The termHmong is the English spelling of the Hmong's native name. It is a singular and plural noun (e.g., Japanese, French, etc.). Very little is known about the native Hmong name as it is not mentioned in Chinese historical records, since the Han identified the Hmong as Miao. The meaning of it is debatable and no one is sure of its origin, although it can be traced back to several provinces in China. However, Hmong Americans and Hmong Laotians often associate it with "Free" and/or "Hmoov" (Fate); it serves as a reminder to them of their history of fighting oppression.[10][11]
Before the 1970s, the termMiao orMeo (i.e. barbarians, wild, seedlings, and even "Sons of the Soil") was used in reference to the Hmong.[12][13] In the 1970s, Dr. Yang Dao, a Hmong American scholar, who at the time was the head of the Human Resource Department of the Ministry of Planning in the Royal Lao Government of Laos, advocated for the term "Hmong" with the support of clan leaders andGeneral Vang Pao.[14][15][16] Yang Dao insisted that the terms "Meo" and "Miao" were both unacceptable as his people had always called themselves by the name "Hmong," which he defined as "free men".[14] Surrounding countries began to use the term "Hmong" after theU.S. Department of State used it during Immigration screening in Thailand'sBan Vinai Refugee Camp.[17] In 1994,Pobzeb Vang registered the term "Hmong" with theUnited Nations, making it the proper term to identify the Hmong people internationally.[18] Soon after, there was a political push from Hmong American politicians and activists to replace the term Miao with the term Hmong in China with little to no success.[19]
Historically, the term "Hmong" is not featured in any Chinese text, only the term "Miao". However it is uncertain if all mentions of Miao people referred to the Hmong people. According to Ruey (1962), the way in which Miao was used in Chinese can roughly be divided into three periods: a legendary period from 2300 BC to 200 BC, then a period when the term generally referred to southern barbarians until 1200 AD, and then a modern period during which the Hmong were probably included. Although the term appeared before theQin dynasty (221 BCE), throughout history Miao was used as a loose and general term by theHan to refer to southern barbarians. Only since theTang dynasty did more evidence of its association with the Hmong become more apparent.[20][12][19] In the 20th century, Western missionaries called the Hmong andHmao the "Big Flowery Miao" (Da Hua Miao) and the "Little Flowery Miao" (Xiao Hua Miao).[21][22] Another source states that the Green and White Miao were the Hmong, the Flowery Miao were the Hmao, the Black Miao were theHmu, and the Red Miao were theXong.[19] According to She Miaojun, the Miao only existed as an exonym in the imagination of outsiders all the way up to theQing dynasty. It did not refer to any self-defined ethnic group united by either territory or language. Others believe that Miao identity emerged during therebellions of the 18th and 19th centuries.[12]
Today, the Hmong in China are categorized under the umbrella term Miáo (苗) along with three other indigenous cultural groups, which include non-Hmong peoples such as the Hmu and the Xong of southeastGuizhou. The Chinese Miao minority was created in 1949 as part of the ethnic identification project in which members of the ethnic groups that now comprise the Miao umbrella group campaigned for identification under the nameMiao—taking advantage of its familiarity and associations of historical political oppression. The push to appropriate Miao as the official name of theirminzu nationality received significant contributions from three Miao intellectuals, however none of them were Hmong. The various Miao sub-groups freely identify as Miao or Chinese while reserving their specific ethnonyms for intra-ethnic communication.[23][24] According to Jacques Lemoine, "Chinese Hmong have the Miao nationality but Hmong ethnicity" because thePeople's Republic of China doesn't recognize ethnicity.[25]
The Miao minority group has been described as extremely heterogeneous. The four main groups classified as Miao in China are the Hmong, Hmao, Hmu, and the Xong. Despite speaking related languages belonging to theHmongic language group, these four ethnic groups have little in common and their languages are mutually unintelligible. Even the group closest to the Hmong, the Hmao, speak a language that is as different from Hmong as Italian is to French. They diverged significantly as early as a thousand years ago, after which they may have had no relation to each other at all. Without their official classification as the Miao minority after 1949, it is unlikely that they would be able to recognize any affinity with each other. However none of the four groups have obtained official status as distinct minorities in China. Their names are generally unrecognized by the Chinese and are only used as part of the local vernacular language. As a result, only a small portion of the modern Miao people initially identified as Hmong.[26][19][27]
The cumbersome umbrella term "Miao" refers to a number of disparate groups totaling 7.5 million people as of 1990, speaking three mutually unintelligible dialects and scattered over seven provinces in southwest China... These multiple sub-groups have been variously divided into large aggregates such as the Black, Red, Blue, White, and Flowery groups, or later the Eastern, Central or Western dialect groups. It was only in the Maoist period, with the national implementation of identification policies... that the diverse Miao in China came to recognize each other as co-ethnics and to identify with and operate under the ethnonym "Miao." Only a portion of those identified as Miao—the ones distributed over western Guizhou and parts of Yunnan, particularly the border areas—call themselves "Hmong" in their own language.[27]
— Louisa Schein
