This article is about the Sun's astrosphere. For astrospheres of other stars, seeStellar-wind bubble.
Top: Diagram of the heliosphere as it travels through theinterstellar medium:
Heliosheath: the outer region of the heliosphere; the solar wind is compressed and turbulent
Heliopause: the boundary between the solar wind and interstellar wind where they are in equilibrium.
Middle: water running into a sink as an analogy for the heliosphere and its different zones (left) andVoyager spacecraft measuring a drop of the solar wind's high-energy particles at thetermination shock (right)
Bottom: Logarithmic scale of the Solar System andVoyager 1's position.
Flowing unimpeded through the Solar System for billions of kilometers, the solar wind extends far beyond even theregion of Pluto until it encounters the "termination shock", where its motion slows abruptly due to the outsidepressure of the interstellar medium. The "heliosheath" is a broad transitional region between the termination shock and the heliosphere's outmost edge, the "heliopause". The overall shape of the heliosphere resembles that of acomet, being roughly spherical on one side to around 100astronomical units (AU), and on the other side being tail shaped, known as the "heliotail", trailing for several thousands of AUs.
TwoVoyager program spacecraft explored the outer reaches of the heliosphere, passing through the termination shock and the heliosheath.Voyager 1 encountered the heliopause on 25 August 2012, when the spacecraft measured a sudden forty-fold increase in plasmadensity.[3]Voyager 2 traversed the heliopause on 5 November 2018.[4] Because the heliopausemarks the boundary between matter originating from the Sun and matter originating from the rest of the galaxy, spacecraft that depart the heliosphere (such as the two Voyagers) are ininterstellar space.
The heliosphere is thought to change significantly over the course of millions of years due to extrasolar effects such as closersupernovas or the traversinginterstellar medium of different densities. Evidence suggests that up to three million years ago Earth was exposed to the interstellar medium due to it shrinking the heliosphere to theInner Solar System, which possibly had impacted Earth's past climate and human evolution.[5]
The Sun photographed at a wavelength of 19.3 nanometers (ultraviolet)
Despite its name, the heliosphere's shape is not a perfect sphere.[6] Its shape is determined by three factors: the interstellar medium (ISM), the solar wind, and the overall motion of the Sun and heliosphere as it passes through the ISM. Because the solar wind and the ISM are both fluid, the heliosphere's shape and size are also fluid. Changes in the solar wind, however, more strongly alter the fluctuating position of the boundaries on short timescales (hours to a few years). The solar wind's pressure varies far more rapidly than the outside pressure of the ISM at any given location. In particular, the effect of the 11-yearsolar cycle, which sees a distinct maximum and minimum of solar wind activity, is thought to be significant.
On a broader scale, the motion of the heliosphere through the fluid medium of the ISM results in an overall comet-like shape. The solar wind plasma which is moving roughly "upstream" (in the same direction as the Sun's motion through the galaxy) is compressed into a nearly-spherical form, whereas the plasma moving "downstream" (opposite the Sun's motion) flows out for a much greater distance before giving way to the ISM, defining the long, trailing shape of the heliotail.
The limited data available and the unexplored nature of these structures have resulted in many theories as to their form.[7] In 2020,Merav Opher led the team of researchers who determined that the shape of the heliosphere is a crescent[8] that can be described as a deflated croissant.[9][10]
The solar wind consists of particles (ionized atoms from thesolar corona) and fields like themagnetic field that are produced from the Sun and stream out into space. Because the Sunrotates once approximately every 25 days, theheliospheric magnetic field[11] transported by thesolar wind gets wrapped into a spiral. The solar wind affects many other systems in the Solar System; for example, variations in the Sun's own magnetic field are carried outward by the solar wind, producinggeomagnetic storms in the Earth'smagnetosphere.
The heliospheric current sheet out to the orbit of Jupiter
Theheliospheric current sheet is a ripple in the heliosphere created by the rotating magnetic field of the Sun. It marks the boundary betweenheliospheric magnetic field regions of opposite polarity. Extending throughout the heliosphere, the heliospheric current sheet could be considered the largest structure in the Solar System and is said to resemble a "ballerina's skirt".[12]
The outer structure of the heliosphere is determined by the interactions between the solar wind and the winds of interstellar space. The solar wind streams away from the Sun in all directions at speeds of several hundred km/s in the Earth's vicinity. At some distance from the Sun, well beyond the orbit ofNeptune, this supersonic wind slows down as it encounters the gases in theinterstellar medium. This takes place in several stages:
The solar wind is traveling atsupersonic speeds within the Solar System. At the termination shock, a standingshock wave, the solar wind falls below the speed of sound and becomessubsonic.
