Transport of dissolved species from the highest to the lowest concentration region
This article is about the generic concept of the time-dependent process. For other uses, seeDiffusion (disambiguation).
Some particles aredissolved in a glass of water. At first, the particles are all near one top corner of the glass. If the particles randomly move around ("diffuse") in the water, they eventually become distributed randomly and uniformly from an area of high concentration to an area of low, and organized (diffusion continues, but with no netflux).Time lapse video of diffusion a dye dissolved in water into a gel.Diffusion from a microscopic and b macroscopic point of view. Initially, there aresolute molecules on the left side of a barrier (purple line) and none on the right. The barrier is removed, and the solute diffuses to fill the whole container.Top: A single molecule moves around randomly.Middle: With more molecules, there is a statistical trend that the solute fills the container more and more uniformly.Bottom: With an enormous number of solute molecules, all randomness is gone: The solute appears to move smoothly and deterministically from high-concentration areas to low-concentration areas. There is no microscopicforce pushing molecules rightward, but thereappears to be one in the bottom panel. This apparent force is called anentropic force.Three-dimensional rendering of diffusion of purple dye in water.
Diffusion is the net movement of anything (for example, atoms, ions, molecules, energy) generally from a region of higherconcentration to a region of lower concentration. Diffusion is driven by a gradient inGibbs free energy orchemical potential. It is possible to diffuse "uphill" from a region of lower concentration to a region of higher concentration, as inspinodal decomposition. Diffusion is astochastic process due to the inherent randomness of the diffusing entity and can be used to model many real-life stochastic scenarios. Therefore, diffusion and the corresponding mathematical models are used in several fields beyond physics, such asstatistics,probability theory,information theory,neural networks,finance, andmarketing.
The concept of diffusion is widely used in many fields, includingphysics (particle diffusion),chemistry,biology,sociology,economics,statistics,data science, andfinance (diffusion of people, ideas, data and price values). The central idea of diffusion, however, is common to all of these: a substance or collection undergoing diffusion spreads out from a point or location at which there is a higher concentration of that substance or collection.
Agradient is the change in the value of a quantity; for example, concentration,pressure, ortemperature with the change in another variable, usuallydistance. A change in concentration over a distance is called aconcentration gradient, a change in pressure over a distance is called apressure gradient, and a change in temperature over a distance is called atemperature gradient.
The worddiffusion derives from theLatin word,diffundere, which means "to spread out".
A distinguishing feature of diffusion is that it depends on particlerandom walk, and results in mixing or mass transport without requiring directed bulk motion. Bulk motion, or bulk flow, is the characteristic ofadvection.[1] The termconvection is used to describe the combination of bothtransport phenomena.
If a diffusion process can be described byFick's laws, it is called a normal diffusion (or Fickian diffusion); Otherwise, it is called ananomalous diffusion (or non-Fickian diffusion).
When talking about the extent of diffusion, two length scales are used in two different scenarios ( is thediffusion coefficient, having dimensionsarea / time):
"Bulk flow" is the movement/flow of an entire body due to a pressure gradient (for example, water coming out of a tap). "Diffusion" is the gradual movement/dispersion of concentration within a body with no net movement of matter. An example of a process where bothbulk motion and diffusion occur is human breathing.[2]
First, there is a "bulk flow" process. Thelungs are located in thethoracic cavity, which expands as the first step in external respiration. This expansion leads to an increase in volume of thealveoli in the lungs, which causes a decrease in pressure in the alveoli. This creates a pressure gradient between theair outside the body at relatively high pressure and the alveoli at relatively low pressure. The air moves down the pressure gradient through the airways of the lungs and into the alveoli until the pressure of the air and that in the alveoli are equal, that is, the movement of air by bulk flow stops once there is no longer a pressure gradient.
Second, there is a "diffusion" process. The air arriving in the alveoli has a higher concentration of oxygen than the "stale" air in the alveoli. The increase in oxygen concentration creates a concentration gradient for oxygen between the air in the alveoli and the blood in thecapillaries that surround the alveoli. Oxygen then moves by diffusion, down the concentration gradient, into the blood. The other consequence of the air arriving in alveoli is that the concentration ofcarbon dioxide in the alveoli decreases. This creates a concentration gradient for carbon dioxide to diffuse from the blood into the alveoli, as fresh air has a very low concentration of carbon dioxide compared to theblood in the body.