The non-equivalence between the Miao and the Hmong was acknowledged in interactions between Hmong refugees and the Miao. The Miao people that Hmong travelers from the West met were highly varied both in their language and cultural practices. When Hmong refugees from France and the US initially made contact with the Miao from China in officially sanctioned visits, they were introduced to the Xong Miao people who were neither Hmong nor spoke the Hmong language. An eyewitness recounts several occasions when a Hmong and a Hmao tried to understand each other's languages without success. They also met an assortment of Miao people who no longer spoke their native language and only knew Chinese. Many of the Miao they met did not share the same traditional clothing, myths, and folktales. Some did not even play thelusheng, a traditional Hmong musical instrument. The visiting Hmong were themselves not from China but Southeast Asia, where their ancestors had migrated over a century ago due to conflicts in theQing dynasty. Not understanding the differences between the Miao and Hmong, initially some Hmong-Americans did not believe that these were real Miao people, but other ethnic groups. Some thought that the different costumes were the result of lost traditions among the Southeast Asian Hmong.[19][27]
Some Hmong went further to seek out "really Hmong" people through unofficial channels with whom they could speak Hmong to. However even after successfully finding them, they found that there were dialect variations that differed from the Hmong that they grew up speaking. As Hmong refugees discovered the differences between themselves and the Chinese Miao, some non-Hmong Miao people such as the Hmu started referring to themselves as Hmong to express nationalistic sentiments. Contributing to this trend is the tendency of professional linguists to use the names of smaller ethnic groups to refer to the broader categories such asHmong–Mien languages rather than Miao-Yao languages. This is due to the outsized influence of groups outside of Asia such as the Hmong and Mien who are able to articulate their cause, thereby affecting some proto-nationalistic movements within the Miao to identify as Hmong despite not actually being Hmong.[19]
Miao or Meo carried strong pejorative connotations in both China and Southeast Asia. It was more so a stereotype such as uncivilized, uncooperative, uncultivated, harmful, and inhumane than a name of an ethnic group and was used in daily conversations as an expression for ugliness and primitiveness. Due to these negative connotations, the Hmong promote the use of Hmong as a replacement for Miao.[12][22] In modern times, however, Miao has lost such negative connotations in China and has since been officially recognized as an ethnicity, which includes the Hmong. The Hmong in China are often happy or proud to be known as Miao while most Hmong outside China find it offensive.[28][29] According to Louisa Schein, Miao is a neutral ethnonym within China and the only term that encompasses all its subgroups.[27]
According to Gary Yia Lee writing in theHmong Studies Journal, the choice to identify as Miao was a deliberate and strategic decision its members advocated for in recognition of its potential benefits. Rather than being split into multiple smaller groups with short and murky histories, the Miao chose to adopt one ethno-name representing 9.2 million people claiming a long history dating back to ancient China. Their larger population granted them the strength and support befitting of the fifth largest nationality in China. In addition, by claiming kinship to the San Miao referred to in ancient Chinese history, they positioned themselves as pre-existing inhabitants of China prior to the arrival of the Han, imparting a "legendary stature to the present-day Miao" that "bestows the dignity of great antiquity, authoritativeness and a firm standing in the documentary record".[30]
Contemporary transnational interactions between Hmong in the West and Miao groups in China, following the 1975 Hmong emigration, led to the development of a global Hmong identity that includes linguistically and culturally related minorities in China with no previous ethnic affiliation. In 1994, a Miao woman from China was chosen as the winner of the Miss Hmong Beauty Pageant inFresno, California. Costume styles were imported from China and used in festivals.[27] Scholarly and commercial exchanges, increasingly made over the internet, have also resulted in an exchange of terminology, including some Hmong people accepting the designationMiao after visiting China and some nationalist non-Hmong Miao peoples identifying as Hmong.[22]
In Southeast Asia, Hmong people are referred to by other names, including:VietnameseMèo,Mông orH'Mông;LaoMaew (ແມ້ວ) orMong (ມົ້ງ);ThaiMaew (แม้ว) orMong (ม้ง); andBurmesemun lu-myo (မုံလူမျိုး). With a slight change in accent, the word "Meo" in Lao and Thai can be pronounced to mean"cat".[31][32] The term Maew and Meo derived from the term Miao.[33]
Likely routes of early rice transfer, and possible language family homelands (archaeological sites in China and SE Asia shown)
A DNA study in 2005 in Thailand found that Hmong paternal lineage is quite different from lu Mien and other Southeast Asian tribes. The Hmong–Mien and Sino-Tibetan speaking people are known as hill tribes in Thailand; they were the subject of the first studies to show an impact of patrilocality vs. matrilocality on patterns of mitochondrial (mt) DNA vs. the male-specific portion of the Y chromosome (MSY) variation.According to linguistMartha Ratliff, there is linguistic evidence to suggest that they have occupied some of the same areas of southern China for over 8,000 years.[34] Evidence frommitochondrial DNA inHmong–Mien–speaking populations supports the existence of southern origins of maternal lineages even further back in time, although it has been shown that Hmong-speaking populations had comparatively more contact with northern East Asians than had the Mien.[35][36][37] A 2020 study, however, states that Hmong in Thailand cluster with other Hmong groups only due to their practice of endogamy.[38]
In 2011, Hmong DNA was sampled and found to contain 7.84%D-M15 and 6%N(Tat) DNA.[39] The research found a common ancestry between Hmong–Mien peoples andMon-Khmer groups dating to theLast Glacial Maximum, approximately 15,000 to 18,000 years ago.
