Serwer ofMother Jones, Greenberg told Goldberg that while she "never made such a statement", Blumenthal "was looking for corroboration but I told him I didn't have any." She told Serwer that "I did not intend to assert these allegations as fact ... the entire sense of the quote is inaccurate."[59][60]
Blumenthal said that he had quoted Greenberg accurately, accused her of denying she had made the statement, and believed that she had since been "intimidated by Goldberg and the pro-Israel forces he represents." Greenberg had made the same comments to Adam Serwer ofMother Jones.[59][61]
Blumenthal has written two books based on the periods of time he spent inGaza and theIsraeli-occupied territories in theWest Bank. He documented what he said were Israeli and Palestinianwar crimes in two books:Goliath: Life and Loathing in Greater Israel (2013) andThe 51 Day War: Ruin and Resistance in Gaza (2015).
Goliath, published by Nation Books, outlines what Blumenthal characterizes as Israel's aggressive shift to the far-right, and its crackdown on local activism. In the preface, he writes: "Americans' tax dollars and political support [...] are crucial in sustaining the present state of affairs" in Israel.[62] The book consists of 73 short chapters. Chapter titles include "To the Slaughter", "The Concentration Camp", "The Night of Broken Glass", "This Belongs to the White Man" and "How to Kill Goyim and Influence People".[63][64][65]
The book received a positive review from Nancy Murray inRace & Class, calling it "a work of unsettling but scrupulous and courageous truth-telling".[66] It was also positively reviewed in theJournal of Palestine Studies bySteven Salaita, who called it "one of the most important titles published on the Israel-Palestine conflict in the past few years".[67]
Eric Alterman, writing forThe Nation wrote that its author "proves a profoundly unreliable narrator" and his book will "do nothing to advance the interests of the occupation's victims."[68] His article and an extract from Blumenthal's book in the same issue led to many letters being received byThe Nation, several of which were published in the next issue rebukingThe Nation for publishing Alterman's article. Abdeen Jabara, past president of theAmerican Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, wrote that he was troubled byThe Nation presenting "two sides" by allowing Alterman to do a "hatchet job" on Blumenthal's work, because "there is no equivalency between whatever Palestinians have done or are doing and what Israel and Zionism have done to the Palestinians." Other correspondents, among them Charles H. Manekin, Professor of Philosophy at the University of Maryland and former Director of theMeyerhoff Center for Jewish Studies, challenged the accuracy of Alterman's article.[69] Alterman's statement in his original piece about the book being "technically accurate" was queried and he explained it was an issue of context, as Blumenthal "tells us only the facts he wishes us to know and withholds crucial ones that undermine his relentlessly anti-Israel narrative."[70]Jonathan S. Tobin, writing inCommentary magazine, described the book as having a "complete lack of intellectual merit or integrity".[71]
An event was held at theUniversity of Pennsylvania on October 17, 2013, featuringIan Lustick and Blumenthal discussingGoliath.[63] Blumenthal objected to what he saw as "Israel's attempt to engineer and maintain a Jewish, non-indigenous majority."[72] Blumenthal said: "there is absolutely no way for Jewish people in Israel/Palestine to become indigenized under the present order. And that's what really has to happen." Consequently, they should be "willing to be a part of the Arab world." A "choice needs to be placed to the Israeli Jewish population" (which he also referred to as the "settler-colonial population") "and it can only be placed to them through external pressure."[72] "The maintenance and engineering of a non-indigenous demographic majority is non-negotiable", he said.[63]
