Human rights inRwanda have been violated on a grand scale. The greatest violation is theRwandan genocide ofTutsi in 1994. The post-genocide government is also responsible for grave violations of human rights.
As decolonization ideas spread across Africa, aTutsi party andHutu party were created. Both became militarized, and in 1959, Tutsi attempted to assassinateGrégoire Kayibanda, the leader ofPARMEHUTU. This resulted in thewind of destruction known as the "Social Revolution" in Rwanda, violence which pitted Hutu against Tutsi, killing 20,000 to 100,000 Tutsi and forcing more into exile.
After the withdrawal of Belgium from Africa in 1962, Rwanda separated fromRwanda-Urundi by referendum, which also eliminated the Tutsi monarchy, themwami. In 1963, the Hutu government killed 14,000 Tutsi, after Tutsi guerillas attacked Rwanda from Burundi. The government maintained mandatory ethnic identity cards, and capped Tutsi numbers in universities and the civil service.[citation needed]
In September 1996 Rwanda invadedZaire, precipitating theFirst Congo War. The immediate targets of the invasion were the largeHutu refugee camps located right across the border in the vicinity ofGoma andBukavu, which were organized under the leadership of the former regime.[4] The Rwandan armychased the refugees in hot pursuit clear across Zaire, while helping to installAFDL in power inKinshasa. The historianGérard Prunier estimated the death toll among the fleeing refugees to lay between 213,000–280,000.[5]
In 2010, theUnited Nations issueda report investigating 617 alleged violent incidents occurring in theDemocratic Republic of Congo between March 1993 and June 2003.[6] It reported that the "apparent systematic and widespread attacks described in this report reveal a number of inculpatory elements that, if proven before a competent court, could be characterized as crimes of genocide" against Hutus. The report was categorically rejected by the Rwandan government.[7]
In December 1996 the Rwandan government launched a forcedvillagization program which sought to concentrate the entire rural population in villages known asImidugudu,[8] which resulted in human rights violations of tens of thousands of Rwandans, according to Human Rights Watch.[9]
According to a report byAmnesty International, between December 1997 and May 1998, thousands of Rwandans "disappeared" or were murdered by members of government security forces and of armed opposition groups. Most of the killings took place in Rwanda's northwestern provinces ofGisenyi andRuhengeri where there was an armed insurgency. Amnesty wrote that "Thousands of unarmed civilians have beenextrajudicially executed byRPA soldiers in the contextof military search operations in the northwest."[10]
When Kagame visited Washington in early 2001,Human Rights Watch criticized Rwanda for its involvement in theSecond Congo War in which "as many as 1.7 million" civilians had died.[11]
Regarding human rights under the government of President Paul Kagame, Human Rights Watch in 2007 accused Rwandan police of several instances of extrajudicial killings and deaths in custody.[12][13] In June 2006, theInternational Federation of Human Rights and Human Rights Watch described what they called "serious violations of international humanitarian law committed by the Rwanda Patriotic Army".[14]
According toThe Economist in 2008, Kagame "allows less political space and press freedom at home thanRobert Mugabe does inZimbabwe", and "[a]nyone who poses the slightest political threat to the regime is dealt with ruthlessly".[15]
Kagame has been accused of using memories of the genocide to muzzle his opposition. In 2009, Human Rights Watch claimed that under the pretense of maintaining ethnic harmony, Kagame's government displays "a marked intolerance of the most basic forms of dissent." It also claimed that laws enacted in 2009 that ban "genocide ideology" are frequently used to legally gag the opposition.[16] In 2010, along similar lines,The Economist claimed that Kagame frequently accuses his opponents of "divisionism," or fomenting racial hatred.[17] In 2011, Freedom House noted that the government justifies restrictions on civil liberties as a necessary measure to prevent ethnic violence. These restrictions are so severe that even mundane discussions of ethnicity can result in being arrested for divisionism.[18]
The United States government in 2006 described the human rights record of the Kagame government as "mediocre", citing the "disappearances" of political dissidents, as well as arbitrary arrests and acts of violence, torture, and murders committed by police. U. S. authorities listed human rights problems including the existence of political prisoners and limited freedom of the press,freedom of assembly and freedom of religion.[19]
Reporters Without Borders listed Rwanda in 147th place out of 169 for freedom of the press in 2007,[20] and reported that "Rwandan journalists suffer permanent hostility from their government and surveillance by the security services". It cited cases of journalists being threatened, harassed, and arrested for criticising the government. According to Reporters Without Borders, "President Paul Kagame and his government have never accepted that the press should be guaranteed genuine freedom".[21]
In 2010, Rwanda fell to 169th place, out of 178, entering the ranks of the ten lowest-ranked countries in the world for press freedom. Reporters Without Borders stated that "Rwanda,Yemen andSyria have joinedBurma andNorth Korea as the most repressive countries in the world against journalists",[22] adding that in Rwanda, "the third lowest-ranked African country", "this drop was caused by the suspending of the main independent press media, the climate of terror surrounding the presidential election, and the murdering, in Kigali, of the deputy editor ofUmuvugizi,Jean-Léonard Rugambage. In proportions almost similar to those ofSomalia, Rwanda is emptying itself of its journalists, who are fleeing the country due to their fear of repression".[23]