A rare haplogroup, O3d, was found at theDaxi culture in the middle reaches of theYangtze River, indicating that the Daxi people might be the ancestors of modern Hmong–Mien populations, which show only small traces of O3d today.[40] The most representative ancestral lineages of Hmong-Mien speakers come from ancient individuals from Guangxi (GaoHuaHua) and Guizhou (Songshan_o2), dating back to the Ming Dynasty.[41] Other studies also confirm the significant role ofAncient Northern East Asians in shaping the Hmong genome.[42] Overall, Hmong–Mien cluster with Tai-Kadai and Sino-Tibetan speakers compared to other Chinese populations.[43] A 2020 study shows that the core Hmong-Mien population derives more ancestry from Neolithic Mekong (32.3%–35.3%) than Late Neolithic Fujian (23.7%–26.4%), suggesting strongerAustroasiatic affinities although Tai-Kadai ancestry peaks in groups that live in southeastern China.[44]
Genetic stratification exists within the Hmong-Mien population, with northern Hmong-Mien populations exhibiting more genetic similarities with Tibeto-Burman/Sinitic populations and southern Hmong-Mien populations sharing more alleles with Austronesian/Tai-Kadai populations.[45] Hmong-Mien populations within the Miao cluster exhibit stronger genetic influence from neighboring populations like Han Chinese. Other Miao populations are more related to Hmong populations from Vietnam. Yao populations in Guangxi, in contrast, share more genetic drift with Tai-Kadai populations. Bunu-speaking Yao populations exhibit strong genetic affinities with theGaoHuaHua population due to their geographic isolation. She populations from Guizhou cluster with their Hmong-Mien neighbors and received significant input from Tai-Kadai populations whilst She populations from Fujian received more input from Han Chinese populations.[41] In 2021, researchers found that the 'GaoHuaHua' population in Guangxi contributed to the ancestries of modern Hmong-Mien groups in Guangxi. The 'GaoHuaHua' population was modeled as having 66% Dushan-related ancestry and 34% Boshan-related ancestry. They also received Northeast Asian-related Shandong ancestry, which emerged 9,500–7,700 years ago.[36]
The most likelyhomeland of the Hmong–Mien languages is insouthern China between theYangtze andMekong rivers.[46] In particular, southwestern China was suggested to the original homeland of Hmong-Mien peoples.[47]
Migration of people speaking these languages from southern China toSoutheast Asia took place ca. 1600–1700 CE. AncientDNA evidence suggests that the ancestors of the speakers of the Hmong–Mien languages were a population genetically distinct from that of the Tai–Kadai and Austronesian language populations at a location on theYangtze River.[48] Recent Y-DNA phylogeny evidence supports the theory that people who speak the Hmong–Mien languages are descended from a population that is distantly related to those who now speak the Mon-Khmer languages.[49] Another study shows that the core Hmong-Mien population in southern China derived most of their ancestry from Neolithic Mekong (32.3%–35.3%) than Late Neolithic Fujian (23.7%–26.4%).[44]
The time ofProto-Hmong–Mien was estimated to be about 2500 BP (500 BCE) by Sagart, Blench, and Sanchez-Mazas using traditional methods employing many lines of evidence, and about 4243 BP by the Automated Similarity Judgment Program (ASJP), an experimental algorithm for automatic generation of phonologically based phylogenies.[50]
The historical migration of the Hmong according to Hmong tradition
Hmong traditions and legends indicate that they originated near theYellow River region of northernChina, but this is not substantiated by any scientific evidence.[51] According to linguistMartha Ratliff, there is linguistic evidence to suggest that they have occupied some of the same areas of southern China for over 8,000 years.[34]
The author ofGuoyu, written in the 4th to 5th century, considered Chi You's Jiu Li tribe to be related to the ancient ancestors of the Hmong, the San-Miao people.[52]Chi You is the Hmong ancestral God of War. Today, a statue of Chi You has been erected in the town namedZhuolu.[53]
A scene depicting theQing dynasty's campaign against the Hmong people at Lancaoping in 1795
Conflict between the Hmong of southern China and newly arrived Han settlers increased during the 18th century under repressive economic and cultural reforms imposed by theQing dynasty. This led toarmed conflict and large-scale migrations well into the late 19th century, the period during which many Hmong people emigrated to Southeast Asia. However, the migration process had begun as early as the late 17th century, before the time of major social unrest, when small groups went in search of better agricultural opportunities.[54]
The Hmong people were subjected to persecution and genocide by theQing dynasty government. Arthur A. Hansen wrote: "In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, while the Hmong lived in south-western China, theirManchu overlords had labeled them 'Miao' and targeted them forgenocide."[55][better source needed]
Since 1949, theMiao people (Chinese:苗族;pinyin:miáo zú) has been an official term for one of the56 official minority groups recognized by the government of thePeople's Republic of China. The Miao live mainly in southern China, in the provinces ofGuizhou,Hunan,Yunnan,Sichuan,Guangxi,Hainan,Guangdong, andHubei. According to the 2000 census, the number of 'Miao' in China was estimated to be about 9.6 million. The Miao nationality includes Hmong people as well as other culturally and linguistically related ethnic groups who do not call themselves Hmong. These include theHmu, Kho (Qho) Xiong, andA-Hmao. The settling region of the Hmong in China is further western than that of the other groups, mainly in Guizhou, Yunnan, Sichuan, Chongqing, and Guangxi.