Philip Weiss of theMondoweiss website responded to Blumenthal's comments saying that "similar attitudes about indigenous culture have been used in intolerant ways in our society. I see some intolerance in that answer."[73] In the Acknowledgements toGoliath, Blumenthal wrote that websites such asElectronic Intifada andMondoweiss had "provided essential outlets for much of the reporting" contained in the book.[74] Petra Marquardt-Bigman wrote that the "single-minded effort inGoliath to portray Israel in an extremely biased way in order to promote comparisons to Nazi Germany that would justify political campaigns aimed at eliminating the Jewish state qualifies even under the most stringent criteria" as beingantisemitic.[36]
In 2013, RabbiMarvin Hier, founder of theSimon Wiesenthal Center, said that the center ranked Blumenthal in ninth place in their"Top Ten 2013 Anti-Semitic, Anti-Israel Slurs". Hier said that "we judge him by what he wrote. He crossed the line into outright anti-Semitism" and that "he quotes approvingly characterizations of Israeli soldiers as 'Judeo-Nazis'".[65][75] Blumenthal responded by saying the Wiesenthal Center's list associated him with such people as American writerAlice Walker.[75][76] He commented that he,Richard Falk, andRoger Waters (who also appear on the list) "had stiff competition:Ayatollah Khomeini [sic, Khamenei] was number one."[75][76]
Responding on Twitter, Blumenthal posted a cartoon byCarlos Latuff, who had appeared on the list the previous year.[77] Marquardt-Bigman reported that the cartoon depicted Hier as mad; Blumenthal has defended Latuff on Twitter.[36]Gilad Atzmon praisedGoliath on theVeterans Today website: "I really want Blumenthal's book to succeed and be read widely". He thought Blumenthal had "brilliantly though unwittingly managed to produce a pretty impressive journalistic account in support of my criticism of Jewish identity politics and tribal supremacy".[36]
Blumenthal appeared before theRussell Tribunal on Palestine on September 25, 2014, inBrussels, Belgium, to testify on allegations ofwar crimes and genocide by Israel against residents of the Gaza Strip duringOperation Protective Edge. Blumenthal was in Gaza during Protective Edge and, according toRichard Falk inThe Nation, provided an analysis of the "political design that appeared to explain the civilian targeting patterns".[78] During his appearance at the Russell Tribunal, Blumenthal made a comparison between Israel andISIL.[79]
A few days later, Blumenthal andRania Khalek created the Twitter hashtag #JSIL; "The Jewish State of Israel in the Levant",[80][81][82] intended as a comparison between Israel and theIslamic State terrorist organization.[83]
Blumenthal and Canadian-Israeli journalist David Sheen were invited byInge Höger andAnnette Groth, members ofThe Left (Die Linke) party, to speak with them in the German parliament in Berlin, theBundestag, with the meeting being scheduled for November 12, 2014.[84] Blumenthal and Sheen stated that Höger and Groth's party colleagueGregor Gysi, tried to cancel the meetings,[85][86] because Gysi wished to dissociate the Left Party from anti-Israel campaigns.[86]
Before the cancellation,Volker Beck of theGreen Party described Blumenthal as someone who sought to "invoke consistently anti-Semitic comparisons between Israel and Nazism",[87] Weinthal had presented his evidence about Blumenthal's writings and activism to Gysi.[83]
Later, Blumenthal and Sheen waited for Gysi to discuss his claim they were antisemites, an assertion Gysi denied making.[88] Gysi, followed by the two other parliamentary members, left his office and crossed down a corridor to enter a restroom, where Sheen and Blumenthal followed him, but failed to force their entry. The two MPs held their meeting with Sheen and Blumenthal in a non-party room, but cut all links with them after hearing about the incident with Gysi.[84][88] Blumenthal and Sheen were banned from setting foot in the Bundestag again. In an e-mail explaining the ban, Bundestag presidentNorbert Lammert stated: "Every attempt to exert pressure on members of parliament, to physically threaten them and thus endanger the parliamentary process is intolerable and must be prevented".[84][89]
InThe 51 Day War (2015), Blumenthal writes that he was inGaza during and following Operation Protective Edge, the2014 Gaza War. Blumenthal said that the catalyst for the military offensive was thekidnapping and murder of three Israeli teenagers by aHamas cell. He stated that Israel'sWest Bank operation was not aimed at rescuing the teens, who were known to be dead, or capturing their killers, but destroying a political agreement between Hamas and thePalestinian National Authority by targeting theThird Hamdallah Government.[90][non-primary source needed] The book is based on his observations and interviews with citizens, physicians, and others. He writes that, during the operation, Israel targeted Palestinian civilians and media organizations, conducted execution-style killings and attacked refugee shelters.[91]
