| Indonesian Liberal Democracy Era | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 17 August 1950 – 5 July 1959 | |||
| |||
.jpg) PresidentSukarno voting in the1955 elections | |||
| President | Sukarno | ||
| Prime Minister(s) | Mohammad Natsir Soekiman Wirjosandjojo Wilopo Ali Sastroamidjojo Burhanuddin Harahap Djuanda Kartawidjaja | ||
| Key events | |||
TheLiberal Democracy period in Indonesia (Indonesian:Demokrasi Liberal), also known as theEra of Parliamentary Democracy, was a period in Indonesianpolitical history, when the country was under aliberal democratic system. During this period, Indonesia held its first and only free and fair legislative election until 1999, but also saw continual political instability. The period began on 17 August 1950 following the dissolution of the federalUnited States of Indonesia, less than a year after its formation, and ended with the imposition ofmartial law andPresident Sukarno's decree, which resulted in the introduction ofGuided Democracy on 5 July 1959.
On 17 August 1950, the Republic of theUnited States of Indonesia (RIS), which was a state created as a result of theRound Table Conference and the recognition of Indonesian sovereignty by theNetherlands, was officially dissolved. The system of government was also changed to a parliamentary democracy based on theProvisional Constitution of 1950.
The period ofliberal democracy was marked by the growth of political parties and the enactment of aparliamentary system of government, but also by a long period of political instability, with governments falling one after another. The1955 legislative elections saw the first free and fair elections in Indonesian history, as well as the only free and fair election until the1999 legislative elections, which were held at the end of theNew Order regime.[1]
Following more than 4 years of brutal fighting and violence, theIndonesian National Revolution was over, with theDutch–Indonesian Round Table Conference resulting in the transference of sovereignty to theUnited States of Indonesia (RIS). However, the RIS government lacked cohesion inside and was opposed by many republicans. These factors among many others, resulted in the dissolution of all the constituents of the RIS, which were later merged again as part of theunitaryRepublic of Indonesia by 17 August 1950, the fifth anniversary of theDeclaration of Independence.[2]
However, divisions in Indonesian society began to appear. Regional differences in customs, morals, tradition, religion, the impact ofChristianity andMarxism, and fears of Javanese political domination, all contributed to disunity. The new country was typified by poverty, low educational levels, and authoritarian traditions.[3] Various separatist movements also arose to oppose the new Republic: the militantDarul Islam ('Islamic Domain') proclaimed an "Islamic State of Indonesia" and waged a guerrilla struggle against the Republic inWest Java from 1948 to 1962; inMaluku,Ambonese, formerly of theRoyal Netherlands East Indies Army, proclaimed an independentRepublic of South Maluku;Permesta andPRRI rebels fought the Central government inSulawesi and WestSumatra between 1955 and 1961.
The economy was in a disastrous state following three years ofJapanese occupation and the following four years ofwar against the Dutch. In the hands of a young and inexperienced government, the economy was unable to boost production of food and other necessities to keep pace with the rapidly increasing population. Most of the population were illiterate, unskilled, and suffered from a dearth of management skills.Inflation was rampant,smuggling cost the central government much needed foreign exchange, and many of the plantations had been destroyed during the occupation and war.[4]
The first cabinet of the new nation was theNatsir Cabinet. It was formed byPrime MinisterMohammad Natsir with the backing of theMasyumi and theIndonesian Socialist Party (PSI), following a failed attempt at a coalition between the Masyumi and theIndonesian National Party (PNI).[5] During this cabinet period, there were rebellions in almost all parts of Indonesia, problems in national security, such as theDarul Islam rebellion,Makassar Uprising,APRA coup d'état, and theRepublic of South Maluku independence movement. Negotiations on theWest Irian issue were also held during this cabinet, though these only resulted in a stalemate. On 22 January 1951, the parliament passed avote of no confidence, resulting in Prime Minister Natsir returning his mandate to the president on 21 March 1951.[6]
Following the resignation of the Natsir Cabinet, attempts were made by political leaders, such asSartono, to form acoalition government between Masyumi and the PNI. However, this proved to be difficult, as disagreements arose, including over the turnover tax, the regional councils, the West Irian issue, and seat distribution in such a cabinet.[7] Eventually, an agreement was reached, withSoekiman Wirjosandjojo serving as prime minister. Notably, no one from the PSI and the Natsir faction of the Masyumi was a part of the cabinet.[8]
The Soekiman cabinet was notable for its poor relations with the army and its suppression of theIndonesian Communist Party (PKI), following a series of militant strikes between June and August 1951. The first (and only) crackdown against the communists in Indonesia up until the events of the30 September Movement.[9] The Soekiman cabinet would eventually fall due to a foreign policy crisis, which committed Indonesia to the 'free world.' Resulting in the resignation of Foreign MinisterAchmad Soebardjo and the fall of the whole cabinet in February 1952.[10]