Xijiang, a Hmong-majority township in Guizhou, China
The Hmong or Miao began to migrate to Tonkin (Northern Vietnam) in the 19th century, where they struggled to establish their community on the high mountains. They recognized the Tai-speaking overlords of valleys, who were vassals of the Vietnamese court in Hue. The Hue court ofTu Duc at the time was facing crisis after crisis, unable to retake control of Tonkin and the border regions. TheTaiping rebellion and other Chinese rebels spilled over into Vietnam and had caused anarchy; the Hmong communities thrived on either sides of the Red River, harmonizing with other ethnic groups, and were largely ignored by all factions.[56]
After decades of distant relations with the Lao kingdoms, closer relations between the French military and some Hmong on the Xieng Khouang plateau arose afterWorld War II. There, a rivalry between members of the Lo and Ly clans developed into open enmity, also affecting those connected with them by kinship. Clan leaders took opposite sides; as a consequence, several thousand Hmong participated in the fighting against thePathet Lao Communists, while almost as many were enrolled in the communistLao People's Revolutionary Army. In Laos, numerous Hmong genuinely tried to avoid getting involved in the conflict in spite of the extremely difficult material conditions under which they lived during wartime.[58]
While there were Hmong soldiers who fought with the communist Pathet Lao and the North Vietnamese, others were recognized for serving in combat against the NVA and thePathet Lao, helping block Hanoi'sHo Chi Minh trail inside Laos and rescuing downed American pilots. Though their role was generally kept secret in the early stages of the conflict, they made great sacrifices to help the U.S.[61]
Thousands ofeconomic andpolitical refugees have resettled inWestern countries in two separate waves. The first wave resettled in the late 1970s, mostly in theUnited States after theNorth Vietnamese andPathet Lao takeovers of the pro-U.S. governmentsin South Vietnam andLaos respectively.[62] TheLao Veterans of America, and Lao Veterans of America Institute, helped to assist in the resettlement of many Laotian and Hmong refugees and asylum seekers in the United States, especially former Hmong veterans and their family members who served in the "U.S. Secret Army" in Laos during the Vietnam War.[63][failed verification]
Hmong girls meet possible suitors while playing a ball-throwing game inLaos.
For many years, the Neo Hom political movement played a key role in resistance to theVietnam People's Army in Laos following the U.S. withdrawal in 1975;Vang Pao played a significant role in this movement. Additionally, a spiritual leader,Zong Zoua Her, as well as other Hmong leaders, includingPa Kao Her or Pa Khao Her, rallied some of their followers in a factionalized guerrilla resistance movement calledChaoFa (RPA: Cob Fab,Pahawh Hmong:𖬒𖬯 𖬖𖬜𖬵).[64][65] These events led to theyellow rain controversy when theUnited States accused theSoviet Union of supplying and using chemical weapons in this conflict.[66]
Small groups of Hmong people, many second or third generation descendants of former CIA soldiers, remain internally displaced in remote parts of Laos, in fear of government reprisals. Faced with continuing military operations against them by the government and a scarcity of food, some groups have begun coming out of hiding, while others have sought asylum in Thailand and other countries.[67] Hmong in Laos, in particular, developed a stronger and deeperanti-Vietnamese sentiment than their Vietnamese Hmong cousins, due to historic persecution perpetrated by the Vietnamese against them.
A Hmong family in either Chiang Mai or Lamphun, circa 1954
In June 1991, after talks with theUNHCR and the Thai government, Laos agreed to the repatriation of over 60,000 Lao refugees living in Thailand, including tens of thousands of Hmong people. Very few of the Lao refugees, however, were willing to return voluntarily.[68] Pressure to resettle the refugees grew as the Thai government worked to close its remaining refugee camps. While some Hmong people returned to Laos voluntarily, with development assistance from UNHCR, coercive measures and forced repatriation was used to send thousands of Hmong back to the places they had fled.[69][70] Of the Hmong who did return to Laos, some quickly escaped back to Thailand, describing discrimination and brutal treatment at the hands of Lao authorities.[71]
In the 1980s, 1990s, and early 2000s,The Center for Public Policy Analysis, a non-governmental public policy research organization, and its executive director, Philip Smith, played a key role in raising awareness in the U.S. Congress and policy-making circles in Washington, D.C. about the plight of the Hmong and Laotian refugees in Thailand and Laos. The CPPA, backed by a bipartisan coalition of members of theU.S. Congress and human rights organizations, conducted numerous research missions to the Hmong and Laotian refugee camps along theMekong River in Thailand, as well as the Buddhist temple ofWat Tham Krabok.[72]
Although some accusations of forced repatriation were denied,[73] thousands of Hmong people refused to return to Laos. In 1996, as the deadline for the closure of Thai refugee camps approached, under mounting political pressure, the U.S. agreed to resettle Hmong refugees who passed a new screening process.[74] Around 5,000 Hmong people who were not resettled at the time of the camp closures sought asylum atWat Tham Krabok, aBuddhist monastery in central Thailand where more than 10,000 Hmong refugees were already living. The Thai government attempted to repatriate these refugees, but the Wat Tham Krabok Hmong refused to leave and the Lao government refused to accept them, claiming they were involved in theillegal drug trade and were of non-Lao origin.[75]
In 2003, following threats of forcible removal by the Thai government, the U.S., in a significant victory for the Hmong, agreed to accept 15,000 of the refugees.[76] Several thousand Hmong people, fearing forced repatriation to Laos if they were not accepted for resettlement in the U.S., fled the camp to live elsewhere within Thailand where a sizable Hmong population has been present since the 19th century.[77] In 2004 and 2005, thousands of Hmong fled from the jungles of Laos to a temporary refugee camp in the Thai province ofPhetchabun.[78]
On 4 June 2007, as part of an investigation labeledOperation Tarnished Eagle, U.S. federal courts ordered warrants issued for the arrest ofVang Pao and nine others for plotting to overthrow the government of Laos in violation of federalNeutrality Acts and for multiple weapons charges.[83] The federal charges alleged that members of the group inspected weapons, includingAK-47s,smoke grenades, andStinger missiles, in order to buy and smuggle into Thailand in June 2007, where they were intended to be used by Hmong resistance forces in Laos. Out of the 9 arrested, one was an American, Harrison Jack, a 1968West Point graduate and retired Army infantry officer who allegedly attempted to recruitSpecial Operations veterans to act asmercenaries.