According to Petra Marquardt-Bigman, Blumenthal testified at the Russell Tribunal that he arrived in Gaza "at the onset of a five-day humanitarian ceasefire on August 14". She said his interviews at the end of July indicated he was in Washington, D.C., which suggested he was probably elsewhere, rather than "on the ground", for the first few weeks of the war.[92] She said a tweet by Blumenthal on August 22, indicated he had by then left the area. Marquardt-Bigman wrote thatThe 51 Day War was marketed as an "explosive work of reportage" and that Blumenthal "went to Gaza only some two weeks before the end of the fighting". Marquardt Bigman wrote that certain of his tweets show an "uncritical acceptance of the terror group's propaganda", a reference to Hamas. She said Blumenthal returned to Gaza to cover the "victory rallies" around the time Hamas accepted an indeterminate ceasefire.[92]
Of theBattle of Shuja'iyya in July 2014 in51 Days War, Blumenthal wrote of theAl-Qassam Brigades (the military wing of Hamas) who ambushedIsrael Defense Forces soldiers, that although they "had not vanquished the vaunted Israeli Army", "they delivered a bloody nose to its most elite units."[93] Sonali Kolhatkar wrote in theLos Angeles Review of Books that "Blumenthal's casting of the Al-Qassam Brigades as an army of resistance against a brutal aggressor is an essential transgression from the standard narrative of the Middle East conflict."[93]
In a video recording of an event at theLondon School of Economics in March 2016, Blumenthal described the Al-Qassam commandos as having "burst into the [Nahal Oz] Israeli base and kill[ed] every soldier they encountered in hand-to-hand combat. [...] The message it sent to young Palestinians in the West Bank, in Jerusalem and abroad, was incredible ... You see your people in commando uniforms, bursting into a military base and showing up the occupier."[94]
Kirkus Reviews described the book as being "Explosive, pull-no-punches reporting that is certain to stir controversy."[91]The 51 Day War: Ruin and Resistance in Gaza was awarded aPalestine Book Award that year by theMiddle East Monitor.[95] Avi Benlolo CEO of the Simon Wiesenthal Center toldThe Canadian Jewish News in 2016: "While shunned by conventional media outlets, the book is popular on major anti-Semitic, neo-Nazi and conspiracy theory websites such as Stormfront andDavid Duke's Rense, where his work is used to promote anti-Jewish hate."[35][96]
Blumenthal, an advocate of theBoycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) campaign, was invited to speak aboutThe 51 Day War at a TorontoPEN Canada event in February 2016.[97] Blumenthal said: "What certain groups—which are very partisan right-wing groups affiliated with the Republican Party in the US and the Conservative Party here—decided to do is to declare me an anti-Semite, that I actually hate Jews." He explained: "However I decide to observe Judaism is irrelevant, because in their view, you can disagree all you want with Moses, but you can't disagree with King Bibi [Benjamin Netanyahu]."[97]
At the beginning of February 2016, it became known via a release of emails from the State Department that, duringHillary Clinton's four years as Secretary of State, Sidney Blumenthal had sent her at least 19 articles by Max Blumenthal concerning Israel which she had distributed among her staff.[98][99] In August 2010, Clinton emailed the elder Blumenthal to say: "Pls congratulate Max for another impressive piece. He's so good."Alan Dershowitz, also an associate of the Clintons, warned of the potential for problems over the connection with someone so critical of Israel.[98]
When author andHolocaust survivorElie Wiesel died in July 2016, Max Blumenthaltweeted that "Wiesel went from a victim of war crimes to a supporter of those who commit them", referring to Israel, and "did more harm than good and should not be honored". According to Blumenthal, Wiesel "repeatedly lauded Jewish settlers for ethnically cleansing Palestinians in East Jerusalem". Wiesel was criticized for supportingElad, an Israeli group which encourages Jewish settlement in the area.[100][101]
