Scholars have commented that Gimli is unlike other dwarves in being free from their characteristic greed for gold. They note, too, that he is unique in being granted the gift ofGaladriel's hair, something that she had refused toFëanor. The events recall the Norse legendNjáls saga, where a gift of hair is refused, with fateful consequences.
Gimli was born in theEred Luin in theThird Age, son ofGlóin. Gimli had wanted to accompany his father on the quest to reclaimErebor, but at age 62 he was deemed too young.[T 1] He was a remote descendant ofDurin the Deathless, chief of the SevenFathers of the Dwarves and ancestor of theLongbeards. Gimli was of the royal line, but not close to the succession; he was the third cousin once removed ofDáin II Ironfoot.[T 2][T 3]
Gimli is first seen with Glóin at theCouncil of Elrond; they tell the Council that the Dark LordSauron is searching for Bilbo, and askElrond's advice. They learn thatFrodo Baggins is now the bearer of theOne Ring. The Council decides to destroy it by casting it intoMount Doom. Frodo volunteers for the task;[T 4] Gimli isamong those chosen to help him.[T 5] There is friction between Gimli and theelfLegolas as their races bear an old grudge against each other.[T 6]
When the company is forced to enter the ancient underground Dwarf-realm, the Mines of Moria, Gimli is at first enthusiastic, hoping to find Balin there.[T 5] However, Moria is still inhabited byOrcs,Cave Trolls, and aBalrog: Balin and his folk have all been killed. The Fellowship finds his tomb in the Chamber of Mazarbul; Orcs attack, and they have to fight their way out.[T 7]Aragorn leads the company toLothlórien, populated by Elves hostile to Dwarves. Gimli refuses to be blindfolded, risking a conflict, so Aragorn has the entire Fellowship blindfolded.[T 8]
Gimli's opinion of Elves changes when he meetsGaladriel, co-ruler of Lothlórien: her beauty, kindness, and understanding impress him so much that, when given the opportunity to ask for whatever he wishes, he responds that being able to see her and hear her gentle words is gift enough. When pressed, he admits that he desires a single strand of her golden hair, to be an heirloom of his house, but that he could not ask for such a gift. Galadriel is so moved by his bold yet courteous request that she gives him not one, but three of her hairs.[a] Gimli's gesture of respect and humility towards Galadriel changes Legolas' opinion of him, and they become firm friends.[T 10]
AtAmon Hen, the company is divided, and Gimli joins Legolas and Aragorn in pursuingMerry andPippin who have been captured by Orcs.[T 11] After running many miles in a few days to the land ofRohan, they meetÉomer, nephew of Rohan's KingThéoden, with a troop of cavalry, which has killed all the Orcs. When Éomer speaks badly of the name Galadriel, Gimli responds harshly, but Aragorn prevents a fight.[T 12] Gandalf leads them to Rohan's capital,Edoras, where he rouses Théoden to war againstSaruman.[T 13] Gimli proves his valour in combat in theBattle of Helm's Deep. He and Legolas engage in an Orc-slaying contest (Gimli wins by one; he kills 42 to Legolas's 41). Gimli saves Éomer's life by killing two orcs and driving off two others.[T 14] Later, Gimli's vivid description of theGlittering Caves of Aglarond moves Legolas to promise to visit the caves when theWar is over;[T 15] and eventually they make the visit together.[T 16] After the battle, Gimli witnesses Gandalf casting Saruman out of the Order of Wizards; he sees through Saruman's lies with the words "This wizard's words stand on their heads".[T 17]
After the destruction of the Ring, Gimli leads many Dwarves south toAglarond, becoming the first Lord of the Glittering Caves. They build "great works" in Rohan and Gondor, and replace the ruined gate of Minas Tirith with one made ofmithril and steel.[T 22] After Aragorn's death, Gimli (then 262 years old) sails with Legolas into the West, becoming the first Dwarf in theUndying Lands.[T 23]
Fan art of "Gimli son of Glóin".Dimitra Fimi notes the small leap required for fan activity to switch from book-based to film-based.[1]
The nameGimli first appeared in Tolkien's works in "The Tale of Tinúviel", the earliest version of the story ofBeren andLúthien Tinúviel, found in the second volume ofThe Book of Lost Tales. Here, the name belongs to an aged elf, a prisoner along with Beren in the kitchens of Tevildo, Prince of Cats (forerunner ofSauron).[T 24] During the writing ofThe Lord of the Rings, as told inThe Return of the Shadow, Gimli's character was first namedFrar, thenBurin, and he was the son of Balin.[T 25]
The Tolkien scholarTom Shippey writes that Tolkien has Gimli "swap grimproverbs" with Elrond. Shippey comments that dwarvish heroism is expressed in their veiled speech, as seen also with King Dáin's stubborn replies to the messenger ofMordor. He sees these examples as unified by "delight in the contrast between passionate interior and polite or rational expression; the weakness of the latter is an index of the strength of the former".[2]