In July 2009, theCommonwealth Human Rights Initiative issued a report critical of the human rights situation in Rwanda.[25] It highlighted "a lack of political freedom and harassment of journalists".[26] It urged the Rwandan government to enact legislation enablingfreedom of information and to "authorise the presence of an opposition in the next election".[27] It also emphasised abuses carried out by Rwandan troops in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and described Rwanda's overall human rights situation as "very poor":[28]
The report details a country in which democracy, freedom of speech, the press and human rights are undermined or violently abused, in which courts fail to meet international standards, and a country which has invaded its neighbour, the Democratic Republic of Congo, four times since 1994. ... Censorship is prevalent, according to the report, and the government has a record of shutting down independent media and harassing journalists. It concludes that Rwanda's constitution is used as a "façade" to hide "the repressive nature of the regime" and backs claims that Rwanda is essentially "an army with a state".[29]
In the lead-up to the2010 presidential election, theUnited Nations "demanded a full investigation into allegations of politically motivated killings of opposition figures".André Kagwa Rwisereka, the president of theDemocratic Green Party of Rwanda, was found beheaded. "[A] lawyer who had participated in genocide trials at a UN tribunal was shot dead". There was a murder attempt onKayumba Nyamwasa, "a former senior Rwandan general who had fallen out with Kagame". AndJean-Léonard Rugambage, a journalist investigating that attempted murder, was himself murdered.[30][31]
In 2011,Amnesty International criticized the continued detention of former transportation minister and Bizimungu allyCharles Ntakirutinka, who was seven years into a ten-year sentence atKigali central prison.[32] Amnesty International called him aprisoner of conscience and named him a 2011 "priority case".[32]
In October 2012, the body ofThéogène Turatsinze, a Rwandan businessman living in Mozambique, who was thought to have "had access to politically sensitive financial information related to certain Rwandan government insiders", was found tied up and floating in the sea. Police in Mozambique "initially indicated Rwandan government involvement in the killing before contacting the government and changing its characterization to a common crime. Rwandan government officials publicly condemned the killing and denied involvement."[33] Foreign media connected the murder to those of several prominent critics of the Rwandan government over the previous two years.[34][35]
To improve the perception of its human rights record, the Rwandan government in 2009 engaged a U. S. public relations firm,Racepoint Group, who had improved the image of Libya'sGaddafi, Tunisia, Angola, Equatorial Guinea, Ethiopia, and Senegal. An internet site was set up by BTP advisers, a British firm, to attack critics. Racepoint's agreement with the government stated that it would "flood" the Internet and the media with positive stories about Rwanda.[36]
In 2020, regime criticPaul Rusesabagina who had fled the country and become a Belgian citizen, was tricked into boarding a private flight to Rwanda, arrested, and the next year sentenced to 25 years in prison on charges that human rights advocates called politically motivated.
2011:Charles Ingabire, a journalist and "outspoken critic of the Rwandan government", gunned down in Kampala.[40]
2014:Patrick Karegeya, former head of the foreign Intelligence services and supporter of the opposition, found strangled in a hotel in Johannesburg.[41]
2020:Kizito Mihigo, songwriter who fell into disfavour of the regime after a song released in 2014, died in a police cell days after being arrested.[42]
The following chart shows Rwanda's ratings since 1972 in theFreedom in the World reports, published annually byFreedom House. A rating of 1 is "free"; 7, "not free".[43]1
On 26 July 2022, chairman of theUS Senate Foreign Relations Committee raised concerns about the Rwandan government's human rights record and role in the conflict in the Democratic Republic of Congo. In a letter to US Secretary of StateAntony Blinken, SenatorRobert Menendez called for a comprehensive review of US policy towards Rwanda.[64]
1.^ Note that the "Year" signifies the "Year covered". Therefore the information for the year marked 2008 is from the report published in 2009, and so on.
3.^ The 1982 report covers the year 1981 and the first half of 1982, and the following 1984 report covers the second half of 1982 and the whole of 1983. In the interest of simplicity, these two aberrant "year and a half" reports have been split into three year-long reports through interpolation.
^Reyntjens, Filip (2013).Political Governance in Post-Genocide Rwanda. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 98ff.ISBN978-1-107-67879-8.
^Reyntjens, Filip (2013).Political Governance in Post-Genocide Rwanda. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 105–108.ISBN978-1-107-67879-8.
^Prunier, Gérard (2009).Africa's World War: Congo, the Rwandan genocide, and the making of a continental catastrophe. Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp. 22–24, 67.ISBN978-0-19-975420-5.
^Prunier, Gérard (2009).Africa's World War: Congo, the Rwandan genocide, and the making of a continental catastrophe. Oxford: Oxford University Press. p. 409, note 200. Cited on page 148.ISBN978-0-19-975420-5.
^Hilhorst, Dorethea; Leeuwen, Mathijs van (1 September 2000). "Emergency and Development: the Case of Imidugudu, Villagization in Rwanda".Journal of Refugee Studies.13 (3): 267.doi:10.1093/jrs/13.3.264.ISSN0951-6328.
^Prunier, Gérard (2009).Africa's World War: Congo, the Rwandan genocide, and the making of a continental catastrophe. Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp. 365–368.ISBN978-0-19-975420-5.
.svg)