Subsequently,Jake Sullivan, then senior policy adviser forHillary Clinton's presidential campaign, said: "Secretary Clinton emphatically rejects these offensive, hateful, and patently absurd statements about Elie Wiesel."[102][103]
Killing Gaza, a feature-length documentary Blumenthal made with filmmakerDan Cohen, was released in 2018. The work concerned the2014 Gaza War, seen from the perspective of the residents of Gaza.[104]
According to a 2019 article byBruce Bawer inCommentary magazine, Blumenthal has published content critical of theIsrael Defense Forces and favorable toHamas in the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. He has been sharply critical of Israel's conduct in theGaza war.[38][105]
In November 2023, biology researcherMichal Perach wrote inHaaretz that Blumenthal had argued most Israelis were killed by Israeli soldiers during theOctober 7 attacks. Perach accused Blumenthal of manipulating sources by selectively cutting out inconvenient passages, editing, distorting and changing the meaning, and pushing details while obscuring the main facts.[106]
Blumenthal tweeted in December 2023 that Israel was "inventingstories of mass rape on October 7."[107] Haaretz journalist Sagi Cohen[108] andJewish Insider writer Gabby Deutch accused him of spreading conspiracy theories about 7 October attack.[109]
On January 16, 2025, Blumenthal interrupted US Secretary of StateAntony Blinken's final press conference to ask him why he continued to arm Israel "when we had a deal in May".[110]
In June 2012, Blumenthal resigned from the Lebanese newspaper,Al Akhbar, over what he considered its pro-Assad coverage. In an interview withThe Real News Network shortly afterwards, Blumenthal was critical of Syrian president Bashar al-Assad, describing him as a dictator and saying that, "by all accounts", forces affiliated with Assad were responsible for theHoula massacre. Blumenthal also said that "the Assad regime was running an institution of torture in prisons" which made Israel look like "a champion of human rights".[111]
In September 2013, Blumenthal reported forThe Nation from theZaatari refugee camp in Jordan on the conditions in whichSyrian refugees were living.[28][112] He wrote of being "staunchly against US strikes, mainly because I believe they could exacerbate an already horrific situation without altering the political reality in any meaningful way". The refugees in Zaatari deserved to be heard[according to whom?] and commented in the article: "there was not one person I spoke to in Zaatari who did not demand US military intervention at the earliest possible moment."[112]
After Blumenthal's visit to Moscow in December 2015, according to a 2018 article byJanine di Giovanni inThe New York Review of Books, he began to promote views supportive of Bashar al-Assad and the Syrian government's position. Blumenthal was, di Giovanni wrote, among a group of "Assad apologists."[28] Following the December 2015 trip, he said theWhite Helmets were connected toAl-Qaeda and anti-Assad Syrians were members of the group.[28] In his opinion, the group was "driven by a pro-interventionist agenda conceived by the Western governments and public relations groups that back them" and were being used as a Trojan horse, an excuse for the United States to propose having "70,000 American servicemen" invade Syria.[113]
In an article forNew Politics, Charles Davis said that Blumenthal had implied in an October 2016 article that the White Helmets were involved in a "false flag conspiracy" to claim a UN convoy to rebel-held Aleppo had been bombed by the Syrian and Russian military. Davis wrote: "In fact, a White Helmet's member was among the first civilians to appear on camera at the scene of the attack, declaring in English that 'the regime helicopters targeted this place with four barrel [bombs]'." Blumenthal said the account provided by the White Helmets "remains unconfirmed by both the UN and SARC, and no evidence of barrel bombs has been produced". The UN later concluded their convoy had been hit by barrel bombs dropped by a Syrian regime helicopter.[9]