It was previously thought that once subsonic, the solar wind would be shaped by the ambient flow of the interstellar medium, forming a blunt nose on one side and comet-like heliotail behind, a region called the heliosheath. However, observations in 2009 showed that this model is incorrect.[13][14] As of 2011, it is thought to be filled with a magnetic bubble "foam".[15]
The outer surface of the heliosheath, where the heliosphere meets the interstellar medium, is called heliopause. This is the edge of the entire heliosphere. Observations in 2009 led to changes to this model.[13][14]
In theory, heliopause causes turbulence in the interstellar medium as the Sun orbits theGalactic Center. This turbulence results from the pressure of the advancing heliopause against theinterstellar medium. However, the velocity of the solar wind relative to the interstellar medium may be too low for a bow shock.[16]
The shock arises because solar wind particles are emitted from the Sun at about 400 km/s, while the speed of sound (in the interstellar medium) is about 100 km/s. The exact speed depends on the density, which fluctuates considerably. The interstellar medium, although very low in density, nonetheless has a relatively constant pressure associated with it; the pressure from the solar wind decreases with the square of the distance from the Sun. As one moves far enough away from the Sun, the pressure of the solar wind drops to where it can no longer maintain supersonic flow against the pressure of the interstellar medium, at which point the solar wind slows to below its speed of sound, causing ashock wave. Further from the Sun, the termination shock is followed by heliopause, where the two pressures become equal and solar wind particles are stopped by the interstellar medium.
Other termination shocks can be seen in terrestrial systems; perhaps the easiest may be seen by simply running a watertap into asink creating ahydraulic jump. Upon hitting the floor of the sink, the flowing water spreads out at a speed that is higher than the localwave speed, forming a disk of shallow, rapidly diverging flow (analogous to the tenuous, supersonic solar wind). Around the periphery of the disk, a shock front or wall of water forms; outside the shock front, the water moves slower than the local wave speed (analogous to the subsonic interstellar medium).
Evidence presented at a meeting of theAmerican Geophysical Union in May 2005 byEd Stone suggests that theVoyager 1 spacecraft passed the termination shock in December 2004, when it was about 94 AU from the Sun, by virtue of the change in magnetic readings taken from the craft. In contrast,Voyager 2 began detecting returning particles when it was only 76 AU from the Sun, in May 2006. This implies that the heliosphere may be irregularly shaped, bulging outwards in the Sun's northern hemisphere and pushed inward in the south.[20]
Illustration of the heliosphere as released on 28 June 2013 which incorporates results from the Voyager spacecraft.[21] The heliosheath is between the termination shock and the heliopause.
The heliosheath is the region of the heliosphere beyond the termination shock. Here the wind is slowed, compressed, and made turbulent by its interaction with the interstellar medium. At its closest point, the inner edge of the heliosheath lies approximately 80 to 100AU from the Sun. A proposed model hypothesizes that the heliosheath is shaped like thecoma of a comet, and trails several times that distance in the direction opposite to the Sun's path through space. At itswindward side, its thickness is estimated to be between 10 and 100 AU.[22] Voyager project scientists have determined that the heliosheath is not "smooth" – it is rather a "foamy zone" filled with magnetic bubbles, each about 1 AU wide.[15] These magnetic bubbles are created by the impact of the solar wind and the interstellar medium.[23][24]Voyager 1 andVoyager 2 began detecting evidence of the bubbles in 2007 and 2008, respectively. The probably sausage-shaped bubbles are formed bymagnetic reconnection between oppositely oriented sectors of thesolar magnetic field as the solar wind slows down. They probably represent self-contained structures that have detached from theinterplanetary magnetic field.
