Holly's acting career began at the age of 20 when she appeared as Carla Walicki in two episodes ofHill Street Blues. She was also in one episode ofSpenser: For Hire. At age 23, she joined the cast of the ABC television soap operaAll My Children as Julie Rand Chandler (1986–1989). She portrayed the comic book characterBetty Cooper in the TV movieArchie: To Riverdale and Back Again in 1990.
Holly has been married three times. Her first marriage was to actorDanny Quinn. The two married in 1991, and divorced two years later in 1993. In 1993, she metJim Carrey during auditions forAce Ventura: Pet Detective. She did not get offered the part, but the two developed a relationship while working together during the filming ofDumb and Dumber. In 1996 they were married. The marriage lasted less than a year, and they divorced in 1997.[15] In 2001, she married Francis Greco, a Canadian-born investment banker.[16] The couple adopted three children, sons Henry, George, and Alexander Holly-Greco. In 2008, while married to Greco, Holly became a Canadian citizen.[3][4] The couple divorced in 2014.
In 1992, Holly, her father Grant, and their families established the "A" Fund atHobart and William Smith Colleges in memory of her brother, Alexander, about whom Holly said, "He was a boy filled with dreams, hopes, and plans. Although he was only 14 when he died, he had traveled extensively in Europe and Central America, lived in New York City and Los Angeles, and these experiences produced in him a fascination for architecture and archaeology."[18]
^The Irrational (Drama, Thriller), Jesse L. Martin, Maahra Hill, Travina Springer, Simon-Binx Productions, Samuel Baum Productions, Off the Cliff Entertainment, September 25, 2023, retrievedApril 17, 2024{{citation}}: CS1 maint: others (link)