Charles Davis stated thatThe Grayzone published an article by Blumenthal and Benjamin Norton which cast doubt on the Syrian government's responsibility for the 2017Khan Shaykhun chemical attack. Blumenthal and Norton cited a report bySeymour Hersh which said sarin was not used in the attack. A week before their article was published, theOrganisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons confirmed the presence of sarin and aUnited Nations investigation later said the Syrian government was responsible.[9]
Oz Katerji wrote inHaaretz in July 2017, that "[v]irtually any group that speaks out on the Assad regime's campaign of systematic slaughter have been targeted by this coterie", consisting of Blumenthal,Gareth Porter, Ben Norton and Rania Khalek "with the express intention of defending a regime guilty of human extermination." Far from being anti-war, they are "acting as full-time advocates for Russian and Iranian military imperialism in Syria and to provide them immunity in the American public square from war crimes charges."[16]Gershom Gorenberg wrote on October 14, 2016, forThe American Prospect that "Blumenthal's concern for Arab lives and rights seems to vanish once he locates the Assad regime as an opponent of American hegemony."[32]
In separate articles, Charles Davis and Oz Katerji wrote that, in January 2017, following claims made by the Syrian government, Blumenthal blamed the contamination of the water supply for Damascus in the Wadi Barada valley on militants opposed to the government. A subsequent report by the UN found that "Syria's air force deliberately bombed water sources in December [2016], a war crime that cut off water [to] 5.5 million people in and around the capital Damascus."[9][16] Hetweeted in April 2018 that every time government forces "liberate" a rebel held area those opponents of Assad "allege a chemical attack."[114]
Around the same time, Blumenthal toldSky News Australia that it was quite probable the Syrian rebels were responsible for theDouma chemical attack.[115] "I cannot think of one pundit on the national scene, in cable news or in any major newspaper who has questioned the drive for regime change in Syria", he toldAl Jazeera in an interview in June 2018. It is "left to a small group of journalists and online activists to really sift through what we believe is disinformation from our own governments aimed at stimulating a war of regime change."[116]
In September 2019, Blumenthal was part of an American delegation which visited Damascus to participate in an Assad-backed trade union convention and to stand "against the economic blockade, imperialist interventions and terrorism." The Syrian government does not allow independent labor unions and strikes are illegal.Bellingcat wrote that recent visitors and a tour operator in Damascus had told it that Syria was not generally issuing travel visa to US citizens at the time Blumenthal visited.[31][117][118][119] Muhammad Idrees Ahmad, writing for Al Jazeera, said the delegation included Rania Khalek,Paul Larudee of the Syrian Solidarity Movement,Ajamu Baraka, former RT producer Anya Parampil and "other pro-Assad conspiracy theorists".[117][31] The delegation visited government-held areas and, according to Idrees Ahmad, were accompanied by a minder from the Assad government.[31]
In 2019, Bellingcat wrote that Blumenthal was a recipient of theSerena Shim Award, a financial award for "uncompromised integrity in journalism" awarded by the Association for Investment in Popular Action Committees, which Bellingcat said was a non-profit group that supported Assad.[117] Blumenthal, in a tweet, said he had not received money from "the 'Assad regime' or any lobbying group connected to it".[120][independent source needed] Blumenthal challenged his critics assertions when he was interviewed byRolling Stone in November 2019.[121]
In 2018, during the2018–2022 Nicaraguan protests, Blumenthal wrote a "lengthy, insinuation-infused attack"[122] on the journalistCarl David Goette-Luciak, a freelance reporter forThe Guardian. The article, which was published byMintPress News andThe Canary, stated that Goette-Luciak had links to the Nicaraguan opposition partySandinista Renovation Movement (MRS) and to US organizations that supposedly fund the MRS to destabilise the government.[122][123][124] Following an online harassment campaign, Luciak went into hiding. When he returned to his home, immigration officials arrested him and deported toEl Salvador. Goette-Luciak said the officials threatened him with torture while he was in custody.[122][125][123][124] A lawyer for Blumenthal toldThe Guardian "there was nothing to suggest [Blumenthal]'s reporting contributed to the deportation of Goette-Luciak."[122]