At a distance of about 113 AU,Voyager 1 detected a 'stagnation region' within the heliosheath.[25] In this region, the solar wind slowed to zero,[26][27][28][29] the magnetic field intensity doubled and high-energy electrons from the galaxy increased 100-fold. At about 122 AU, the spacecraft entered a new region that Voyager project scientists called the "magnetic highway", an area still under the influence of the Sun but with some dramatic differences.[30]
The heliopause is the theoretical boundary where theSun'ssolar wind is stopped by theinterstellar medium; where the solar wind's strength is no longer great enough to push back thestellar winds of the surrounding stars. This is the boundary where the interstellar medium and solar wind pressures balance. The crossing of the heliopause should be signaled by a sharp drop in the temperature of solar wind-charged particles,[27] a change in the direction of the magnetic field, and an increase in the number ofgalactic cosmic rays.[31]
In May 2012,Voyager 1 detected a rapid increase in such cosmic rays (a 9% increase in a month, following a more gradual increase of 25% from January 2009 to January 2012), suggesting it was approaching the heliopause.[31] Between late August and early September 2012,Voyager 1 witnessed a sharp drop in protons from the Sun, from 25 particles per second in late August, to about 2 particles per second by early October.[32] In September 2013, NASA announced thatVoyager 1 had crossed the heliopause as of 25 August 2012.[33] This was at a distance of 121 AU (1.81×1010 km) from the Sun.[34] Contrary to predictions, data fromVoyager 1 indicates the magnetic field of the galaxy is aligned with the solar magnetic field.[35]
On November 5, 2018, theVoyager 2 mission detected a sudden decrease in the flux of low-energy ions. At the same time, the level of cosmic rays increased. This demonstrated that the spacecraft crossed the heliopause at a distance of 119 AU (1.78×1010 km) from the Sun. UnlikeVoyager 1, theVoyager 2 spacecraft did not detect interstellarflux tubes while crossing the heliosheath.[36]
NASA also collected data from the heliopause remotely during thesuborbitalSHIELDS mission in 2021.[37]
The heliotail is the several thousandastronomical units long tail of the heliosphere,[5] and thus the Solar System's tail. It can be compared to the tail of a comet (however, a comet's tail does not stretch behind it as it moves; it is always pointing away from the Sun). The tail is a region where the Sun's solar wind slows down and ultimately escapes the heliosphere, slowly evaporating because of charge exchange.[38]The shape of the heliotail (as found by NASA'sInterstellar Boundary Explorer – IBEX) is that of a four-leaf clover.[39] The particles in the tail do not shine, therefore it cannot be seen with conventional optical instruments. IBEX made the first observations of the heliotail by measuring the energy of "energetic neutral atoms", neutral particles created by collisions in the Solar System's boundary zone.[39]
The tail has been shown to contain fast and slow particles; the slow particles are on the side and the fast particles are encompassed in the center. The shape of the tail can be linked to the Sun sending out fast solar winds near its poles and slow solar winds near its equator more recently. The clover-shaped tail moves further away from the Sun, which makes the charged particles begin to morph into a new orientation.
Cassini andIBEX data challenged the "heliotail" theory in 2009.[13][14] In July 2013, IBEX results revealed a 4-lobed tail on the Solar System's heliosphere.[40]
The bubble-like heliosphere moving through the interstellar medium.Energetic neutral atom (ENA) detection is more concentrated in one direction.[41]
The heliopause is the final known boundary between the heliosphere and the interstellar space that is filled with material, especially plasma, not from the Earth's own star, the Sun, but from other stars.[42] Even so, just outside the heliosphere (i.e. the "solar bubble") there is a transitional region, as detected byVoyager 1.[43] Just as some interstellar pressure was detected as early as 2004, some of the Sun's material seeps into the interstellar medium.[43] The heliosphere is thought to reside in theLocal Interstellar Cloud inside theLocal Bubble, which is a region in theOrion Arm of theMilky Way Galaxy.
