As part of the2023 WWE Draft, both Morgan and Rodriguez were drafted to theRawbrand.[6] On the May 19 episode ofSmackDown, Morgan and Rodriguez vacated the titles due to Morgan suffering a shoulder injury, ending their first reign at 39 days.[7] Morgan would make her return on the June 23 episode ofSmackDown.[8] AtMoney in the Bank on July 1, Morgan and Rodriguez defeated Rousey and Baszler to win the WWE Women's Tag Team Championship for the second time.[9] On the July 17 episode ofRaw, Morgan and Rodriguez lost the titles to Chelsea Green and Sonya Deville afterRhea Ripley attacked them backstage before the match, ending their second reign at 16 days.[10] The following week, Morgan was scheduled to face Ripley, however, the match never began as Ripley viciously attacked Morgan with a steel chair.[11] This was done to write Morgan off television, as she suffered another shoulder injury.[12] Rodriguez was diagnosed withmast cell activation syndrome,[13] which kept her out of action for much of 2024.[14]
While Rodriguez remained out of action, Morgan returned from her injury and resumed her feud with Ripley, with Morgan legitimately injuring Ripley during a backstage attack on the April 8, 2024 episode ofRaw.[15][16] In the aftermath, Morgan captured theWomen's World Championship by defeating Becky Lynch at theKing and Queen of the Ring event, while also beginning to display morevillainous traits. Morgan succeeded in stealing Ripley's on-screen love interestDominik Mysterio and excommunicating Ripley fromThe Judgment Day atSummerSlam, joining the group herself on the following episode ofRaw, turningheel.[17][18]
AtBad Blood on October 5, Rodriguez made her return after a seven-month hiatus and attacked Ripley to help Morgan retain her title, becoming the newest member of The Judgment Day, turning heel.[19] AtCrown Jewel, Morgan defeatedWWE Women's ChampionNia Jax to win the inauguralWWE Women's Crown Jewel Championship after interference from Rodriguez and Mysterio.[20] On the November 11 episode ofRaw, Morgan and Rodriguez failed to win the WWE Women's Tag Team Championship fromBianca Belair andJade Cargill.[21] AtSurvivor Series WarGames on November 30, both Morgan and Rodriguez competed in the women'sWarGames match alongside Jax,Candice LeRae, andTiffany Stratton against Ripley, Belair,Bayley, Iyo Sky, andNaomi in a losing effort, with Morgan being pinned by Ripley.[22] At thepremiere ofRaw on Netflix, Morgan lost the title to Ripley despite interference from Rodriguez and Mysterio, ending her reign at 226 days.[23]
At theRoyal Rumble on February 1, 2025, Morgan and Rodriguez participated in thenamesake match, but were both eliminated by Nia Jax. On the February 24 episode ofRaw, Morgan and Rodriguez defeated Belair and Naomi to win theWWE Women's Tag Team Championship for a record-setting third time after interference from Mysterio.[24] On Night 2 ofWrestleMania 41, Morgan and Rodriguez lost the titles toLyra Valkyria and the returning Becky Lynch, ending their reign at 55 days.[25] The next night onRaw, Morgan and Rodriguez regained the titles from Lynch and Valkyria in a rematch to become recordfour-time champions.[26] On the June 16 episode ofRaw, Morgan suffered alegitimatedislocated shoulder during a match againstKairi Sane, leading toRoxanne Perez joining The Judgment Day and replacing Morgan as champion. WWE recognizes this as a separate reign, thus ending Morgan and Rodriguez's fourth reign at 70 days. Since then, the team has been on hiatus due to Morgan's injury.[27][28]