Third, there is another "bulk flow" process. The pumping action of theheart then transports the blood around the body. As the left ventricle of the heart contracts, the volume decreases, which increases the pressure in the ventricle. This creates a pressure gradient between the heart and the capillaries, and blood moves throughblood vessels by bulk flow down the pressure gradient.
There are two ways to introduce the notion ofdiffusion: either aphenomenological approach starting withFick's laws of diffusion and their mathematical consequences, or a physical and atomistic one, by considering therandom walk of the diffusing particles.[3]
In the phenomenological approach,diffusion is the movement of a substance from a region of high concentration to a region of low concentration without bulk motion. According to Fick's laws, the diffusionflux is proportional to the negativegradient of concentrations. It goes from regions of higher concentration to regions of lower concentration. Sometime later, various generalizations of Fick's laws were developed in the frame ofthermodynamics andnon-equilibrium thermodynamics.[4]
From theatomistic point of view, diffusion is considered as a result of the random walk of the diffusing particles. Inmolecular diffusion, the moving molecules in a gas, liquid, or solid are self-propelled by kinetic energy. Random walk of small particles in suspension in a fluid was discovered in 1827 byRobert Brown, who found that minute particle suspended in a liquid medium and just large enough to be visible under an optical microscope exhibit a rapid and continually irregular motion of particles known as Brownian movement. The theory of theBrownian motion and the atomistic backgrounds of diffusion were developed byAlbert Einstein.[5]The concept of diffusion is typically applied to any subject matter involving random walks inensembles of individuals.
Inchemistry andmaterials science, diffusion also refers to the movement of fluid molecules in porous solids.[6] Different types of diffusion are distinguished in porous solids.Molecular diffusion occurs when the collision with another molecule is more likely than the collision with the pore walls. Under such conditions, the diffusivity is similar to that in a non-confined space and is proportional to the mean free path.Knudsen diffusion occurs when the pore diameter is comparable to or smaller than the mean free path of the molecule diffusing through the pore. Under this condition, the collision with the pore walls becomes gradually more likely and the diffusivity is lower. Finally there is configurational diffusion, which happens if the molecules have comparable size to that of the pore. Under this condition, the diffusivity is much lower compared to molecular diffusion and small differences in the kinetic diameter of the molecule cause large differences indiffusivity.
Biologists often use the terms "net movement" or "net diffusion" to describe the movement of ions or molecules by diffusion. For example, oxygen can diffuse through cell membranes so long as there is a higher concentration of oxygen outside the cell. However, because the movement of molecules is random, occasionally oxygen molecules move out of the cell (against the concentration gradient). Because there are more oxygen molecules outside the cell, theprobability that oxygen molecules will enter the cell is higher than the probability that oxygen molecules will leave the cell. Therefore, the "net" movement of oxygen molecules (the difference between the number of molecules either entering or leaving the cell) is into the cell. In other words, there is anet movement of oxygen molecules down the concentration gradient.
Inmachine learning andartificial intelligence,diffusion models, also known as diffusion-based generative models or score-based generative models, are a class oflatent variablegenerative models. The goal of diffusion models is to learn adiffusion process for a given dataset, such that the process can generate new elements that are distributed similarly as the original dataset. Diffusion models were introduced in 2015 as a method to train a model that can sample from a highly complex probability distribution. They used techniques fromnon-equilibrium thermodynamics, especially diffusion.[10]
In the scope of time, diffusion in solids was used long before the theory of diffusion was created. For example,Pliny the Elder had previously described thecementation process, which produces steel from the elementiron (Fe) through carbon diffusion. Another example is well known for many centuries, the diffusion of colors ofstained glass orearthenware andChinese ceramics.
In modern science, the first systematic experimental study of diffusion was performed byThomas Graham. He studied diffusion in gases, and the main phenomenon was described by him in 1831–1833:[11]
"...gases of different nature, when brought into contact, do not arrange themselves according to their density, the heaviest undermost, and the lighter uppermost, but they spontaneously diffuse, mutually and equally, through each other, and so remain in the intimate state of mixture for any length of time."
The measurements of Graham contributed toJames Clerk Maxwell deriving, in 1867, the coefficient of diffusion for CO2 in the air. The error rate is less than 5%.