To obtain the weapons, Jack allegedly met unknowingly with undercover U.S. federal agents posing as weapons dealers, prompting the warrants, part of a long-running investigation into the activities of the U.S.-based Hmong leadership and its supporters.
On 15 June, the defendants were indicted by agrand jury; awarrant was also issued for the arrest of an 11th man allegedly involved in the plot. Simultaneous raids of the defendants' homes and work locations, involving over 200 federal, state and local law enforcement officials, were conducted in approximately 15 U.S. cities inCentral andSouthern California.
Multiple protest rallies in support of the suspects, designed to raise awareness of the treatment of Hmong peoples in the jungles of Laos, took place inCalifornia,Minnesota,Wisconsin, andAlaska. Several ofVang Pao's high-level supporters in the U.S. criticized the California court that issued the arrest warrants, arguing that Vang was a historically important American ally and a valued leader of U.S. and foreign-based Hmong. Calls to CalifornianRepublican governorArnold Schwarzenegger and PresidentGeorge W. Bush to pardon the defendants went unanswered pending a conclusion to the large, ongoing federal investigation.[84]
On 18 September 2009, the U.S. federal government dropped all charges against Vang Pao, announcing that the federal government was permitted to consider "the probable sentence or other consequences if the person is convicted".[85] On 10 January 2011, after Vang Pao's death, the federal government dropped all charges against the remaining defendants saying, "Based on the totality of the circumstances in the case, the government believes, as a discretionary matter, that continued prosecution of defendants is no longer warranted."[86]
The presence of Hmong settlements in Thailand is documented from the end of the 19th century on. Initially, theSiamese paid little attention to them. But in the early 1950s, the state suddenly took a number of initiatives aimed at establishing links. Decolonization and nationalism were gaining momentum in the peninsula and wars of independence were raging. Armed opposition to the state in northern Thailand, triggered by outside influence, started in 1967 while again many Hmong refused to take sides in the conflict. Communistguerrilla warfare stopped by 1982 as a result of an international concurrence of events that rendered it pointless. Priority has since been given by the Thai state to sedentarizing the mountain population, introducing commercially viable agricultural techniques and national education, with the aim of integrating these non-Tai animists within the national identity.[87][88]
Many Hmong refugees resettled in the United States after theVietnam War. Beginning in December 1975, the first Hmong refugees arrived in the U.S., mainly from refugee camps in Thailand; however, only 3,466 were granted asylum at that time under theIndochina Migration and Refugee Assistance Act of 1975. In May 1976, another 11,000 were allowed to enter the United States, and by 1978 some 30,000 Hmong people had emigrated. This first wave was made up predominantly of men directly associated with GeneralVang Pao's secret army. It was not until the passage of theRefugee Act of 1980 that families were able to enter the U.S., becoming the second wave of Hmong immigrants. Hmong families were scattered across all 50 states but most found their way to each other, building large communities in California, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Washington State and Oregon. Smaller, but still sizeable communities also formed in Massachusetts (Lowell), Michigan (Detroit), Montana (Missoula) and Alaska (Anchorage).