Outside the heliosphere, there is a forty-fold increase in plasma density.[43] There is also a radical reduction in the detection of certain types of particles from the Sun, and a large increase in galactic cosmic rays.[44]
The flow of theinterstellar medium (ISM) into the heliosphere has been measured by at least 11 different spacecraft as of 2013.[45] By 2013, it was suspected that the direction of the flow had changed over time.[45] The flow, coming from Earth's perspective from the constellation Scorpius, has probably changed direction by several degrees since the 1970s.[45]
This section needs to beupdated. Please help update this article to reflect recent events or newly available information.(January 2019)
Predicted to be a region of hot hydrogen, a structure called the "hydrogen wall" may be between the bow shock and the heliopause.[46] The wall is composed of interstellar material interacting with the edge of the heliosphere. One paper released in 2013 studied the concept of a bow wave and hydrogen wall.[47]
Another hypothesis suggests that the heliopause could be smaller on the side of the Solar System facing the Sun's orbital motion through the galaxy. It may also vary depending on the current velocity of the solar wind and the local density of the interstellar medium. It is known to lie far outside the orbit ofNeptune. The mission of theVoyager 1 and2 spacecraft is to find and study the termination shock, heliosheath, and heliopause. Meanwhile, the IBEX mission is attempting to image the heliopause from Earth orbit within two years of its 2008 launch. Initial results (October 2009) from IBEX suggest that previous assumptions are insufficiently cognizant of the true complexities of the heliopause.[48]
In August 2018, long-term studies about the hydrogen wall by theNew Horizons spacecraft confirmed results first detected in 1992 by the twoVoyager spacecraft.[49][50] Although the hydrogen is detected by extra ultraviolet light (which may come from another source), the detection byNew Horizons corroborates the earlier detections byVoyager at a much higher level of sensitivity.[51]
It was long hypothesized that theSun produces a "shock wave" in its travels within the interstellar medium. It would occur if the interstellar medium is moving supersonically "toward" the Sun, since its solar wind moves "away" from the Sun supersonically. When the interstellar wind hits the heliosphere it slows and creates a region of turbulence. A bow shock was thought to possibly occur at about 230 AU,[17] but in 2012 it was determined it probably does not exist.[16] This conclusion resulted from new measurements: The velocity of the LISM (local interstellar medium) relative to the Sun's was previously measured to be 26.3 km/s byUlysses, whereas IBEX measured it at 23.2 km/s.[52]
This phenomenon has been observed outside the Solar System, around stars other than the Sun, by NASA's now retired orbitalGALEX telescope. The red giant starMira in the constellationCetus has been shown to have both a debris tail of ejecta from the star and a distinct shock in the direction of its movement through space (at over 130 kilometers per second).
The precise distance to and shape of the heliopause are still uncertain. Interplanetary/interstellarspacecraft such asPioneer 10,Pioneer 11 andNew Horizons are traveling outward through theSolar System and will eventually pass through the heliopause. Contact toPioneer 10 and11 has been lost.
Rather than a comet-like shape, the heliosphere appears to be bubble-shaped according to data fromCassini's Ion and Neutral Camera (MIMI / INCA). Rather than being dominated by the collisions between the solar wind and the interstellar medium, the INCA (ENA) maps suggest that the interaction is controlled more by particle pressure and magnetic field energy density.[13][53]
Initial data fromInterstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX), launched in October 2008,[54] revealed a previously unpredicted "very narrow ribbon that is two to three times brighter than anything else in the sky", now known as theIBEX ribbon.[14] Initial interpretations suggest that "the interstellar environment has far more influence on structuring the heliosphere than anyone previously believed"[55]"No one knows what is creating the ENA (energetic neutral atoms) ribbon, ..."[56]
"The IBEX results are truly remarkable! What we are seeing in these maps does not match with any of the previous theoretical models of this region. It will be exciting for scientists to review these (ENA) maps and revise the way we understand our heliosphere and how it interacts with the galaxy."[57] In October 2010, significant changes were detected in the ribbon after 6 months, based on the second set of IBEX observations.[58] IBEX data did not support the existence of a bow shock,[16] but there might be a 'bow wave' according to one study.[47]
Energetic neutral atoms map byIBEX. Credit: NASA /Goddard Space Flight Center Scientific Visualization Studio.Graphs of heliosheath detections byVoyager 1 andVoyager 2. Voyager 2 has since crossed the heliopause into interstellar space.Voyager 1 and2 speed and distance from Sun
The heliosphere is the area under the influence of the Sun; the two major components to determining its edge are theheliospheric magnetic field and thesolar wind from the Sun. Three major sections from the beginning of the heliosphere to its edge are the termination shock, the heliosheath, and the heliopause. Five spacecraft have returned much of the data about its furthest reaches, includingPioneer 10 (1972–1997; data to 67 AU),Pioneer 11 (1973–1995; 44 AU),Voyager 1 andVoyager 2 (launched 1977, ongoing), andNew Horizons (launched 2006). A type of particle called anenergetic neutral atom (ENA) has also been observed to have been produced from its edges.