In November 2017, Blumenthal discussed the decision of theUnited States Department of Justice to classify RT as a "foreign agent" in an interview with Tucker Carlson on Fox News. He told Carlson: "I go on RT fairly regularly, and the reason I do so is because, while the three major cable networks are promoting bombing and sanctioning half the world, at least the non-compliant nations, RT is questioning that."[33] Charles Davis, in an article forNew Politics, stated in 2018 that Blumenthal is "found almost every week defending Russian foreign policy on platforms such as RT andSputnik", and has defended Russia's role in the Syrian Civil War.[9]
Blumenthal was skeptical of accounts of PresidentDonald Trump and his administration colluding with Russia in the2016 presidential election in an interview with Tucker Carlson. He said that establishment Republicans and progressive Democrats were using the Russia story to avoid "do[ing] anything progressive".[126][127] Petra Marquardt-Bigman wrote that, in a December 2017 interview withSputnik, Blumenthal had said "the Trump transition team colluded with a foreign power to subvert America's political system". She said he was referring to collusion with Israel, not Russia.[35]
Peter Beinart wrote inThe Atlantic that while Blumenthal andGlenn Greenwald have a strong dislike of PresidentDonald Trump, they are more fundamentally against "hawkish" US foreign policy resulting in them minimizing "Russia's election meddling to oppose what they see as anew Cold War".[127]Matt Taibbi inRolling Stone cited Blumenthal among a group of journalists who had expressed what he described as "healthy" skepticism ofRussiagate.[128] Blumenthal described Russiagate, in an article forTruthdig, as a "vicious backlash ... against Trump's moves toward detente" with Russia.[15] A 2018 article in the Ukrainianfact-checking organizationStopFake described Blumenthal as a "pro-Russia American journalist" who "promotes Russian propaganda".[7]
For his writing concerning Ukraine,Sławomir Sierakowski, the chief editor of the Polish left-wing magazineKrytyka Polityczna, included Blumenthal in a 2014New York Times opinion piece entitled "Putin'sUseful Idiots". Sierakowski discussed Blumenthal's statement that the "openly pro-Nazi politics" of the Ukrainian political partySvoboda and its leader,Oleg Tyagnibok, "have not deterred SenatorJohn McCain from addressing aEuromaidan rally" and did not "prevent Assistant Secretary of StateVictoria Nuland from enjoying a friendly meeting with the Svoboda leader this February". He said that Blumenthal's statement "distorts how these things work. A whole range of Western political leaders traveled to Euromaidan, and virtually all of them were photographed with Mr. Tyagnibok."[129]
During the 2022Russian invasion of Ukraine, Blumenthal falsely claimed theMariupol theatre airstrike was the responsibility of Ukraine'sAzov Regiment rather than Russian forces.[130][131][132] In 2023, he was invited byRussia to address aUN Security Council briefing aboutarms supplies to Ukraine.[133]
The Grayzone and Blumenthal have denied the scale of the detention ofUyghurs inmass internment camps in Xinjiang.[37][34] "I don't have reason to doubt that there's something going in Xinjiang, that there could even be repression",[37] he toldAfshin Rattansi onRT UK'sGoing Underground in July 2020, adding "we haven't seen the evidence for these massive claims [of a million people detained]".[37] He has asserted that the exaggeration or manufacture of crimes against humanity in Xinjiang are part of a United States government campaign to discredit China. In an email toAxios (which they quoted in an August 2020 article), he accused "Cold War ideologues" like the website, of "a desperate campaign to suppress [The Grayzone's] factual journalism."[34] Representatives of the Chinese Foreign Ministry have approvingly tweeted links toThe Grayzone articles on this issue.[134]
Blumenthal's bookThe Management of Savagery: How America's National Security State Fueled the Rise of Al Qaeda, ISIS, and Donald Trump was published in 2019 byVerso Books.