Hmong people have their own terms for their cultural divisions.Hmong Der (Hmoob Dawb), andHmong Leng (Hmoob Leeg) are the terms for two of the largest groups in theUnited States and Southeast Asia. These subgroups are also known as the White Hmong, and Blue or Green Hmong, respectively. These names originate from the color and designs of women's dresses in each respective group, with the White Hmong distinguished by the white dresses women wear on special occasions, and the Blue/Green Hmong by the bluebatiked dresses.[89] The name and pronunciation "Hmong" is exclusively used by the White Hmong to refer to themselves, and many dictionaries use only the White Hmong dialect.[90]
In theRomanized Popular Alphabet, developed in the 1950s in Laos, these terms are writtenHmoob Dawb (White Hmong) andHmoob Leeg (Green Hmong). The final consonants indicate with which of the eightlexical tones the word is pronounced.[91]
White Hmong and Green Hmong speak mutually intelligible dialects of theHmong language, with some differences in pronunciation and vocabulary. One of the most characteristic differences is the use of thevoiceless /m̥/ in White Hmong, indicated by a preceding "H" in the Romanized Popular Alphabet. Voiceless nasals are not found in the Green Hmong dialect. Hmong groups are often named after the dominant colors or patterns of their traditional clothing, style ofhead-dress, or the provinces from which they come.[91]
The Hmong groups in Vietnam and Laos, from the 18th century to the present day, are known as Black Hmong (Hmoob Dub), Striped Hmong (Hmoob Txaij), White Hmong (Hmoob Dawb), Hmong Leng (Hmoob Leeg) and Green Hmong (Hmoob Ntsuab). In other places in Asia, groups are also known as Black Hmong (Hmoob Dub orHmong Dou), Striped Hmong (Hmoob Txaij orHmoob Quas Npab), Hmong Shi, Hmong Pe, Hmong Pua, and Hmong Xau, Hmong Xanh (Green Hmong), Hmong Do (Red Hmong), Na Mieo and various other subgroups.[91] These include the Flower Hmong or the Variegated Hmong (Hmong Lenh orHmong Hoa), so named because of their bright, colorful embroidery work (calledpa ndau orpaj ntaub, literally'flower cloth').[92]
When Western authors first came in contact with Hmong people in the 18th century, they referred to them by writingethnonyms which were previously assigned to them by the Chinese (i.e.,Miao, or variants).[citation needed] This practice continued into the 20th century.[93] Evenethnographers studying the Hmong people in Southeast Asia often referred to them asMeo, an alteration ofMiao applied by Thai and Lao people to the Hmong. AlthoughMeo was an official term, it was often used as an insult against the Hmong people, and it is considered to be derogatory.[94][95]
The issue came to a head during the passage ofCalifornia State Assembly Bill (AB) 78, in the 2003–2004 season.[96][better source needed] Introduced by Doua Vu and Assembly MemberSarah Reyes, District 31 (Fresno), the bill encouraged changes in secondary education curriculum to include information about theSecret War and the role of Hmong people in the war. Furthermore, the bill called for the use of oral histories and first-hand accounts by Hmong people who had participated in the war and were caught up in its aftermath. Originally, the language of the bill mentioned only "Hmong" people, intending to include the entire community. Several Mong Leng activists, led by Dr.Paoze Thao (Professor of Linguistics and Education atCalifornia State University, Monterey Bay), drew attention to the problems associated with omittingMong from the language of the bill. They noted that despite nearly equal numbers of Hmong Der and Mong Leng in the United States, resources are disproportionately allocated to the Hmong Der community. This not only includes scholarly research, but also the translation of materials, including the curriculum proposed by the bill.[97] Despite these arguments,Mong was not added to the bill. In the version of the bill that was passed by the assembly,Hmong was replaced bySoutheast Asians, a broader and more inclusive term.
Dr. Paoze Thao and some others strongly feel thatHmong can only be used in reference to Hmong Der people because it does not include "Mong" Leng people. He feels that the use ofHmong in reference to both groups perpetuates the marginalization of the Mong Leng language and culture. Thus, he advocates the use ofHmong andMong in reference to the entire ethnic group.[98] Other scholars, including anthropologist Dr.Gary Yia Lee (a Hmong Der person), suggests that for the past 30 years,[as of?]Hmong has been used in reference to the entire community and as a result, the inclusion of Mong Leng people is understandable.[99][better source needed] Some argue that such distinctions create unnecessary divisions within the global community, arguing that the use of these distinctions will only confuse non-Hmong and Mong people who are both trying to learn more about Hmong and Mong history and culture.[100]
As a compromise alternative, multiple iterations ofHmong have been proposed. A Hmong theologian, Rev. Dr. Paul Joseph T. Khamdy Yang has proposed the use of the termHMong in reference to theHmong and theMong communities by capitalizing theH and theM. The ethnologist Jacques Lemoine has also begun to use the term (H)mong in reference to the entirety of the Hmong and Mong communities.[1]
Linguistic data shows that the Hmong of the peninsula stem from the Miao of southern China as one among a set of ethnic groups belonging to theHmong–Mien language family.[101] Linguistically and culturally speaking, the Hmong and the other sub-groups of the Miao have little in common.[102]
Vietnam, where their presence is attested from the late 18th century onwards and characterized with both assimilation, cooperation and hostility, is likely to be the firstSoutheastern Eurasian country into which the Hmong migrated.[103] At the 2019 national census, there were 1,393,547 Hmong living in Vietnam, the vast majority of them in the north of the country. The traditional trade incoffin wood with China and cultivation of theopium poppy—not prohibited in Vietnam until 1993—long guaranteed a regular cash income. Today,cash cropping is the main economic activity. As in China and Laos, Hmong participate to a certain degree in local and regional administration.[104] In the late 1990s, several thousands of Hmong started moving to theCentral Highlands and some crossed the border intoCambodia, constituting the first attested presence of Hmong settlers in that country.[citation needed]
In 2015, the Hmong in Laos numbered 595,028.[105] Hmong settlement there is nearly as ancient as in Vietnam.
After the 1975 Communist victory, thousands of Hmong fromLaos had to seek refuge abroad (see Laos below). Approximately 30 percent of the Hmong have left, although the only concrete figure we have is that of 116,000 Hmong from Laos and Vietnam together seeking refuge in Thailand up to 1990.[106]
In 2002 the Hmong in Thailand numbered 151,080.