In 1855,Adolf Fick, the 26-year-old anatomy demonstrator from Zürich, proposedhis law of diffusion. He used Graham's research, stating his goal as "the development of a fundamental law, for the operation of diffusion in a single element of space". He asserted a deep analogy between diffusion and conduction of heat or electricity, creating a formalism similar toFourier's law for heat conduction (1822) andOhm's law for electric current (1827).
Robert Boyle demonstrated diffusion in solids in the 17th century[12] by penetration of zinc into a copper coin. Nevertheless, diffusion in solids was not systematically studied until the second part of the 19th century.William Chandler Roberts-Austen, the well-known British metallurgist and former assistant of Thomas Graham studied systematically solid state diffusion on the example of gold in lead in 1896. :[13]
"... My long connection with Graham's researches made it almost a duty to attempt to extend his work on liquid diffusion to metals."
Yakov Frenkel (sometimes, Jakov/Jacob Frenkel) proposed, and elaborated in 1926, the idea of diffusion in crystals through local defects (vacancies andinterstitial atoms). He concluded, the diffusion process in condensed matter is an ensemble of elementary jumps and quasichemical interactions of particles and defects. He introduced several mechanisms of diffusion and found rate constants from experimental data.
Sometime later,Carl Wagner andWalter H. Schottky developed Frenkel's ideas about mechanisms of diffusion further. Presently, it is universally recognized that atomic defects are necessary to mediate diffusion in crystals.[13]
Each model of diffusion expresses thediffusion flux with the use of concentrations, densities and their derivatives. Flux is a vector representing the quantity and direction of transfer. Given a smallarea with normal, the transfer of aphysical quantity through the area per time is
Thedimension of the diffusion flux is [flux] = [quantity]/([time]·[area]). The diffusing physical quantity may be the number of particles, mass, energy, electric charge, or any other scalarextensive quantity. For its density,, the diffusion equation has the form
where is intensity of any local source of this quantity (for example, the rate of a chemical reaction).For the diffusion equation, theno-flux boundary conditions can be formulated as on the boundary, where is the normal to the boundary at point.
Fick's first law: The diffusion flux,, is proportional to the negative gradient of spatial concentration,:
whereD is thediffusion coefficient, which can be estimated for a given mixture using, for example, the empirical Vignes correlation model[17] or the physically motivated entropy scaling.[18] The correspondingdiffusion equation (Fick's second law) is
In case the diffusion coefficient is independent of, Fick's second law can be simplified to
Fick's law describes diffusion of an admixture in a medium. The concentration of this admixture should be small and the gradient of this concentration should be also small. The driving force of diffusion in Fick's law is the antigradient of concentration,.
In 1931,Lars Onsager[19] included the multicomponent transport processes in the general context of linear non-equilibrium thermodynamics. Formulti-component transport,
The thermodynamic forces for the transport processes were introduced by Onsager as the space gradients of the derivatives of theentropy density (he used the term "force" in quotation marks or "driving force"):
where are the "thermodynamic coordinates".For the heat and mass transfer one can take (the density of internal energy) and is the concentration of theth component. The corresponding driving forces are the space vectors
because
whereT is the absolute temperature and is the chemical potential of theth component. It should be stressed that the separate diffusion equations describe the mixing or mass transport without bulk motion. Therefore, the terms with variation of the total pressure are neglected. It is possible for diffusion of small admixtures and for small gradients.
For the linear Onsager equations, we must take the thermodynamic forces in the linear approximation near equilibrium:
Here, all the indexesi,j,k = 0, 1, 2, ... are related to the internal energy (0) and various components. The expression in the square brackets is the matrix of the diffusion (i,k > 0), thermodiffusion (i > 0,k = 0 ork > 0,i = 0) andthermal conductivity (i =k = 0) coefficients.
Underisothermal conditionsT = constant. The relevantthermodynamic potential is the free energy (or thefree entropy). The thermodynamic driving forces for the isothermal diffusion are antigradients of chemical potentials,, and the matrix of diffusion coefficients is
(i,k > 0).
There is intrinsic arbitrariness in the definition of the thermodynamic forces and kinetic coefficients because they are not measurable separately and only their combinations can be measured. For example, in the original work of Onsager[19] the thermodynamic forces include additional multiplierT, whereas in theCourse of Theoretical Physics[20] this multiplier is omitted but the sign of the thermodynamic forces is opposite. All these changes are supplemented by the corresponding changes in the coefficients and do not affect the measurable quantities.