Except forregions near obstacles such asplanets orcomets, the heliosphere is dominated by material emanating from the Sun, althoughcosmic rays,fast-moving neutral atoms, andcosmic dust can penetrate the heliosphere from the outside. Originating at the extremely hot surface of thecorona, solar wind particles reachescape velocity, streaming outwards at 300 to 800 km/s (671 thousand to 1.79 million mph or 1 to 2.9 million km/h).[59] As it begins to interact with theinterstellar medium, its velocity slows to a stop. The point where the solar wind becomes slower than the speed of sound is called thetermination shock; the solar wind continues to slow as it passes through theheliosheath leading to a boundary called theheliopause, where the interstellar medium and solar wind pressures balance. The termination shock was traversed byVoyager 1 in 2004,[30] andVoyager 2 in 2007.[6]
It was thought that beyond the heliopause there was abow shock, but data fromInterstellar Boundary Explorer suggested the velocity of the Sun through the interstellar medium is too low for it to form.[16] It may be a more gentle "bow wave".[47]
Voyager data led to a new theory that the heliosheath has "magnetic bubbles" and a stagnation zone.[25][60] Also, there were reports of a "stagnation region" within the heliosheath, starting around 113 au (1.69×1010 km; 1.05×1010 mi), detected byVoyager 1 in 2010.[25] There, the solar wind velocity drops to zero, the magnetic field intensity doubles, and high-energy electrons from the galaxy increase 100-fold.[25]
Starting in May 2012 at 120 au (1.8×1010 km; 1.1×1010 mi),Voyager 1 detected a sudden increase in cosmic rays, an apparent sign of approach to the heliopause.[31] In the summer of 2013, NASA announced that Voyager 1 had reachedinterstellar space as of 25 August 2012.[33]
In December 2012, NASA announced that in late August 2012,Voyager 1, at about 122 au (1.83×1010 km; 1.13×1010 mi) from the Sun, entered a new region they called the "magnetic highway", an area still under the influence of the Sun but with some dramatic differences.[30]
Pioneer 10 was launched in March 1972, and within 10 hours passed by the Moon; over the next 35 years or so the mission would be the first out, laying out many firsts of discoveries about the nature of heliosphere as well as Jupiter's impact on it.[61]Pioneer 10 was the first spacecraft to detect sodium and aluminum ions in the solar wind, as well as helium in the inner Solar System.[61] In November 1972,Pioneer 10 encountered Jupiter's enormous (compared to Earth) magnetosphere and would pass in and out of it and its heliosphere 17 times charting its interaction with the solar wind.[61]Pioneer 10 returned scientific data until March 1997, including data on the solar wind out to about 67 AU.[62] It was also contacted in 2003 when it was a distance of 7.6 billion miles from Earth (82 AU), but no instrument data about the solar wind was returned then.[63][64]
Voyager 1 surpassed the radial distance from the Sun ofPioneer 10 at 69.4 AU on 17 February 1998, because it was traveling faster, gaining about 1.02 AU per year.[65] On July 18, 2023,Voyager 2 overtookPioneer 10 as the second most distant human-made object from the Sun.[66]Pioneer 11, launched a year afterPioneer 10, took similar data as Pioneer out to 44.7 AU in 1995 when that mission was concluded.[64]Pioneer 11 had a similar instrument suite as 10 but also had a flux-gate magnetometer.[65] Pioneer and Voyager spacecraft were on different trajectories and thus recorded data on the heliosphere in different overall directions away from the Sun.[64] Data obtained from Pioneer and Voyager spacecraft helped corroborate the detection of a hydrogen wall.[67]
In 2012Voyager 1 is thought to have passed through heliopause, andVoyager 2 did the same in 2018.[68][69]