Myanmar most likely includes a modest number of Hmong (perhaps around 2,500) but no reliable census has been conducted there recently.[107]
As result ofrefugee movements in the wake of the Indochina Wars (1946–1975), in particular, in Laos, the largest Hmong community to settle outside Asia went to the United States where approximately 100,000 individuals had already arrived by 1990. By the same date, 10,000 Hmong had migrated to France, including 1,400 inFrench Guiana;Canada admitted 900 individuals, while another 360 went toAustralia, 260 toChina, and 250 toArgentina. Over the following years and until the definitive closure of the last refugee camps in Thailand in 1998, additional numbers of Hmong have left Asia, but the definitive figures are still to be produced.[108]
Hmong girl (aged 15) preparing wedding dress, Phố Cáo commune, Hà Giang province, Vietnam
Approximately 5% of the Hmong population currently lives outside of Asia, with the United States home to the largest Hmong diaspora community. The 2008 census counted 171,316 people solely of Hmong ancestry, and 221,948 persons of at least partial Hmong ancestry.[109] Other countries with significant populations include:[110]
Hmong people inVietnam have been perceived differently by various modern political organizations and in different historical periods. Since the Hmong are an ethnic minority in Vietnam, their loyalty toward the Vietnamese state has been frequently questioned by the state. However, many Hmong in Vietnam are fiercely loyal, regardless of the current ideologies of the government;[112] the Hmong inLaos andCambodia are the most supportive of active resistance. These tend to be Hmong Christians that have been targeted by all three Vietnamese governments.[113] The Hmong in Vietnam also receive cultural and political incentives from the government.[114] which led to the Vietnamese Hmong further diverging from the Laotian Hmong, since the latter are strongly anti-Vietnamese due to the Secret War and Communism.
The Hmong presence in Thailand dates back to the turn of the 20th century when families migrated from China through Laos and Burma, according to most authors. A relatively small population, they still formed dozens of villages and hamlets throughout the northern provinces. The Hmong were registered by the state as the Meo hill tribe. Then, more Hmong migrated from Laos to Thailand following the victory of thePathet Lao in 1975. While some ended up in refugee camps, others settled in mountainous areas among more ancientHill Tribes.[115]
Many Hmong refugees resettled in the United States after theVietnam War. Beginning in December 1975, the first Hmong refugees arrived in the U.S., mainly from refugee camps in Thailand; however, only 3,466 were granted asylum under theIndochina Migration and Refugee Assistance Act of 1975. In May 1976, another 11,000 were allowed to enter the United States, and by 1978 some 30,000 Hmong people had emigrated. This first wave was made up predominantly of men directly associated with General Vang Pao's secret army. It was not until the passage of theRefugee Act of 1980 that families were able to enter the U.S., becoming the second wave of Hmong immigrants. Hmong families scattered across all 50 states but most found their way to each other, building large communities in California, Minnesota and Wisconsin. As of the 2010 census, 260,073 Hmong people reside in the United States,[116] the plurality of whom live in California (91,224), then Minnesota (66,181), and Wisconsin (49,240), an increase from 186,310 in 2000.[117] 247,595 or 95.2% are Hmong alone, and the remaining 12,478 are mixed Hmong with some other ethnicity. The vast majority of part-Hmong are under 10 years old.
Sunisa "Suni" Lee ofSaint Paul, Minnesota is a notable Hmong-American; she is a three time Olympic medalist in artistic gymnastics. In the2020 Summer Olympics, Lee won silver in the women's artistic team all-around, followed by gold in the women's artistic individual all-around and bronze in the women's uneven bars. With these results, Sunisa made history as both the first Hmong-American to compete in the Olympics in any sport and the first Hmong-American to win an Olympic medal.[119]
Canada's small Hmong population is mostly concentrated within the province ofOntario.Kitchener, Ontario has 515 residents of Hmong descent, and has a Hmong church.[120][121]
There is also a small community of several thousand Hmong who migrated toFrench Guiana in the late 1970s and early 1980s,[122] that can be mainly found in the Hmong villages ofJavouhey (1200 individuals) andCacao (950 individuals).
The Hmong immigrant population ofDetroit is a central focus of the 2008 filmGran Torino, though that city does not have a significant Hmong population.
A significant example was the deportation of Zoua Yang and her 27 children from Thailand on 19 December 2005, after the group was arrested attending a church in Ban Kho Noi,Phetchabun Province,Thailand. Ms. Yang and her children were detained upon their return to Laos, after which the whereabouts of much of the family is unknown.[124]
In 2011,Vietnam People's Army troops were used to crush a peaceful demonstration by Hmong Catholic, Protestant andEvangelical Christians who gathered inDien Bien Province and theDien Bien Phu area of northwestern Vietnam, according to Philip Smith ofthe Center for Public Policy Analysis, independent journalists and others.[125] In 2013,Vam Ngaij Vaj, a Christian pastor of Hmong ancestry, was beaten to death by Vietnamese police and security forces.[126] InHanoi, Vietnamese government officials refused to allow medical treatment for a Hmong Christian leader, Duong Van Minh, who was suffering from a seriouskidney illness, in February 2014.[127]
TheU.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom has documented official and ongoing religious persecution, religious-freedom violations against the Laotian and Hmong people in both Laos and Vietnam by the governments. In April 2011,the Center for Public Policy Analysis also researched and documented cases of Hmong Christians being attacked and summarily executed, including four Lao Hmong Christians.[128]
^abcdefTapp, Nicholas (2002).Cultural Accommodations in Southwest China: The "Han Miao" and Problems in the Ethnography of the Hmong. Nanzan University. pp. 77–104.