The formalism of linear irreversible thermodynamics (Onsager) generates the systems of linear diffusion equations in the form
If the matrix of diffusion coefficients is diagonal, then this system of equations is just a collection of decoupled Fick's equations for various components. Assume that diffusion is non-diagonal, for example,, and consider the state with. At this state,. If at some points, then becomes negative at these points in a short time. Therefore, linear non-diagonal diffusion does not preserve positivity of concentrations. Non-diagonal equations of multicomponent diffusion must be non-linear.[16]
The mobility-based approach was further applied by T. Teorell.[22] In 1935, he studied the diffusion of ions through a membrane. He formulated the essence of his approach in the formula:
the flux is equal to mobility × concentration × force per gram-ion.
This is the so-calledTeorell formula.[citation needed] The term "gram-ion" ("gram-particle") is used for a quantity of a substance that contains theAvogadro number of ions (particles). The common modern term ismole.
The force under isothermal conditions consists of two parts:
Diffusion force caused by concentration gradient:.
Electrostatic force caused by electric potential gradient:.
HereR is thegas constant,T is the absolute temperature,n is the concentration, the equilibrium concentration is marked by a superscript "eq",q is the charge andφ is the electric potential.
The simple but crucial difference between the Teorell formula and the Onsager laws is the concentration factor in the Teorell expression for the flux. In the Einstein–Teorell approach, if for the finite force the concentration tends to zero then the flux also tends to zero, whereas the Onsager equations violate this simple and physically obvious rule.
The general formulation of the Teorell formula for non-perfect systems under isothermal conditions is[16]
whereμ is thechemical potential,μ0 is the standard value of the chemical potential.The expression is the so-calledactivity. It measures the "effective concentration" of a species in a non-ideal mixture. In this notation, the Teorell formula for the flux has a very simple form[16]
The standard derivation of the activity includes a normalization factor and for small concentrations, where is the standard concentration. Therefore, this formula for the flux describes the flux of the normalized dimensionless quantity:
Solving this equation, one obtained the time-dependent diffusion constant in the long-time limit and when the particle is significantly denser than the surrounding fluid,[23]
At long time scales, Einstein's result is recovered, but short time scales, theballistic regime are also explained. Moreover, unlike the Einstein approach, a velocity can be defined, leading to theFluctuation-dissipation theorem, connecting the competition between friction and random forces in defining the temperature.[23]: 3.2
Diffusion in the monolayer: oscillations near temporary equilibrium positions and jumps to the nearest free places.
Diffusion of reagents on the surface of acatalyst may play an important role in heterogeneous catalysis. The model of diffusion in the ideal monolayer is based on the jumps of the reagents on the nearest free places. This model was used for CO on Pt oxidation under low gas pressure.
The system includes several reagents on the surface. Their surface concentrations are The surface is a lattice of the adsorption places. Eachreagent molecule fills a place on the surface. Some of the places are free. The concentration of the free places is. The sum of all (including free places) is constant, the density of adsorption placesb.
The jump model gives for the diffusion flux of (i = 1, ..., n):
Due to the conservation law, and wehave the system ofm diffusion equations. For one component we get Fick's law and linear equations because. For two and more components the equations are nonlinear.
If all particles can exchange their positions with their closest neighbours then a simple generalization gives
where is a symmetric matrix of coefficients that characterize the intensities of jumps. The free places (vacancies) should be considered as special "particles" with concentration.
Various versions of these jump models are also suitable for simple diffusion mechanisms in solids.
For diffusion in porous media the basic equations are (if Φ is constant):[24]
whereD is the diffusion coefficient, Φ is porosity,n is the concentration,m > 0 (usuallym > 1, the casem = 1 corresponds to Fick's law).
Care must be taken to properly account for the porosity (Φ) of the porous medium in both the flux terms and the accumulation terms.[25] For example, as the porosity goes to zero, the molar flux in the porous medium goes to zero for a given concentration gradient. Upon applying the divergence of the flux, the porosity terms cancel out and the second equation above is formed.
For diffusion of gases in porous media this equation is the formalization ofDarcy's law: thevolumetric flux of a gas in the porous media is
The diffusion coefficient is the coefficient in theFick's first law, whereJ is the diffusion flux (amount of substance) per unit area per unit time,n (for ideal mixtures) is the concentration,x is the position [length].