After the fall of the Soekiman cabinet, another Masyumi-PNI cabinet followed, this time, it was led by the PNI, under Prime MinisterWilopo. During theWilopo cabinet, a major political realignment occurred. The PNI was growing suspicious of the Masyumi and was looking to postpone elections, fearing it might be won overwhelmingly by the Masyumi. This coincided with the PKI's new national united front strategy, which saw the party offer its support to the PNI, and didn't denounce the current cabinet, as it had done with the Soekiman cabinet. Meanwhile, the Masyumi was experiencing a split, as theNahdlatul Ulama (NU) formed their own party, following doctrinal disputes.[11]
Under the Wilopo cabinet, economic conditions began to worsen, as the economic boom that occurred during theKorean War was over. Prices of exports began to fall, notably rubber, which fell by 71%. This led to the cabinet cutting expenditures, including the budget of the army. However, the Wilopo Cabinet's proposals were unpopular with thearmy. The Army's high command came into dispute with the parliament in what it saw as excessive civilian meddling within military affairs. After a dismissal of a pro-government officer in July 1952, the parliament began demanding a significant restructuring of armed forces leadership, and after three months tensions culminated inthousands of demonstrators mobilized by the army inJakarta.
President Sukarno managed to temper the demonstrators and assure the army officers, but refused to concede to any demands. Soon after the incident, a significant proportion of the army's high command was replaced.[12] In March 1953, the cabinet fell, after what is now called theTanjung Morawa affair, where police killed five peasants near Medan while removing squatters from foreign-owned estate lands. Before a vote of no confidence could be taken in parliament, the cabinet returned its mandate to Sukarno on 16 March 1953.[13][14]
After over six weeks of bargaining and five attempts at various party combinations, a new cabinet led by the PNI, with support by the NU, was formed withAli Sastroamidjojo serving as Prime Minister. This time, the Masyumi was excluded, along with the PSI. Under the Ali Sastroamidjojo's first cabinet, the bureaucracy was expanded with more PNI officials, the economy was under a period of Indonesianization, with the government encouraging indigenous businessmen to open new firms. In practice, however, many new firms were bogus fronts for arrangements between government supporters and Chinese, which became known as "Ali Baba firms," in which an Indonesian (‘Ali’) was front man for a Chinese (‘Baba’) entrepreneur.[15]
In April 1955, theBandung conference was held, and it represented a triumph for the Ali Sastroamidjojo government. Around 29 states, attended the conference. Those present includedZhou Enlai,Jawaharlal Nehru,Phạm Văn Đồng,Mohammad Ali Bogra andGammal Abdel Nasser.[16] Ali Sastroamidjojo also continued the duties of the previous cabinet to carry out elections. On 31 May 1954, the Central and Regional Election Committees were formed. The plan at that time was that elections for the legislative branch would be held onSeptember 29 and for theConstitutional Assembly would be held onDecember 15. However, again as experienced by the Wilopo Cabinet, the Ali Sastroamidjojo Cabinet dissolved in July 1955 and was replaced by theBurhanuddin Harahap Cabinet the following month, after a deteriorating economy, which resulted in the NU withdrawing, and the collapse of the cabinet.[17]
%2c_p94.jpg)
Following the dissolution of the First Ali Sastroamidjojo cabinet, vice presidentMohammad Hatta announced the names of three candidates for the new cabinet formation, namelyWilopo,Soekiman, andAssaat. However, these three candidates agreed to choose Hatta as prime minister and Minister of Defense. However, because Hatta was still serving as vice president, Hatta appointedBurhanuddin Harahap to form a cabinet. Burhanuddin Harahap's cabinet consisted of a coalition of thirteen different parties, though in practice the cabinet was dominated by the Masyumi, with other parties only being added as complementary. The PNI did not sit in this cabinet, but the PNI together with theGreat Indonesia Party (PIR) led byWongsonegoro, the PKI, led byD. N. Aidit, and other parties formed and acted as the opposition.[18] The army was not entirely pleased with the newly formed cabinet, since it believed many of the new cabinet members to be as corrupt as their predecessors. But it was pleased at the opportunity to arrest several PNI figures for corruption.[19]
Under the cabinet, the long-awaited 1955legislative andconstitutional assembly elections took place. Rather than resolving political issues, the elections merely helped to draw the battle-lines more precisely.[20] Under Burhanuddin Harahap, harmonization between the government and the army began, as well as the termination of theNetherlands-Indonesia Union, as a form of protest over theWest Irian issue. The cabinet resigned in early March.[21]
The next cabinet was again led byAli Sastroamidjojo, who became prime minister again. Unlike the other cabinets, this cabinet was the only cabinet that governed through elections during the era of Liberal Democracy. The cabinet was notable for the fact that 17 of the 24 new ministers were without previous cabinet experience.[22] Under the cabinet, the Round Table Conference (KMB) was cancelled unilaterally, both formally and materially, cooperation continued with Asian-African countries, the decisions of theAsian-African Conference inBandung were implemented, and domestic reforms were enacted. After a year, the cabinet had to return their mandate to the President, following a split between the PNI and Masyumi parties.