^Cheung Siu-Woo "Miao Identity in Western Guizhou: Indigenism and the politics of appropriation in the southwest china during the republican period" in Hmong or Miao in Asia. 237–40.
^Lee, Mai Na M. (2015).Dreams of the Hmong Kingdom: The Quest for Legitimation in French Indochina, 1850–1960. University of Wisconsin Press. pp. 78–79.ISBN978-0-299-29884-5.
^Michaud, J. (1 April 2000). "The Montagnards and the State in Northern Vietnam from 1802 to 1975: A Historical Overview".Ethnohistory.47 (2):333–68.doi:10.1215/00141801-47-2-333.ProQuest209752840.
^Michaud, J. et al. 2016 The Historical Dictionary of the Peoples of the Southeast Asian Massif. Rowman & Littlefield, pp. 177–80.
^Grant Evans "Laos is getting a bad rap from the world's media" The Bangkok Post 8 July 2003
^Smalley, William Allen, Chia Koua Vang (Txiaj Kuam Vaj), and Gnia Yee Yang (Nyiaj Yig Yaj).Mother of Writing: The Origin and Development of a Hmong Messianic Script.University of Chicago Press, 23 March 1990. 10. Retrieved fromGoogle Books on 23 March 2012ISBN978-0-226-76286-9.
^Not to be confused with the Thai royal titleChao Fa.
^Graham, David Crockett (1954).Songs and Stories of the Ch'uan Miao. Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections. Vol. 123, 1. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution.
^Duffy, John, Roger Harmon, Donald A. Ranard, Bo Thao, andKou Yang. "PeopleArchived 2012-09-16 at theWayback Machine". In The Hmong: An Introduction to their history and culture. The Center for Applied Linguistics, Culture Profile No. 18 (June 2004): 3.
^Ratliff and Niederer, in Tapp, Michaud, Culas and Lee, Hmong/Miao in Asia, Silkworm Press, 2004
^Tapp, N. 2001, Hmong in China. Brill[page needed]
^Culas and Michaud, 2004, in Tapp, Michaud, Culas and Lee, Hmong/Miao in Asia. SIlkworm.
^Baird, Ian G. (2013).The monks and the Hmong: The special relationship between the Chao Fa and the Tham Krabok Buddhist Temple in Saraburi Province, Thailand. In Vladimir Tikhonov and Torkel Brekke (eds.), Violent Buddhism – Buddhism and Militarism in Asia in the Twentieth Century. London: Routledge. pp. 120–151.
^"Laos, Vietnam Troops Execute 4 Hmong Christians" (Press release). Center for Public Policy Analysis. 16 April 2011 – via Scoop News.Laotian and Hmong minority Christian and Animist believers continue to be hunted, brutally tortured, and killed by the Lao military in significant numbers in key provinces in Laos.
Forbes, Andrew, and Henley, David, 'Chiang Mai's Hill Peoples' in:Ancient Chiang Mai Volume 3. Chiang Mai: Cognoscenti Books, 2012.ASINB006IN1RNW.
Hillmer, Paul.A People's History of the Hmong (Minnesota Historical Society Press, 2010). 327 pages.ISBN978-0-87351-726-3.
[TYPN 1992] The section on nomenclature draws heavily onThai-Yunnan Project Newsletter, Number 17, June 1992, Department of Anthropology,Australian National University. Material from that newsletter may be freely reproduced with due acknowledgment.
W.R. Geddes.Migrants of the Mountains: The Cultural Ecology of the Blue Miao (Hmong Njua) of Thailand. Oxford, England:The Clarendon Press, 1976.
Tapp, Nicholas (2003),The Hmong of China: Context, Agency, and the Imaginary, Brill Academic Publishers, Inc.
Tapp, N., J.Michaud, C.Culasc, G.Y.Lee (Eds.) (2004).Hmong/Miao in Asia. Chiang Mai (Thailand): Silkworm. 500 pages.
Chia Youyee Vang.Hmong America: Reconstructing Community in Diaspora (University of Illinois Press; 2011) 200 pages; Combines scholarly and personal perspectives in an ethnographic history of the Hmong refugee experience in the United States.
Hamilton-Merritt, Jane (1999).Tragic Mountains: The Hmong, the Americans, and the Secret Wars for Laos, 1942–1992. Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press.
Johnson, Charles.Dab Neeg Hmoob: Myths, Legends and Folk Tales from the Hmong of Laos.St. Paul, Minnesota:Macalester College, 1983. – bilingual oral literature anthology, includes introduction and explanatory notes from a language professor who had sponsored the first Hmong family to arrive in Minnesota
Keaw, A. H.Man: Past and Present. Cambridge: 1900.
Mottin, Father Jean.History of the Hmong.Bangkok: Odeon Store, 1980. Written in Khek Noi, a Hmong village in northern Thailand, and translated into English by an Irish nun.
Savina, F. M.Histoire des Miao. 2nd edition.Hong Kong: Impremerie de la Société des Missions-Etrangères de Paris, 1930. Written by a French missionary who worked inLaos andTonkin.