Lydia Wilson, in a review forThe Times Literary Supplement, was critical ofThe Management of Savagery.[135] She wrote that Blumenthal overstates his case "with misleading or one-sided examples" in an account of the United States involvement in wars during the previous two decades which "tips sufficiently and with enough regularity into full-scale conspiracy to allow any careful reader to dismiss it." Wilson commented that Blumenthal "uses long-debunked myths", originating from Russian and Syrian sources, to explain theGhouta chemical attack in 2013.[135]
JournalistChris Hedges, in a positive review forTruthdig, described the book as "insightful".[136] A review byNasser Baston in the British newspaperMorning Star stated that it is a "useful antidote to the torrents of pro-empire bilge promoted by conservatives and liberals alike".[137]
On February 24, 2019, Blumenthal posted an article onThe Grayzone website about clashes on February 23 on theColombia–Venezuela border during the2019 Venezuelan presidential crisis and theshipping of humanitarian aid to Venezuela. The US government and media had stated that humanitarian aid trucks that were attempting to enter Venezuela from Colombia had been deliberately set on fire by Nicolas Maduro's forces. In his article, Blumenthal wrote that "the claim was absurd on its face". He said footage fromBloomberg News showed that opposition protesters on theFrancisco de Paula Santander bridge in the border were preparingMolotov cocktails, "which could easily set a truck cabin or its cargo alight". He referred to having seen similar situations during his reporting on theWest Bank.[138] According toGlenn Greenwald inThe Intercept, "[Blumenthal] compiled substantial evidence strongly suggesting that the trucks were set ablaze by anti-Maduro protesters".[138]
In August, Blumenthal interviewed Maduro.[139]
On October 25, 2019, Blumenthal was arrested and charged with assault of a woman in a case related to a May 7 incident at the embassy of Venezuela, Washington, D.C.[140] The US Department of Justice dropped the case against Blumenthal in December 2019.[141]
In May 2020, Blumenthal said onTheJimmy Dore Show thatGeorge Soros is funding anti-government protesters in Venezuela, as well as in Hong Kong.[142]
In February 2021, tweets concerning aGrayzone article by Blumenthal were the first to receive a Twitter warning label stating: "These materials may have been obtained through hacking". The story was entitled "Reuters,BBC, andBellingcat participated in covertUK Foreign Office-funded programs to 'weaken Russia', leaked docs reveal". The story referred to hacked and leaked documents which, it alleged, show a British Army unit has used "social media to help fight wars". Twitter's head of editorial in Europe, the Middle East, and Africa is a reservist for the same British Army Unit.[143]
At a recent similar event in New York he [Blumenthal] praised the people in the [anti-vax] movement, spun conspiracy theories, stated the issue wasn't one of left versus right. ...One of his [Blumenthal's] past assertions was that the White Helmets, famed for their rescue efforts on behalf of innocents, were nothing more than al Qaeda—a conspiracy theory that has been thoroughly exposed and refuted.
Max Blumenthal, who has been criticized for promoting conspiracy theories about Syria's White Helmets. ... The GrayZone Project, which spreads conspiracy theory narratives about Venezuela, Xinjiang, and Syria, among other places. The source Ross cites is:Blumenthal, Max (January 6, 2018)."How 'Russiagate' Helped Secure a Dangerous Arms Deal".Truthdig. RetrievedJune 13, 2022.
Goliath, winner of the Lannan Foundation Cultural Freedom Notable Book Award.
Blumenthal went to Moscow on a junket to celebrate RT's tenth anniversary. We don't know what happened during that visit, but afterward, Blumenthal's views completely flipped.
I was forced to conclude that unless I was prepared to spend endless stores of energy jousting with Assad apologists, I was merely providing them cover by keeping my name and reputation associated withAl Akhbar.
Blumenthal's political reversal started with a Kremlin-sponsored junket to Moscow in December 2015 – to the same gathering where General Michael Flynn was compromised and where Jill Stein abased herself.
Max Blumenthal emphasized and exaggerated everything that might make the Israel Defense Forces, and Israelis generally, look like the most reprehensibly amoral of human beings, while suppressing facts that showed Hamas terrorists and other Palestinians in a less than favorable light. [...] Only a month after the RT bash, Blumenthal founded something called "The Grayzone Project," which describes itself as "a news and politics website dedicated to original investigative journalism and analysis on war and empire."
Look at some of these quotes he uses in his book. 'A Nazi-like mentality also exists in our country…" 'That says a great deal about the Nazi mentality that is dominant here…' 'In modern day Israel, the African refugee occupied a similar role as the devious Jew in Weimar-era Nazi propaganda…' 'There are Judeo-Nazis…'
The Grayzone also published a transcript of a discussion between Max Blumenthal andChris Hedges in which they agree that Israel created a "shock-and-awe campaign of misinformation" in order to create "political space for its brutal assault on Gaza."
The conspiracy theories have largely been spread by social media users abroad, notably thenames_ahmad, Max Blumenthal and Jackson Hinkle.
"Why did you keep the bombs flowing when we had a deal in May?" Max Blumenthal, editor of the Grayzone, an outlet that strongly criticizes many aspects of U.S. foreign policy, called out to Blinken, before he was escorted out.
UPDATE: Feb. 24, 2021, 9:34 a.m. EST According to Twitter, this instance is indeed the first time the "hacked materials" warning label has been used.