Following the fall of the Second Ali Sastroamidjojo cabinet, president Sukarno expressed his desire for agotong royong (mutual assistance) cabinet, in which all of the four major parties, including the PKI would work together for the national interest. However, following vociferous opposition from the other parties and theArmy, Sukarno was forced to back down. On 15 March, he asked PNI chairman, and formerMayor ofJakartaSuwiryo to form a cabinet, but he failed, with the result that Sukarno himself called a meeting on 14 April of party leaders and military officers, at which they were all asked if they were prepared to join the cabinet. The Masyumi, most of whose members refused to serve in the cabinet, accused Sukarno of acting illegally, but to no avail. The party later expelled its two members who joined the cabinet. Sukarno appointed cabinet veteranDjuanda Kartawidjaja to head a cabinet made up of qualified individuals who did not represent any parties. The cabinet was announced on 8 April and appointed by Sukarno the following day at theMerdeka Palace.[23]
Unlike other cabinets, this cabinet was the only cabinet in power through a mandate given directly by the president. This cabinet was forced to resign because of changes in the political system made by President Sukarno through thePresidential Decree of July 5, 1959.
Even as early as 1956, president Sukarno was openly criticizing the parliamentary democracy, stating that it was 'based upon inherent conflict' that ran counter to the Indonesian concept of harmony as the natural state of human relationships. Instead, he sought a system based on the traditional village system of discussion and consensus, which occurred under the guidance of village elders. He proposed a threefold blend ofnasionalisme ('nationalism'),agama ('religion'), andkomunisme ('communism') into a co-operative 'Nasakom' government. This was intended to appease the three main factions in Indonesian politics – the army, Islamic groups, and the communists.
With the support of the military, he proclaimed in February 1957, 'Guided Democracy', and proposed a cabinet of representing all the political parties of importance (including the PKI). This shift into a more authoritarian form of democracy culminated on 5 July 1959. Sukarno issued aPresidential Decree of July 5, 1959, which among other things contained the dissolution of the Constituent Assembly and the replacement of the constitution from the 1950 Constitution to the 1945 Constitution again. This event marked the end of Parliamentary Democracy and the beginning of theGuided Democracy Era. The government then formedProvisional People's Consultative Assembly (MPRS) institutions in aguided democracy that implemented a political system of balance.[24]
TheProvisional Constitution of 1950 differed markedly from the1945 Constitution in many ways; it mandated a parliamentary system of government, and stipulated at length constitutional guarantees for human rights, drawing heavily on the 1948UN'sUniversal Declaration of Human Rights.[25] It was abrogated on 9 July 1959 when PresidentSukarno issued adecree dissolving theConstitutional Assembly and restoring the 1945Constitution of Indonesia.[26]
The position ofPrime Minister of Indonesia (Indonesian:Perdana Menteri Republik Indonesia) was the main head of government of Indonesia during the Liberal Democracy Era, with thepresident officially only acting as a figurehead. During this period, the prime minister was in charge of theCabinet of Indonesia, one of the three branches of government along with theProvisional People's Representative Council and thepresident. Under theconstitution of the unitary state, the cabinet was once again responsible to parliament, with the prime minister appointed by the president. Due to the instability of the coalition cabinets, prime ministers often facedvotes of no confidence. Every major policy change had a chance to be opposed, either by the government oropposition. As such, some cabinets lasted only a few months.[citation needed]
Throughout the Liberal Democracy era, a large number of political parties existed within Indonesia. The main four were theIndonesian National Party (PNI), theMasyumi Party, theNahdlatul Ulama, and theCommunist Party of Indonesia (PKI). Other smaller parties existed, including theChristian Party,Catholic Party, andSocialist Party. The large numbers of parties resulted in a proliferation of political parties and the deals brokered between them for shares of cabinets seats resulted in rapid turnover coalition governments including 17 cabinets between 1945 and 1958.[citation needed]