Consider two gases with molecules of the same diameterd and massm (self-diffusion). In this case, the elementary mean free path theory of diffusion gives for the diffusion coefficient
We can see that the diffusion coefficient in the mean free path approximation grows withT asT3/2 and decreases withP as 1/P. If we use forP theideal gas lawP = RnT with the total concentrationn, then we can see that for given concentrationn the diffusion coefficient grows withT asT1/2 and for given temperature it decreases with the total concentration as 1/n.
For two different gases, A and B, with molecular massesmA,mB and molecular diametersdA,dB, the mean free path estimate of the diffusion coefficient of A in B and B in A is:
The theory of diffusion in gases based on Boltzmann's equation
In Boltzmann's kinetics of the mixture of gases, each gas has its own distribution function,, wheret is the time moment,x is position andc is velocity of molecule of theith component of the mixture. Each component has its mean velocity. If the velocities do not coincide then there existsdiffusion.
In theChapman–Enskog approximation, all the distribution functions are expressed through the densities of the conserved quantities:[14]
individual concentrations of particles, (particles per volume),
density of momentum (mi is theith particle mass),
density of kinetic energy
The kinetic temperatureT and pressureP are defined in 3D space as
where is the total density.
For two gases, the difference between velocities, is given by the expression:[14]
where is the force applied to the molecules of theith component and is the thermodiffusion ratio.
The coefficientD12 is positive. This is the diffusion coefficient. Four terms in the formula forC1−C2 describe four main effects in the diffusion of gases:
describes the flux of the first component from the areas with the high ration1/n to the areas with lower values of this ratio (and, analogously the flux of the second component from highn2/n to lown2/n becausen2/n = 1 – n1/n);
describes the flux of the heavier molecules to the areas with higher pressure and the lighter molecules to the areas with lower pressure, this isbarodiffusion;
describes diffusion caused by the difference of the forces applied to molecules of different types. For example, in the Earth's gravitational field, the heavier molecules should go down, or in electric field the charged molecules should move, until this effect is not equilibrated by the sum of other terms. This effect should not be confused with barodiffusion caused by the pressure gradient.
describesthermodiffusion, the diffusion flux caused by the temperature gradient.
All these effects are calleddiffusion because they describe the differences between velocities of different components in the mixture. Therefore, these effects cannot be described as abulk transport and differ from advection or convection.
The number is defined by quadratures (formulas (3.7), (3.9), Ch. 10 of the classical Chapman and Cowling book[14])
We can see that the dependence onT for the rigid spheres is the same as for the simple mean free path theory but for the power repulsion laws the exponent is different. Dependence on a total concentrationn for a given temperature has always the same character, 1/n.
In applications to gas dynamics, the diffusion flux and the bulk flow should be joined in one system of transport equations. The bulk flow describes the mass transfer. Its velocityV is the mass average velocity. It is defined through the momentum density and the mass concentrations:
where is the mass concentration of theith species, is the mass density.
By definition, the diffusion velocity of theith component is,.The mass transfer of theith component is described by thecontinuity equation
where is the net mass production rate in chemical reactions,.
In these equations, the term describes advection of theith component and the term represents diffusion of this component.
In 1948,Wendell H. Furry proposed to use theform of the diffusion rates found in kinetic theory as a framework for the new phenomenological approach to diffusion in gases. This approach was developed further by F.A. Williams and S.H. Lam.[26] For the diffusion velocities in multicomponent gases (N components) they used
Here, is the diffusion coefficient matrix, is the thermal diffusion coefficient, is the body force per unit mass acting on theith species, is the partial pressure fraction of theith species (and is the partial pressure), is the mass fraction of theith species, and
As carriers are generated (green:electrons and purple:holes) due to light shining at the center of an intrinsic semiconductor, they diffuse towards two ends. Electrons have higher diffusion constant than holes leading to fewer excess electrons at the center as compared to holes.
When the density of electrons in solids is not in equilibrium, diffusion of electrons occurs. For example, when a bias is applied to two ends of a chunk of semiconductor, or a light shines on one end (see right figure), electrons diffuse from high density regions (center) to low density regions (two ends), forming a gradient of electron density. This process generates current, referred to asdiffusion current.
whereJ is the diffusion current density (amount of substance) per unit area per unit time,n (for ideal mixtures) is the electron density,x is the position [length].
