1834–1835: Samuel Peete (Resigned in 1834 and was re-appointed)
1835–1836: Unknown
1836–1842: Elisha H. Rice
1842–1844: George P. Beirne
From 1844 to 1916, Presidents of Huntsville were again elected by the people, with a President/Council system from 1844 to 1911 and a City Commission form of government from 1911 to 1916:
1844–1849: Joseph Clark
1849–1850: George P. Beirne
1850–1851: Edwin R. Wallace
1851–1853: William Echols Jr.
1853–1854: Samuel Peete (Resigned)
1854: Joshua Beadle
1854–1855: William Figures
1855–1859: Zebulon P. Davis
1859–1860: John J. Ward (Resigned)
1860: John James Coleman
1860–1861: Zebulon P. Davis (Resigned)
1861–1865: Robert W. Coltart
1865–1866: Zebulon P. Davis
1866–1867: Robert W. Colart (Removed by Union Army)
1867–1868: E. B. Clapp (Put in office by Union Army, later resigned)
1868–1870: William B. Figures (Approved by Union Army to replace Clapp)
1870–1872: William F. Mastin (Died)
1872: James L. Cooper
1872–1874: John A. Erwin
1874–1878: Jere Murphy
1878–1882: Zebulon P. Davis
1882–1883: Thomas W. White
1883–1889: Edmond I. Mastin
1889–1893: Jere Murphy
1893–1897: W. T. Hutchens
1897–1899: Jere Murphy
1899–1903: Alfred Moore
1903–1907: Thomas W. Smith
1907–1908: R. Erle Smith
1908–1910: Thomas W. Smith
1910–1913: R. Erle Smith
1913–1914: R. L. O'Neal
1914–1915: Dr. J. D. Humphrey
1915–1916: Milton H. Lanier
In 1916, returned to the Mayor/Council form of government:
^Roberts, Frances (October 21, 1971)."Henry B. Chase: A Man for All Ages"(PDF).Huntsville Historical Review. Vol. 1, no. 4. pp. 22–35. RetrievedMay 8, 2013.