The twin Voyagers are the only man-made objects to have entered interstellar space. However, while they have left the heliosphere, they have not yet left the boundary of the Solar System which is considered to be the outer edge of theOort Cloud.[69] Upon passing the heliopause,Voyager 2's Plasma Science Experiment (PLS) observed a sharp decline in the speed of solar wind particles on 5 November and there has been no sign of it since. The three other instruments on board measuring cosmic rays, low-energy charged particles, and magnetic fields also recorded the transition.[70] The observations complement data from NASA's IBEX mission. In 2025, NASA launchedInterstellar Mapping and Acceleration Probe (IMAP) to capitalize on Voyager's observations.[69]
1972–1973:Pioneer 10 becomes the first spacecraft to explore the heliosphere past Mars, flying by Jupiter on 4 December 1973 and continuing to return solar wind data out to a distance of 67 AU.[64]
February 1992: After flying by Jupiter, theUlysses spacecraft becomes the first to explore the mid and high latitudes of the heliosphere.[75]
1992: Pioneer and Voyager probes detectedLy-α radiation resonantly scattered by heliospheric hydrogen.[67]
2004:Voyager 1 becomes the first spacecraft to reach the termination shock.[30]
2005:SOHO observations of the solar wind show that the shape of the heliosphere is notaxisymmetrical, but distorted, very likely under the effect of the local galactic magnetic field.[76]
2009:IBEX project scientists discover and map a ribbon-shaped region of intenseenergetic neutral atom emission. These neutral atoms are thought to be originating from the heliopause.[14]
October 2009: the heliosphere may be bubble, not comet shaped.[13]
October 2010: significant changes were detected in the ribbon after six months, based on the second set of IBEX observations.[58]
May 2012: IBEX data implies there is probably not a bow "shock".[16]
June 2012: At 119 AU,Voyager 1 detected an increase in cosmic rays.[31]
25 August 2012:Voyager 1 crosses the heliopause, becoming the first human-made object to depart the heliosphere.[3]
August 2018: long-term studies about the hydrogen wall by theNew Horizons spacecraft confirmed results first detected in 1992 by the twoVoyager spacecraft.[49][50]
5 November 2018:Voyager 2 crosses the heliopause, departing the heliosphere.[4]
^abBrandt, P. C.; Provornikova, E.; Bale, S. D.; Cocoros, A.; DeMajistre, R.; Dialynas, K.; Elliott, H. A.; Eriksson, S.; Fields, B.; Galli, A.; Hill, M. E.; Horanyi, M.; Horbury, T.; Hunziker, S.; Kollmann, P.; Kinnison, J.; Fountain, G.; Krimigis, S. M.; Kurth, W. S.; Linsky, J.; Lisse, C. M.; Mandt, K. E.; Magnes, W.; McNutt, R. L.; Miller, J.; Moebius, E.; Mostafavi, P.; Opher, M.; Paxton, L.; Plaschke, F.; Poppe, A. R.; Roelof, E. C.; Runyon, K.; Redfield, S.; Schwadron, N.; Sterken, V.; Swaczyna, P.; Szalay, J.; Turner, D.; Vannier, H.; Wimmer-Schweingruber, R.; Wurz, P.; Zirnstein, E. J. (2023)."Future Exploration of the Outer Heliosphere and Very Local Interstellar Medium by Interstellar Probe".Space Science Reviews.219 (2): 18.Bibcode:2023SSRv..219...18B.doi:10.1007/s11214-022-00943-x.ISSN0038-6308.PMC9974711.PMID36874191.
^Brandt, Pontus (27 February – 2 March 2007)."Imaging of the Heliospheric Boundary"(PDF).NASA Advisory Council Workshop on Science Associated with the Lunar Exploration Architecture: White Papers. Tempe, Arizona: Lunar and Planetary Institute. Retrieved25 May 2007.
^Brumfiel, G. (15 June 2011). "Voyager at the edge: spacecraft finds unexpected calm at the boundary of Sun's bubble".Nature.doi:10.1038/news.2011.370.
^Hatfield, Miles (15 April 2021)."SHIELDS Up! NASA Rocket to Survey Our Solar System's Windshield".NASA. Retrieved18 December 2021.The NASA black Brant IX sounding rocket carried the payload to an apogee of 177 miles before descending by parachute and landing at White Sands. Preliminary indications show that vehicle systems performed as planned and data was received.
^"Fact Sheet".European Space Agency. 15 March 2013. Retrieved15 December 2018.
^Lallement, R.; Quémerais, E.; Bertaux, J. L.; Ferron, S.; Koutroumpa, D.; Pellinen, R. (March 2005). "Deflection of the Interstellar Neutral Hydrogen Flow Across the Heliospheric Interface".Science.307 (5714): 1447–1449.(SciHomepage).Bibcode:2005Sci...307.1447L.doi:10.1126/science.1107953.PMID15746421.S2CID36260574.