Analytical and numerical models that solve the diffusion equation for different initial and boundary conditions have been popular for studying a wide variety of changes to the Earth's surface. Diffusion has been used extensively in erosion studies of hillslope retreat, bluff erosion, fault scarp degradation, wave-cut terrace/shoreline retreat, alluvial channel incision, coastal shelf retreat, and delta progradation.[27] Although the Earth's surface is not literally diffusing in many of these cases, the process of diffusion effectively mimics the holistic changes that occur over decades to millennia. Diffusion models may also be used to solve inverse boundary value problems in which some information about the depositional environment is known from paleoenvironmental reconstruction and the diffusion equation is used to figure out the sediment influx and time series of landform changes.[28]
Schematic of semipermeable membrane duringhemodialysis, where blood is red, dialysing fluid is blue, and the membrane is yellow.
Dialysis works on the principles of the diffusion of solutes andultrafiltration of fluid across asemi-permeable membrane. Diffusion is a property of substances in water; substances in water tend to move from an area of high concentration to an area of low concentration.[29] Blood flows by one side of a semi-permeable membrane, and a dialysate, or special dialysis fluid, flows by the opposite side. A semipermeable membrane is a thin layer of material that contains holes of various sizes, or pores. Smaller solutes and fluid pass through the membrane, but the membrane blocks the passage of larger substances (for example, red blood cells and large proteins). This replicates the filtering process that takes place in the kidneys when the blood enters the kidneys and the larger substances are separated from the smaller ones in theglomerulus.[29]
The apparent random motion of atoms, ions or molecules explained. Substances appear to move randomly due to collisions with other substances. From the iBookCell Membrane Transport, free license granted by IS3D, LLC, 2014.
One common misconception is that individual atoms, ions or molecules move randomly, which they do not. In the animation on the right, the ion in the left panel appears to have "random" motion in the absence of other ions. As the right panel shows, however, this motion is not random but is the result of "collisions" with other ions. As such, the movement of a single atom, ion, or molecule within a mixture just appears random when viewed in isolation. The movement of a substance within a mixture by "random walk" is governed by the kinetic energy within the system that can be affected by changes in concentration, pressure or temperature. (This is a classical description. At smaller scales, quantum effects will be non-negligible, in general. Thus, the study of the movement of a single atom becomes more subtle since particles at such small scales are described by probability amplitudes rather than deterministic measures of position and velocity.)
While Brownian motion of multi-molecular mesoscopic particles (like pollen grains studied by Brown) is observable under an optical microscope, molecular diffusion can only be probed in carefully controlled experimental conditions. Since Graham experiments, it is well known that avoiding of convection is necessary and this may be a non-trivial task.
Under normal conditions, molecular diffusion dominates only at lengths in the nanometre-to-millimetre range. On larger length scales, transport in liquids and gases is normally due to anothertransport phenomenon,convection. To separate diffusion in these cases, special efforts are needed.
In contrast,heat conduction through solid media is an everyday occurrence (for example, a metal spoon partly immersed in a hot liquid). This explains why the diffusion of heat was explained mathematically before the diffusion of mass.
^abcdeS. Chapman, T. G. Cowling (1970)The Mathematical Theory of Non-uniform Gases: An Account of the Kinetic Theory of Viscosity, Thermal Conduction and Diffusion in Gases, Cambridge University Press (3rd edition),ISBN052140844X.
^J.F. Kincaid; H. Eyring; A.E. Stearn (1941). "The theory of absolute reaction rates and its application to viscosity and diffusion in the liquid State".Chem. Rev.28 (2):301–65.doi:10.1021/cr60090a005.
^J. L. Vázquez (2006), The Porous Medium Equation. Mathematical Theory, Oxford Univ. Press,ISBN0198569033.
^Stauffer, Philip H.; Vrugt, Jasper A.; Turin, H. Jake; Gable, Carl W.; Soll, Wendy E. (2009). "Untangling Diffusion from Advection in Unsaturated Porous Media: Experimental Data, Modeling, and Parameter Uncertainty".Vadose Zone Journal.8 (2): 510.Bibcode:2009VZJ.....8..510S.doi:10.2136/vzj2008.0055.ISSN1539-1663.S2CID46200956.