Writing inMallorn, the journal of the Tolkien Society, Lilian Darvell states that Gimli's request for a gift of Galadriel's hair is to be contrasted withFëanor's earlier request of the same gift, described in "The History of Galadriel and Celeborn", inUnfinished Tales.[T 26][3] Galadriel rejected Fëanor's request, though he made it three times. Darvell comments that given Galadriel's ability to see into people's hearts, and the darkness she saw in Fëanor, she must have seen something better in Gimli than in "one of the greatest of theNoldor".[3] Darvell notes that the gift of hair has echoes in both literature, as inBereniceand the Lock byCallimachus andCatullus andThe Rape of the Lock byAlexander Pope, and in Norse legend.[3] InNjáls saga, Gunnarr's bowstring breaks in a desperate battle; he asks his wife Hallgerðr for two hairs to use as a replacement, but she refuses because he had once struck her, and he is killed. Darvell comments that Galadriel's refusal does not kill Fëanor, but it does result in a distancing, which might have led him to refuse to send ships to rescue her fromNúmenor.[T 26][3]
The scholars ofinternational relations Abigail Ruane andPatrick James view Gimli as an exemplar of "neoliberal institutionalists" within theeconomy of Middle-earth, since his "people avidly pursue gold and treasure".[4] In their view, he and his Dwarves also illustrate the interdependence of nations through their networks of trade and allies; the varied "relationships among Dwarves, Elves, and Men provide a foundation upon which to build and [to] ally against Sauron and illustrate how complex interdependence can reduce perceptions of insecurity and create opportunities for cooperation rather than conflict."[4]
The Tolkien scholar John Miller writes that like the Elves, the Dwarves have withdrawn from history and become subject to "an increased aesthetic sensibility",[5] exemplified by Gimli's lyrical description of the Glittering Caves of Aglarond. Miller argues that as well as praising the beauty of the caves, Gimli's account "emphasizes their stillness, their abstraction from the history marching along outside".[5] He suggests that the dwarvish love of hand-crafted workmanship could be a pre-modern aesthetic, an immature or adolescent appreciation compared to that of Elves or Men.[5]
The philologist Susan Robbins writes inŽmogus ir žodis that with the words "I say to you, Gimli son of Glóin, that your hands shall flow with gold, yet over you gold shall have no dominion", Galadriel gives Gimli, alone of all the Dwarves, immunity to the dragon-sickness. Robbins defines this as "bewilderment or confusion that makes one so greedy for ... gold that one would rather starve to death [for] rather than give any of it up",[6] the fate that overwhelmed the DwarfThorin Oakenshield and the humanMaster of Laketown inThe Hobbit. She notes that Tolkien stated that the dragon-sickness, the effect of the magic spells placed onSmaug's golden hoard, had been derived from line 3052 of theOld English poemBeowulf:iúmonna gold galdre bewunden, "the gold of men of long ago enmeshed in enchantment".[6]
InPeter Jackson'sfilm trilogy, Gimli is played by theWelsh actorJohn Rhys-Davies.Brian Sibley has asserted that Rhys-Davies used "his distinctive Welsh-derived accent" for the character.[8] Several other sources state, however, that Rhys-Davies uses a Scottish accent; the ScottishThe Press and Journal praises him for the "convincing" Scottish accent, calling his performance "raspy, croaky, bearded and brilliant".[9] Rhys-Davies himself states onThe Fellowship of the Ring extended version DVD that the accent was by intention Scottish, and that it had been his decision to use it.[10]The New Zealand Herald quotes Rhys-Davies as saying of Gimli that "There is a gritty sort of fierce belligerence, and in the end I thought an almostGlasgow Scottish accent would serve the character."[11]
In Peter Jackson's films, Gimli's prosaic and blunt style, contrasting with the refined Aragorn and Legolas, provides defusingcomic relief, with much of the humourbased on his height,[12][13] along with his competitive, if friendly, feud with Legolas, where Gimli consistently finds himself out-achieved.[14]
Gimli was portrayed by Ross Williams in the 3-hourToronto stage production ofThe Lord of the Rings, which opened in 2006.[15] InThe Lord of the Rings: The Musical, he was played by Sévan Stephan throughout itsLondon run.[16]
The classical composerCraig H. Russell's 1995Middle Earth has as its second movement "Gimli, the Dwarf"; Russell describes it as sounding "like a rugged Irish tune". The piece was originally written forstring ensemble, and re-orchestrated forsymphonic orchestra.[17]
^A similar request had been made, thousands of years previously, by Galadriel's uncleFëanor, greatest of theNoldorin Elves (whose creation of theSilmarils may have been inspired by that same silver-gold hair). Galadriel refused Fëanor's request, but she grants Gimli's, perhaps because of his humility.[T 9]
^abcdDarvell, Lilian (Winter 2015). "'Beautiful and Terrible': The Significance of Galadriel's Hair in The Lord of the Rings and Unfinished Tales".Mallorn (56):22–24.JSTOR48614834.
^Rearick, Anderson (2004). "Why Is the Only Good Orc a Dead Orc".Inklings Forever: Published Colloquium Proceedings 1997-2016.4: Article 10.in the actors' commentary found on the extended DVD version of The Fellowship of the Ring, John Rhys- Davies describes his decision—not Jackson's nor Tolkien's—to add a Scottish accent to his portrayal of Gimli the dwarf.
^Bryant, Brantley L. (2014). "One does not simply laugh in Middle Earth: Sacrificing humor in Peter Jackson's The Lord of the Rings".Postmedieval: A Journal of Medieval Cultural Studies.5 (2):184–198.doi:10.1057/pmed.2014.6.ISSN2040-5960.S2CID161197262.
^"The Lord Of The Rings". Shaun McKenna. Retrieved1 September 2020.The World Premiere production opened at the Princess of Wales Theatre in Toronto on February 4, 2006 and had its press opening on March 23, 2006.